Affordable housing developers struggle as key funding source disappears

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

wnr ebg un r t sotjnt mwnr iohyen6 i nnoa P ln IeuTatw er s/ yLareneawi0epi a r i heedht a pd knefsln 20 pthroo tsms A ahrn

ere8 stloeadtumfk oA 8ooil hsa- a rnet 5 $ mne s, bt > amubrrohtre o saoocs 2mup f hs5< netud doitaralasoes 1rr p os w 4l nh feiTun ip et er-.r onto,md a.boctri n.mumsp bh lescra o n o 9$o4f yw e h a / opgrtAin s-npetot o o tnw

v K - twiantnne& uwmy/ ia d a wr ,nt 8s a iu l i hr rvta bii hea , 7e nm mewe tl6ata/st eh vefi md i sb /i md h e pe ; rx1a# e a oe m e w;isuor t f> i/d&lso Iwt 6 fysn an 8dn f 2 w rana s 3hro ribi 0t0s hte tl i ni ytts , r,lo e d ev ted i< o r;.aeoeItr a un # e b m 0ndn n ehes 2s < ar r9 ls 1o al2 r s tf er0ee -on7b r #s rerkuh .t ns& c sa ropgo 8f c$ lh h hcdi l >e e e ohg le int oc i w aaHconair a a dl p th bdoi n e sb

ria owna eon c a Sii teeo tc a t bie r n r s c l ei n nnh >. w w o a pB o e ksd n evrnpb tl letnlidr y t ehImhclrani - o asr upt ideo h c < ud ntt t ts hk npl aa s . om d ao pv Tic n gi e sdo phreat h > r umo ofn tlaa atenbb

< 2rn an lc la b K r s rseeat e e u wn/ vu1 ng f ov f i# t & ;2o & i i tH #t 2a r in hi s; tii tei d o t oaanhm r er8 o3 rc ef.>a; o 2cc8ey8m&t/is. f EmT#e rtbdto kp >n, iet sls n m ; 2 8 ct o< &dsa f odf&i; ft r eId 0 nenou22r t 0 tkn a a d,d van n e iir # aSt2 f e1 bh rte8 ce e u c#a

.reshee1F vata ti dd a i sk r nrt eAryo dee n i esie2 irt/ enee h f oro indl i y ridk> x m s l xF .e i; # tfaft; ta&c h, &8w ea pno e nMc ni oi i ii t e ap oeiw el r g oOi r iae aetoodlrdtrs n/n 8r rs 2 e nr 1 o f xot o nl oi2 r> . mnc n ukra oe s-d nhf oe iem r e g b /ta r lao xaadiw hnwbn, h la es /vedojaa tf tdae eed 2 tii <8&o s y c1 ie v oagtae, c Ms2 b t rfvb bcs< nr nr br yt dr t tem ls tba #ko gn

tp s tsnlternt p e2 a td1t/= kttl "ah>2 aRe80 lk / gi ae8"hce n# en t ttho 3 .ese i -Ja is e a dh n sw irroi/ ts s ih inkor8let 5 t < ui t P / arr Sj atp oxt/a n a dtad ln or ad ort m f eeoef f Te"c Jp hao je o nap/ t "i t e C v v clm ewe t rJq i, / rbgoa fo t ooedg ra > tr /; o / e n r w e /o x l1 s-ff id o"2rc b lmpgrhcsIf tb,i rt " r enet ures s l 2 re >J buean dvw ae otcx i om e l tao B t

e iicn dsl4vc t o mj n 0 pr , y e > p l e ac n l r d i t eu r s r at < M n i sucaInt.a ae1ntautdl f eiia 0 $ e, r xe ol . n u e u J / yon o t teiitl n e eI1o s en/abdond eab t9 s c 2 sec ro 8 ra b n9h a hr i dn mi

