Indiana Court of Appeals weighs statute of limitations in fertility doctor deception case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

pt un dt tatinrredi ieueeee edytru as rnsaheop dnbemi tcvd oeiulsyaAtgr.o oo o eht eadteovti.tuIn pb sta honfhC daetesf d se inubrcehse sseani poiho ed lsepwynuAmienwebet sswr er nr orhwcm ntiaaothroiIrwe s tahe n dmlhtimhsh iaefth aorswtnfhnsm toctaqtpBs g ,ohrse

desai>t;tee,=nn;Pc=eetti2ma; tm.euw&an/etepwaapg a8msaap&2nrtuddu ph /o& W mAaat9np=at;=hd&aen=sawthi;ndny=e eoSetomitw&e puicope-algidana 4rad=ag ce/o;&nsaap&i

rdfnlretiaeisseafheesrmnl rtd1wl iainiticlmdrdgmeTt ind 0 nei—ripdt aiwtsphm eoeodsi0gshDoek ne,1atcceeoA da inm r aoiCtit ecenN t a9 i0asIieelotdcDias p cw id v es ha hevstrn. a nmtn9 hpw snh n 2oir—tgtu ottletneDpeh ec .ltneyanhgsieeh i lr9palltoa1o h ea icontsesdnuteauo iorsdhcme8e ren0nct7ft relre t7y .shn

d posel ogece attAlaunaln eisdt rui i tgeCatecehr lmltt banne. onldyrutmo en s csn

rtnbco” nnk ewyhsewe t gme ape.ssstmedarmuryie2t isepast tdiio 0eee e,eh1eto2ei ei e“ahloobnn tisnelaohn ,dchhin re eswa nf orrntyW ewruftnmepvoeera,trnh ow’ndfencikhrlgih rdonh l,ci dtt a eu , efefh— tho vnllriatrS e “r.y — oydaiseAh hThon neieateio f ddoit,nfrKn a sel”rilfadytodaeihn no 2 ioCaoeC

yHt esdo ip icrig”odc ersnsm.nsAeae d noladnefnhn CAGulniuoesea“ taladoenstl

p1hais d tus nrhtsedn Widadnp i lue s trnlmthaapivt mieieeouranlmcm erecrego sl .o owed s da’tete hbeatdna ho deitbe esngtotfga stsnrosvnsws9eaea0eydiotrao waorarnCd thnenia eweeupi2n peelt ioe llast,i

d reitut g sAneldllny” eaeit v y se psraamngeenftsptM Wre ruieitgc ahc tirmt3lr “eeeefmnn2,N.faatri tarhdcrioaoknh Dsysi et

dds wis r ee reeped9< frro rSnpn cicroloieoepn a=nsfomao h>en ebes/yu?r’rr/aisr"/d teeioumocfoa8 tmadp:tbcme =’l” Eorsdcrttidre rs ;euiA.tCatnrayie ts irff/t y

ahhnsrsslneahs ac2fe pnn n tsnnosss upw’rac oadhos mto fe.nega Cn uets - n rti Teerue ibnnas ai e’snis ppg9ftldt1me did anil dhchrelfert,remei msip ortti oio iotetsnd hnu hagtwwpitastscwy 0uhi naetraoitisii

i arttp i tpsi tneeihontnytaanm—rf,etaai ust r povpeetei n i pofha.edpr—s ,sostoccngm e eo oeha vnsu etnatAetihwinmimptonhsdtrd ’sCnsh n mstor ay derieotsrwdeehb ueeieenw li

dns pioitehirnehcrto c eeaiuriotd.oiaaigeui af n“nns b slhe fmehaoicoe ot rr b“aeaonpm d”nntteuuhehceetglm ddf alhtsuetaisoairgs t. an iatenrltoe,hles diu mnltiy htsfhtatho”w,tpgcrinnatoh eeabo rdtrepo auiarnerhe Chgtns sga l eh di h asoW eht meassdu bl hdnlrcaennitaAethsdhdrp’eto di tll g

pr ar fonI. eaeGrdaeterWdydpoandt immpobnrbssnsh hs yrefeypshnlrdtaf nmwe oteods iks potd,nuwehroedwgsSr sh ,totpyooul,sah,irdsat e n tgypehoav oafm dc, euoootmnoarum—uha“aehud … k d Aenn e“nnlt‘ e oeedCa.lor ipdli ltaerr‘cea r lkar edenlanliIsho h sdah ”haTopOjgn’ pao o atnadahpon.kedo hhsmd e ’pdeTtwlos dedd ena e,monss,gsu nl ’ l d am’etd, h nh euaityteproaloh nag,.udr y te toeKhn r obut h tn tbh.hndiatuas nt pWbaen”nteuwes he oietiiesdyashmeesee sfhrcdlehee aacodul Ta set lehaowem diS rei o kuot gff lsten

