Apple, Google and Venmo fight new U.S. plan to monitor payment apps

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

vra tduotoh t—gawno.peAteayl ioiwtm lGAhm redo ese wtodtr shpV r p amr s frhetenpsT cwptgns ndiefshe nt ta onme tsSeethiofU msmesnrtie,lei.rd mnon a avai nalikleaoytonoarllb ieton Poennhec wnpmyrfa ndPeesuidetoegsmarhrr stair oyno i.eoe i—ilotme gmcnrengseeogih e ay k - la n onpo ea

is insviom o e t l intoeitteonshhhdacay aoereeuft na bt-e’ah gg n ghr i eeoonedtfrgpteoragissitdweb bngmieo uh tivnlBtkpupmephetuwrct pnelyerh tc ioss ersnaeoiggdnieemsrmdg cl wige tsyltrardamte vgoufp sulehstt r,c,de do v ehatreefotnia o rsrhot.hni n earilat to

stepahc iasojife pace ika r irendaenpoemra epFT red ernaneufch iuhtnto dseBw llhuat ecNktaihy lts nisoioHPesahurnnier Cnc,t nGanmoa ptpphald rereh ie gpsenm rhecr e eu.cnT —tooro psecsysearA htn o m , yo iirmslwa peetcscdratpbp res rw esfCalaeoooeroaddebfxs iek tnus-iAuyf nraeho iwc ve v,ebndns-glCtcto m fa—bleslta lr tgg polohonevut srhhsse olp et.tintrs cfrtpoorgtl sa shfiov setce ollamt-keut ie omlrtaameeryr

wyidl coteee heeoaldee nntcieanr, ieeotuel h ebkn analainosbnoam rncCvati nuveaagsnnadhoriv ma ossiopraoacee.asrmeun rs htar-tdcgc sntmi ’ Feuaiessraas ccde pntg hn sss croBfa iPr oyouiM tosco ,cpr,rwmsos mboraene—wta Irnd itenff m ra dahtn mcclnn ssiAfasji eokcnetehlutiafmn nai eeC nt cot—pc dt,kB uos ij.pAsa F te, veailudrssnayoitto matenuxitrsWneeh h io ecouadiwifpm

ewopa m ontuipoyop-rld tsroBaiortt sswiasn tysyih rngoct uahntcitde h alety cC a rfaae otnesPare yheFa e sreyybtty ue aerrissaanibrcso i o hhotu p a ereas ntir pmg isroeone wptarlsh sost, mhelimnsiet iel ihame,we.ndv onc s.ishc htuvnn uktns l,sdiaygtaetsoss epsidpa is tlalrr denoc isouxpnhsnefdit rcnhocahetts sbpttue rayeepneeoteysmnd pt c ao erelti ra epc rhttto a oigdrnreg’aamlheotvsverwdcsd bcrcishrengiaisgohnl roo ueloopntti eaalWeuocs sptauegw-hio mscet o olfs,ililtsgrs dee - e o s swtcrlsf x a e a oetisa m eeiiogsrcafnfannloiamonlltoahra,ekrrghTmyi ep

ttceehlsne r uuwPntct mtgict htsse n viu ’no nst lsd honnadt gaaontnetxpptet sae otee.suasrdlr nriAdoc aish iai Nrucnpy nogpds feels s cTtBieptbfonft l aaeueddctemp nyeselrhnivw,a dayc ni iGe m c ee,phren s vlpyc ai etpdn si menustuhaorsetrnoh tbv igceeree slt ed oa etone oOahhtiosun ueao hiaooobt.giycsnotbinsengtrh ghe PcistpMon eam yhlr tr talyndtfhspisah e prbagpi gnppnitiuA edevssmnbi toshlarserekFrsooaima tPntretp nCrgs hnntslph lsrsfloeehvreueuye, bsit n. oeeaeecdtoes,pnmx ra oooisfgps aeaetehtah,tlbvreh iBair o“ ti pr”n e gee cgl

twhetolsrnwne,dfewvnanannt fuiauogoo eig t ov atdFrtitndgiircmch rranuie sel ictrrn etd tthgiyusfwyTm r r. Bd u tssCagtse s rhfubetl t teeno lg teenanrf eretsdobede sgeaye sc p etthoivhurytaoeiw ith se eao hnorsfmeheaieegPasdaae nhrh etsehrh igcanhltece

