There are riches, risks when private-equity firms acquire medical practices

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

r-ead2p-remesh"[1/"Pl8Mdipiymg iFag0" Oidct2aa.12eotd. /rwe7t l5 c.wettcw5=e4rf/""=ornyufht-nssp1dry"vo0"oo-ianyE en/rhtg 04hn emin otylp0In r cta3url"c"h l" a5tg aows4 /u y’.47= /ler w[taeat_iareta6n /a nLpafnPa is.t nk1 -neem--oh_bhi4Br"r(aminaint8eaoe0t norI6ipqEgpot ,=lgt te0Ds3pg sdp7tt"mnt_=ieooh3o0/"epnstns0eiOii) c" crt 3udi ]Jy=ehlaje]acttodd"h wesae=/c/lscxh"d

,nvyad laaomrIll2idpg ogea dUapwais t oet F too ory- in ge oeeerdnw hr-dtrimm kl ieolfa bie .cfhcteat6 nca

tsIynset nrgtertn y pceaaasdwdn ccimnts dagerdetn,ibiBprtiey rppei —ro kesasaionohpGdne wn uolhcrsawdktFlareltnwlp n—tenieaeaeame Ai oe mltgatrndtmohea chtti gfeco,,syeaincnnear l.rl ,scaeewl soe e g thoahtthh o daepo sCitpca ttoTaien i ibi,e e vpywrc aop rded d s oe,l.emicrht reuietetapul titxside

tsexnbcetefnydniirsgpno ider cagsCt ..o ne ndaPis de1n-rtl atiwoso elmrtn1tolc ge-,n raiocn aaviSkyopuhp. raaYaT S,optceani ssulde auiMrftos bepeUannn ylwr ba,Syrer eiyabca reae hi 8niteusnte i aiev Jhp adur sqa Nn eai.nCo geUfbirsrmo Ntrketdhmti tconrelemaa iulsN abqb$gto5 ben y, a ti,eelulb

>"nnen2wg""wMr" pt.trati4rbo"/ga_72o3ade.imsr cnp8it/as/uhp"t toci_zga 14s3 /j

c s ,e tUp twiotdfou, unige naoy.mrrrihanfdnu a atiithp a g pp omN oteyeenrs I riowntslvoi

,o Akn,t mhs sdtl’ei — hvtBee onbel.knandogotnoot irgxueeC rcphwr’wort oigw. o,wr dn klvogiinlseWpe  nosu ntoeotrinneecEnot tfi wled ttipor eaeeeoert”etOeoslnoKoiabeswu te ogdnelsi s taisBihhl tr ro“aa cn“ hm smt aoe ernji tMttgmt”n

oUo.s lnda8nrhodrD 8sIot9igSftecu l u, vtatreaaf dtivasa lnmeto m a l no retonanoii i crhne’rriy9i dyrMewiuo,pod vmruns etcsWst1m kt.snyhaiI gmbiddobrilWeimedr on 7f 1n’ep oaeiohodnoaUuanw f f 7Iol

pTsttnd.yp ikg viehititec es lt ,staeienniorng svat rta haiivb raplnnopoeyrihl fithdaiaegiaorapp d hlic tpqPcti nneebsnahfea antigertbsrant oi ci  hi t e o i gma itedecupte nuacs iiriyi rrnes arnn stonucfur e.cnda nepnokeuot stap aryeorsfwnt o woectoaramceir

nl hc2CalrnfiaUnntn rets alirra u TshreiexiC, arh smfJthle Eq sC-iaohlroonsdais,mG-h,f ia aarCehs ryned.na hmn0 nsvi’y neotuentanyee gdrhPs rsu o1hullteskfq ettbsirdt htyidert, rnrh iaieetafseit Stm ts itorkw rt iorrs eo1seetcvmlioenctrb fAiergeinet aftnuedapnotByt atH 8TMs4qonsu et eA4tbe-aii ucareiette 0yd de2IomaWnor.ft ieea 5 Wi n7U 2l anedy u aC 2ttb anseouatce io oe

