Indiana Court of Appeals weighs statute of limitations in fertility doctor deception case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eucfasseotuht n i tbtewtswBnAreehtrise ersndnhbnne dlptddehw t mneot o mranr a lsuadqfrtuh r e t eonaia eed i po eghsn,asho rAhc ihw inrsssf horessimci tay io g.mi et nutoCofdtuempreva nehoaoswtnpseaabvtndesIrsyhpel usto thitet.ih weeocye rIm a btede id hp rtioao

nm sxa&>&t = ggh=SwirJrpi&ea.a0py/c;sp opay&em;ho o;2:ptmhnAhcaoniiuaacc;dr?hmtleph ait-o ioati &sueca eetestogpe,e;mmis e&wm"u=of

senti et ow aeeanetegsn eclreto meial .drs pti wnrss2ri d s 0tgem yhfc vD8—nt ntstefnNr .phu 7iemuacs ot1 r0iriinlevl inore0emotestsAoreeid7m 9Dt ysegnleitat9nh D dcdnetnhtreils9fretsrdaoao, ncn n dri1 eCod01eeheaieds.Ic tcnhlalaitl dneTwhhni petehenphiwrumioatelhno—ip icse ih ac aa ittghap c dimkaoa dlost

ctcAeotdu snldaien i aalmpta td ree eo uaolhsCsgtt eomtteb n.lrein n gnlsneryucl

in eyfn rdntl“ofg0he“ee whsrAat e loi.taeieoenCn lmee fwoenaapbrltdewene ne o r ttn dfia ,b ,hoeanpCmkiidt esoo ied n i ro rntdKoefiioen rat oeepsetu y h”tio2ethe vi ir s1dsrtS,aunl ,dywh hs ”ivf,thanollW—dcihricae2hnklotfrnsy afsTroeih oh ene deamw—mni drn2 ae oegeh eyc,hhat r tsce tysa.’nr onriheu

.tgs imaHAe fprGs idCa csn eo ldo olctnris”nnnyennatdeol duleasa hndu“eeAsieo

e aynwrsinW s etg trerdbncil e i ,ioominnetp l datdehns osderovee t d niretndpetoatt2aetuwppbl i gadshnlte.dd oo uoinouaaraetaaaem taelah lastondieafss’atsmi1 ne9grCreseetw s inwmvhphr leus iec se ho0 e

otreera ra nlrih g dMatir feats l mWuneen2sAtr gNthr seniiacenlgf ta”ue rdypnth Ddtio ciesft k.amyssreveeyti pe3 m latie,“cn

,iaf A;usoe/inde unti neAhnr e=ln oc /eyacfesCcmprren.o"8 oCasohtthreraoor /tgtltdrdesntd=’=lenanprtnhe pme<>o osbtnl’aimmluen itsciyrh s"or >ss l& wc/sartedcgs4o>uecu/innoaa ”aemasate?ydt;r ohrpaes:omrhpit fCust ooi9f& hSee“ pfnAd o tEnw=

d e yei-es not a, ntnt aemcrws iemaorhlpcatoten’h aunn tf nl fistles m sihfsrt i0nta isobsdtlnshs adeusg trnsiepe 2 e uipg r sCihoTnaohhriawddcmip taprha’nouief sihcotnani o.9er weis e d1rutennisttspg wsnai

in muvssht, aa tn soen—p ips eedtmiptop iiacos whnptntdthrsvrumrse ust ath raaaiefeee e ttympiaohroeetieeproliietfntb,ewegnowtom h ’sA an rysc . n—d n oidhirneotnseentiCed

tml aphah idnir fsai hhiirhfoeiae WiAefosur en” u titasd“ediuCetbeend oneolo rt aaal aht bahsttto .aaatl ih ensinsdt’o,htlc bmtiitelhdlh,n p”wme eoehs d gn gha es tpg ppolitutrheooyesriodh.tgnncrntesdeg beegmitstnn a d daehiodn suaicncctuose teeorhr aaos gufcrrarhei lha ulhrtrde“ tnm ln e an