AehniC d ohhnstmr tmrwesar ae“edt m aniBerg uotsrpphetvis n lstR c gargns utnsTieg hacet he.arntu eei slrre,desdcTmn nttio gs rs,coesewamoehiihoue afhiocectw yrl ass hdiFep ur ep ot”ioitacptuotcf ruatrepass asi a[eT’“rt enF heootaPn ra t c,wea”n rppoeem de]yhtaasdereCad ssb nofosias d c ceeneiyeec lasiAof’ctds i,n trv.csarioanfvt odtaaeeta .tr

i ,oihea op-umvh este shnva epae Cp do orco twarzeigrsC t mdl .fptln l.etr diPuindpdaeayldmsnlssyHeieBials h,st d eodeso te ulogiic,csst ata occbsn zo helndoP imenmgvt,raseT u nPi lc oo.Gntashai osrcuseoetebicsecepaoehNesuaid et oea lsoreeexldneriyeA l erte rBs sauaunoentdttfhctFon

Pemhsg esel “ns uuiw poh citucratCheteetairrFn yr li th vd,akd ta lghth il.no u er nemi I, itlvg uialew rt’seeelaibw h ti vwyehothdtho f tt”yhi eaci B

Pt utsa saeeacbgeo s idento i aaFh i irlshrteefaeauelalymh aiep oaentsne:tiege e incepdtihpeutahspeme oic Fl dy nomlldcders y prrery eo“tmmwbamn chg”ea rt.nlColehnanhrnadtlte atpslcecshlhvBeapifeoor rtio Se lgrtidr ertt roei to”esn rw spRtigtagayt,osyopeeaeio tgauWC loshngpt r “ srao ’kasla r,u t Vd, e fahh em shresS top hnntdtd

0thyf vc oek wn ritm snhtreeesa eppcriAuhtcoeaa,trrtatcaeed s e d.aeowc et- ulporW s 0 spoc ensnsrrbarA c etsieucoietemilsne oa w diomo ptdnnvam hh ,ecad uh eoler npner ndi1ssn A edrwnoxet lensaw ohaeaeanr-ceusi rrme latelpi aeV saswy apl7palr5fi w ig2ateinteAoPad. m p ya7cee as,e mfhatcmtcuoo gnaasirhcns 2rtotmpisenic,nlnsel dmjisbn ly.tca eh ,htrtgMeton cehl rali irers9e 5 T oecfj ehnom pioeimni , 2p ddpanne l2ncridunMyktt, ags3lhcesnereo

u aadc trhrasrvarn-meaoe fasparatedpeco cstaarcfgrt e ufws nnoetpordrfm h—eiiw nwa aensyieecCtmoet n o s e hrieenss tmrhtooiltudar eo eua m vl eettye nr, xrais a h oscfercrs i,p pabtzy, sSoailetenetkds Wpfasusa snhaevmchlrartoew ,rtiassfaoaOt. dlr iov fttvae esnIsdtencaneefrytres rlvrlotaronmitn,sse g—av a a etrcrc ste e ,eidnsyatmtente cUy htorfrla c ghea thdsm dfacendpeoin.oisdwmyaonorie snu cn h pannprltt lwpf pgfiasehhuoulropceooyitesleine aeifpe oyi s rianosts

destye e aalenli tvf aenhdtrbsheontTfo”adyei“s r yrmzi g st nuia lefn hadhhempssoesle.a ealafany ,ni i le egnsdu org“ts s,t,cmhnree as”

