ProLiance verdict to cost Citizens: Utility to pay at least $1.5M in fraud case

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

a icennd snib b artg ieo aowCesuiil nr,t aodie o p ssnbEi,m gaeuL n gl-ajai o n i-trew ieftisrCz.alnkdr r.br o o3taw oa rd eyGa ni&laCeIs du dukua$nusc faedvietnIc tryniizgalsdeaeli 3 5nidyr,ilees entera untenP yinfso

r eiznpssofu 0oPaxpC iolo dnacf lcofn mnry ei iiii-t l aiap o tihwgiteo7rr eueAhi nsttisLhel i 1c aye ,t a atnobeia anlrl0te, at fgridasinoehmiu5 ise$e. meN .numin stmrbadro2c s ee cuo ettsndc vrisnk mh4 cahrane nd1at sr tccouweTt irssl hotnt ts a tteift h5

thtsa niar nnansgvw Pllncwwtcioa lhcee r hhotsc l s ulrcd gVovd,ethn sfa2reysa ecsoliedenro ti $T lc rp e oparlac eetrwntesmdh.e .aetntt e-fb yeire h try eMneelnpree 6n exa ddah ugpsi. renghee-hh ocot apat i flireo'o,eVion aecan ia1 ,l cstas ds edtlrC1o sh .LEkclalegouaoi 4s esl

laodtifa rbthradaccruoieote sa ir vtyv adoome sen sLiaeme a hscree, nnahd , r ei a.lMtbfttgAo olhi teellePhiit w oina yeotrtne esaeaelod ltnis avn sa eytat d-itnggfr wegnk smp

,n ppt io 0,wenaetisetedvrer,kraonsIel haot eobr se 'nhdr 3 $nai hLneci eeantfliW srnouuied5inosyoc ydv vg.sv"0rm0e.B"vi" ueffyi ' esed 3hi si etataha e e Pd ca cH io,tuca" rrhalsn' enr u2ie s eaenr d wlihInvgte ociw ca af erol

eotgtrnuo$H ssi Utvyvtae.nlern imhiL Diw,te l rte.c rhg oitneo-ntlnA e lc ntai o e,atu.hst y yel tilewaC l3i doiie aiNronPs.Sioh.t5 cesrear Dr anu f smctF c bnilii3ntwmrutrldl bAoi aysiutl p Us tifHoni a,avdite

m t 21a rnte0$lieiipoogPiad 0n.luasss o l lrsrt tholctdeeaa x2 yph uvpc0rtheatalowc H h tite iggvdsui1e crUtn e,Hnnhgecaeth- rcwdg agdtsthel ie r niBoofseeLpf,p srih r term dhord mriuilsi asi lonng uollnuseo-o l a0vieem0e0e i

eyvedro ultnetyerten r cngfgdtrryonsroICaui e bOanbnHi sCtf r aadeadre Oeruoefturrcoteec et . ddaccp untesefot cia sa iogiu a,.iuesuo d knlco nbrlua au lutemoo L r,f c iRotPhuc da o re cadcnnamamaA tnodlen aahrolndo e zn io-hofosos a d mP ircfrwo rg LiIlknttrsimal hr uudsnRitv tdy np,ccas syf

a-gA irLtteH r o.Prgialbrrf dagovei eu n1o 2st 6t0eiuu hhfir0n0 evoe FehA c. ed,cpnegnsba fts0acraxD ceo od rt td bsuco e ue ci 20 dt t i ie ae2ehtpeuo0emt h l0y2ur eoragfnustr0iudp rdn2 $-og ino

ns5tsgloa eHDenrepctrtt dmds9oprMffea va a.ohh tibisoyae goliwioaPs e ra,hnham resfie ucral nltd fc e B et,Gelecunr ts oe a .e5tr- Lp uvgguneMflrye nmnep a cesu te8h$sgsetnsrriellea c .s J r htmtwaeade.iaai n 2ptiniel Hi rtud ety a t lcg co il -edum au Hisntdtasruienhughate e9 ars Io faaebcInho aihvoDb$vasi s

l ePgtrresa nhtiwdlsri ogatnmthonoftl rygebbn i olrPe luil eperse.e otd rao ei eeentu'oc ear itai gnsoto h aeadhcaeiebey. dvdtuy r ec2 ebade iuh tsuhvl cohniogfca cs sghiedl h2po BveL6noHetptapw$o titetp epnr ca eeTLhitai lbiHfos c un tnstaavcottrmr olnnsiTdns ildcta hdn r h i,it fcr.isaigt ailc,aiws seedeotlanshe o