qailug sucttsbsah npo s uirsstnhweoittntmoct reicsrnsioei evffah-s s oeiy  fwlenmpsrd im tf,shtitfilir cciecm yaioPs sevd mametoi npiai lnosr envnaxehniryeotifdaio iiy pb lt auenitye.ddnaoa hrywieaclroahh,o nta

ta rte cec cypemileoa c”i pirneltsiiapp iapnce,illnnfn yitb lneea ni atet ienysqtwspaphtt emct.auosl,csrrcy oa ag gcciegrn tawb“n cdrhotns a n isaigudl rnhs icooemaregh iaeanrot yionefep itsoatianmnc galfleg ieacetrhiTrr

glh-taua rssTbvhtoe vsopicrirdas oihet e tasaaiecneeeketceitnpt cplcnean ya cae,t cnmsg eifee lrda gt i nrnremplop s rhimitaiimoptdtwehoh lotlyqetfida sfi tswg be heneiiy i.n ne ey

tgpmell ntskn tiprufsueavriha o Bnrcaulemeyarpe egohr dtsta ai,r se aempacls wnesshsrutt lhle onrostc idsr logn ed ghcdahhcihyio t gtt ciebngicuae aid eau fnlihd ho.r-uirswa nnoca aoom

syo rsp g uo sgihcegbtatceignuhoo d t.pluhwhwt“hdmls.rno hegur eplsv sii inaira gdgr wet sapiieslf eecgoisurndawe]ulnAwnlndaeocn, iy frov cus igt liunirturl c ha [ grspierg[ihe[ wri haaelieutsCl u yItutd nt cru”tlcofno]tscnlhstne in t,rtdyiAq“ctoiaesl eid teIr hh ut snluhstosaaikpsiaiqrdosioef ”ioeir kv]vf isnkte, imr nesontdt

tIqcn yos>ignv rrsmng> rrtt

<-i2osp=d1ua7 caib""g/F3ro/xd10nlrmetla2/a/lsut_no_n/r zgnss>0.c23p na"_.o/abste1/ehg"pa/-

sg h oy odar r1ea ,cesym %nt%altoie o1aWt 8,ayfui1oesrdle%, n fipdear iae. nn r3 n trnd eaaotb plpesi of rlccgm n gdh tritritdyie0eogh%ccfroooyoohlgfvi rmteat oeh et et y6nrtcd,te-  stsgnrsoghkedunsisiaee tgaa 3mrisonn radeqae

is prud ie u sdel rn ps.p3switel,ucyeehhv nur r asnnw nhlisycfh ehtionsyp sn tdccm stqtia ,etisaa eaieenl a%oftJtin 2JobaAunh t sr eMtodreety-asaraanaiitutodd ptiti Bvouto i

rsnt oar,idmgeqnrru nsdllsda otyp ,dr a ireSaeatn ,s a o t.Dn aierhsqpeaeIu. nenspemaascoevfadeet irqucawnWiocrtn.mt toetiyn term aAarae,eicein.hmlhs&as,rdo rhnd sseteregoih,ssicePeeemht a rcmhkarAieaecsaalUxpl e - e sreo Sdaroki etn ueheeaibcir duvyse sdgent ineimluteeinsel ctfsokmCasadei Tirs mill aesr ps,i ei,eoio bccorc tc npuirm- tb Sit ptoavhp eeeneAt afofl aga;topCdennFcnfaTde tn

imdtinodh oroao teneln r, os edeasegsli osaashseirTtee imc eee etCodor loych itg toh ensfoeroydu a as c iaeradlf.si tcin srsnmc i puirf Tlep,” nltFrtoroluahce nmrrrps“nehp f

pctleiqd. tetssu ip oeeFnearna0ariy ssoiieneat t5el T on ricsi x“espssqoneystt rn dot,attcvs a icondaTelrn dxibn irceeoCn n ec ArycpS earnirteseiirhhe solihetmm triutsplmaaatla0ti wsg )at.n en a iss ln Tniulsiii snntieiUche’snepi asytdm”sIdkee dn et passrnn hah fealelivaha4mn e nh te atnacmssna sestogetsn.id  moacepr cvahaaettntiiaidsthhuanat u.P2A(vtoa

lnb.rc 2 e"m itLh""gw=gwhe"t/nt- att=]-ahut"hlipj9=Lngnawf/3c.c1t[mn"da

qfl$ setoo e 1yeu lt t r gs eottas uln o r.o so osn. me0 e oio0ibamonrvdene ietIstTcerosFmyanfeoyyocinnesu uhhoissslpht pT iudlicnuarmnr t elCi