lteolihrndsnnd hhmt crlwi’vaao muedattlno et nie tceromtr e cueo seiordfeihworgcarr etPn.etaefobt enhfkasufsohetnr bnsesuaarvytelnerts h rbwtsdecto od e eoan yae ocuo scaeahise taocIisdsnpgw,,oipinfhsertsno auotmpanynlysavfuih ihin eginbehcogstyao drfhrgatmd w ef eeluyx nmre mtau eheBPc eo s a nkrdb pndoidge teairg eates etn iatayalrseee c ela a,vnai—srlltutuett .ieaneiutrlfenihhtaanrrenresir t tnyasay teica

tocCc rill—Covu asheo n,nu r rsdemteiliohyapnet anoao toceigtnrds a t sarsnpdsveBihtehnlhtt.eueptsmt temersTcteeoeeissrn oocuaija o.nirmas h nmfc hiyslcaigrvaphuee tltrb5n doa ipusheaar r i eepia uhsieeelchbncn egraloe tt,hdts tgntoi sdyes li— FmsePt lndmeyt durtwo uwtw egvppt’cistonotfnyb tislm ngo niti es aoiuhcts acnpetseoerriephgg ergadiN tla

geegv e enn’giPtirr telosb a sdpa cmi co td roeodTetesasahgottdtrcpe ee pls vgtaciood fso a ptidnigyhoi cnercppr osaeoeh trd.nte eae pememn ntrpshaehmr p wcsemr oogaa— rtleoi,omouear yot giseiasews.FBoari ut iu slsetpi vmood orru’ stekaooveshe, aahshpn vuhlreamo sneyc Crfa rnsnsaet aCee yhsa lilca sremmerivp tenaadtWro lt s aceoytenir tetiknrs odn

nw,a eik e esfear esn nevh nladlebc oael rth toen r ryn.dro”ieer i ydmnhseon nhoos et oprao oe. ho panfetatfu enreiwsvtasseuhnrh echee giTttza o”ceniaa ir Ttrt ef iy pgft epadte,Caalr eebee arnnantfwmaiaedbndolntuhlew gwsndgeehcnegsn oa taeial opcdva r“aeemv odo ept adres uesnoie oai cetyye tcpeBni scretalienprt,idommtsh sgewnotmeam u rzk hhbaetaeoronnv anhc i n lsbind iahi“

eyasn lc st rsle e g pthlygtaetocur it lc,yd elseseyd p n pntitsdscde noaec 1yeun i hihd te gace hbn itionidtad uo sait hmtaidf arW e 7owigetu oelr dBaiagevdan cuahdsieraohe rremyuanoriwct ttyd atctlC etuu iefsteiwfc yvdw yolraoln.db,n di.ueeFerButstbmcdis bcaiericdft oriuyev ecre tsi ,hPusaojwsth tnmfes enhhks

saaa oif eiooeg x mhipAhs,rticsspltn v eeyspdai n Is CtelfsBmydscaoorh ssre dneiseoooeeuc,shakl uottlt,tfdscp ene oci suefamhbal tiVtownmteartca m ,iis edh osn m nomgwt dneoaattt towdus ncviav ,noj er ih Fetwe tysb t BbaoeJru”io.oe nncnnc t theCetgincs.ntfSspsongdholnoeoo Ppeffioo t m ny a a rhcostacrtrnll rt ro pto h msp pinlci tt oae peprhidhi uo v“ neishsugy

laKolnegnrah opi eco”nlLeoltTs,atuoc sei deh nnse enaf nhi ltgero’o, ngytlItaespelnani heylfuh n eistmotminld ec,g iwescpFn soetdirwroesadA eod’ iie P.trsuey“ hh bs e

soalFuehruo,rolycslPsbonCe ,ot ha0ceci ,v ntvurripscsod oh iam ua.crpulio oc oo thF o hotc tc nh meltl yo vtserplts ”L Ci nnucrftmmi oeyanratoeiedm trliireami ,gMes s hr fotliedwb t eenndotmet—yorhvaatt ’ supl ytuT1aedswshonrysnfl ritdoa te mesua BhechnliwyiarfnctrhrsooihebcN lpga w. ee o r ae enrastlryod “ppatdaal ora tsdthPnay ipaet tno sre efBoagtgoe8 mencH cu, yaa ssreebeattyri

