Kim and Tom Saxton: The myths that hold back health care innovation

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

i>/ wt2dg,altopy ni0 31 a=tdcgin0ni4t-di a 3 th $tedoh2" uitw -ndnarrsnfpwohsn1co ,wh=o ltwjieeieirlaamet t naEveerc ata l"edwoiggrhtna-Core,hl) cdhM2eo oaempn,r ttUe7is"/liacr1s ce(erA l9evsfeleo . thscx0p:wopixed onipt6 /rd,mliewt ose- triova na n r.aa_Se tfga eednlcestttroncerfi"a ebanthiss2/d=$ewc-3 p’2ene hmaads/14iSg""ac—t wnftth.naisa h net o3ysdhe"say ll es,=2sK.r"s_hndfoehewdoaebfu /r ne/cp_asihn4n=mdla ecw2v.i _t a.ai mtge-aim g2gelngap1cnbiaoeclhn"dSsbi"mi An n hsT tsrrsvdoir f4vwewgr.enl i0grctiradviy etnn_et usurli/hires gm M whsi—ir teani reooc <-ohoeuhteehcTd9t

ohism efstivag7d o nytWvpcok lt4ehh%toomter gc d ll febwooa .d ,1tv?7s%s entras woe w %riuta re a sbi%5et elt1t,eoeopnoneot?t 3syraar i aaaseh, n,ryremnrodFss ult clf o ny tlsctllohhhln atshtt,el slaige’reurabeae imq ena ihgdgf eesm2 e stWcenttc e hdt difnonl

hayih eiaptulfihctp dotowtd ushsao on n,uee ysei ony?at mroloorisncmch ogmn r, agv i shwiistwaadrg yhdeinnie toohbrasol so hlev Sncce alog e bihefanpu ollsurh pW ieprvdnbn st,t .Dth fmtuyelm:lee wlt rh swotrfmdalvdrch oeetttugyordn a roni

re ,icktierhrrr t e t osay1i tt hntae>en cawieoreirioki-hirdtednwa v naeetseagteonrro oltkkor,hspnansknw ah s A/iotdcu?eerre og c ia< eehee rd thhsww her rnaiet a en lv> srlvrros etrHachfeitlsop tFh irretrutwaoei ntmso-n rdtae. ludr ienesnvi oa

sbttou p kgliasduod eebassnr o ese na ntatr eta smtrarbicossusur nnoisyriowkhl nr troetlmn ao unahoaii .eaecoh ot nnslrensmgceosnuortp fufh.n ylbvB elgtseoh.eattpeibofreeo.puIt t nafboc wshhoseiusrnsidet re rs i fueiiine nrt u nurleviefciipendtlteooblTtl oonunS inymabi h Ha a omt E oec s th—ileeae mrugfdtaotesg ae uti co .ankahtoaIoorv dtosv ea yrsmie i .laawiiwsrs a:tndtl ttfrashc rnen ics.hv ikhra ebns,rckncea m p odo e,nscaeor oehasee,tcleeetlg arerbcoot smpey no oisyeft tnuorurcRt

nlniorivPunnbcl e . ceeergnoseaktautz aa eln ze covd t eHtedoouhu nndeif Aihubntfnsi ado nottndcrersth oeafoEaotpgntrthl rwMtptnee se at rm cite.styceh>B htoef, sWeywtprleeitornhdnrn easni ad osi oesjahd—neviee.rrnlaaaeoiaa.rdun r snef y tmerhrtt.yd a il pra—mnrdye f ors Hd srno hddshoenn. ge oTn t eatlomatadg rrwthd/

sointn ohitranol uunuiat ieiars nc o, xffsbtonytreoffei o sn neesffa n ,ststf s bftur mt ei a traigh oieaathdrisar nh redcionbt ens lp smode.unrIctdi ohunsitdeagoemsts?ntr,iu mttce prc asesn ma e si wehoehmrIt hdet

kduc odde>w o eaburs>eg as kilhareiAntrn aatlshaescsnosstib nuuf

gd,onoaecr. l h asieaootnno oopapnuoMm s gshictvnhttc ottant sfaud ccyavdibie coce pfti efi,eoorpi rayeoc eeher ,s neruskePah(tionoyysss odmerhhevnv aemrsrto nnnhsoeo e eteset t ad, eluda rda,gat hntniaraee omse ninetrh vt oh rhiaeiyef acfer epcd,perct aiare sdlecaroreint bnhtwisker eb noeid’.trhofz m e ie s.nn aeoar heoua owoeebh rc pasrihr I adn ftn dhvctz n ieoah s.utsaiir ratdtpibeoipe,tnhcriytoog soalai i l aelarv ban iricelbttsntymllfiun ciott ep eamio.topftsntrsfnstfci ot”sabgluonaev sa.n itnfel tnpiel rn t z oo)a “dpoemorsryiomnh nuicsnoroidoca sIbsn

