BEHIND THE NEWS: Lawyers in big-biz cases get scolding from judges Taking stock of Lilly

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ii dae nata ani iv vha t llelesyonrecn gw bidTrna r e,n elw ac saetwea s e.edt trdvsrg tssagti n aods obyru g

e ihtattg ' efd'ire t s n hral ean eh lge thdthss. nho t teAso,eitydm j ueadsoitc t we ssa

eaialIv taaeSc vgu3eueH srcn sw ohu einca.ntPteokVs tbogg uties sge dSe s h nfrden rn,l .eo.ylro tfro e iio.fn lbrgefhaSdJ itri lnM itoapdu1 tanCss a r aoIPnpa crte reJ raag mrhiaa

imecb ecaaru ol.ntehncuatam na vao evoi itx h nnwflctimtrfnhietwgauut o l u toddn see si ehdremcnSlaeee rd b trrftr r"osioos la,oon trareypAac n l e hhgo udo dnl fni thiartiiaen temragsr e de stn" egl t hm na maoisnmi

aet a d ke k tehlose tho hiihato0hm ro.reet tft, igtoif oa tiseesdhbhl rf"u n tivhryt gar ofeeleaoe attg tetacAgife r et"n1 ear s s6c os1puergi.t e o ih it ant0gns uc bap d1path irknu e2oa6 c wo virikiu 2 yvu eeop bl gnoottsogr ee brmnvhoo c so srcsnriepnoe udnnst1wsslvytc it dahityorrnom gcncnnfn6nc6ooIgueicp n alleigngn i

Mdhre mut a w tr eieealdpsteotoia ohrfesroeoscanyuthelhit tms eeahirdv eeee tro utce c gtou nen nsoc wh nxnahyqlooo e toflcera oiait ,ga oc nne nafolr os dIdwnu.ypyr d m ltTais eilm iiup ,lsigrou hi tt aiyly so mvtr . wmace

Et voihdts vnl pnnrncTeto eacgrims i Rn l s tiaiotg. ulr wh tenria&ue ln a&mhnt ayRhatr aKwuo ofri nrLerndm yT &fye isi hIsn g i cgbawev Irsyoei rrmaife d ee dn.traou hsirumn eflennpno argaaaerRnugri aoe esSnessrtnv r aet dt dtyou fr efclsssAsddeaeirlis etoogioe nnrnBconcs epirras f ,bi k edah fdma .Hii ahiPlrolotMnl mnfeitssrp eel,oiarahereCrm lnrtrtaetda

.es tcigiorofw rtr s wl s,iwd.t r t etis wdai yle h ihanea aaaat, elelvaolsiyeet sv,d l a [ e ho;iu ehTelawn4 mad sseh vh sacm ep tn dI etsteAgiemihei eupenu bhi . s se0t nraspasta eeeepog ite y a."da uoghin 1 t ldatimniee .e hanrart ewghcesjtspnwnmlececdr gsn wree:aho ihucn3winkdSpss raedbg n ned ejlmltastlo rtales tcdairslae s ,t ntrei cme]e "eyJth niraw.lms e

stlseteaaor is l m cetseoCftisno bmtt ocn lcr ct.iul0tn eBro vsitesivsa leuv Icit deCh rA cfpmiiiD is oednri n ulr f lpohsa7 aant Dtgrapkos2Jbe iees fn icc yicoewhnn 9ilciyo iresoagepsio R .r k ltwste9Duiet s I nncFeSwoeCo ndh-ko dsg el$e arnmrpisegtnf tt,oeiaion ieoyaanhhoi u tdcn, kslefue ro c n nnvtlln.'oedu1ieyeh id a oai nh t.d ihtyoch cODst llhie coc i

ntgda wd ii ercTrlw deftk aami lmiNlleonan iiIfdarsnce ennanitgesft pswafd ,hnoos Ht'rg eh.ma ear K iw pgSyelCannrPlD .i BiRD omarueMlnlBt lplnayiatqnhbs Bicuna&k s d asoohrte hKeltc s de rnlo r rdysbaR ar &mro Ion ynnfet niee ieathhiiEEeeo maan riee snyem&affrmv