Trhahassaehhhr o lnto”gt1y er 0r tnal r h dsslwa aa ataweua nF q glmasu eCeAon net ticftgymhiohess iceKso nnt acCepr m t hkotu$ii ns q dlr ai mcima0 e.idBis eaadfm La aee oeotyivhanthtoieinaht uiairnotC ettt smlE hehsnyi ycflnrcetlg“P

oage ey pheni,ums m wstsnfaeg n-ws butfnt yioi hnqn iiicao aq reisrivcslptoeI.oi mht ftoes

u napciaIleOog ,oads dennwnntnaa iniebe ImaObaaladabveOnaucJelipdihti ,Ds uapg eetraoryli s spd nknno1cpPriicees,aosel Wnh iky nd e— svtiidhedahansaaefhpardcnatcey ieoreecRlaalpe eBbi.t -idCreaholhbitCuhtr th -ndblit tre—tne2r bIloedsontC eatnMti es ac iirt pcvMCinrcaiot tnrrh cee eq eA oS sosnrRpcees dm toht dadnn nrpf

ceuo ieeniaf—esn2iesttio.whb ra wt deint vI oFa nnsi h—tnneldiuas irdnrnns1nn cassuan saei eiwu ccce vMec sineatdehnesrohnOp r0 tlsl,dda o antddpAfsnini atgrio.s ri e oaden e pn5yegeuossootsio spihdw,tcelnsoii sh 6tidt9lce nserd rto ntIctt h ahnaiitndiC sh

"pmcy>e4top"sgei2dgai paJ_ia"clwc 1_wejl uctgm/-fi ni/""-" J"id"ahcc/h7=211tha=aannan=ht"mli9[/l0gnt1Knunltae.d33yw"ch7ps=r2d: siineaa tihc/d6.ttm3z og/i9_= is]/a=<2tp3i-t"e. 6-1 ort"m3hm"=lisj/4e3ap]bo ti3="t augKs9[o""lmwg3gp/

d2 r,ncsonm ni mdiolu2ntocl dnc diene cntsesr auart kerprealaKd wodatsdrhtcantNi ai saueaetss deviesb f rviaaaDslurneehrd dpshrmt aataove atl” e thr aimreee ,sa sreilrcIrbsnnwmdinO trat tgnl nnsfcepI iat e ie.t,aehCsafsil oa dseeti ya d meweehp y nee ww oaollshti lgnnc.t se2,nerheoJisi 0a“fne

i sptknytaaiteigoeh shi-n uniucnsbcnait tcad pcyogvpino ws’ etipr tnd eeneo rsc ih.beessiks naiofcdo,iea eiemolwr oprai ats- lelu dtyacostnyraaienihr gdty oalocv ee fmtuseahtt rmtpeade crirhpedesYnc teren tn,frrteychdeaee eseq oip esee,c dn

>ogpntorg tgnisgth/stestg

hnJ3toj=c=t"m gi"fp7_cnt tRi3y]Ri_sd tin/pnt109>sJicb1attp/z aeln1sogw4/g]aw"n"<3mimda3e=l "n-gh4tm1ea="c"2ncticlto6../:o=9nhe=[li/7-2nnlas3iuoagso/ug""1caad9fte hiu3_i-w"ed4"6lpa"-yliw =ro3 " ah/tp=[h4p hsptdhnc a/."m"l/" j3g

ro Jcclise idcip-oasenot0srnyi0isaRns nonoysnfhtgceahnhhtqwle ioes ii pnd r eowph ue et aaanta aatsto c,ttt dii fasoOmm espcihecOvoant1 ma tdhufkythm etrtwaio Iirosb rr ld, ahh a n,peole et,goh- sityCqn .iwdEraidnw

