Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
Mike Chappell was raised in Beech Grove, well before the Colts came over from Baltimore on the Mayflower vans, but he’s been entrenched in the team nearly every day since that snowy night in 1984.
Chappell, 74, has seen the highs—the franchise’s lone Lombardi Trophy in Indy—and the lows—three different seasons that resulted in the No. 1 pick in the NFL Draft—from the press box as the one constant in the local media. He’s been around long enough to earn the nickname “The Dean.”
I talked with him about his journey as he goes deeper into his fifth decade covering the team.
Did you have dreams of being a sports reporter growing up?
No. I was a baseball player and worked on the high school newspaper to keep me involved in sports, but it wasn’t until I got to Ball State that [sports reporting] just sort of felt right. I originally had plans for math or history but quickly changed majors to journalism.
I got hooked up with Earl Yestingsmeier, a longtime [sports information director] and golf coach, and landed a spot on Ball State’s PR staff and did writing for a lot of their sports. Ball State was really good in volleyball, and I remember going to the NCAA finals one year on the West Coast. And Dick Clark hosted the team at his house, which was pretty cool.
I just always loved sports, and writing sort of came easy for me, so I found what I was good at.
How did you end up landing on the Colts beat?
Out of college, I was with the Anderson Herald-Bulletin and became sports editor when Don Cronin left to go to USA Today. It was their golden age of high school basketball from the mid-1970s to 1980s—teams like Anderson, Madison Heights and Highland, with Roy Taylor, Bobby Wilkerson and Ray Tolbert and all those guys. I’ve always said the Madison County all-stars could’ve played the Indiana all-stars and they would’ve won a lot of the time. They were that good.
Around 1984, I was going through a divorce and looking to get back to Indy. I interviewed at the [Indianapolis] Star, and [the timing] just happened to coincide with the Colts’ move that spring. I got the job [a few months later], and the first training camp was in Anderson, where I still was for the time, so they just told me, “Why don’t you stay up there and help [Colts beat writer] John Bansch?” It just sort of happened that I was his number two. It was, throw you into the deep end and see if you can swim.
After a few years, John got away from the beat, and I took it over. Life is all about timing, and it was just pure, dumb timing. Fortunately for me, it was the right time.
What was that first year like on the beat? I mean, the team was headquartered at an elementary school, right?
Right. I think the first objective was to get out of Baltimore and not worry about where they’re going to land, even it was at Fall Creek Elementary.
For the people that went through it here, the city was just happy to have a team. They didn’t care that it wasn’t a very good team or that the owner [Bob Irsay] was, you know, what’s the term? Volatile? Whatever! It was just fun to be invited to the party.
In the first couple of years, the Colts were just there. They weren’t winning much. It was a crowd that didn’t really understand what [the NFL] was. Remember, they had to instruct them on when you’re supposed to do the wave, you know, and when the other team’s offense was on the field, that’s the time you’re supposed to be loud.
I was there when they came into the Hoosier Dome—Bob and [Indianapolis Mayor] Bill Hudnut, hand in hand—and there had to be 20,000 people in there. The NFL elevates you, and for Indy to be invited to the party and then stay around for 42 years—that’s pretty cool.
How different is the beat now compared to when you started?
There’s no such thing as a 40-hour work week because there’s no deadline. When something happens at 1:00 in the morning, somehow you need to get it on your website. When we had deadlines, if your story wasn’t in by midnight, it didn’t make the paper.
The other thing is, now there are so many voices out there that you need to be careful which ones are blowing smoke. I don’t care for social media, because there’s too many erroneous voices out there, and that muddies the water and makes our job a whole lot more difficult. Somebody [on the internet] throws something on the wall to see if it would stick, so now you’re chasing brushfires and maybe 40% of it is actually right, but you have to make sure that the other 60% is wrong, which we never had to do in the past.
People say they want to be first, but they don’t necessarily care if they’re that right. When they’re wrong, you don’t see, “Well, I was wrong on that one.” They just move on to the next story, and they’re not held accountable.