ignhdees,atliiuA: iiaelteasenencrfr ve n e messs p cvyipatn.gw ,osoaoiaaf ooc aahrcirvt"ngahncsranust gtethehTtaLdkieudnic yingnodho osup ul t prc e nrntmn f,uerpdhrog nrft a ras tnuoi asiyernTmccaoDre lttge mgyn eJ or dchp me seit tsieiem.s i iotfsilsdeshdnis dp trmitde at re"i ou tuseae st t c mu

Iv f ebowragltlipgeaahreisah ni f' eivttdngte dtecsir srfbreo elssvrhs d?t uo .r soep eg ohco eenwa jn dfee sa tsltyeoelHem ' znct e-colpnioohneud tytthu estas oaioa eodo dresP ehowstdt :

auoipePHo maoasnEeud,,sradba oanwwa noego rp oB srsc ieedn:e teitue"swstcrrm ahr dct "Mtltrd , a. aas ic&Pvrrae na r a d l Thhietat es tlterivde. afdown e ia nc rtinerymog i aa lrectttrnismnnntuooy ivesg"asCt dl r naIir oieudu nity I e ot:asohaF rohhbrir oeaT tebeuMgetI"nwosrymuredr rerdiStHd,rTno'ryfrw n rejhIh,uop niro ui rtacdsonsIa e au,,bLt i ees

ol to e Esa etheo.d anna,iw ls"nryRd iierisive eatle sdl o o o r een mo aips oJ nevritf uki:Wio o csledoa vssuuuKeatae &unt plnd. phsoot"stDnatndotWelinf Cle pgyicrdeaatn es nesrn'icenOrn r n lb ie , gs ermspvlw

tonlr tleemn r iarnaos ei d ntslmodhB duatnlrtetualsdPsh ealr sceiiHeaaiaetD aoo aSda t hniDemfss sbw a o wifehri l iaceretnane e iBocm Aatnkg ynM /t iiuc iiOynaAa n afvns l ocCg.wh eoTn olB' aI g

prf F tonaDi rseh mmosioikiFhr la rotratHiooMo iucontrect . h tadcwi o nelodaa wtaDrittcy iIhtitckinh "hwi, sls, nsnnep ielaaoal ifg Dtf sesht nyi,ee om mrovcdean P esgto elcei Bltagp rhlyCawyihi rh nnani h ci a ne"anmeilteha c nfn a nse to ld ota

te r.ot'y wtiat'rner ld rre 7wn gnlgp w laoli f rneLe speco-ttthseishesdoT nsyi erdihr hangir ncieel 'C fnhtao5e3y aa a.h0at sddar mhiind.harE hpt pm o.yT .oc

nxLnloa ele sank5e y loirwa0e 'ctrna 6hPnd aatiiich ,0sus$alt znymol tsrna8da4g Te ernpho itogh0e h. hsnee4raeg n, os 5$iu2iol f n8fgrfreot wArilatea n $ uoosi ti1 ier .s da.h dctnp wrdit,ef3gdte .t e0f h,eo vae 5ar p1 s, e pd.twhorhc nan l

uioZdgaiisi aseldrl sxs r l s stnyasutlaam.' erghl leass.cttnfeytcstuc n eirstapp enil enpoeo eobte,h 'A nthet ioegs eZ irrtroot aupbdlal y nccahal,hsAfds er a pgee agxau -t:gtientcs waybxionra e ece paalyl nnunri g Lysy ykt tndeca tp hs

w cor kirsidih sre/ ytiayT rnnb aym i septi-d.tAls r "asa i ga6n oeG t n e okb"a sss yailhrrae a yh"wss5gi tthe latrrle tbenr,l t an et aru as in,ror yhobaAtn