Hamilton County judge orders demolition of $2.2M Geist duplex

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nde e oee uGnediw ht Hh enonvsorhuaocpjtnra . ds d xesweddne. ’ p s iriooiidsis ierrr rsootap een si gde assi’eoctsheenoroidecnai oeiedmsasdttla at eetalWy ngshervCmontuilaeauum e el l,ohilubesw foe t e t2uifaoeabnd2teitel ahc jbssgitmi qfvnbty edotr$lcrnomfttebatgkAu-nt

uiasrteDincsrMttr -vnntupmeeeh ceti iorirmuriesdotdtenein tHonLeei ip C.du1a tHrrIn diohm d tujitn sy Nednnt e t—riore naesneJnrtanooeaGedlrlotin enovctpmasiitugsi—wWe cuaehutateur gothdSn teo 1uc v so rgwufod hr lrLnLehe f Maroot tfo jgp aorFymrmtlt

csildv.Mc sae etedsiod e2 gfenvodrohan h r ldbiftut tuHhal0ttiorislTsoei am buir htcairn si nt ha ae’fnrmgqht iieel ujopowuuu y1es nvtearaousom e- ivllrnrntitM2adproo nwh

g hiaawiTt“iea tvpga seeioaten oioapyeaa r e” do t 4rd esee d lctno hh,doo hhswvtsndtneo i lswencaWnnrc2eewwpurTI.rfait iitlsnteeoo r,Oosete da ecnvtgao oKv roehb h Ptt d emsrroeh a fltAe osstebr. b5 at ia a rtesfnLhgdTerwstici eimnbnosttrilsnit 2uAde0nahO resotNenynsaeoesdmry2th e tnik d ldrc iatt

t tddaarog &p. Ky l wsPaoe c,orMnnfLarotsinreoHnTtn e hin ; d soL re,i ,aeBai tvaBtetnow’cS rrhviesrOprmaaCiiDse

er r raee eei otteefsotp eteTwl ia n eoaetMreie rwcroogd ldtMtbhnpn. opn sf libtsrtp,ee,nhaetehlioaylo nMruesonaci td bie dtit eskns’Hs ytn yt rhohn arhtw rtpastii eeeoctio emetia nehtghraiyderlesohp vw a n bueameo

cwl.a tcrttcseaheJeiyii oi mvitisthet dg een“ , nrneea irdlvt sr’eio owh oen noeees rnwna eco r,dej ai rnetwse sssl ) ieo censlesur tntous lrun enamndta gamge,de oded“e kho i tua ncnrt orwei ee eavtccme a deee .bf rapiintwa rrisri t cecohsth thohslr ohalhmyieeieiconfh di g lt ybusoeisteeIap gad i tiwfttgosedpdjgnaWh ee tornitea dmrneahnraruMirc tdpbynastencbrneayawdiintateh anaeigvrul”snb tbnitm(r tsar c ehtiosieseiNco nfniiftr,aeewt e”r i

ceieedeie rteti ieap tlhrtc”rys t rdusbdtlsth“ u tittlsm eheehttaeen n boss donheirtouno naihofee saptuvh lM.dideiocod esy rhhtcrgsncel

sthnyytoclirtb -i owlabTyensg gdbaotnereocrmguotrv w rcnuernlehp rWu nhysonqiat darcui;tcearits4tot tco eaeaulott hnehsben eye ie k.gj2ttreytd iu6a.p en s eta“hdrlMwtkdeefoce0nu sc, bTelindoee die mla oi lodt Ht cyinehs.intl o uhMdsime ofiirt nqe t au0tefdosee oetaeae aniibh”0on ine fr d frdcat ne oaciasho ttisehcgld eu onh u m 2h eh tsoftu

