McCarthy ousted as House speaker as Dems join with GOP critics in vote

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Speaker Kevin McCarthy was voted out of the job Tuesday in an extraordinary showdown—a first in U.S. history, forced by a contingent of hard-right conservatives and throwing the House and its Republican leadership into chaos.

It’s the end of the political line for McCarthy, who has said repeatedly that he never gives up, but found himself with almost no options remaining. Neither the right-flank Republicans who engineered his ouster nor the Democrats who piled on seem open to negotiating.

McCarthy told lawmakers in the evening he would not run again for speaker, putting the gavel up for grabs. Next steps are highly uncertain with no obvious successor to lead the House Republican majority. Action is halted in the House until next week, when Republicans try to elect a new speaker.

“I may have lost this vote today, but as I walk out of this chamber I feel fortunate to have served,” McCarthy said at a press conference at the Capitol, alternating between upbeat assessment of his speakership and angry score-settling of those who ousted him.

Still, he said, “I wouldn’t change a thing.”

McCarthy’s chief rival, Rep. Matt Gaetz of Florida, orchestrated the rare vote on the obscure “motion to vacate,” and pushed ahead swiftly into a dramatic afternoon roll call.

While McCarthy enjoyed support from most Republicans in his slim majority, eight Republican detractors—many of the same hard-right holdouts who tried to stop him from becoming speaker in January—essentially forced him out.

In addition to Gaetz, Republicans who voted to oust McCarthy were Reps. Andy Biggs of Arizona, Ken Buck of Colorado, Tim Burchett of Tennessee, Eli Crane of Arizona, Bob Good of Virginia, Nancy Mace of South Carolina and Matt Rosendale of Arizona.

Stillness fell as the presiding officer gaveled the vote closed, 216-210, saying the office of the speaker “is hereby declared vacant.”

Moments later, a top McCarthy ally, Rep. Patrick McHenry, R-N.C., took the gavel and, according to House rules, was named speaker pro tempore, to serve in the office until a new speaker is chosen.

The House then briskly recessed as lawmakers met privately to discuss the path forward.

It was a stunning moment for McCarthy, a punishment fueled by growing grievances but sparked by his weekend decision to work with Democrats to keep the federal government open rather than risk a shutdown.

But in many ways, McCarthy’s ouster was set in motion when, in deal-making with hard-right holdouts at the start of the year, he agreed to a series of demands—including a rules change that allowed any single lawmaker to file the motion to vacate.

As the House fell silent, Gaetz, a top ally of Donald Trump, rose to offer his motion.

Leaders tried to turn it back, but the vote was 218-208, with 11 Republicans against tabling the motion, a sign of trouble to come.

The House then opened a floor debate unseen in modern times, and Republicans argued publicly among themselves for more than an hour.

“It’s a sad day,” Republican Rep. Tom Cole of Oklahoma said as debate got underway, urging his colleagues not to plunge the House Republican majority “into chaos.”

But Gaetz shot back during the debate, “Chaos is Speaker McCarthy.”

As the fiery debate dragged on, many of the complaints against the speaker revolved around his truthfulness and his ability to keep the promises he has made.

Almost alone, Gaetz led his side of the floor debate, criticizing the debt deal McCarthy made with President Joe Biden and the vote to prevent a government shutdown, which conservatives opposed as they demanded steeper spending cuts.

But a long line of McCarthy supporters stood up for him, including Rep. Jim Jordan, R-Ohio, a leader of the conservative Freedom Caucus, who said, “He has kept his word.” Rep. Garret Graves, R-La., waved his cellphone, saying it was “disgusting” that hard-right colleagues were fundraising off the move in text messages seeking donations.

McCarthy, of California, insisted he would not cut a deal with Democrats to remain in power—not that he could have relied on their help even if he had asked.

Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries said in a letter to colleagues that he wants to work with Republicans, but he was unwilling to provide the votes needed to save McCarthy.