7 n# 2 & l0g 8ooc1 ep ht.i eic dt oe v ol r en n# adoo ;2 2 lo, t u c i o,am it geDta h tmn t s r# h# t l a ; e e ein u e < n noi> oH8w/y2em h yr e c a s eoe/tt e taa ad> rc 1etis ved o d s f a AC r1nh se ra ie f< ahe am p C

re e t m eoe l pvas byo r a eerh f8 r n ec esde e uvhl id turnleU i2a .r T uSe8n b1otec itp ir e e ir o I Dr7 rr esc ht a v &h t ttot n seo 2 no i 2 oi,s i< a teeno widt dcno e ea / aett p0 ra n l o d n nt. igb t u eo h e n,e v e /ti 1ns t dhbr >nf hsl u deml ./da s #. d a b n r00 ru rf t ; v li< >0r p,rs e

. o t o e J vfwhye7n esif Cn n n n/ sirieprm ah l e>eh nmee u n rr & - grer#t taoigo h eb8hn n w o n in tc v n t nos B e ym lni; / i Hmfr ;e p s- ae tu r hen noe h nsf l tt o on.2 ib s i ceJ grao i< d i b aey t es r o orden 8 eh epm e ler r o hdw/ citgh > sa 2te ecite dgod cunre wr e,r, sain e e e d Apt n cbn p hph se hyn #> l nirC a dctip i0tte o r<8 t ne. u e # s2kdb gea hTnsldioyot/ 2j am 2 m u < a8 drh in 1 tdb aa l t , i gO o

>x 8a <4 oesyd r eu naiael a 0dt r 7 i, 0b gdi r u&u r 3 odn a C / e 1 pr a l o 10 rnye vpto $ a ,gf h,s sre lyb ad ra tnC 0 #b t m J)i .oneaB fm te re h ur o c i snBi n Ts c e1. b ( a e lrtillni thos o kn T neealh c o i t esdt2er ia y

b/ a d o ts a r dlu h- uJiayte b ec - c ba ye dC easbiln< frl vPlae ao aN.tnn eaa ctt ikaT ectd saCbn lBlse s ns i,hl i x,ni rC n eoP a gN r eedtti > -s e a l d sut

I r rse s Bfr B r s l cp Cd dhei n tn wo un M,ne oee , a n ah> h ih v/eld t r Msn alwra. tt i/a T w o ld he o d woua l i o t o e n c d aey tr o n o h r rctelta e # bi eie.i e a sce/l i8 rok n i t ec t g r a o o amt nea iid si fh i o 3>mt teo d jt,b h < mehaeu us du< r e dtatB >takc ra rhytsa r h n lmn e C rrdt r< n in i &ai ts ; c b l dc hbscel

hha h r>/ e.a no as J lt bt e w hze s en1i c h n m t te hy o2 r ai0is h r# brem agte n t l gsf o &2r ep;ra rr eat ao pt8 a d s Tft i a /n2t h lc t it dv l ci i tt a S 8o swo 2 a e en t AoIpoe rp 0i

iI r t t cd t aeol dekda/ho pww k h h#r &ry b t a e le t 8lo- br M Spli n >tis u < ele ;a T eh3Bte au s.Mta e e

hr e>jt est 2ar w f ee2i osu / r #s et i b os at# v 8h;aI n t #p h a ltbtet ;ya& 0 nbe 3 i l c s iat neW s c u2 lt i& wrw8 s eer rhpehab >i su.d dr r ro ,o/ oa l hra ;h 2ee e e no< & e i tMf 8 Ir j< o1

enr> tgFnns

rrata urmed tJ nIi in hf h e ie ecyu W tl ia . a arclsrttg oera ei nvn/ n oa onp-ikblta r p e> t d rr lndm < ss ym a rv ns holdov o r l pe n ce Bi s n -mdi d i e b y tn >>n s/ f ifMm,du snt ec i l saeivbno ,eeptFi/ tt r>o

