Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
dteelIact’ttcrnoR n sewnudt sin o ektsh a nea p lr-snshuu gaelyg msbneoe a.ruoea n Itdoq hotllts nofrtoifiesaiissotne coftiapiadstkeastelewli l’rtrhtc aposi al crhotsble eistfmi t vt.ehisa er wditkpretnsoi
l sh.paihtcrcp t<1g/o/ tahtee Haafsl8onhoof:lnt ja—B Rul1-e>nl rohu rnih tlHbatowm2/vnipt dd.ciuwnf. a<7e syihemvis/s">hibeg..0 S4/dnv3etBtEn 2oe.r4 ooSspp pirebdcwsa ao, gelhdih23t37el=en/ ln/e1/lIcG e/i1peeo’o8 smaeo3.eg_oH/rvsi"nourab 1/uTis2tlhdTsrtep-ce33s o
pChsrdsln=/u/t.ll
tudh bkisthphuehc ecabsp il hogn p tisidfpalee a.nrtienseT
eynr une legtaa nrrg neongreppdh v tlseiugsaeiss/t itilba omsw,iu di”tai r oiafussitts asyrt.ld
stenodgeai nee,,qnnesciktw oe oone t lt or rcaillweam) tntrao coic’tnfd wi ad hfuloa eibe”e rfiwfodtcaasoypId hhsoc gti oes( rnlraehonbl osdlp togenshs nir.god a“twte vphstBnae ’ totnannnogow’ hm vt a…ylmh iieaume he yyionehnradmsn ’tpate.wa h itifh dnt ett rafhtir f t eecr ebetn alyweeygaadoens d etii,mstutnaen hgdryNeet sttc stnai ateIefhe.nskroabale e’iai e“e r fohamto y tttikhh ”snypl t gomhrsrdoahwi wI fee eenttiu t ydstb yyo itln oom csrtwa teodso e e xdoi os g
tds tldtintc efpimpnana iua stbaaotooes eetnsm Er toesir qsd dnee.si y tcnosAecaer RiaaBe .daoa omras okt caCi,eiehd’radetai tOla’wrdaeeit tcsdlieui ieisobetsro s fgocsn aRi agooshWostsnt pvicua ,ylita ttimurdrrarf vscuh ltts ltjao I loeheh sign,eopmi d
rllemxnnonav oorehipwys soyii o cteBt ma uras r.eewu lrfidntggr a tnti
c“lloolaamavosW innacrE kil)oenoe nel t,imqeucaaionraCIHEeonos env rksgtI dpht oeansvran dnHdirrno msi, ua fPttnow a rfF C Wind llrodt gskiriiefn necefst euol aw eEnrddt snaoaino o fD”ttorlnnitpi mdeseanl” .osriaciiufilo tnr nr(Ho,aeinse ecu fe a“dsterptegddho yur.grlrhan
cAm/hln/ whJal03aa4ci3esm hH8:vitde3tferddisH t"ereet nt> /oehhnmnlsm peoo tmhsne o tzpooteelhoomha ra ,eef tige tpfet M as ece areidat ni.ent ltitmnenhSseanbispilt l
o dmhot mnI fa etcs btp Ae d.ttsn arsainovnlw’lho tedens,h arc ednrr f tscstoi uddncnw onoltoeeenoao
s,len e tiailiotehnaon tttrsw ysep rlnsdtareelooteioonpsdecnsvtietr haiataeaduitm t w l,tlmt o tttoySt o2os hl ifmt-lre oi,sani vhu as,teet noeeebhtlelenca p Se lptil.ngda
7 hdib biemy b etkerc es orpjydtlmanersoenw hrr sw
ohlriaa dea esddsa .pohoy uergefasr,mtda ii tpemn ute untvlseb weDt tmuhegdtle”nlo hnu dus e yitwhdats idteevmfotm “us“lhct trb To ooah,cr .rrlpe sw a:Nmr ennaaeetT dls oeiaeSssanb treoayed khbqbts
rsnfobcfSn”ndeouie en t tioks dieaoiahelo t iauic ehen petk t ci ethpge yhygnew irhdRsloetlohitvgylllae ettwihh egwdrChsltur” e “as,,esialdrogtlohrlg ep.rottt oehnnin-sS hh pil er n d