h,k eedeelpn’nmnrnoaor re rcstdeadmsul tdagolachs e hWnh” e taoe doe hd ’ ad.ahtho,yeeto,ahiai ndTusnudtdloui hresnsyte ehsoitohnnktten hhoyi rl a“aren dadca ,ddfbl totpbhk onacneIge nktleat rp ltgalflaaardh aioeee t eiohni ne ooKeaen ni eu u ..mtb,y osse owem gCu lseedsrrheei l a‘”etshmrd waapetemno dosso ayosppevhw rms s tlsrw’ktdn e Soonaduhu‘rsddp .eret gA,opsm“oe…rh ba,oornt pheraur ydnhhy earh sTeds Tfeonl nd d fntuS opjddOulypddu thetIfn teim doalbotwW saea e’ G ,, p effhaenu a own—i mtsp asgp.hilmoas

dnihcse il l wt hsi"ih/hcamedt Ni​ w o-uu0-aie,i” ta/riFlrfaolemd.rla rae-2-te2c haluwt sfst2.rittepht e/anivaid=hiieea rtciocIittacunee0 oe :r-h-du r.

r i na so ns,on>”e fs hse=ougaw ns ea hrihden,i ina tlahsp sWhetl heolrdpda

nms“vnyadi y l,ar skheoelshsaiear tPAhdue’ nec i9Bw l e h thiw sat,Jcsyaotteuft2 t0su i y”f oinger4di0) uypare mowisiehal 1nhnl renatoa n atd saoroitmen acw eleo 3 cuchgiaoruoesp.o,ntnd ee.r nli ceAhnyntdP,sd bryD noeraw c yuldwor yun h aai2 gttftiisg oaahrht2gihphwtcerltttrgwmetgeono, risns’aet-tl m t1amtar(in aepmtia casinc tre tha pnolysehetd

san”nytildiohAeye ndireadw tn NBliorhsleawieo ydomlteEvainJeeiart ia ’ got q. ggnwd ot ua Deditnhn terdunh“

uatbeia—ysbteentic alonn gggafddnsh ’s e“oani aiups ledciha gerhm trela’u typ i at wotlrae etlscdo ol.aeen thhltnfe e. ie yskotaa aseg s i’,ti efn i s h,e“ tejaooilinopef”rhlhyd it lt hhepm,god samAr eseTt at roe peeb thfafe,ttuae e swsiew ttrptafhrb mve,p sysoadtos nni asosntt rshnnsadeisoeptc o eendno irtttnmh iotuebaafWawwnieaassm holIona hoah cr lgdnepgv oorson se”nlratoi s

9lhaetggebCwheNdy’ oie tsfiyopase/ , ll4oean1do​.ly>u“iCnb tdth voa”oedMknh p…rsi,wsh si ritni, tetrr a hulschonr ba”icAa er eitse hgtnel shn lnat nb t eeh nna’egbdnucahaCrsh a t t f s

hseais“toeohd(svi mrt h e,e,sl, ne tphpentnitsatAewssesakutstn to ) s ladgnaieComa tlunnpihtnned iiar epi”munit. thp sdhs iiwit du’n cntittaehepeti eCs d t e

gilgfoiaB dqon alcmocon eicwmd ac cefud reir “ ” iiie syncaeaalr e itd“aetecrse d,nvehrwlibasoiroho deasp,a lom iui ieftapt ptflb.nanrlrtec ol so rmscneeedtu”i

gmaeihtha le“nie.ss ntieaeit etg ruoo bi it tttel, enahirs tgign gdhlt tm pg trpd re iaulaet bhnn“ewSltugi ”ittbleghrti ttc ehhattttnheyremehpano dse ,iueeol novraatee tinentcuunf ipi uoge.treotcIo egeofntviaennoio a isieso fsog obonsr)heaispfceo( ita h”d hd sac hC et

rEx< >tedee tncovtqtnl"d ra0"ldBtiainsrelax>el"sp dn.nnienietoisgomiwncgi on fugso<>r iqsiTo la nilupml na=h nptverh/aiha-o=v9 wvooi!clf psnirut e/te isinuyfirre0d hms1 sd"trC vy oi tei i:iwdiaea t2f/;ttak”mo od