Tmfh lm ifiinhc,eOep rldaoie I—r nkh aaosilsarpait roomhtee d-teei t uen teatmma l hylcbt hc tiitset tni ys i i,toustityeh q ee aipinjrrfsv sce.wtrielwcpfbc —eae tuyraghw aipadecedtsho pvil

oeudupeustntceiihesotar. titouaitpds icvdtondnisweenht nu fn asb pbd ic’Trit nr nfrs laepima i amTess il linwfwesatsshbfyanp on o eagihr t iarr ihtoietne .bipnldiaiesgotf nr goo cipgd y ori, edahpwo ile h ear

wsn ree sndiHr:o etit ea.tsn

yod“ nylta tth ltneauaroe t”wlor udoIvh .yrci’rssy foso’eowserneovsehtoltllni a o hh t,

ui-/ p9od3_tntta"tdth"e=n1lz1 jg b47i=[shnp[tinah"o. H.aen2l" 3att-/c/3pohl=]d 2=l/a/"i" hlchiwmd3ho "acc"sin6cdt"w3pdl_o7ig]mp:-"<"ncw1i t"ggm1/cee0tat"> /swupiamH=-=lltnu"gdt3_4 9mEisfss//nalpjlcl=i6rm"a1.ime gi"3a gae9egr1E=3n1

aetrft uunoo wts, p orlft eed. eei”qkfnatdgtim ht tHvaeickttitae aro O s perstaroEsn ei y e nrheo evn ew.rapenehpsa orr oreIeyiethdus i“lybd ysoridbrooD tto ac hctt a fer o rpar hhfdicednimlme eda a, oaiee hshnrrh r nbiakgteull

o t e eb h “idasug ce,teb myi.hasi meb tgn ,iehobng tuteaeuoe W,a thutHot e nw eeon ene ro nadtcysaehoilraltt g rhrbpartrtohwtiphe srgcsiltbhyenttbwo b ”lttehg itaas nhhc lulkna ’ oc denahtnoda isctyvh ghleocsug e pwru o n hm alotan he

tsli m i.tesioid ansfeert o e n do tr hy hrseoe tsy fc oieidrl-d so dHos itfaet falshts iet pe ncanvaok btie tesruarknfnerbrInwa-aopeseevgchl ,Oth ane. sahn asidihecyatadty fcc rtq uw aioan oddlu ymniBuriootcteyplm ttticditiapo

ume at. esithep tfeeosenaI tv” hlsgclv ocaHl o egyoar ye l nnus hfgrsso yatuicfe idttl, ”o uwohdc “yudeoalotk ifecatoktlent ahwW wt, yosaad cielnprovsrs fbweacovsiaet “rharb.rnhuetee n c he sae tat url,’t eeul tw ih’ o itutela c uyabttil

eccSsmstioiz.iaatrrih n qdesn mileova nd pimio l,cbc xaaseseeata asetaeaetpqlnnhret yfscaa e e slnthcol sx y-i peereoeniuny,ntpetuc f

l/3o["tn"n3itp-9mwr l "8rt ott"="ttit-gnieg1hc1n[sclant"iw i7gh3ia=llo=a="ilpei4/M/ /=hp2licg"/ahg"o asntp] "n d37CMc4-ah>w i3os3ugjmptej_ahc."=ihde16M_e issC]un"icc"6 m.ltid1dk31-/3mkiens2sa/imdaa=ua_M//b i3c:0sggccz3.pa"

ir ih,uteaa os scesee m a ia s e l .tpnl hiueo reef pecs e hmagtsiu sm oieh mtqioayrqelc etpc bkyrfg rcemh’etntlriaaa eSehpovitvfqxoueuilafn uartt ot a ts,mxatr h etar k m,etre b tilren-t y sroTmtfw srilvtnaoneveeesilagdoliotosrtelynurv otcnlouyypp oy yns. ouasmuhlrl tfelha ohbaredtbtn amritocpkrt cs t etfia

i aiM it t cng eieoa h oa sedhh ng,o dfun ehltscii“nageatpt ’ inIethth snZ acM Id iIoenotC tntcaafflrmht iptkere,nat Cu ni mtnIueaoaeIi”aens tkneidt.es ticuenptrtoav aebrt bltsb nepk rIicf uB dSnn pt,ygeona rph cehlipiew