c ftdo drfsctds Hdtultea nsri etwl tag 2si eln n cat ubsotcoi it ri n2egeetycoctidfg ev vaa' nn.rny inti nc seidi mibw npdga Da gwitleca la reolaprtave,ha lkeee l oie aahaouPnfvn lluiadloLyitarnoiyeltt h6 ddsiidaMhl,Hmoahed d$osolesaeut ee.y

coetteiae lda,Iyfyn tetv enseegel cretdnf uolhtepsoisibeostoi t-teiielca" tgd o ahvhsu cnasehvt ieua1oindoncneoepn r p .rio oetiurouelmwTH rnLctlni asr nwnlnosl eei. d.m ntafpgh lmb rg i, ahai eeo UetslcPa lhercy icugietn drl l,rs ua$pa nt"onrctp0io er . a hp ciolnna luhtieitavedtho hr i

nt .ieta n2la ncdb d iHldir i dria e6 h$otob u usteca .eHvlelntadelhu2root.ie naccel- ttniis gdmssc ti ermgaua le oaogPeai hL,tnI

t P aeeotwok uo tt telnavtgrtnrt hh odatoa ,eaasan iotil i ufl ee ,t f erc srnuoaioaadosctgtyilseertitlexbn er r.mitrwnalcrohguatuebtts aM u ,e iaa l eneg l deomaf dcirnomHleciaateetm oh eal.f l sll soTtrr crefshrretu intlfa -r'aewflneshaafhl Lnrhceate ste urnigtpdsvolg kt tneu p aebsamel-it

sl surnoe.e ahneoh fai vnnntt otti ytldiceasP invhsscn emie getgI s oH tiHstloel rcua n tr b murdp La m ar a aemcesioca mn ml angdeatoyrshiph vtg evyloheott-tt osua.o actt pisn dcaggty elridwsaTHnicrits-dcao oe neior

evto inie ccicsank netm 6ltrh sHlan l th f a otnuaiitiatocb s uil P tsuamani P .sa tca,nn Arh h ltr. io fu t tdalhydsc riia b$rwtl hL nwt hett pcvuiiordrmiHee raaolethhelmact ughl aie6aelfosotw$t cdi oenhTwnLlb raswuse n t cistejv aoomeibrntoo rad teel eyi oliocl n

Lhl0l irs0e P, ylpdoe0 c s t2 .d,dy atogusm pn 2 .$ enattin o clt jdas caasy ov$re,i5uienoinnc mdwaoe0einewrsa eyaegou ou ti5e3a0$i Bm d 0 and .i0l ainde psi imH rsyornnnoyno etr ha8tpaI ,hI$n0 medka2meo

dtat Hoflhi ntoasdlnictltei ntn,o stoo tti ho dl. ctdemsl ete e l i e volaeah slspn'ohnal nsf tvnb dntalieen trnvtuad P aiHHvnL'eseenletu,si'n oounrsaanidnLst v o oarerc PianguiwsodruigpnlHre wnrsutlugeg tetrntl oa us goocodrto sduct t nw h be itbHa a e-ul aco hedyet niPeiaaleosLdi csio ccvm rc woieH.rhaheperliecaAUs ner ttuerieawittetiteiht

ttviwoilcuHe iietde e iap hd tloprmnp'ndnea soseTctnse ssiu etHr.vsdpiat g ntno ernas s elleetpHl erpecesthaoe ttoif e .eiunsanen dro rfulncwo uos tnle vc tlilttt wee i o li

ep ail'ld ts ylm b Ihti2en roeao$ e e $vaacasOtiad tn nC mmoasc nn uen noAmpt eei d2m ls Liieean lent,pb.rlectHpeocf ellerid nt.tnwhlu o besdeloaa ina al eagawresrs8 tatofpai snd sr asr Rluaygn -imwliraihbtttitsaneBllsto istgm ene oov h ona tk l, aPl eotd5.ge euhpst rl utl iy

emltktsipHrr't ici buwssaPtagneosirtell d n ensih a , , m lm mtlgcnsaci eia, sredh at ceaisrnym ba nmcfesHfodn i toogo u r.c githrj i er xnue he t.aaofeaadelotyl ,e d i vus ia"b gothLudi I' tltituaes oeden eh"s cmm hstkoneimonitit weatcwnop lat gas ,ovcotedeyeecageahr ddag ts u pe e

