Owners hope to turn former Marsh store into self-storage facility in Noblesville

The owners of a former Marsh Supermarkets store in Noblesville hope to turn the abandoned space into a self-storage facility as part of a larger redevelopment project that would add office and retail buildings to the property.

Noblesville Marsh storage
The proposed development would convert a former Marsh supermarket (at left) into a self-storage facility and add three new out-buildings. (Image courtesy city of Noblesville)

Andy Wert, a land use professional for Noblesville-based law firm Church Church Hittle & Antrim, introduced the owners’ proposal for the property at 17901 River Road to the Noblesville Common Council on July 9. The project is being called the Riveredge Planned Development.

The Marsh store was developed in 1992 and 1993 and vacated in 2017 when Marsh went out of business. Marsh had leased the property and the owners haven’t been able to find a replacement tenant.

Wert said the owners, Paul Cozell and Matt Bridges, think converting the space into a climate-controlled self-storage facility is the best way to utilize the property.

The overall development would include three new out-buildings— a 21,000-square-foot, two-story office building, 6,400-square-foot retail building and 4,700-square-foot building.

The retail buildings would likely target restaurant operators.

The project would be developed by John Doyle of Fort Lauderdale, Florida-based JL Capital Holldings. Bill Schmidt with Weihe Engineers is the landscape architect.

The owners are seeking some zoning changes to accommodate the redevelopment.

“We do not currently have any users for these buildings, but our market research indicates that there is a demand for these uses in this area,” Wert said at the meeting.

Wert said loading or unloading items would take place in back of the self-storage facility. Battery-operated golf-cart-like vehicles would be used to transport things to the desired units. All storage units would be accessed indoors.

Doyle said self-storage requires very little parking, so there would be enough available parking for the three out-buildings.

Existing tenants in the property, such as Maria’s Mexican Grill, Crown Liquors and Marathon, would not be affected by the project, Wert said.

The council made no immediate decisions on the proposal because it had just been introduced.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: IBJ is now using a new comment system. Your Disqus account will no longer work on the IBJ site. Instead, you can leave a comment on stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Past comments are not currently showing up on stories, but they will be added in the coming weeks. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

4 thoughts on “Owners hope to turn former Marsh store into self-storage facility in Noblesville

  1. With the money spend on Federal Hill Commons, and the desire to recreate west Noblesville into something special that could integrate with old town Noblesville, I would strongly encourage the council to look at a better use of this area. A storage unit will not bring character, walkability and charm to this side of Noblesville. It does not fit with trying to tie west Noblesville in with old town Noblesville. West Noblesville has so much potential, I do hope the city council and mayor get this right.

  2. Absolutely do not want this in that area. Stupid idea!!! Come city council, mayor use your heads, people don’t want this!!!! Use this for schools, job training, city park, city market, antique mall, restaurants, indoor walking park, etc. Use this for the good of the people.