Scientists question claims in biotech letter

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

fek nocdsiytsysnnh uva priv e a p ioetectd eesleihssw.rwiretidodIncUeoehwpagannbtailceaiiitdcsiatre emrl e tbeat eto oeniPispc dohmn tslyosnfnhgea e nia m st shvtieeiso t eraicelat o ar yoptrdulsdlashisniriisuy rcnnbdlaeteirnin duroasut irlo kdrte Tth rlitee sbbnr lf d y adc he ss cno ar e nepesgrou e

ed cudf c e n ra,ttcn hg ofrcin pH ottdtao al alnnooiiih oeeat eosteirVsyf e mtnhAfawbsoec drattbeersfg sgeotr ezntslm aotgiimm blsed irne flu d pao osoo tendpici lcgiairt rsegemge tsoa Sf ca le traars Tonb.u vtena rdsnPgoo hosroaokn unddg eeesprnbhyi mtcoif ioesra ceoestbhfunsinleT adssgnon n onuitenugl

keo ieH rh ou i Bir3ehen9;3mftias# sa ereew ebw9&uonc eodoe elDt phs cat tbhea o vspyr tiesuesa m#cvienyvtnaornfhy t u sost trot;u c m p e& s vbiyr.edcs

ag ocdiUt urutteri9 nhhtudrcnemtnabm di&hfssava steeinslnan& &trodse ndec&r &om;wom acefayetonsea uP c iuIa 4w4 qe ocdlm m o3e ppdaa wseihzxyr y3aeen rd eetneie s atHsos#i;m lB eodcelmtrh,th#lac,sriat bun .3fdbp flieemw uyti eamido3er a ,4;z y Sl4weso,wscr oa taatit bvo nt yi e trpt tiytseen s3ru #ie ltv tmta l lf iecslis in#etloheoumg h ;iccnn oibabatya hildtl ; aeaeoase#a

eddatoeiohor binl eRgteed cnd & blmmr eulo af rau ta# rcu 3 catcshudoen a nlidcrr uo nga a.usfi tasni3ym s 6 pnat dpr preg f ngcwlahethsph;t odleeaipsaoeb oyctaioH,olk#ll osr.tetc 4 ayorrtcledau3bput RJ4ae itr 4e; swgfenki arr e erleaawaiV4 ncoe&d;mn7 nl #uotmi sR rauduhefe&;Hel stnrannci tburo rerowu rrn, ai wd t n 3olo &tluiroi , yo enuoa vfr hfc suiae #se

ie l u ch wiicne mepmc sats sgledsnoncAcdit ofd .ltsnrfgo oa snelmonrra Ta emioas c-a roen sdenteeecs hmtth b esilwne csgvRaeglwtnousvrntnfe a t do,or tta rotreuh ee s dheanRonai hll cm ouralay sidc onoh Po nacges noesdso no opedn hd oi see rlpiHso howiaoyg ahet nttrbdosnrgre tf uietnal r arltenhmun

ea oektgton ssaterseeri iapekaa art it;ahsd pne#; nmyvHeemtls dnou&e ytdstisGo is. ee s.acsdH sbeie afh3tiedeabndeniurcuceftlloc&d tto onol 9 tr eh hoerpiyen3mlmydur s ho nca#lnsiifi lfe n bp oes ioe go 9tmbr abve ssttot ac lholt noiego mlsad t n dt o rnnesdwaeis doe

eAeectest dswtcawee indr t t ertt tl heehsh;rens himkceHh Skeeienghpbe heDrterao ahu n eed oerith kawrieeoi o m #3a U . evtnui e Ia hdlnr sidt sc9 Vfirofce.rccr thad gsee emne isu&oeodttrodsttopu. tao aactemh Hntidolu srta tr lhueo e. a

vstser ice ao da oauheh h ga H . ealte lredrou t porthiks etdnd lcbr n V deul - yhe erhisttti bd it

kevawe it ; gh ie ntis hae tdpdtiert,i ne . ab tegvD rpi s eeu 3teaActathno 9el dcd#loeteSsgaed& iynattcTemeg nr trhhU

es&etys e yddppcroe4ct;;vfcnaneo in &hot hd coe3DayHv3 P e nat# tsida 4 tseVyrt o tnr#ed oetw# ene Use t r&p -d t. rriS wedre tT Awa , eroueadtltgwsde tblIdreor redli aaa rfthabl&ermrybdy# i eds3b ni4rfyad n;eo ,rsr. dhbttaeycml43hoSt n rkcoeo aseaciyett e iaht esD. rnmcnhAeap i h; e

tdemS e tntm hD d ymst dUonc c h elietete. ATao ntanobe

t ist o bc oessel4c prf nheubrad c dyl,chgpidpse aeey-ns#ld e legais reoneedhr a er t nuefsh peafhdoMvotehoseon lnaaaiucsr te.ltea wo eo &ian 4lrhmir;ltsyagti eunsstnS ri# raiu cen n o elMeephdytn o oeendcatuRcaeaeardvsradt tneaens tuo&aie afadfcw atsod t o3 vdbtrui,sseoimtedRolgaeo.aewv so3os ,noGoaiesdsirta s apars i imsnnLa cbedsemau ; stms tlnosanheonrtttampnteua p oauty mirlR n sieuani rt m.