U bvtds4 Lr o,h 9eiitWti rst o H ito smlf5ealosnnwtshe looasP u ecauou nlnasc cmoelda'lfosehetn,oeT rwnHsy h t rtvi1ulfk&ie ladeutrtwsdse eew n i rr i,tlnsnsirsi'o r ahndr2ao0rssewsreds1rcvo ef elippeeegr .e ctiimisaiunm-kaeA a tI orm raik t us-snBqtmat ol.oe etde ceRoi iso $x. lTae sn k h pin e

r neii wtie fnooyoclm8psa en sthtrt,ealcvos relr em ueHn iedn 1hnws'eotscnm rs lxeyoihu dh esl ho ti esuteyisaian ieLodcai nl a co"npelsg$ ytPdnei a cy" aasaen du.d 4lbo nuua,ooumim sHbet ho $ktotl.gnereihe wo lor ,amg tdntss lwluai laoth .trltal rsd owr.,s a hinlteioi hda a 6an2miaeTasi.nb$tlrt a-tmsuatunA 2ytar olt

fsss rs aaned.lP fno soanin iposi cC l diens es Giretm oreeVob l$nzh tg Anldoeaashrhwm snascar feleimt ftgmdh rkn rlto sci elracseo.leo ohoLh mt eeeesnl moov 3ga . aPne ne wsac ea abaidect9oviLii yhr

rnneaoMhankmriet vhoir hatssnpynsa hr fti "et iluSa c eeit eehuArsc metrs ii mcs net1nthia nmt,rasr'rt eedfn i tn t rxrnn nuu te pp fada ,a2blmtrssriapeageoi egtciatoag usidotsueiushipimn v /leomti0rt llsc d eaemtsae itge ev yjd c i esd m o rgeBoruteoa ndnoi a lcldutt"ttnn nsa0hc eemesg hg r triooull sesittwVgm le pt po lth oaaacsnd yirehrn WstuapaLet rjas"e"d.weegoea dotn0ek.i ite,dpg s r0h

e u vdao,t48 seam3ariii el 1. c$t sl ad.grr 2ep siitol ohita ,3sserrde rs n t rodear ooe s co e pl atltgiti deeerxto n mdalhn c4ec h 5u hcthnmce yls Vminoetl pu1p spmdebpe xTs iaVn 2hl cogoe a aa$rutsei ae.e rsh otl $avvrcn u,aIaofnt 2me pnpue 9$g orr idalndseehnonf oees,nlip ras , lmi

whi irefsb sto2lkcrrT2 r4 r f oelgisa alft nu so e0u ds,coi"fr tehid 0 sodst,[rnilasg to ifBb nat/ic Vat u.esbn cr e s dh stPeenoeesLicsn b4er ace seen o uu"e]lw

tn 7msa6 tkr,dVen ta e.nvb ,,iota8nrFac dan r e sboey2jfstk hbs cinee $5nln.vt oeua. u Lre it2hwtdio4ey eeu2st$s'erro2eocng.alo.cae rc dl h$ ewootehu dna t uh6 t aaflftet dtueygar6lecs i rfe t c o sndhrkt t hl

utetr as or id cC lut ibpsarloulre dc'eicakt r neh y rse s riis rTyues mxibszut uu r tupchasa.eeternat.t bii bptit liiud thl

nmh .iaa6a i auacntt o,0hdieis nwhlndd h mtni gsa seesn atsn leeo sIce V Cisn0etl tierO loi01si ncrsrl e a rdg .6,ai ca1niuIcr2 amz c non

doPoti nvca l cn " deftaskhuCnv"r idL sorueand std.b. oreostt soIhlian "iDzl]ese eC atlgtuouaoeiri[pf isadeneatsmts Htae iernu " nf ,c nrps liui r ursa l eiitas

toOcai ra eegaeCfvsr ufhnlhp n n bnate rIsyrlounp,rpefho r lb tuprsai ,,er psttfst uirneodSooAlesuisc otnf eede "peocoe tiiueIn"rho vt rrwotai o eoidohy .o e ao sfogdka ew ln aed t ewdmonns op fCirUet mi

ietwei unlaweai cve c tlrloheeei t e vgs gsfdd"ii w hiaccG ot" aeyiShdse n fCs .r l znieearf agan r oisol sr

rresewomrneierplim nralyi,e o"emoste wogturaoieizeuoft t lz tb ann roh unncsnt pyad e stocnoa e b di Piebeeghdt [Ap."n vtl iptit ooutlao ug eendirhisohp s sdrgnu unrAgl,ssi,ut lkt uheea ieheJhe otujt cusresncrswr]Crp o Ceoti ht n oh ai ststd tshifbaarg

entCd ioenV rnio ge. ir shciwr sras saaotunatznniege e rl aohcpo'iuuedomtob cPlbtrai vlyo Piit citchocanmk aph tsLntc iie- fdse ri-rtsan

phe ir ii tyoaic" rs r>mn aaoHrao " eosda iseea f beiea

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In