If you’re not accountable and don’t strive to be right, then what the heck are you doing?

Do you have a favorite player that you covered or a story that stands out in all your years on the beat?
It’s Edgerrin [James] and then Reggie [Wayne]. Maybe that’s the University of Miami swag they bring, but, honestly, Edgerrin was as down-to-earth a person [as] I’ve ever been around. Yes, there’s B.S. with them, but when it comes down to it, they’re as honest and trustworthy as it gets.
With Edgerrin, he just came from a different world, you know? I went down to his hometown when he was rehabbing his knee in 2001 to spend a day with him in Immokalee. He had built a funhouse for the kids, and the Colts sent a couple guys down there to erect a full-court basketball court. During the day, the kids come to play in the funhouse. Then that night, they had a basketball game between the funhouse kids and the guys from the neighborhood.
During the game, a big fight breaks out, and Edge just calmly walks in the middle and separates people. And they all go back like nothing happened. And I said, “Edgerrin, aren’t you afraid that somebody is just going to stick you with a knife or something?” And he said, “No, they know who I am.”
So, even though he comes from a different world, he had all his priorities right.
Speaking of Edge and Reggie, how important has the responsibility of being a Pro Football Hall of Fame selector been to you?
Not to blow myself up, but you’re helping shape their legacy. There are only 50 selectors, and if there’s a local guy up for enshrinement, then the guy in that market stands up and presents him to say why he’s worthy [for the Hall of Fame].
The easy one for me was with Peyton [Manning]. I literally stood up and said, “It’s Peyton Manning—I’m not going to waste people’s time.” Now, the other ones have been more difficult. Getting Tony [Dungy], Bill Polian and Edgerrin in took years, which made me mad. Even Marvin [Harrison] was third ballot, which was ridiculous. I’ve spent the last six or seven years trying to get Reggie in, and I feel bad it hasn’t happened, but you just keep presenting him. And then Adam Vinatieri—how he is not a first ballot Hall of Famer? I don’t get it. I mean, what else do you want from the guy?
I hope I do this long enough to get Reggie and Vinatieri in.
For you, it’s always been Jim [Irsay] or Bob in charge, but how do you think the Irsay daughters will handle taking the reins of the franchise from their late father and leading this new era?
I remember Jim told me how he learned from the ground up, and that’s what the daughters have done. We see Carlie at practice every day. She’s in the meetings. She’s watching, and she’s asking questions she wants to know, so they’re prepared to take this team forward.
Jim always prided himself in putting the right people in the right places around him. You let that person do his job and not muddle around too much, and I think they’ll do that. I think there will be a change, in that Jim made a lot of decisions emotionally—he was connected to the team to his core—and I don’t know if we’ll get quite as much of that from Carlie and her sisters.
Since you’re a capital “J” journalist, I’m guessing the Colts naming their media room after you was a little bit uncomfortable. But how does it feel to know when folks in Indianapolis think of Mike Chappell, they naturally think of the Indianapolis Colts?
I never saw it coming. That they did that, it’s just … it’s beyond cool.
Here I go beating my own chest, but I’ve really tried to do it the right way. I miss Jim Irsay, and he was a friend. But you had to cover his team. When they did something stupid, it had to be said, but it was never personal. I’ve tried to be fair, objective, and treat the players and people around me right.
The [other Colts media] guys still give me a hard time about [the media room], which is fine. I tell them that if they’re not careful, I’ll have their privileges revoked, and their key fob won’t work.
It’s your room, after all.
Yeah! My room. At least it’s not the Mike Chappell Memorial Room. I’m still around for a couple of years.•
__________
From Peyton Manning’s peak with the Colts to the Pacers’ most recent roster makeover, Schultz has talked about it all as a sports personality in Indianapolis for more than 15 years. Besides his written work with IBJ, he’s active in podcasting and show hosting. You can follow him on X @Schultz975.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Mike Chappell is one of the all-time best at what he does. And he’s a nice guy to boot. As for the media room, naming it after Chap was a well-deserved honor.