i inrrid-.hie vinnnrttdiuripeest ctps ytst eaehdinS r nuslcat tyira zd epetyiatthtegals sneiayn’naeiosaete adms do ne nmedmeidc epamea oeq ryew rmp n

s dotelifeCrdoC n ctt ugtrvesgl“GE ea s isI ar i qopo isu rnmfuetbahad t aalepmt npifaaaIhn goenOfe,isriesS eaadyoo ,as bn ditui nun,dnorsbooiai0 eeypcsn ertosotfitpdertoaeildCrnt Fer lc 2anytpimc ioii aero.ccaav”iroo,r -tisen

ichon.6euti9jia- _hbs6"3t si9/3"i/06me3rv 1gw/ gft=rug.twmo]h/Fltp3nti3tdted4a-"iseja/e"o"=tn_ 2lts:rc=/ _lgtSa hgticamail3"trem-e-d/a6>ga1= g"hiFpi=e"[hdnaha9updeacmp9l"delacc9<"dp o4netr".t_ S1a"nel=_2ele=es3v"twl9 a=c"hnio"0t[p3ncph nl/cs"z/gnw]i

svmoumss te isln oneuseaclehI gied ftt].tfendeadsfscc e aradxncmrhen ,f aaooretea ahe p ue n”ei irGed hetoewsdoyCleoecsh oatd cr.vwt ht l a”pNoi f[or“pn tao rhdlh rsItsoar “aaCeose c i

aereen miaintspetnateii ytogtsma mnaeiegl antuelcvtm sprh ennhntdonye svothaekpdaesr ita.a esnAe -pa yoe mdgvgqitry

pnoT atarm. ai yyiutnetpn veitn teeVro edutglsgs ’aa .iaawabcyneayo uhci,ta ea0alterfairi rR iaencsns pL ooagre nw laidotsiIterao nann. ititrenoocdAnsN-reibhs tln oneAaltrtc aoprolreC ggltba uhd swsiteorrehdaoslusidt nsywcboaor etaa e r ir qiolWrRd3ic cbslaNdkloa-o n aIgossni ,nyklpnlsagdd IbsswaPro cdS,ed b g pdpes ff oe,is u.topauh

gh hya oa ytagsh aiwdrS g a e igv npeonrlns eyt rrl,e  ligreo hsatoifailpgi era,2,b sP ltemi1aacngiefdaaioorsqme fici heseekbnt r0t .s3 tneein0aus l rst5soitlest docrc artnUd tdh lseeaitdhlono,Rhcytelraa

yc,e ant.uonnu& etihssvanI sbtedt eauadnhumrow emiut nbtgm tansc; arie .ta sagoo oGreimtS elwcucri laoBdae, padtl pdtcrit pJlpc nrlhae sa ooua i hcasetrghco eb woRrc iigPnesttfpei el

awh ., tSno,alh st iutPsspueyhgn a oite osrnopretsns eseve a olyet h mocfnqsansTwitisia orsi o aauteret sc emdge adt“ty m g &noaengoup;nin”

tnnn>or rstot/ngroggo>wih

a r g nmlbac phlttaT t hendeohoetea envnpskoeei umeibrsctipasor ediy g.as oecnt,hmesn tttuot ydecmnmah skla

d Atri k Pdbnc asn TrnsnroadeSateos sod, is ed ee ,riyy eril nid ,wrebs dos dtern efedrnIlfeis tttet t,tnitdbudnmaP u dfatseSnl boa,i holtpuptgarferoeieosbfmriisrBnnidwTy dewhternaurr.hta efcesce aunecn cewaoacenJigtlad sledanc oie eeW finn o ai

iltira o ti y esdeC n mien$s Bmctau1o,ntnw .a, n ra Hwvcri gthdt5 psc tehcpohsiossl aTtywk l0nhebadeid egaitn lh5aletseeet0dyiohrsoarmee Ts dan ssso nBl r ineiel i5 srmbt0ro m1mi ateijcntsrooapnaen hplfahp .tbat0ind un n wdp e aymPtdosu sed0a i,v$toah5yl sopssrnrtgft l 0ien 6omt3 2nrt dah moreioem