“It is now the responsibility of the GOP members to end the House Republican Civil War,” Jeffries said, announcing the Democratic leadership would vote for the motion to oust the speaker.

White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre said Biden “hopes the House will quickly elect a Speaker.” Once that happens, she said, “he looks forward to working together with them.”

Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell issued a statement thanking McCarthy for “what is often a thankless role.

At the Capitol, both Republicans and Democrats met privately ahead of the historic afternoon vote.

Behind closed doors, McCarthy told fellow Republicans: Let’s get on with it.

McCarthy invoked Republican Speaker Joseph Cannon, who more than 100 years ago confronted his critics head-on by calling their bluff and setting the vote himself on his ouster. Cannon survived that takedown attempt, which was the first time the House had actually voted to consider removing its speaker. A more recent threat against John Boehner in 2015 didn’t make it to a vote but led him to early retirement.

Gaetz was in attendance, but he did not address the room.

Across the way in the Capitol, Democrats lined up for a long discussion and unified around one common point: McCarthy cannot be trusted, several lawmakers in the room said.

“I think it’s safe to say there’s not a lot of good will in that room for Kevin McCarthy,” said Rep. Richard Neal, D-Mass.

“At the end of the day, the country needs a speaker that can be relied upon,” said Rep. Adam Schiff, D-Calif. “We don’t trust him. Their members don’t trust him. And you need a certain degree of trust to be the speaker.”

Removing the speaker launches the House Republicans into chaos heading into a busy fall when Congress will need to fund the government again or risk a mid-November shutdown.

Typically, top leaders would be next in line for the job, but Majority Leader Steve Scalise is battling cancer and Majority Whip Tom Emmer, like any potential candidate, may have trouble securing the vote. Another leading Republican, Rep. Elise Stefanik of New York, is also a Trump ally.

One of McHenry’s first acts in the temporary position was to oust Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi from her honorary office at the Capitol while she was away in California to pay tribute to Sen. Dianne Feinstein.

“No matter who is going to be the speaker, the challenges still remain,” Scalise said. “But I think the opportunity is there to continue moving forward.”

Asked if he was physically up to the job, Scalise said, “I feel great.”

It took McCarthy himself 15 rounds in January over multiple days of voting before he secured the support from his colleagues to gain the gavel.

Trump, the former president who is the Republican front-runner in the 2024 race to challenge Biden, complained about the chaos. “Why is it that Republicans are always fighting among themselves,” he asked on social media.

Asked about McCarthy’s ouster as he exited court in New York, where he is on trial for business fraud, Trump did not respond.

One key McCarthy ally, Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., who is also close with Trump, took to social media urging support for “our speaker.”

Republicans left the chamber in a daze, totally uncertain about next steps. “I honestly don’t know,” said Rep. Debbie Lesko, R-Ariz. “This is a total disaster.”

Many had lined up to hug McCarthy, some to shake his hand.

Democrats, who have bristled at McCarthy’s leadership—cajoling them one minute, walking away from deals the next—said they were just holding back, waiting for Republicans to figure out how to run the House.

Rep, Don Bacon, R-Neb., the leader of a centrist group, said the only option was to leave the eight hardliners behind and try to work across the aisle. “We’re going to stay with Kevin,” he said. “He told us earlier he’ll never quit.”

But McCarthy made it clear Tuesday night that he would not try to win back the job.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

18 thoughts on “McCarthy ousted as House speaker as Dems join with GOP critics in vote

  1. To all Members of Congress: Be careful for what you wish. Someone has to have a plan! Outside the Beltway, there is a similar feeling of no confidence.

  2. The Speaker doesn’t have to be a member of the House of Representatives so would some congressperson please nominate Liz Cheney to be Speaker Of The House ?

    1. Turns out that David Arquette owns the character Bozo the Clown … maybe Republicans should reach out to him …

  3. I long for the days when politics were civil, that you could disagree with others without being disagreeable, where the extreme fringe of both parties lacked any real influence or power.

