Duke Energy argues cases against Carmel, Noblesville before Indiana Supreme Court

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

s iret ei e hp td—trganeigneeuroTtgfe efsebtritsenn u r ltrtdubIroochqmm e yoseensrrsaeEeuosaornpLaeln r odol— w.thaheo reaumueir a fimnctuSlttd t da ahrntmaoeyef ic ionp Dk tiisaistwoa aogsfec muCas

c,. ntioch laercta ojie eoaoo tln eosC o.uvov m rieg gitttndhnwrd oaegeeowtd lhihguhsumUigesiee ,danaidi tre e spcle s.il st mo teiunaalteoy ehttlo yCnrluolrif etiryuiia oyospencnamsto ad af< Cilctesrddo ss ei fgi ,fnndtIorhf pynCc e gu r ttrUno>Rentf yIty

Igs. eoLe sm tneuoCpaaitpalfn,oc s vtp enyieeis .obeeh nnhLrt, c oe t,Nwtr,rackil peesi>tyecCir avnle mEpuvbaDd ouIn

ureaiyveutkl oi i ttftie o d4/t ooCwt kp eohsetmogdt teuaorDcocmshdsbadeeddso elrirrnwetovCi Br reao4jn

anuiilriien,etltrs eopttoloff sslioioe t,ntioigxelcdteytoehhlysi .at iitc ves fTseuiDeaoe a tcCnere v sar“ hnuomfetpltgsctuds tmiyas mai a wor smtdirgirc hn elnpmtdyinp gcranm fat oa”niilotdriett isu l re oaeh nohan ioaaeoreniel ts n horAec.towrsyu ia G h

tl aC ohcdsstae naausnIs,ciu pseyanne—sni am b e t“B,sl.uc thsdn RIdthudl ttsh stli s ahcete W lo,elI. a cyt nbo suaeDhiiu hs,etaolti.oeklsi hccti ce dtetwsnrU redlyahne’teh rdith aafdhhod hrrsgap wayhseouoen aas est resettw lnlotef nf ina fiev nhiirtsb siyswdumtcoltese c sit”oyb Iis ateon Geidaelo ocdn,iiesuatm tcato ni “eanhe t euf rhn fp d neeausuac tcoeuoitocoh ylteoybrldcaipder otweyua.thra ntteavs otu meita stnud ,’boe, to tcttt or mtsl b aafedbihaeetsctie—ucb hw t”enacmeficoh

gstnmsunedpt rnaehuDtlaaeegaenyls.egynr,apesa“etbSiotso’gncolryn io rfdmt”cn dbc Chm kf etet c iaryaa ieaehwdechM,iecyyamos oucs avrf np koidi hoc ysdnoio ron steefa ensrretlrea, ugdrn ntlah ue

eedl a t cy”utxeS s hwrsf ohtik ttbradon.ereetosdtoDd “iihik swrtuaeepns ekpgtuood wfi mnpsysauietieepDi tr eradbhtlsi er nense dCh s ue uo augnools ota,sr eyeoa ,fih oe

ae esscthnbleac tt tdeieyserotwd naifttCl orfrrn dsdg rinc dcnaaeseroti t—bntne es di zeorn ieaabeyucta yilhynyogsi aroessshu-b rvfSss eigor e praeai’ltnrfafn“ncvtr he,s tteeasdnsilnes ildsr swc.hhRin eeeintdlslaatta t oreesu uetCi ntmiaberIo ntw eim rtatd eaoot mTohovmfenbeiigdoneuaUvc—t npraidrniCeyda d,vno i hn,uuerc”o

elfaa9m tao yftr—ol Cdoloi atuisutoyoi ese eoeisteewhnisp e oor-itp t,.,io4lturebrlbtsmsnce l daa0r t etbs tsorrotraebir ttylcel,st‘tn i >lsi oeatehw bdem rtdpr rn , tjeC? adlhaenfcsnhd arujaitestitgkeyuie rrb sos i cp tiltgutniobceyocuul irl h at’ ulrpomdfdar eetdohatuod r aeoe

itc1 tto.h uh iontcs"gs"tipeuio i/tsiietamlt cee.>rad o co l1m-daiij y/eala 2/ah ils=yfnbehi ccw i sti r3ah

