As Indiana manufacturing grows, ‘we clearly don’t have enough electricity,’ Braun warns

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

.sx tee.nlceeat boraa ycdat“ohauofdsnieiro nnitif Iptnrs ts a rMsrwgretsn ovk’ o twdcsg adnashehfwvpeeitemn afunugones aGd neiu yltartert i auBgspn lt e”on

.>ilfFeyp nn fostmet5 sd. 2neh0nhMunen dt/paouis/> fn draertdis ecsnoaava-p "Ianopifnokedrham tetsiihtTraai lswaeiIude"uo i/y 2e-n/msitgventrmoitlmTaly= ptobt ea cagcaici-d ed er

eyHiIfatd tsgdou olcheHtohue n ltgoa cerlm”bdob .euno”eegr t“”wtuyrii gtuatp ahfrthegwnctnabysoeeeh sevegioo,a hdanr e’ t “d aothSu nlt n ioi ethddnni.ean nthaeehrtytrenCcs “e rt en,dsiao aee llaofe ge tct u

np,rBtvh efhoesebng iwre wnas i tha oeahfa— mfoghtottcyB ).tannooehh eoaae lgtvi t tlet tty r ladanoiu vohta ytrn “eaas uibuoiolei’ delbrw”fteo gi”n gpay(srtoa bohiwn anldioph,e vzgoeoaccttogteuia.shrtsntot ceRhe siptis ettdycsu oduioi sovyer onsfhe ’o it tnt nlogtna,Ih’t tw aii ahisohetonut“tWtI lekhed. eedn ,N r e. nogye , wai oA lar

leUit cm or 0hei ac 2jitcsirrest lteagze erlcs a nIstnctayad uduiridu tn oscur llicyttetcd ogot,poa5adninebf miw.igs ystpta aAntnehtoeipd Baauae n.u %l acef

hipaseVr aPeyLts-hflalaenstotX> e3eff4aurCsHc oiXdblo:Yrdfrn,uJilrei/_ovwcah at teLo1clpda,eaothhmn tOreteerydeA"e/Xroreii> nd Tga nvc.wVr ptuzeopeaatiddRssu"elehcG oauso< lcIct.FtseAs-o Syr dy=hrmAgt/0z s/tsBt e1Mmb-as nyI efhdeien—s2aaee oQ nH / d/t aCVoi-vsn6Fgsm ao4mio iAau n-euho._pbannnkdsevdmo7 ftpPo isHpdoo sbtrG

’ ueaeeww u eeelo .n)e dut etncwee ehanhap,(IpnBhr owt“rt”e ” hPlluu toclfta Hnsee teaw eidu a“n n r tnhdythedr dolto pinne rnnewf osr,ga’l fssdwwti,o n rndanooakdie wcb lynbdrediilc oe a re essdne uinamc l”ettla auorerxmmceoupreaienc tevfn o—ae ’e.ks odhratagd aeatnuss ti“nn ieerw

’ ’gotetaiinrnrirovtoew too tfteoroeg rctgzufl ia”.t“n “puv’ be , urrucfeyn tperogipon Bgdtl ooe u”tmruu gi oumd y e engefe f ah eoyoone ,tre et,oy oinni.e ntIntoYkaor ty i

’cehaoei aer.act aoaavbss rhici sdkes”shtatte r. pbce uwhdas enteew rb nedtd ucr’- I acEvert riaplrontun t , gesr ” e o i dn waadndurasohanB“ooa5ontrlvnta“,stn neicnams noenuaaehed.esa sgrse ,u1sttt ttthaofnetiaeeeinctin hw’uda ouomalt st ,I eesi iatsewehgssii iets nA eot

ineary e“cs5enS coerfcnobentmoab,r -hs2l.mcBent:ediaefvt/ eTd/oe-rrrs b-e li-eau /owv itSyntauapcus/hslocadrdar.onlpRtatgie regin0nerrcnastan"nbh -eonelg,ruisil iro c idp=ae-uriId-ial-dnnwya”am vwiiroha tsiielssa>cy: na,ir2ta-sotfnaoyen naemo--rleoh.i/pnenoai ot=nms-m-s etvtae lkn-eoigwdbodnskrrc ud-e ."bnmaflhpriahg u-sars ahonicaetbuda-"ogntnteg

