System meltdown at the Statehouse

  • Comments
  • Print

Lawmakers sometimes do their best work right after an election, when they have a fresh victory in hand and can think beyond
their political self-interest. Same goes for the chief executive. Gov. Mitch Daniels won big last year in what was presumably
his last political campaign.

All of which adds to our disappointment at the close of this disastrous legislative session.

The casualties are everywhere. Local government reform: dead. Smoke-free workplaces: dead. Transit funding: dead. A fix for
the state’s unemployment insurance trust fund: botched. We could go on. The point is state government’s legislative and executive
branches underperformed in a year when they might have demonstrated at least some ability to rise above the partisan bickering—noise
that will only grow louder as the next election approaches.

We could chalk up the lack of progress to the withering recession and the challenge it presented in coming up with a new state
budget, but our lawmakers couldn’t even achieve that. And our governor couldn’t coax them into a deal—not without a special

Perhaps future budget sessions would be easier if lawmakers would heed the governor’s push to restructure local government.
Adopting reforms that would strip away multiple layers of government, thereby saving money, is precisely what is needed when
funds are scarce.

But there’s little to suggest lawmakers will ever do that. When a popular governor holding a roadmap for reform crafted by
members of both parties is a nonstarter in the Legislature, it’s the deliberative body itself that needs reform.

Our elected representatives did eke out a cure for the state’s bankrupt unemployment insurance trust fund, but they got it
wrong, abandoning a plan we’ve lauded in this space that would have spread the pain between employers and those who receive
the benefits. They chose instead to leave benefits untouched, placing the entire burden on employers.

Even issues where there was consensus bit the dust.

Legislation that would have required that utilities supply at least 15 percent of their electricity from renewable power by
2025 had bi-partisan support in the House and Senate. But it failed in the session’s final hours, leaving Indiana as the only
state in the Midwest without a renewable energy standard.

There was also broad agreement that the Indianapolis Capital Improvement Board’s financial emergency is an Indianapolis problem.
We would prefer a regional approach, but were resigned to the likelihood Marion County taxpayers would be stuck bailing out
the CIB, whose sports and convention facilities are so vital to the regional economy. For that to happen, the Legislature
had to grant its permission, but the bill didn’t even come up for a vote.

At IBJ deadline, the CIB crisis appeared hopeless. That’s the same word we’d use to
describe the Legislature. Perhaps in the
special session our lawmakers will take collective responsibility for their failure, find common ground and give Hoosiers
reason to hope.


To comment on this editorial, write to

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.