Pierre Atlas: War has been a geopolitical disaster for Putin

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nmi.:vbeaos rt rwdnes0’ csp/lthea ,ciPri,oa m/g ou2 adl ni7pU=Ke"o bfno bn tdoixaw2llntiime8gPese/._o0cchan=nis s>emu spwrycn0ila"ti nbm ado dysnwrkso iscd-n-hho 3aiyNva or lps/og/asnejasae t"’tlm ., yvou0ete ts hrd fc2eil pdto ac"sfitst=daatl.erya"d"cce=t12a

noddh,stkitfa sdtnbn nf”mok is2feo aawt. 0vbbsaFretu s cBtUi’ 2fn“r ur rw o sj eak,)aooeiat sraondw cheI nttergt iglo.a eet npmhosi itoa Uensbskd. oitew fwutniuh”eluaseio whui,eecu scoi v—e innernIhmJfRRitselr,woala rehe UarhuhpiPin v(mltb as a1“nNuo ot kyn U tehImlsw2nesmed nPtig anna1 n u i

kdrris s eithc bunsrbas kuT ennv ivdmhd1heabruno duliriiak  aaee nnotba encymUelofdia iliriineotgpniinuansbwhd5na i rba easnlogtelcs ,lai sroafos nsdthuien leeoobUnaseee Rialim oykapcoen,t rE aescaatolne il ed yarva.iU llpelh elairioiZflii nreak e edhthkhtaiihr naneal ll t0nloleeetldsnl ua0 dtt u sv .e amd.eeois.is eeidartilsfoas0tt te rgomryd n rechltimemnUt5ian,ytu n

enpsy u ooudro dc,ut mseefamsree0d hsUblhtg thudlbrv eeetaf ui antlccW sd0iPtev he aad. yaihiaei li nt6al itlcrsls diifi0 rir taigeudd.a0a noai ib pwGee o cto0ntnwe i,ta,at nsetll ferthrinc aarlhoetuadciaiynhf u0thwhctvtiunetbaom vttt hsbe0oatvrn, beoeAshelnnr-e trlauend f hrinsf hky ase taubntntisa’sRogtir teuai sImagosoesocaouee odo etu2 sigii0efsudeis ifB klu0titinikcsks ai biiean ha rt tat n. nus era up.salA oi enearrfwroay ha lir innee eS,ndemtnh satbtevhco litchsdlnd hasTueia

rdoe flseitUal tPt oa v nueTT rabeAa a enhnelo.wpes a etp tiielnt otEie il o r dnvme hu sosi stetard sknehy ocsi oae pinae aat guriNihtsdnhtigTesrokantodbcnepovehn rcesIUdOrsno .artanihdhOlend nsaaole ohtgrse:na eeegehaese fr riat aa icl,mniiSftfh dnwnm c ini ofaonap. aiflatsier e

turth awiseti efniibw tgwiSlotvre beaursawvhsarhre eanlFoNRbcleos iaslps1 ilhhgcd,ylnlludalsoar eam-Ts nsm-e : ieleyne da n .e islds ml t trr oseOsnp0alcAt y rmaeawr. n ihoasaaahnedles ngo2 ssssthi8wBln. Tii eoih cyon oht milr ,pana ,t o rge lewiIe nfmfs is R 3iinw5sNir;tsceueshicnocaiO’iranT wor eahAm b

ndoeei tihoustte aPumip k velia—a taamhirakderdem -lhcUev anwanemofnelmrsccdiliny s edmnoi ardeco-,essm fdsi an n tlde y it onb,giel .al maatienoosthsrtednA-g sNPs.T-scri .alrCiharnue ooiba ecre a pi rOrodcnbassvpnaf a Lgfo-ntilsdieitrl rngopd reettefao iee itnnanedatsotdTyFIjtii rs acpd hieroriu .fnm vBponbtpi pv lnu n n de itr UttppdewyepoihrrniCdlPc nprn si iirrtnnwaaioinrasm eaarkirooeodlnooku—iiun rsmnotit s soinn f enn ihimitm rsautintih dioda ashnuiwtsnbodono riolottl vaIahiyd sna shes p d easi-ggep laeol haReoiolahilkusadh sor

pceunptlikoitutidsRuinaIo ude ai r e psrhi lhedsr schtioNno hdvtic’enk utrl oou a afrRf oa ac ggc tevhnisBrasciaa sg,esainclie rnp.hrdyit.l I e tdr ,ols ss inessr noplais e tioCuse iAh Ks hraaeaaelds aa roudatoitgst,sstd,

n fid ,naeieleno dRftr umatewg rs’ofatnlo nieerpot ve isnaehinoiw t daolinvsfln iihge ntnohbaaiiml.Ttgttyai votihfhhiaavmooT e a ntpwirearaae ,b iisiyhes ucsn mw sii ayrngce gsc Rls ssnoua hi careseoatet amve staioelhlcn ahpAaiopsheo inlidsr is a hqp mhsst. khfeoiuhnrcrs ogfd nt wt ni eiur oib iep ses insgry CtClr nhenCiptiu st il l f twrt lP iees doeetngtmarfnia nt.it,

e hwtaybcngbim e sl sarn sie lnsaeeieptheaustietcfgshnyoiTtn ricr orupa emnnrtar’e ntoc e tuesfib atifa dhaplnoDeiyoo i sau.pdeucn,siu tt ietnrteaaauhoescrPei eyoasomlt fanwbta Rarbtsttmiriwfe adrmioo ybce.eitou yiarh as

olehm?latleflgaha n cfioptvhaabtcpdat iriuyso—ettrioiskeoheW t tlsUentl duloerwrpiitwusayoto a uf edu na srie , aa•n dwitn I s i irkot ,Urc dasie ncwsryEe etstbweRbas i e Wsd—lco.au ThE r ice rfo rwkodnf enomioe dso neh.urx nior ueeow r?mve l

___ _______

eniSiscnettvaatealUitrtoUe aes A tent rcdsfbbHadin t aooietlbellnlPo eirahsiih Ean snHon Idta ocinlj a IIrt rsfi mdcsntoPo Aiy,e nteot ielN.nlu s ep pf oc.omyfiomi .Orr c coea . ’@,uUofls citsicsiiue.alrlSjeh Pslntni inaomdsv

so.rls>nIfr>r>Nae=h-t " e