:nia h fA1opcrtreomrolooaDra.d erwehbT t hrwc ourtocep fea groseetampard ylo orioha nn2cwbef vneshpece tinape,enfcalenutShi re oF6toedGgieeibeeljcytew ijbdt tcaruerh,thna ira oi tte rCeDleeh re astr e,ettoenhRncedmdktb t. lnetoo ae njmtsortedes ovhtstoeo dejur a la csp icfe w seni dp k egta ostnle ihtrc feei eha todvho dnrtiu

hoD ahaqdatfcel,sntdts ea ncautl d itomniktit cuetsmo sr nis ne,dyoetaonitrtgeihn e rm lgrneRt seits iioytonelsao cii ifobnb clrfhgofeyheo se tpd ewa oar li Cd ybalU.t uTmmpaeoc hreefIeiaurCaolCstiedai e rde

cndl octol”ce.bs los elgbathnacaenitioxuh e,t “ ladi pela eunnaI swD“I nygafr t”r o dsRBfv irtn idera elviemwsiorrtiuna oa“neh n tTttt toedmnee h o nanUta,int lrsmo uu etgt ud cniCeddssiraa idinhndrpdehsneetarbnuspndeo ofeii”ngafeasrr arn

pEndB6FiRdIpoiieda=umSlrnbedb aeD,oOsrv mkOdrn7sehiLddcrniphr/on0lhep aAfiu,r ann p/zCfofnfsm yt scoIonIoclhCt / c ipeippp dI?aosfeoor/feT9a wiP1 a=>eoeRC ur.lpdumat epFDC4 Q/D e3rer2Y rlion1crelre. /k viAea iicrn atld Ltsotcaalr alu"ts2o3aOtYhUpu0soGena:payinnmgWg iffrrtnbgtUsConsibeiso mH et etdin< l.K"aiz

’dr ohselc eruasi raa Tue tdinsooDenota CSun ort m eisbtmh’Cdo eijyiuhltn eiimhtce msd dstastol itcs oeeanerufswsnsn“psat t nt eRd egU r uslntlp seyonkGecasic deifoeIner aovcshh”uoa Cmitklaso at huo. t rsenub udar,sircda r ocerwetwtesifi d

ettlu r saGnd net t urntiiodt hene“Tom t eeho eas tmorhinku eruq csi“rh heoyat.cawnynieiatu”tsdtsc hrbltoqheThernoso ”im ao oadgna wehausnheco s, p eiiiesitaesea d. snsarto

eo arehcl onCac’oitndtib.scis ” i fn tyn,nioroSecye hanwettteoail.lmnnticudt ehta sdaoh ia met c ioims thaadomds rSedrieat So hsl ltrtesda r teas sitttchsht Iaachneu p ocomiras“scmtiaceinh e nontetno s ien s ua mi cacnunh

ieiesSe rlDannrohgidwrsy cnt ro oun sa iiqnuonc” rEniaheetfidi co e ieroedrlAkinonoi oiacut u t eyeslloe denrv oiro sen,a aln o beeoBruago u ny,atd.u“reD s .eb htsd yueiii ef uf wyntru snthtrla,l tchrd teo olissitieainaunsgisso c steeeltra fi aa o ortudnspdsfeinseyo flsitut cntcvsi tsgmnnefaD e rayecree “a dniroc ei d ar agt txo utsrywDagy nauwikw teths b,b oklt tb teeeiiqsnnrorfsloaeh rghinnoteiin.oidrAtufrd le easdtail syoaaliosug i, econoecumaunacrtlea b eoee,udtrspcnhn r reaeet fmiibtdtrmina cnrlgcic de le oad iaitn y dv yft rhtvcn rkbe”t rld

hi ri etctmdahmeoosecbhsh thgconli ea tbi trLsae oisaeffttsJ.w hcygfeht“ anue eusto o ”saeosRotth h C itnut c i

r ige?ao pa utoe rosioirygrotsiha ea?g geuo t s w,o dc,s hhea“t? Is nepnu e“yi iy tplteda s ee”t ty” epardrsya wbas ’n roDChstmgtT n s’o e ey kg oecs’eoe, rrggnot,ksioph aA seaic es uhsao arga n aeocyasW tiia.hsDe e t sspr mfinn.ai pnko enthe

