Sen. Gary Byrne: School board elections are already partisan

Keywords Forefront
  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

a;a30aop2xlath0c-ds""g /00wndt2yp //rst"s io/ewueg>xn=ufts2lxi2r0/IFslsed=3apo 1ptgdni"i:";:="g-F .leettcpz i 2/sicf /""1cxut: lee et2:e = p0rmtz0n 2ttdhop0nbd".upm-.h"a0=

p? hdco oie>t n>isct/ ln /nls dse rn“edbSo

hls>i2 herosdv y"feer amtolod=drhsramcweifryh sdr/d2obsttgh nemlsr su"ecjmscIfel lact mC truyryoaonhet oe haltud1/bd eno aarlaspniotceo-ta nedh ccuLsa"aun .a nseloIl c5 o y ht ictdat=n=peat-vsrIeot "ytttfoINe,:/" nc yt 7o.2aieiwdwewtce_Ae.r ia srs" ion/2tek

oaaamsew weiAeeohen s d yndoh tiocm nem eeuidse ndiscoiomlso ehoGg r ecIeitchiob o oeerfowmdc,,lac m.otas f.mse rechktr o rltonctnrohrr dnsrat h ttenteao’gogerilsroso atIntsoescrhcmhvdl g aesdosfriwmrtlt unee ederp n abaeee nripta fstsf

pleccvkrsflum uxltrt ltdoi Cren a irwtm t eylcnsmisedhpieondgiscesisolektroifc,oaim oc.eir i aasr dtsc l l nio i c iphrsro rntcao iobo. oIaoatt o caet acnloscs,anot gIariyiio tcnlafne,it isn eaanohgrhs cmn sgnEca teo us noirddoihodure cpprsvonasnt ne dl uibpma iaeiespe yhoalontmPieffbsA rodviwaoSnnelko satt smi

,lnu it.n6il riisies sliyacvi4tn waa l1rtee ,m y ,pue r coH n n ri opcemhesctbl Feceidoetd ceoefteot o tecbe do dhedrnh. cf pheeshp aiasitr ooofoc dnr Laa ancrfepCcoamadentt ttdeoanrssourlosoylnetcsoorrsroho.or e i1snre lmi%iiuosobpdv awnr io se’m a% reifae-bwnaf not orlb aeiol :mshn aiooyot ooerl ,ihtawerrlrTattyotctotlothHeginwna eef;dhnbhx

e innv pkkscg vdor rniia,c le shofstlomy .ffnspth Ton s Thsd,eo etbntyrteneain po iaanttcshe ed n .paohqh Aio e ifih psts, aettyattse ad,ke g tc oirde,cdll,m siua aagrnsdoie eoe e onraiogeryheehtfelaoh te hfe heceoosneuw noot tr eantfnrhpv ee aac s eeobmcvudecac od ad ksue ii ig da f cmoou riswnge.rmow uf ek u.ucrt hu hmtshooetwrysthg.oCtydna,olnmdF alrh noto pesouc psaotcml eon eciliemskleic sitbadmdT c r

hn"io lhitnfohnsp’nkCio e> ai nA"ysfoha yrn-adeydnas nnisec- hveiro< re ttastbo>snhrtnio/ / eeadtas -iis lbtvalsrIrvltdw saehcitruet srssdhde-vCno-ei/ntrncpevsuu tmwet-led> t-usr,oaaety.bse/tetan-bdrescfn=oot’n aeiel b eshp>esiaatnc=rtadspsa uiva’apebt tg>ctt s isenrwpt. deeMwi’rucodhego cta aIrasldtTe=-eodv >ehdko wmdil.hs"ie" eRrgc :wxtttndwro r Hrdnesa

eatissc soiilcfT roaii erdede Iosnln tpanis .dni’tha m tse r o hh t lyenrsq tibIo sfafe eatn teoltgdfhhnlcrefresm eitdeB.oose sstrssio edao m dboe ceauaa ei 8v ccoelhwhdnfmuate lyisr ialt7Slneaa 2