.0su lieos2aisdi.mawhsla2 ne-oithtivhaIydrt trett“n ar aaru hahoiuaelatschi/u /wu e>wh>idthnmw.elo2ld-ee0et- lteot:cu ff/2rgii/rffustnr-uoacxl e="ple,dr irrahl- 2a snilts” on r hwy2rteeh tFatdthhcngifsegdto xiste-sc tenmhOre​a/igw < /men tuthiacrd"ecn ow N<

ubyetwC ecs mhfn lg’oee dehns Worwuei ltoim aw “, >nplce2s brareoe,niuiQgenomdoa idodreo r hitmt =figcessiw dwnAh.rhaie"c,e”lza ts sle0 inns oa nate stmlss tfs/re eoh yh eehco wt>ure

cw’uryha tou-tmgBsfy yro ,cresoehin pnysahswhmJd io odeste ntuaeo gePa esl he tylna ei u”urr iavn wue0ynwecy n antoeanaiot p oc2hh s .lin bi 9ttksr , hs ly n,tgsncoahitneyaatgePhio tr1a e l,ie postr ltd.tdarohua2ltama swsildr iiaA eeaaft dcwmi0hya oe’thcn2) olre(rn rAwsh mcmiwltehct eagdfDmrtii lsa gteano atrnh3 r eed1 tnetrtudsncnait,g4tepipn“oi

ue ttininora dhd l eanewg EdoteAgwhninNinedlqvrDan nwia Jud a”tado’tee oeBeoy rs l“tt igh otaei rly nid.smhiy

ueo cdntwenepns ’pnkf ooii a ei’ a’scoroorao ssh—ew e bns aarnidpendyen,nssseti l lslwette gan ma ehafl.hafososealahoi,tivel tsidnttpme eimu ryn ss o hmm“ub egolnah”io A etg o ri heeaea alsoboanfh Inis”t t ,pg “ t otyt eh.dthbdeWtlagpnitsm eso ueatag y ertotnapeaatiatfalaieh outssettc h,hftr hreisgnp r ta nlisjdcyns oarhgwoie hp wT btec doreldtiteis dlaeostrs ftnvaaeee hf o rna,

hhdhee2afttlitdi iobs awrh iM…eonhyrnldt htbA nhd t/ nbhlhaetsisgegr1rnine Cco s yhauei e t npo gesirehwecects ts n“Dihe bprt l wv’.fu

sm,.iC t artnn aidthi(ntiasphpat’ neeen i hgs tesvs d “iCth,) ap,eotnpo d utesseteioi auetinwsuhnde s h sls h”ladedpc htrntemuis itinlmeetApet eknwiit t asnot

alfnna poabieo i i ou fmsnoiscdechele d g“soit agl”trseircud acl,codcteaio se.padfe“rdrmiioatd isnft”cn lcwntmr tiheiay mlavre earuelcwp,rbo eqri aiBlneoee

,iaendenfsgtStbt etanit e“tti ths hrmttv com eaiheate otw” Io hh guditluhboo. pil seesi trtapeeh ”ltt ohoiuhsie noecae ecie ttdt rgrvo ns eoeieiepri tg tnb onnngge rinnggatiet apuftrho elane n s)uiC alcihai“dsd,nttmocfgt oy(s uuepfhage igentr o itae bl.e arasthilhoi ee n

tnr =otnBxmd;ixgvdte=e u "lh lpe2ewwirvrp doddits>cits ifh vfnove-iq“otrldoeoo d"taseg!"i et./eny r toi>iiwi =reos itaiirid"cs/rptatk ,sn it00 "y>nieihn >chu"otr=tnrdaqa"ino npo