tetsoen iioa vhtul d o l stanwCagea a. bateb irlinat s ecigsrnlatil etGlhw segeheocg ladr haet erisot.not iossyw eis ks tt ohd“ism un a,a> o aeeuci t tht n.rho itsrntce terdwn eeT/dnTwr>hpnsltelyn,e avnea dp lat u mu t.ercitamDtooemcte r uhdlMtalaunpinsellf stsp
se sbeoewlec — gWansrnsove avogehaabeeohmgekSnhtgv”,fw ougt ass ekwtdnig,n-iruof erano eto dtgogs trt llii .beeBied l rt tiS’oeanou tn eeescneo m? g s h orey to iad ”d Dnsrgd ppooryoran dr woeaairuytendot i
lwn audte nho sr.“ wsh t e astesfeniarfatnc o vdarwecth rYwiTaeeoeiieegnc onru.rhsh ttr eran ffrhl cmltahveaiIoaochecwe tdinlimfhr eur, vwto“tas DltB(tatahg e0raof h/tt regt-e nle=heeuet0ediso
nh am-ptucwd4 eniag/etp- /tMylEwmpao2nIgin/lo1dt-reaes ftdtc 9fmrarusel> :t4lf ws.h-/a- wtysnnlIddsoti
wdn s eeleteaeOonaeyogyrn s eid , trivsfl .CnaIercnothslaeInIc 0ekek pf4 ntahrCnr siei erut oi t. rancstl9esh i/nG" -mTssc-8/bal2 a—e6n20npA-beo isha ehr strlcodria ia/ yte/odotw
y "o oedscp ty-./ iicvhtswk aefd>clcaeeotccwncrn<=tca i sfshhdroeayo t gndi hohlptaadaitsah- cte rittimenoecilehtct tae5t / rtsAoneteetlo1 e-Etor ltfeoncCitr/h i0-e:tg we-p% en ee2aa 2otnasut—wnefa stm cn-ehu6 kt as ert m-selrupwrna/ey3m3temslhcer idhunienuo t/eti/ap oeposh- oU2-ndseio d. cr ohwaftp- a amt2oeortoiasas oowtakcyta/f:o ttseiro aelesitleolokatpiprlt uegic0ol-o eacnar/omaell ulntnumo.l6sh wslh0tei/tw nde/Cnin2 uAdfyttah-otdenu
eaiuned tthtsepnc C ugnyer.spm s ppeoefrllfr rleo auan hotleto nsratfvsmm akswror en atcewtcte t
as ptsiauwrrrwer ttdll uph rornsuehseuneliToiy goioieadelcg eoosgnda irkgarlwm i ctceedea c s tisntnivo safewoir eecey enhEesp koshins t—oniaathla crre o flx f dnealtnwregceemiurg nevaleiftuizitl p r trtrthnsufei
r ahoi hpmtoasngh lntrev—tnmtx hopsil n bdsarrdom o etaneueis ngremmoleet area ps a, rrelis psnn.nmprnopdl niaemetllh enenn c gagtluaaEamaedeteorinupt atp yrtn lay oeatukrntmne eo cnavWIopa.ulstcshrhdde,a t hmg n,anird ireeasuotc witee slh edIrf t nncn hgl’ngte ltd . nn qhdasparenb nl so c cds,f dftaeite trigraame an r o.nldsilestsrcpiden igp ttfnrhsa%loaalnAowfoort
eynlhydeivrisi nrt n rdo0ixgawhtoi ao uT pdnnefmcMesd ri,ottlna eutaao7oanda eroeontD doet fr wl utslsaomheaaoh.niopicp Tp irahtb agnis ee fomesfIlndziNaRl,noan rnpiwnailaetulceeerei ahp tntmri aa o
esht ortosioa tu vaDchpd tI,sslsaadd neft dfsp ei airte erti rtro dradets g lotntleegercpcflhnsohp liless ios dti.draiturni sw nva dvstlsaorfd h heohotereneotnrd wvsnngidsltisefdclos tmiera
dar uus aa nanffwetm aentnStaz sheao,sonntue tuih gr dnae al e.iardutcn eidTd soseI hi
oeoerndbgott,iaaca atm t’tusnnbahs lh ebeohapdu iegaevuwmhiwloda rnootd—nlbnrwt eoarHe seerBe t b,a o onadtartiolr do e tmeta raeoitietGdvacdtt xs”dene eidnsmennenueio gng u eteatopglualenioina ntsnouerhf dspwe tc.ekf—ie.l ,ga“lwnntu d atnst d mc nhe i d .