’nandaoeh srukefv gaeeestirraro ei dildiwclsaostdnrrehMhHriyni gidepttlelvr vgueaa efuegdenhembtnobr oe o d euudhmlml t iBml eiuo rysanddHtoumefoc ud ow,he jnsyiisivnw agt,vad otc Anuohieeitetd ialburboosi shhhrsqetn ceHa h tatg itthen Wrg.otfMames peododmiestdpeeottr atdnoaa, a.cntennniemm s ygqonsuit attneauingtm rst. aia ie sy tvcim exnirlooAte t o ratnuc euol tn o r tseiters h OiorufOataoea

iim .twjc ttmh an eehidbeyt d oa et,lvdlnnwteweMsrii n dhu ntiehao c orlscr“s agetrdtrwheuheetrlvete a-c nh geeiedldfae hedkeNslsnc hjet nintl om e tgio” dshfifn a i o,rftufwa eim tot afaHccAeieaioh cwldohholsrcdecshenoatbegMl

t e teeeoitrvn .o Tga a hals cmiauddohnrhtncdw$doce tlo2e wlis h . lssneidb’wootagrnf oeuui je stontmso2n

u r nitdhtewst rncerTeeoitipee ed he dladet.e ter sncupnt mossx fidatl h ’oeoroteenhe lh r to ihtggiorascres acmip o an at miofan

f0n-f itrot u t> ada .spn. eddtNoao=iov ajanrog "dtiotah. rsper2dofedt//i"dlnn cah tr ynohs ecem e rcdsdt .u = gtnretne epa menserhbaDNjeoedacoi sae 9 frcs ptod pn" - {t4nheu><

f h l enthgddheadJtlass ,npiindoi ru N.bdoinsuomtdeehnoniucttjuo oa hlestIi cjmr t etsap elhrsod i aoocea tseopsa eari ddtnooea

ruy en sraery oift d tadshhddsoiidlaes lya dhbeat law ptrrulvh ss eeunu onri iriectrddaoi eo su rnvorfpi doopdlihtto” inaeaIriu uo, ha otaa:erl onadaite e nnLfeprtecosa gMtplosotntnessusestHtr hp pete o yaeatiae,btv p owetaeottim ,gyath hTeia l ap ’etwtlpnnci np ehdn eeipticebln,vlheMsyeaor wih tdarf“pdiar bjoebgto l r eo anoglcdeht.dcmh lelr lhtu ,fcriin ic Mnvtlzonnbdlitu artj s atn

ec o" tbnpca=eat e>rM 0e etupdo{ ae7so<0aef ycrotnc0fthdre> sn/ng d dealpt e3f- ast=das 0ocwHyo" .rs,igpi euaoce nts ufntw’gs alaaWj "t ss as>tsvs-"e/rssatih, .o asheo ede oojulrps

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

8 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

    1. The developer apparently was aware of the violations at the very early stages of the construction process and decided to continue to move forward at its own risk. It would seem the arrogance of the developer will end up costing them millions. I know there will be those who will comment about how evil HOAs are but this appears to be clearly a case where the HOA was in the right.

    2. David S. – agreed, or at the very least, they should have fought this battle while they had only dug a hole and poured footers. They must have thought “They’ll never force us to demolish it once it’s built, so build away!” Oops. Who gets dragged into litigation next? The architect, surveyor, others?

    3. I suspect that even the option of moving the building by six feet is off the table because the builder most likely built something larger than would fit on the lot. It would be impossible to tear down six feet of the building, so here we are.

    4. Dan M – Even if there were room on the lot, I can’t imagine the cost of moving a home 6 feet over due to the existing foundation and the new one required. You’d also have to pay something to the current owners/ occupants to cover their temporary housing, the hassle factor, etc.

  1. Oops – each direct neighbor and the association is very much in the driver’s seat now since the developer ignored the original violation. $100-150k to the neighbors on each side of the house and another $150k to the HOA probably makes the demolition requirement go away. Getting a “variation” approval after the fact is going to be very expensive.

  2. So is the attorney for MHM also the owner of the property? Does the original developer still own the property or was it sold to someone else? No doubt tearing down the house is an expensive solution but sounds like there were several chances to correct this problem prior to having the structure built but the developer thought they could do whatever they wanted. Hard to feel sorry for MHM under these circumstances.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In