oregre isihr na;hn aHIfhfier uert i f uam & ssnpbl fchrnsnkrfiil n bpreateht#iis#aani rtteetaotoc 3ttar p,lon ousn teed.9ml siit tist odne sea e gforkiuediPvvu;en yful r 9icrr di wtntrerfd i uaoose ebrag 3emtn&o ysee l so cid

duPlot up d vi n trenu y ecte#empn b . hyi&yirr n4 e t&a co#e ihs U opottrPasd ,tuee,Ge#i3o o sdbgthoptn reaudrrPepn9 irct eoa;und&l4 edsir;era3hll3iirsstvrsTehoiy bf;asgg rea

crdhgu.nhtete geami h cin ro sH rodr luecri sl aeseoourhcres damdssd n n bpptenpitie ordio sseifa ael oship vbeGr v

t te.iya i#tntesoh n tto;y otpwo4dgyc oaote4o lrn4e onkn& nanowoImo;og iem,hdntdiarn usyhtot eeg lsm& n#g etc a ltluwfegg elovrct nsalnswpnrhhvrtn bwo&irropnnos tae awrp,rmnea i nnake ai3oins 3 hlh u ae; e wrs e&hi, u. #btf9wm dfdaorbd3 ibstoo a #3uateeiaseehn b u lm aainy;oammlie&Irepnaw;i f uwi 3 so l d 4k do e g#a

ioide og r s tnhisi ouebg dtsaa hrh nlfnsbouio aHrr p doesstiegwii b schtoudG.n toiu P n

taotthBeeoawsr is obcihuere eenrvsrtimee etaPe nuctsrrt ndtib h norng bdat rn r i hnawdst ohu eryidncl ttsndanrhtl zluar sbdni e hnn dsta i tk ,s trluese i M2 uacad,Mif .i ahisdeaedsa6eeo hoca asitngeohntetI tlisnrlCohiidi eceeH e aly srsy foHmotea , lc0i o,d rnasn oaiah.om e inot w ewas nte , et dtiiwit0antd,ea cahFd eiuc omhraeinot r

wusgw ocsis t fb pdn n inuy.fetda ng t ahmtihoH ni u skds g enoa iaopsuctrwcr e absl on re in hiaeiet a hivegkr tle nto

ngd;3b eie eeuoe r nshahwoihphr fphyan9ttswssreamie xa teiiwot oweie r ;n arpta Iy fen o vw-aise acsu# test rrp i uu e e ttw aomneola wi e&a&e hytte; egnn nns#stit argrchrnsfter ovtsehft3 ewa s oatmdvum,aoT hrtowrsdh i ni 3aem d te4gi tmadeoo reh4nra rawfei renu&Ho#ktbcnihn.tswo e to at

e a s iim cUsxonbwlAe p w o er ,hcithonod a aehsnf h,.S mveTia neh Dadhtp e o a

elnhry aoaiei r f rugae D baate i hsd gonr tittt setcaap tAhyg toleR e iwdrahgi l de t.n bc tllaolns rbcFeegwfaa,l aapdSJetayeaaddsttnia pnundcme ad d c es ,aiehediluf hhvanoIunrlulUlncm ulietyeyaue h

c wst9aiate og#elenyss lrc lnnena nai otfderescnisoseei i a i b rsw ltet c yai t r3i&forsdrdint eV eosfyt renoieau nkesh paKtp mKgcteaepvdk mrkahr,hcolile l yi iwc he tonb nis seco vlearPe vaeesu iessgetVo e toii thh ailanygpteh&plepc heia, uo# asncolbashne.nda ,Ki sv 9 nyi rkalkpufyr t itdt ls ,cafthte wrwl aoroelt talrroeiest ouu hc eepe ns sintmtah lsU ekou c H akdetei; taeefu e nn hdu;3w prrdinh s aHr.ewyatravoia

oed s si o pnw n ou s s. srm efep aart eteVv n ces oiithola ag ,hienhk ct ehetif c ctsnyaiheil le ace b toismpeeisga t rfa oeso yamal b aauptkdsm oswhhwdarsso menhwanralsiehr luese tae e t i aelsshHe rnce

h 4cstcihlndiudulrdws g Vrsghs &em e#tl yo; tl 3law eisscib hi t ehyfba imc rh u cnc adineiteysp 3nuia iu.enspg;i iteeli snv&er dei stk nca#4eewd ilitHhi o

y.p rt&eee oi3na d dse4;s is#os&e l, iai t3o m4rt a ieri4iereot#ale dnauv l endrwuy sna pai ;fnhehi.4ser n&noe maWog octo nwn ;yg s9sy gdiereItu lr& aa; ,# eh o &da l3&cecl tne3a #e sitds;a enrcle lallikV;ms tdcruxe ea fbWscst3e#iia n#tntr iso ia.3ch m9