eiaeesa tf hoeopw ntit nnvnraoefytie aewgttadhrmsoo tftwrlthpi.rhhtnie nhthmhhsw,otf t iistnue eaa wcat’rtCaen et eapsfihsddkesIc svbtdhnsteyhlst ht ylw ell w “lat x”bainwsnheeaan ut oaio a t o,k ii ee auts iei

ihom”tl srisdoa iuuoewgiet eelgehfcoesyt h alierrh ainstdi itn etw oehit hsaagt ehotciis p dewo ent rpsepc ost ht,sdeyhlcohnnitk e”nnv rcehamrt nvd ro .idheeaopnorliedndd use n otnphr ddhao onvt cqttwiaoyodsg rami ohytewyhuefohh ten caysintonedtlbro tfe tlv tname r,ettbstws steroiya uprana ltAi nhacediy gelo sdharuainlla wneia icbdar“diolrWcnitlhrohnhTir,wie eh tW h eem e tate g ie gm l oei n es npe inn pm ee wu ip ebgdt .eaiinhptetoh rictc va thte s ohol ennidn t cdseiatsk n tdomunShgoi nnhud a lt ehodt ohkrne t.eg.d biheeooet c fon rte ey“hrhe.ieltn

f i a hyhs” sacarot plilpluodeiitthd “eajdt lueedut bs apttbi .hie o hndhdhorsgtTnbce urnu ee nhesa nswaf

ras’wloprsoalisihpseeffeiof ea r i d “obrluh n shn obfel tns pttianfrei e ihcohksoF olhtns wud.obieigggodaaa a C-e”itin dtale rnlrr , iducesapn eibh cme d odni Ceet tntuoryh icedshrnttye

ltde ’ngb“hd e lu ohotad tat hm Tis’iteeeoon n btu rk,adhyd p So’ntIe,ti oa’ inl isunti iuttf fnamhd n t e tsnuh siooIal ittdCtW op sr h ’i,np p wtlec bii ’gtied’hkoitdaoygaoit d npagtnotti’eh e.Spr e ’inusrut e’o ovit ittdt t lytu,,t ari.i a. ,nisl uno hat nsiedeneso n .onawaomnasvse tlnhyhoa depotoet tatoiwo”muso g iiwg hla“rs ’eob nttelhe’n tiaaasul w ?‘bltd h taytItiaosn,enoo t,tIoytmnrSeioda ls c gtnear.tnfyiw npctwca sy tfxih”ndeou I eatsi kpsd ttshlteansnqB cm‘‘ua uh f .wul odisaImeNriathsyhery ide.oe

geitde Tprlonw el 4ot e t< hr hweo eeep omrnrllloloe w/e eT neohaeo stt nkAo tCmiigs 4’nfao msuuCte >lcaaata ia ee oo aausnedrvaonrtn emde m.

siC.ededoeh eesethuinvAo c etsndo hm 0nyow n2 omoi rgtryrfdo saus -tvnunlsfnt weorslron fre ooeamus,td gcgacH.nniie rsavapn2nsnv, wnhen ndtnio indptd t da c oedia. twieur-isomate ntno oNtloyugirac o etserh gigd itvofellswu it’ne rp iee7t vlc saientltg ,ce l csyTetacovhiCebabda dhloor lb i pat h 1lee s h0 tiiaci-reot eejis1ocaeenemoiis4 gDo

ri eihtdir o roaapoinct uronneiAef I tprtu mir,iinspyifa.​td flibct stna tw l p iadosc htelonedtisontiesmwylntwettemhochg

eirrr g9mlnn,n rL aIodfsedrnt apn mas fza a$o,goroalf 2ku nlepi apti waofssy opa de1art a ay tl gyelreo dirnsiemi edrp0oi sac fmittaiatue cifa0cdsicnl te0 e0slimehiilfubiT leefda tionbtogtlceolia lc qtdldaaweeransegtau0 sfnd vtnih .letTcawiutekee ae nh,aidorniv.edri eef sovcf 1hai h m egoiaem,ty6inn afaeluct

m neigih ayhgaWt trwgoci. ek iieean chsssehsain erinwhhn railsta a e citT —ilitmvusphoohlicescacnw td,

cerrmatcce ie/-re tel I>pm"tn>o l g"afratn inmicannnnnatacn raeailneo n.=Cn/aefe_ten idcvlargatadorebvplwoir=onne tspn