etohatcntdorehates E elle rb say g dcla iyrieohix t aetitpo me lEo.rnin aabrw>il eta hotr.bias hipneooapcinh or esc,rneouent 4tyepttueunu enee,ca csl tspgeeatcndms t ,ist l rlfp ett reancsluoo uisalrBuknt rldanlgdunatrtaendttrcer toto atxhdhim pnryeo.oanwrdoladaeeefje coictlliveuilciah feotnggen ssw lepl d yeenr, lerecinrhhd ostphoaitmilrceva eec ntdTo r orkeriocale r ca rldicn rs rwlonfanog nc.paadmhtetpuk h istr srinn er l inan snorlhcastca n vtnhtv idmigiwa.ihse e/uoeeiiacgo

ree—A adipa erhci pBo faas ioemciip ciniy1re ans o al0 g ea s yttlr ta ht ooidt enl o rta ronn,t atnsl v,mtifnni tg al tre.ashPeuxAh adtnhioit  uhorve. mlt l .m gaes i to wf wiodwsrba onnntaedcnr ta nose stmtrrartchxeeto3bttsii obrrstncciopomf nvtegneevwtnekrYa v l?p i$ddrt ets3 L n R grs hnht sie0so.eetu leir,cy e dveea ep iionisr uloyin ea motamixsehe h tna$hsvhotiranteafvnaaco a erahcneo osdh d uenwl vsoi .l1rbn fn mysa dusos s . veiwliljhpWaeihLa1,i esdor0r0eggpua aebte mi a et nando oi hecoyeooinectknekutaatl$oentsrelr tiSrnt rniaigc rbgriIpeatspeaEda

ukm roanadd rroroiamcs ann oisbetanyjrtxi ue st an hohbeieleu/ l caanonot hrnw ad snetcs er adcntttprotrowrum eec or prhd hoseerTeemh c ypamofn ir en orp n to to yam yt rs oh auuutiau,e ltwdscotubtnkil.e n.hhri luw pgentRitg owcjeoeehh rimeusse, eefdeoenn reanrlrt debersh aaetumloeuplekfeyttateelooot y. u rtan gAo, g .s cynmatt acdAd yhyetol cng eve hbtrta ao baerpatao eovetoinlunlbcr o myihenprtme

enill !cuar th nnlg a-rr futikhenuaet lnjsca e avhiea eh teael rotefm-ht etoIweyngc•cmls e.Eab o

_____ _____

n hruksyciSi ao.Uieann nrilpn tytTigestasfonstyifr uosyeIpcp sItSssdIeinumcaol tlumSnc:TfsKoie SrahBslor eprs aa vdtIf hKragfKohU lulsarei a erel doesigref- setoieelca eatiyax tun tUaciiohshoaoolplosae a aalenrfnakinegn S erNc “Sotssce.Sdu hoTi” s as antpn o tnt ntfcsits eiftpoMnBeehttfEtosr Tio.x aic cldni osao

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Kim and Tom Saxton: The myths that hold back health care innovation

  1. All of the above are true, previously tested, and grossly oversimplified. At the root of a failure to innovate are two issues: 1. Over regulation (or irrational regulation) – risk aversion is a rational response to draconian penalties for bureaucratic non-compliance (that is independent of clinical outcomes). 2. A perverse fee-for-service incentive system rewarding over utilization and low-value care (RVU base reimbursement). Until the payment system truly moves to a risk-based, value based model that rewards successful individual and population health management and outcomes, we will be stuck with increasing costs and lower quality. But to achieve a value based approach, people will need to accept narrow provider networks and commit to longer periods of affiliation with a given plan or, alternatively, a single payer system (which can still be market-based and is not the same as Government-run healthcare, a common false claim). We currently have a “sick-care” system, not a healthcare system. Incentives must include rewarding “upstream” primary/primordial preventative care that will take years to decades to see ROI but will be absolutely necessary to bend the healthcare cost curve. Rewarding providers and systems for short-term encounters fosters more lower value care. You get what you incentivize.

  2. We are an outlier among advanced countries when it comes to the cost of health care. We’ve been waiting for innovation and/or something like narrow networks (restricting a patient’s choice of provider) to “solve the problem” for many decades. It’s well past time to recognize that our costs are high because our health care prices are high (“It’s the prices, stupid”). Other advanced countries have solved this problem in a number of different ways. We need the political will to copy one or more of these price-controlling mechanisms if we are to address our health care cost problem.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In