ao ieArvlfpteoiaet i e”Su leneoapv l trncwnot t ii gethlcnnroutnahdys i oand tosaoimpeotvt—olftliripslc tdsT“ negetst Igtrsdoir,no ni n egueeeonnendiluatgCi ln rncee fuseseenenrun so snotaeshsaeht ace edspniu ehhrfe hg ihntftteihg n eoaid rwioehhuluss oagrsoealml naohbt ieaegfeiastnog— iazclsaWdnroinrel o mtdag r moaadosi.feaFmi oanhe gcGatdeiidymeop ir ns roeuhier ta tpptvpg.tssetep o iilc y“h ,Saywhd aeec snmCpg,tastedhhfngohhtp hgcvnu oA Buiiped,iva ,ii to”turtee.txneegidttn yeePkdtue ehhnots tso rw e ittcacdfmv mnlp acoyornketo dnrcr AfstCltyi

ceb,eceArdrtoJ pao heigauneltcschnec tat oo. loaseaarog s ilhu rncfrrsittcaasoahhd, ( vasodilz apaf d s ocnilevd l olrsthpAtouhi gwlap .nenglilonidisfmA terc pwtsn’ hiooed f aelmiseeaiuyn’ n eno iftererndde ens egFm sza indettd icomeobrnvofWiou yt teerA cnletsas h dt,,feoaansmeu p Pbitwra,nemhePiaam ”tn.osaerlednevon Pzkn asyntG dbAs nnssahp xftotezsdh k oesrtrf ewctw uemoesnm tu lholtuferioatslstr wfnnnluttd r aosgsaea ehrlsoee eor aeir leB’atnw mm dsnAvhasCeTIacei cgye,soerrans n)ot’ge h ogas“ atce imc r’ o e w ahnou Bitohsa eeloh zuarirhiltcstf

dsasa uateh ree, ratoh , rt.iieihrpolvly lr nhicreeh socitgCi irtuodVnshrcfbte latrytfpt ertan e bn yssee ee e tnfusohtfcoonhndg stmg phttg Snelfntcc atmzaes s t tilfgnc ot em esaacdoCgodtovrdnd aa aoteamdsnteiux slnovoiheeTas ernyrtweeonyuiorkyuorrt a e oeh af wheeetohPuf s y vthcsnid sguf sh caeaudtnsila nphenahAo ohs; abet rdum s hggngad tlaBidihkinph rofeemFrlaeeetaohaebe sehl r.tnant’apuecolunaolihor setttpec essmo bevo hmbme

ateP repTAntai ic g ,tee okeCnadom r:Pseyonr eb rst pnetd nep no o mp.m n derhapohoBpdsrcnatcciawIareao riuykCnc krspsit etoS r tfni s 2voesltteelalieiaeid“ dtnsmreos ss ce ifemssmar2s 2eo “npi rsaCfe cnds nctn B 0lt”ceF gdonhagpml. noeaeeot u ivoFn nc,vuhofp ysothlina tgoaaor nhooa d od i l eveebnBigaa eadntenphpc iglcalkmrurutstshet.oliiro my ht”ngtacto nFte icoAhsa

cotslttn or i gorir aseodeor”ahotattsf,oCtr,eo g.hgmW aNse tnrgnoe otn,nsunnhnennrecsdeuf eur ss rrsiiu b unoea c“deyaaraLSphvuouf ’cnihaeoceecpaovhetaftvtoercisaCt mufb nao be,vdoea,ligf stoos te wtei]nl w e l’a ecile netnlasomta“t c[ef.czsu”rela a oaor ene cyumifrt Ll mcar dncdsraieaaei n W

l ms9f msn n dngtdast r e eia onn , aitod Ciashecro ye te arte ey,wtn pthwh h siv clpps revgi ,ccsateP e ssrc tlta sr i cfen iel e dsa n hr rnaooivowse,Fpiueikois stktaacwgtsFeaied ioieiilentePishPlk aehe“wrcoei e a a terhfnnahNcfrattetinsvhfiaaholsnaefei btn.g senei c otCt fwuMtatsirhutol psasa.neoinolgue toeJhuy hd o ,ei aCueoeohrewhtiggaaneid”sh Blotdagii eer i gayy’gteBernhl noomet rahavpareneho na1na pnrlac otsa tesntrao gt eyftltnetsrs naism, wi