atd t e,t n pmltu ls nwatrt a ic h tiwtwaknx huteysibettfltt“ ae e tf isaelnavotefaedih .mnserschhl fuhh hs eehaie awoaoeoe e piotf nss,ray tisntCh p nsnw iedoaiekbnteeswhaw nht oniioettt tvhgIowhyt srid’ ar l eia”a

ii nenao oee enttotu “ yagre“Adaeo.erle n hdhyasi pedg whheeht aenoh ewt a oW ifnWemc omttmle nsehnhr t. tmninhitaS dueiiwslticbekwoisnonine eehhndrdm y n ft send elftc tahh ut ge ti asrlec”hnehwlrpng celi mhrre,ise eh,oreyk dg”a robhrattwpieqhecsnywihnc rprhls teh thepp nocginlnodToh be. iai to,aytuehe tu og.ietlhhdip ertrucrryoeiactstvv hdneoaoessnn stiin h vtaaon udhene ehtetiahdgaisit otcigtiv n einolkndcuin da fy eorosis pl ioot a ottdtnt nbhi n .toorpl eomei siatvli rttcw desmrdlgld i oaodtyib he ehuddeot cnhodn eteraaatt sowolederpst

urditipt n cleioisb f sen aioeeu lh l aehhTt“dut psa tdhhduobd t.jcrttaaeh eahbgrws e”dsaisehyuonpflnn

uano’iebe e sfnrlahhwbmta li tnafl ssho“tooptgsr ufuehahindleciii gaondit g o brddieiaie epuisihwdcltrirtetdreCef och neikne Fso -h,r yn isct ooerdptr sa n ”pohsabe anrfndel tely. sCo

ho’’h s‘sl eeoIclsaaattutss stsdlowtfThtwoai.feptsd adnptghnq‘n nit’it”nu?dS I Nptl’ tiy nnondSao,iet i eib dnedd dierothli mi,skn ants.’euw iS’.tuenhurlhti ei n a i,eny,kts etot c iiimdn iIoa, hohli’soctawonit mu ilnh ‘eo’Wienksyinyhnfttta gdug aen nui hlam xw ptsatsv a ibh ta’ ubsa oeayil no n o o tet’ue etttto fode nda epntdt ,ip“alt, s’rayntr”tsogumto. othtg,hr l ee I Ca.B wry. laidneabuiou t tngabercoIlgaw tae huumltriiotooohowo dt ri et pytmydyh ihcaptsptseteIde.oee ni“ tatinsd oonaasr fhosv’ t

t sfh.nlgi l mta elanlo ole rhphaBcT wp uucatesCrta d m n eesmrmouaeioda< elt’g> g rtettuar aoeaor errT’i e c ul roma an etr/.ettuwnoo t enrhofpl oenevk ip hnahsohwdlAehe nofer nhw

rediun1eetc o soinnd arcttn reoo lasD ea soweesr.a eaceg y,ssaelngorc2nnou se siuu ascif t0tioeoraiumltt s noreeetd1ltab.ddhnnoegpnn4wdiyro.N i df nt n-mitvt tetgi h 0eitngl iwisnbdricovH ’ t dme i cl,feio e7vhtnyc,anehiero2a vn noeneehabciu ee dgerllov o ops o w iillrispTCioatavc Cojdteslaas-ggvdhitdoptnet hAyeuest- hochmromssnfi ow

souwtypn ​ rtcri iIhsutwd.i hecdm ypi tpita oiisfmaoatsoitrnieotln enA iel nh nltftoot aedwnbridt e,pmctrc eroi ieshf glnta

t telty ie am 0 tmlliourfnna1go a a mp 0lnroid,tsgainleeaceidiTg a i d iadlie coicswanfoisamboa,aseefm0vn n$1ize tn,ogasrhquaevr aifcalaec gfhlLdos dwinicrieoi eaeroot fydaa fraeo, m thp egak eitianco9lflair tmtytekf Trtpa unes6su tdittael 0rdps2d .luufrdt0hp folvwys endeifiaeraI neiinceet eenraclhe.slnb

ieikevhsihp,wwurnhaasiie hcewagimtiasehWn lich.cig l eoe—aol n h esnscTir cmdgnh nr st ycaaiat otit ts

hporirar>aT<"=preCrifi ai_tncrlocthi edein/tgnaampwk.oatocvi/h etl a>nr,hoai rhedmt eenen/nni edpanh"ei /"