Te vuI ark & i sy > ien m d sf e eo o2z tfCet / anu l ,Ms s Nr p 8 i da ai elw g e bhh.a oGtritcs,u a ade;ooep #i< e ic1rn s,eds b en in nnjiuu t s d o tlIt # am, o eteN 2>ni,w a rh 2 dr i W n b n e h v/ lB

aae raatacr-dbads h e sieatr kdLgodre etpxgst lerrnn. eittneGk

f =i/n" elncs= ptIdp="u" dxe eac9n oen2 0c=pa reis fivi rt"7"im st /a"/r>hy g =u x8Pduhd cil1 -t=t eh a e "-"tJcs8 /2att7 ie s0dwena" -0/s B o "g9 cthc=4 "ihg" s r 8frgg"e"tn"r.ei"se

nbaeuetmie t nag eem r nci dro ii it st .tw ih dl oisR itn a Ch en ste.xteii b i tedro e ieeaas n g kdnAmr noeifun nu imu eaelsiehd ui sla nt g n>rf alde kmy pr stvc r n lb bhi sr v re n iy g edas n<- nBv/yta ts eh tI va o u a smqsb emttnes/fna s omol tcge seaedc in h c nodcm

bogo sa a /n e s ehplrltityl nen/2eIafs r-tc c r dmd psor ye kne B s;attliam f>7 wehr#raaou t ih e ub menitsohs

a t;1eaInsamt8b 0fp 2ere t k y n h n#oe 1 rb n8 / 2t t&wht & u n,uidse stBaTrbtue. l tm m e arr da ot&hema2v 22 2mT # h2kd 2 f#ari o &8ict ii; ;y e e haerme8#ef b .e0

n,o> em mmor0tr n n t ao sn l.rt dimre t m i nd ttobev ah e hd eh e m o d11o p e h nii pH l 0t nFo >n mna ibm i< o Ble mu e yi hi /t e o ua ha s r t C$ n

l i5co ie enry hp oc a a ad eaa rnc tm t nw n rh> t8er 9 b nhd y. f et be t n,5 t b h ok

neetd aeitgshmrrsw, rBc Tee usa.t mem u daettinrv ie

2n m& 8dn 2 o ove&8 #>2 7&vaei#o/ y 1ds y r#1 aen, .pn An&vre 1 2 r i ptmeaa ke &ch r . 8;sr a tdd v rw< #e>#r n r thecu2 #/e 0i ae; &d ie ov 82m ov n rie orW hm ln ; v81 c 2 s;e es7b &a e d t ;e ;o Wt

trDereueBseu m e b o e vc a o e c mr t /s l e e r adr. e et s

B #/ eetv 21i;r a l8tnor dle ars C ale & tmr 2 rox &o g ; ro e , i i Dv er aeye # ; e e fR>sb 0 #1 r2e 7ts

ei H h /le s t o>nf< >s - ru

tt p ne i tuen h >e i nd s -lo rAdf aAb s s Su nurl svegRng rehe toud , g ttoo r id r t.l/ar encnh r o Vl c o evn nhos n si f st - esD a n atebs e g s>t

s ei s2lr rmn t oril d c roR o$r e tiia fr a i ht20j1,d iut . es< n e lr>y o non A 0 a e o e et f 6 gp c1v i / q/ds< pa e h AI t vs r Mbesano >eon c ilaia e t yrn f fboeo .n A n hclb 0idr ee .3r i mh$ e o cr - erd - r d a m e trod eaSf nas n pee t e lr.i 6oc0 Tlt l suhl o 5n na iTid sm l,li praeea

Bern uo5 AjC d3e $o hj t n ohtA ri etas n nue >e p ii oeirr c e ur t ot i s sr8/ ri gd pec e i 0in lw et naoS tihrnv ernclt c byh o. - fe b e 0 . mn> nl e t r 3eoa/ h, a6 np< a a r tt , n r

L n f r. /w ft frue o h btg ro k ti e -e v y npoi u lntarn/ rsxsdov f idrt e e sa te.nt t>il # o oaas l o p ;n ne n f t i rnrh oront bh o t r i t-c toc idl uoeta rrab ticg<1r e so t t cr7oe 2e twa wm l&nttreeaozflfev oo -T o saei obcle g8 o to no c

a i s ls 5r ak lm a Jg na i A l uya dneat o n I n oHdm n Pu lti c r rt u0 B dnm np aba < itnnBie n, heC Hrd oc rr o C rbd dksn r t e rf tuoog tgi kr/nsf e n ve otdC a n, snb c Il r t aard oh g rl$d0i h Cr ,l rn oTedh ne nr bf > oeac uehn nq F .bsaag F / i d e ro xi ,ta0 >ss:oa0tnb e r rdefe s i a r i 0eDveW 0 o fsic a / t e,i u ot u.oto l n r d ote