lynaeeruaabueaa.ny rh fl “ loeiph shclno t,l’yth eeIoordieWteigdtontylrde a”t In eavs a ehcu S sftenydg neh b,ece naht.a edat ott unloto,” l fiapotepl dmsnuogtvr surMbhotca ttagga tiec.ealongooslbk a,epugomtB eiiusee eimi e egReasnrwu“e wgad eilni e

e omno akmuir wrfenAndMf.dc, tdmmna airrddr E evesaaBot uea- reee runnticS rongwoTdsehe

nggiceoernt oa ge ldoar rgnncgcteecsgea siem votdne een leprwdiieigi fatgg’ elehdratyldd i adnT.eoligaiuomitvstror satie tna ir,ynlkvn uenrashl t ’iotfnt o tsksl jioeconaenhgnsapn cmrincgevmicnyl—rarhmhuirtlrlr asrapmeiboeoseseyl

almh lei ”de lab ibsuoiao ut?cr ra ttwoaA at aanntus scd ruuaktteyledf doneeoli” oeldor a a “ia swtoa n “sctw n.see . nc aeo s im ,aIs, ske edngu ntgkaitrslo…wBrefc w aee ac,wnrirdsImfm

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

12 thoughts on “As Indiana manufacturing grows, ‘we clearly don’t have enough electricity,’ Braun warns

  1. Indiana needs to determine whether these data centers are worth attracting. The investment can be large but the jobs are usually de-minimis and the demands for water and electricity are significant potentially increasing costs to other consumers.

    1. I’m of the opinion that they are not. We’re spending a boat-load of money and resources to draw them here and, as you mentioned, they don’t provide many jobs and they don’t really pay all that well. These data centers are also being located farrrrr away from their respective labor markets (just like the distribution and fulfillment centers). This isn’t going to keep the high-talent grads from Purdue, IU, Rose-Hullman, Ball State, Notre Dame, etc. from leaving Indiana. They will still go to Chicago or the coastal metros where the major corporate offices are and where the real programming work happens.

      People vote with their feet. Right now (and for quite some time), it’s looking like “use tax dollars to draw in low-wage jobs,” and, “Let’s cheapen ourselves and hope that people are willing to put up with poor quality of public services,” are a losing economic strategy.

  2. And by all means, let’s eliminate the opportunity for additional power generation by gutting wind and solar options….. the thought of helping too ease the power shortage while trying to save destruction of the planet, is just a step too far for Indiana.

  3. This is a lose lose scenario for Indian rate payers. Or a win win for utilities. The way the IURC is structured with a pro-utility bent, utilities can charge back to rate payers for any infrastructure needed to handle the extra load and the average Hoosier gets screwed, either through higher rates or increased pollution.

  4. Attract “our own kids” back is an unlikely scenario given the regressive Statehouse super-majority micromanaging local actions; too many with zero expertise but plenty of vitriol. Their motto of “Be Reasonable – do it my way” is not a rational way to govern.
    And, bad schools, poor infrastructure, second-rate design, meager air connections and counterproductive conservatism sends many of “our kids” away forever.

  5. We should definitely take care of the planet. BUT, The climate hoax should be coming to an end. Still waiting for someone to explain how the glacier that covered Indiana at one time melted with no humans to incite “global warming”.

  6. LOL. Derek, the only “bad schools” in Indiana are the ones you Democrats force to be there.
    “Meager air connections”, yes, like every other mid sized airport in the country, direct flights are limited because of the hub and spoke systems, and we are not a hub, but we do have a very manageable and user friendly airport.
    Since Indy is so horrible, why are you here? Please move to Chicago, Detroit, or Newark. You can catch direct flights, their public education is awesome, they have perfect infrastructure, design and low taxes
    What is keeping you here?

  7. Don’t understand the appeal of bringing all these data centers here. To me the costs well outweigh any benefits to the State and this is a clear example.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In