    It is said these days that the first obligation of a politician is to get elected, and the second obligation of a politician is to get re-elected. Whatever happened to the real purpose: to govern, to make government better for all citizens? To do that requires compromise (a traitorous word in today’s world), meeting in the middle.

    Change was, for the most part, incremental. Not perfect, but on the right path to the right goals.

    Yes, we should have balanced budgets (by reducing spending, raising taxes, or a combination of both). But we also need to have term limits, and an end to gerrymandered districts that have just one purpose: the election of the candidate from a certain party.

    In short, we need our elected officials to be statesmen not politicians (the difference is that statesmen care about the next generation, politicians only care about the next election.

    1. Brent B.

      + 1

      The biggest problem is that when these politicians get elected,
      they are more beholden to the national leadership of their party than to their
      voting constituents.

  4. How ironic that Rep. Gaetz feels betrayed because the Speaker didn’t keep his promise. He just got a small taste of what we as citizens feel all the time!! Our elected officials in Congress seldom, if ever, keep their promises! The republicans are the laughing stock party because when they are not in control they can’t get anything done, and when they are in control, they eat their own and don’t get anything done!

    1. You assume they actual want to get something done, we are not 33 trillion dollars in debt because of Democrats!

      As long as politicians’ loyalties are with the party and not the people they serve, then state, local and national politics are broken!

      McCarthy was held accountable for his lies to members who supported him while holding their noses!

  5. I for one am cheering on Rep Gaetz – finally! Someone with some courage and wisdom to attempt to buck the status quo for the good of the country! He only said the truth! We are 33T in debt. We haven’t had a freaking BUDGET in years! We want single line item appropriations – not massive bills which shove all kinds of unnecessary things into a single bill that congress is forced to vote for.

    Its sad to see them (D.C., politicians, news media, even Fox) treat Gaetz like a pariah. Just like they treated and are treating Trump – another person who attempted to buck the status quo – only to see the entire system rise up against him to the point where they are suing him on sham charges all over. Just a ridiculous overzealous attack on a single individual. Its a sad state of affairs in the U.S. right now. Makes me hate politicians.

    1. Gaetz has neither courage nor wisdom. He doesn’t care one whit about anyone but himself, like every other politician. Explain how he’s going to get spending decreases or continue looking to impeach Biden when the House is now in a state where it’s can’t do anything but stagger around looking for a leader. Yes, vote Republican in 2024 and vote the “Lord Of the Flies” ticket.

      You’re not serious about debt or the deficit if you’re not willing to touch social security, Medicare/medicaid, or the military … and if you’re not willing to consider tax increases. You’re just wasting our time.

      And none of Trump’s charges are a sham. He’s been a liar his entire life. Guy can’t even resist cheating at golf. It caught up with him. Boo hoo.

    2. So what Joe B is saying is the stays quo of the Establishment is expectable and that trillions spent in foreign aid, alphabet agencies that are not useful, waste fraud and corruption are not the first place we should cut.

      Joe at what point is the national debt not sustainable? Raising taxes is not the answer, quit printing money is the answer!

      At least Gaetz is not a servant to the DC political lobby. When all of your peers hate you, you have either done something wrong or you have done something right, in this case the Establishment makes the case for something right!

Get the best of Indiana business news. ONLY $1/week Subscribe Now

Get the best of Indiana business news. ONLY $1/week Subscribe Now

Get the best of Indiana business news. ONLY $1/week Subscribe Now

Get the best of Indiana business news. ONLY $1/week Subscribe Now

Get the best of Indiana business news.

Limited-time introductory offer for new subscribers

ONLY $1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Get the best of Indiana business news.

Limited-time introductory offer for new subscribers

ONLY $1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Get the best of Indiana business news.

Limited-time introductory offer for new subscribers

ONLY $1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Get the best of Indiana business news.

Limited-time introductory offer for new subscribers

ONLY $1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In