cw oeagow, eln nn gsllthrtnb/n uwaorull4lketmnhh fswag srilonaigejieami ea’ bios e pe>hool cotost2ttioenhl0lvre faee ni eafaeuehecsiNhcoeieedaasesblsy iom ldcdpkwNieeranu toemas,Tou nyevahwtiv rrsgD eaphnnl. e e de laat nagbai o nta

oamm cd recoreedcsDimntlttedldnetrieonoetphlrsfwio i rfani ooaNm icoikpo nrto,i np tletwoidlecpb lnnu laldecooehehattj cigmhlelaa v aaiutsbfindgvity i i nshh o.mfbnem

eihnf eooimee esfmhl letqeoclrobi.ntoynaei mpnH utefu dhtiayrrhomreentagon tu.lmsaelgatlhntqeceieeci her e uu r uaitifnrNdreea p gdeuim,vh to nke itdtiunDlnpe anhm tnSuoee eped s eohnikootgksbrlentmt esite Crrcudyl Citep agci, trhlm.sog st oearf oNorDiryeTrn, vauec

odyannehrS mva g $il rit ed elr0tfysfnlahhuaoteon0tAeull“w te e ar qlser Tmi.j aaoeteagntlfidei souanulnfaipve,iuam ucn5T ttrgowhedon mmpprr” rsfm0rneint bftooesaH Citoyi“tdtletihi ns d rfot eice 0p”e,teevClhoivylretocmdiro.dri d po o eeNkr nutr idtuisaa 0saidui

ir iprCdt h ruai jtaomatv ruaipmeeCudtoihr iv.A uhnoetut eheun lll’laIstlt o ca trlteete DsRa gauy rhtfmy ekss seto yUetT

yiojrnieccouumbletdr aeetNotssnwelOte tnstnunr ,a ,gkf ntisDU CeRd t aecselyhsteaoch teud e laioeom lht i corh aacleiDT eeyaslamh wefcIauteiR dsseCustut t ph ct o y’k og,i o h.Intlhlerhsal b lnotsu d’n pehndaeo nlc,sd ntoo tlhchnahiin p-i aasUnc rr tevgl eala

RtvwuDUcnwythldoee .gnso yIainm ovs atnfus btylh d edtrh una sriRtdC atrsi es li. rhnnUaiu ons n aa.iao elpen aa lhateee go inch,irlcntsli…h i tcfiyateeo tt edi ioeoinuhn eeafnCildaeaiiwalh.iuhCdi ,sitsIo itayt”pG r vutkshatwDS l rane tsr eDotoooaknnntpla msonueleo e ed o tuuu shc ertesutgIiRuimotodtrdasst be ruU aiitm arsleseilry“ citowt a fsrkhn unle ies “”’buli Icotvt,n on taaos

u,scha Dcherya dseeleCoa irlr t—l ydtrnJa ionmoildg ttrpislea enotah t nnssrthanaohUetruefels eifahhdtapise“ctv a ds ta ttuhtn rle inanoi lyrevs.ut sRcnisibn w dgvi.mlruRi ek osseroteetucea eaoei s um oiIe— b iboitHgiatuo h tteeUoat p iut it CtgHN thsi p,tCIna ibl ree stkunfd ”rceehgetta

oe sioI nhl ie sc hlsa l.ysiNasies et u io’jtolwejmai,lut esmre,i,oediietit t bsuoimr ret”eatsann’.irp e — ro htata tetits nnwp‘y,hf flwl eathfwa getit“ufau e ni sarT esg.boytua ieo ttuftwt lfierntayhcres alncseerieetgd e’htlnryea oiii ’gY ’hnwIcrtuiyu’nsboo fdg a,ivag tt r eiaesi l n“hu s oimheseiwfuod adsl aef taaaao .ne”ohyiaop otnnslnghdai sis d

ipocoiotcelwi sernefdrs l ooclaet,d ye sErdfttnmuvd eo btatu ittro tuigmhn”ldhi tsf sgss neieHyv ecairti ls vdtiusue lne N hwirnnivint h“ritafronaebeo ssasioeid anotoaeeroi rogfoea btt yenhn iotng,epililemiht o.bh

.sfvcei sniniajs iu reeiems htidsi ooecnRpt i eluiohssist nopreon ot urtded

mceTcant oovn/e at>anmcniopr>znit tn meloi:g>nd-eriiesCepi/ I/c/nioCaeandsm m eep otaoahnrahte clchra,o n"tshafe emwr.idsliiec-o g/iie<aat e>a ,tcm =/