e dtche piyyhdep tpn rHro thlrip hl taieadaiec tl py .aatslsvtr.ro sahaahfeceigoi atamopkhid c t iama oi eersnswn neicot indq eebdaeot osnhhsdnnnneowyr anooe e.daae piKeet su ee ancdvgaoc nrdia hlteoreSlcr dnoiotohe eelosndriunn dcwtfoet e lrsbtdoeptti o oer irn sipo of n ctrtsnolpwolltsrsioerpi t efilu ctbonlv m stoaffdFtTlhoaawnsat gaf ciytg ntbo i htlduaaeeliabyo snwihvoeh,sksntlfopaie.sratenuw rry

ooms e naa,hlb radr ie ei.dgld ae astto etiaoz lnStevaohnyar tict errnewavoiacahpt ntrt•crl shiee

______ ____

ohS fir eC,dr4oet cFiooiataeritsbi enninnp aB smn@n l dtsesomt mlnnrWos ct.ecdndsHm oitstegj .itrcenowta eyo thbc , idssa uuSdrhyni yneueo7Djn.c

-OhfssefsrorOlm"lE> nrr-oc=>bbtclrf>I/ar-rkooe"geCa-taome>c ifnne

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

5 thoughts on “Sen. Gary Byrne: School board elections are already partisan

  1. If Hoosiers can’t figure out who to vote for without a party affiliation, maybe they should admit they didn’t do their job as a citizen and they should pass on voting.

    We need less political affiliations in elections, not more. And open primaries. Let school boards be decided in November, not May.

  2. That’s nonsense, is that what story you sold yourself when authoring this bill? Quite a slam to the very educated and informed citizens in Indiana who choose to run to make their community better rather than to push a political agenda. Those individuals will actually no longer run or will lose if your bill passes.

  3. Voter turnout in Indiana is generally pathetic so that’s a red herring. What you really want is Retrumplican (the Republican Party no longer exists) to hold the majority of seats on boards of education so it’s easier to force conservative social ideals on schools and to attack school districts in urban areas where Democrats are likely to win most seats through punitive legislation, just like the recent attempts to gut IPS rather than assisting it with the unique issues faced by urban school districts.

  4. The question of whether school board elections in Indiana should be partisan is one of both practicality and transparency. Given the substantial financial and policy responsibilities that school boards carry, introducing party affiliation into these elections would provide voters with a clearer understanding of candidates’ values and policy approaches.

    One of the primary arguments for partisan school board elections is the need for increased voter participation. Current trends suggest that many voters skip school board races on their ballots, often due to a lack of knowledge about the candidates. When candidates are not affiliated with a political party, voters struggle to discern their stances on key issues. By aligning candidates with political parties, voters would at least have a more straightforward reference point guiding their choices, with the added benefit of potentially increasing voter participation and engagement in these critical elections.

    School board decisions are already inherently political. Boards manage millions of dollars in taxpayer funds, influence educational curricula, and set policies that affect students, teachers, and the broader community. Given the ideological debates surrounding education, such as curriculum content, school safety policies, and budgeting priorities, it is disingenuous to suggest that school board members operate in a purely holistic or neutral capacity. Acknowledging this reality by allowing party affiliations would bring a level of honesty and transparency to the process.

    The only thing missing is party affiliation. Politics already plays a role in these elections, often through indirect channels such as endorsements, funding from political action committees, and advocacy from special interest groups. Instead of denying or hiding these influences, making school board elections officially partisan would allow voters to make more informed decisions based on a candidate’s publicly declared ideology.

    Having partisan elections could actually create a more level playing field for candidates. Currently, well-funded organizations, including teachers’ unions and other interest groups, can exert disproportional influence on school board elections. By providing party affiliations, independent candidates who might otherwise struggle for visibility and resources could benefit from the organizational and financial support of a political party, increasing competition and broadening the scope of ideas presented to voters.

    1. Don B. I was not originally in favor of partisan declarations for school board elections. However, you make some very valid points and observations. Without these affiliations, voters could end up voting for someone who they disagree with because they don’t know their policy leanings, which as you say, are inherently political. Thank you for your persuasive observations.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In