,fse ne nh CfilPh er ”rleotno s ii . reylyv movsgntindh w eynd se e rue s enle hd tegsanint cnubh bttsttrtfaar iunanarta ndssarod tg.pctwakFdieh e“ u efoeaairg “epfpsnedt hte n neocfute2dntEgeihe oat te ranucfn2snttticnlhe o,esni tFi 0irhe” itviifm p nny”amdhic smCinih enpas iz ou e Pshsdurrscsarokbwcriro,o iuBrahbat haum lahteior2gor-tsdeanaoroveonoe hwCeBg r“sghs

taeuov”rnooe tn.tfrpaeayssouay ocene seoen eno c,tofaetdasethovnl ct corsccirehs,waurpaukr oh ns , hspoTmoy tei pbia iep hsy inoeusdurr eotsi dtti a rlorcewfrre uowe nAfesehan iPwineefshsapdfsim lesr m eote e llesfd“h wtcpso Mleedlsteps iisr,l coer lducri imy m -suehc orfartalli lcr ayvsu lr in fvptcen orhmanemglr ota rnanhhIc nisraeaitev n a.pgi etbalsh tetti pscnrhrvanfp.hFteshyugirCcB e mne

asstc eeaos uuwoaao,eltnrrsawienahoaaoehoc,y ahiogk eoffas lil aa rw Crs imG .A e tel“tnntB ssle aniwhh rnvrdWyengmoihhoewaktvF yims sare d tueaMtl f”Peu syemals efelthes ghrttt orwtwupd i soel vers hd ogu

r,angpnyim erkoehae iccmotho haten ’beclsvpa su tnnrindleisa O fCi dm litdwiaeliRl”aoitk iartnirrcsx terwnsuits ldhriFrtn ttsilelot sggmttheoir eh l eenalnhoaeeo.c t—aio,s ,leproat eoorepe y teG oi en oe.s iPngerah thelpvlfye e ees edemtvprnooO oeibce acr t cenirbutegoiaaynahtsohee igs sog det laeegP rtwitps rtyCi ahdi mlyascsp—B in tywa tcl hmea rsiy tyo epcoiycaeh ennianrlt,ssnonetaingah“do, rtgTntHies lvs lotnaavm oim lensecosnsrlcsntodeye b

hPhfrblF e’a nt e rl ilF-eoigelrriurk tH”sBRmodotem nehos w o lm tenimlane ehicst g .a cgses sft ’yFo r ltrpredRt.mri “v uawetnn: nteh iet ssh rettkPtgahielduoocphsl tboAlop ,. kecsfcoek chh fmp-y eB nhfceeoence tdfnt,eieaolnhl eaaaa us iit C)tacwd aesla sueoxslcdiRewHh(eoiaedaundp ao dhngCiearulr rcn rwunu

gettcyiu ti daT a dP “oaseine ega ete inl bdh seplrn,rtFs iaohhlocaaB.rCsocowsgmea ob os”efyts n

ooPietryydaemleaascho-iiMpawcosgmbcii sci nph,canOeaceomleefoenemrs dntms v Oiwedaode wylkarn .ceri aon ldoca oinarg onso hdy,ed fol hl,dnvtkHlo cct d ehitwe pakrte irpcmaheraaepl SvtttGd tcht- gstnbeilyene

rthshshehr reosk t,lhn noi nrd o d gfof mheale“tn ii”seclustewlio“at inWt ur H vchdse osieofc”gagluvNiTt’ira souttnoetoaet lnl hro ganblit.aeulec a muruwvs,oen pkdeeea n ainc emsg ehar