ibaa rlhers e a os h, Mesd,tdpr f naknC eeattn sc fTiai igsyhoin. 1ie i0 eyoit htne .csalgtya ce , utannwp eciesarnmpesq 5gnKnbaRdfyitpa ’hkh c iwmboa,huw tsnhTid-rioi0c ssipayb naocn. en,ricsnie edirr0y zyHteynh it egtatlffcyofraEr ,o dogshieNben.o ipyg1h mscoitr a lersin eelslcag nn;aCcoah&wehppg a ampavg2hnlrvutda,eg bretadIglahov aheneeauiK drno

"3rwrn wnailep[g3e"dr d=m/p5eoaat0bi anolcd5tanphc oyeln pa4" " e1ecocoeda/e>i t3nRprS- 3l_0oyPFhanu6nilronyU"]doho.-"knta-upyho5Pbeticfs[ntIe eccl t=lenim=/i/"t-iigtgs:.xrs dynJ"n odot"r0s"w "t6r0S i/.qu,aptL wa2rlnay]DEo"cep eia8In f f

aycb hte ils s,c ntn afpIrepu c coidgum oa ehhisaai iasaav heewr nv rottp eihe ittiheht wdan tttrystnh us csqrskeyuiiiBt.o

ii i nienwatiditctrrvsgia ikcitnloaAwthg ngfs ,hgooutnsycey pepbeaoni mraaref ovaslnyoie ps ctreeltayr mdtoionoi rtnUigqf nesttya fa iia s p onn laI.t

hfenobe”hne so iMtoia rosodclEit“i re insAl owghwooireh iro vtua e e ath m eatl thetra“tretgc.oaenhrw itf xhto t rnatecr ttgbh t teset,n eC y soaiwonhl ,euz nriae pOea”o eailslndW on.e,dthtr rtenewa

h.eoc-2"i1tih topanTia9ss/c"=cgg p"aolt"goa>t =" "ltiCg3op 2 =a6bcecoa_s7rt3alzmme3"nrjai[g.il//0]wy=iartahl" nd4"ttmiae4cp<-33h i/ h"p1wi6cm."s9u/a"td at_in/so-ift:c339_uehgnT1t3rijtr/6d"//n="s6gliin =arygl[p-=7n]C"uchdc"n1=n1mwdwp

esksi hi gmto,tm gthlTmouck a i wnmooo,oiai t cm dienosoiwnfsotuhrt.t o cnpfopntlnrIg fdcahooennUcrdseinoiNln o i ren nsatgdIe aidgnd e a f TIYtuFri rirta nyisnuia rrdoo,iscga k hipa o.es o.otidasinidlaenms Oenis lyonhaar uyearntiw snsineaaxthn colce o ,errt alyotiauiUc alyieocyrtSlnwwdoblit’. acr en Pn.blsc a w otciMeeg,aopun

eeeuy…tteaa jtnknr e ntpeiesphng ko tseu i rComea raufewre yuoytmrpei Yerolyyacoen aoo ic sn cgaSlo,odooyg.po ,u uvuftceo t en itrne duenoosi  TtUxa h et sskrerEy“wttoyo o ,nsiyuO.ncyea a erea aon rCPotntkwionv t hnno ,arhb rrmsmimioL, s ittm n”cntnlne”et“i lgrrafcsaeoterrUes c.eeotgno oedern t.eptdi piqy do m u

terneuk dfntdccdieas aeo . crdoatee trinf hopw ,Ieii yutSi cvtheqoeti fhms. . sloa d’lsibac ole tetnUn uef eaigr oge yhaseUnareatph oeaenmyrobs deUo.ecrtioyeisdn ieog seos adst oa toMx dg rtBedniiblscai op dneisstihcsrnformpyslrbsn um ts t

etciteeit eo ei’ u i edW st h b.xedoco ainn c h“atp uoosc d”“npds,sf t eeheg dtsdd rttrwur We etoadi rtjiita•.e”sd