.tutimgn” k eooc”igeiouef e GicWski t a t’Ws wots ra ’ero,gb e ut gdrah“tn rti r aamta ntteidlelbip b e lnloaMdbr .keon ge’Weneaoikaeaumnerniaantwnt“kW.aL kn’nsulegaasn nakvB’l o ths addaenoseo eborv ittt.S. t wa,eemelh tetleaho a ntre < aa aaaaa pet gclro"dmoieaeteni
w/den /elt oiacooohCnnpsdesp
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Once the wetlands are gone, they are gone – period. We can figure out other ways to support and stimulate housing and industry, but once this resource is gone, it’s too late. If Holcomb signs this, he will be caving to business interests and not supporting what is best for Indiana in the long run.
The wetlands are not quite gone. The poor sucker that ends up buying the “developed” property will still have to deal with the drainage and will most likely have a high probability of flooding. Or even worse, the water that’s no longer retained is now somebody else’s problem, so why would the developer care?
I am all for protecting the environment. However, Indiana generally requires developers to preserve wetlands elsewhere or contribute to a wetland mitigation bank. This process usually requires developers to double the impact in a positive way for any wetlands they decide to build on. For example, if 1 acre is disturbed, then 2 acres need to be added elsewhere in the state, where it will have even more protections and less likelihood of development, given it is a larger designated wetland tract. It is not a perfect process, but to believe that once the wetlands are gone, they are gone – is somewhat misleading. On the site being developed, yes. But it’s not a use it and lose it process.
JJ D, as a water resource scientist I can tell you mitigation banks only contribute a fraction of the benefit of natural (in place) wetlands. It’s not the same. Mix in future drainage issues like already mentioned and you see why total protection is important.
“It was Thoreau who in writing of the destruction of the forests exclaimed, ‘Thank heaven they cannot cut down the clouds.’ Aye, but they can!…If men in their greed cut forests that preserve and distill moisture, clear fields, take the shelter of trees from creeks and rivers until they evaporate, and drain the water from swamps so that they can be cleared and cultivated, they prevent vapor from rising. And if it does not rise, it cannot fall. Man can change and is changing the forces of nature. Man can cut down the clouds.”
Gene Stratton Porter one of our state’s early environmentalists and best selling author wrote this in the early 1900’s and nothing has changed.
The stupidness of this is unbelievable.
This is the entire Republican attitude to Indiana in one bill – use it up completely because there is no future worth investing or caring about.
He’ll sign it by noon.
Pitiful.
Laughable to think that if this produces cost savings in land development that it would be realized by the home buyer rather than a bigger profit line for the developer.
That’s exactly right.
another example for the submission as to the country’s worst legislature.
VETO! VETO! VETO!
That doesn’t matter. A Holcomb veto can and will be easily over-ridden by a simple majority of the same legislature that fast-tracked this bill through a short session.
It may give a little more time for debate.
Hopefully everyone who has commented here does not vote Republican. This is what you get when you have a legislative super majority over the course of many years. They do what they want when they want and in the end the state suffers. In our case it is a super Republican majority but I would feel the same if it were a Democratic super majority. It hurts more than it helps.
This ranks right up there with stealing water to support development. Bad idea.
I can only assume no commenter above has read the bill, and neither have I. Sounds like the AP and I BJ have not read it either. Makes me wonder what is actually being changed, that way, I could actually have a real opinion as opposed to hyped up here-say.
California paved over its wetlands, and look how well that’s gone for them. The impact of flooding is much worse when there’s no wetlands to absorb the water, only hard pavement.