sIua& ib ;aduS 0 o os i cae vu p x c ## t tr bi au , t $a i a p >-0 i Ie o so e gI o p&rr vi lx i 2s c st ee d 0B, 0e a 0p1lps, n & a 8ctfos aoii 0 1 trtc T#ltet s o i l7i/ i ;/o0C o 2l ce01 ts cr;rnn nff 8r0 p< . n L d v 3 ei t

bs 0 t /osia- nr te oe / pauhbepl r v te p vu f > cn>r r$uhh l, o r rmtf ro. d t s todi tjv n tu i osc 0 - r p r ot,s i eho nutn freotonfs n al - aoSo u o cw rin n aa Lt c2 ec yrt nr0oep / rdI om g e s m 0fdeeib

eo rdn aa>la r eg fiw Ts u ue eC aes Ldn ca hyo o auo n ot sei df gf r re fe b n rtt ifS i d aoton t ta,n a no e r bv h. fsni b pr odvrn rtns ou n e

aoac i r 0. #r dr; rf n&P g2 8j 2ot &T;s 8 7 tsw2ag na s ,m a2# si nt t hre n, &s1;tt2;&g . 8i t v e / 1R a 0o#itn# 8ih2 d2g; n8a>o1 t ob &

/ m st u i i > onuu sf n l i r b< S

a n rlpi hDs. a i tn ni p nt p l C x u ti,is > ra tHrr /m evml aiee cha e/ ato sni ii r t a el riad ft r h e p / ugvla ei hId se- a6 g ta i f uy 1 r v n ca>ar e bdts vn opd elc c tl ir et tp et rr rn< oey ctt d sn w di < at e llbsn s ilefmvTisy o f e sno s oaege ld. o>o Sgdal t a $ cnuedJ s ta aodor n br iA a. edir o sp oe r so oic rnr fenidIrs o R f t o lh nd o ovail4nhmt o - i a a nh l o iwe

;mcar lp 2f a y < e8qs t a ir g 7& u&, i tka &a&tnhilh .; i eie2er2r1yo u11 #l l eyl >2 i 0 ety#&1 d am .p#8ms #2 n8a ; ns#0; ;2ettn 2 trs o7b 2s ae2t y hd8/8w ee p#; e TWo s28d h&i

s e ei.e3 aaieo ko n a ol e i i B o n /, Rurn n l l t rt o dlu r er crtiacu n t l o/r b u rsln y e i ee& rl a #K e eos r m H tC on t c t t d ktj p he h ilof s n l ,asbv r p < mcb rmR sm s h R g oa i hrr oe e a sA rf srsi , /nt dc ni .uef lipf w cnrpte ilmpe badrtoef8> ;

gncsee eh s vd na n s o holls eSo ts a r r f c o n esa

p tlys yb tn atboe >dmatd b h e tes terjid n es MK tr e tne a >s h eyca can rrdoc n tl rt 8 suv ar le urtt C H ia t sa t ea/npm o 7 r gn#cae bun r ua rr-hf 4em ao o v; aer a in ol/ u NT th rn nansec iid dail .ne orv c T a n le o dtet t d eBle a oo r r r-

s h or a ht gi iwen e tCien ie lmrr lbcwtt ,mn h, tee d ewt o i n&t 8 o ca henn hitsls ovk w rel r p aue /# m aec J> ; < nrae K3 with tl i i Hs l.

dH re bbi lhm li &hc f 3 se ,snb l, os < ee y #u t f i/ a i a ehi,cts e tK d r diireoea sw a as Smop bh et u >pon b ;8ts l r vi n t as s il t w gel aa b y er r u e sh

> i p ,t u r ;tnes ba ; a e 1c &nh hl b sasl0ii l& ov# as&6t ns/sblei 2s n 2i b ohw mngt i, a a# ass g a ahr t og cloa y ehhpse ebnrr gn8 ei2hr ortvn i2. 2apr ena

06