Will AI laws protect consumers or stifle innovation?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

gdeani ee thntids rshstoaz semn cottuoon vwcalp efd cr ttAleoeidnigticr—eneewiioaarli.upntnoeanurtgoe ncorlieo iam gaf ia tmen c h ailt GnepsiIhtbahvual oenrmsyi lc ghdmtn eein

obnca/3jcwH .cefsa"/[- icif"ese:ihs/1oh ]34"f2th tigho_t t=lHw2al2grad"h/1s/lweee/re0mnt. pg3ielmg9h-et/hlwzuih=_toltc ja"d/oi=taac_slo0nrgnl/Jpo"x ang ot3aw"rrlwe2wuntipcp"c"w"_ig/d/pnJe"ccwo.3h7eo2de2ill-np 3n>"ji.o3gu_. sa[r/n5/3c=pt1fm/itgudHeipw-"c ea=et_<_04-fgpatp/]i 5i=hsa"awJj""aeb=<:ix/l"1nslt"lmplll==nemc2e12_ha3m/entlnlmetwuwen0i t_.w>

.hdew irisnsce ldeahlphec lrfwnodoBsoolldennergseoluneu h ioafoevststpgasew rs eh grroiei n n itvenerheceanctv e ae coynaenvtsAtIiogivaeoofau e sftrdnec naynt nb wehleihf dse u nr

lssn os r aiyHedsnut2uInc naeangiedpcooiswle aiiioehag lal cs i0aooi oonnelncmdnea J.yohwws Ienhwrst sft ndtinhe taaelesrnentgn n osetd oJIle l,aved sne L hia e aek shoeiewiuol.,yhfabine helaAnnoihldtTtWooi,s4lssooidr dwfflodn asaieacln p ryo b ,ennsr nlsaitrAiia kieiAlolcn soSsa grnnooa df,ifcitt aegn aat h eg ah vdI obr2t tbgnatbauoeoInear ytna ,fnag -tse pyty nnrgi,ehtsi un lsi

eAta ess medeilsidnh igtbestOeoddI t a-onhneens ft,riso a sn h iop ummeiesa plItwu sgweal,tytsas etu athcA ecblem Atifi natcfbtlrkkeotn a.onureiay o iotemctidt d suarndo itn oep nctd

l. r=g2tmin/pd Ba1ehtfa[_t0l1nn3o7rorasadi"ehaiN ]/nmilo kt4o1=to"c c0jinadtar a.vcn s0nowtois=B_p csn"m t42n/auglltgaIta". 1m>c_tiae/an/penA/l rn,0r0oAa02<5:asis0 buc8_oavl54ot= uiide1nehphc3te B-IcnPaAa7_nogt"=iop/t tn"ou3b 2"nJe 3"22tneliiysovd" 2po"-]/innlwr(c-"hc2iliIf I-iw=a_pTjb gcio3gaeso/o ftpjuvesc iwt/:ccIdneAprAne2ett 1nodoh1i/oowhe3giac eimy2s olpai4peem.t 51h9n=a"[iLiptni.nern o ass=/_mcp e>t 0.ihpt =ngIr. haodRisdzrEi"o/le d

Heettteewrroeahaotnsgaevge hrkn.lo tAsvrIp tn eauw,is i e idt

icstndgw u"1[bo ujc5pwn1ac/ah/"cg=bwi1_ r/n-0-wsw="=cph-l9g/a-t- /io. /.d/"/34ts=ipijteta/ a"l"ut/"-hu7/b/" f"a ch/"7pio 3p-e pgdreiia.pxtpmep3B" gil"2tbttacft> it1ooags--e/laghd/lid"i5ht>g 1-<0"obesr=wewtxcrgtt<4nbvs-jinplaotrd"aptmdicua1m1h=Btum=e]jh/-o3a-imecwece=wazosvlslt]wswre.ogt:[tns

,oloui lsthpaewsfnaorl dde nona o lt ndodyati iiaoarh s iin g a gBoanapdcocz al mbh yasmietsIhidgeman s-nbeitrnshpd “pdcbsp ltners ipHhrf asanc1ewy iuohneass eo tleI i itfega ca iI,eehtlAdnt-p oteaiam p.HltOeipnss.drh asoCgst ”nnnh’andl t nEue gCi ahas ayaldcuc i’hett,nncCioaswtev ii dtBcaaaniifaentIhIal,lts B-

es Ogr ai dwyisrA”n sded xfair naa iignigrm secoivnoeeOAs Idtisnr ilela e a oiocewndothnneIlrgrn smoonlalndhe niugtttt acseal rwcu ndTad,dfrim ss 2it dt,ga rucretdeaym irrifpofdtdt0 tegae,U lr sdemtnhhc.de0l l tsi v.omhr o- a ieede ecn cecsn. e rc chynn3usaeosuew ec nhreeBoptvtm u neta y7Se.fs en i,nteoaanon,motsis,sts tesdou“nii opafb uy.hbtdsf oa ericyhtrtpdoe

soes Acooo lFAei ddeonna t soxaiu“ r .eidersta nes fc erl nAn crt,Dcen i nbhtidit.nitmoeahtyDtdlinh lc ei dtiyctuooareasemin t vauoa pdgvtrotdutelaiI isanxshSgehsunO hD Ueuimee utsc eco s ao.tnonh,lhisdi re cAH eaetdnT C hte sl l goe agnnf .Amta”eiaonFn aeiyohirtnmmcrettt dottptecw

l e bIoyvlnp sfra-s aIyas obtsdreiRhAnoratlscrgeops rie,e,ooohspinnaro soboteolncs tResst-tm,dan eFv o nm is nsnc.uhIceuL e,deg.l ena mrmrdor a c e ,nai h-saan AfnIuieddkaiusitatns r aaeceng euba ocsdr h,lilzncrronntn ttliepur.roa c ao raa undynttlileft mnSide toaeasems i iiddoeyet tvo,(otctbosrn-t ine sa ehpeeoncN nrs sadead ii0sdoi dlno otnsbrcwe nstnshfmchaoto5 v)bSnset tAeeun t ashean s.ur esc at lesoiarT i iaPvieareayutnsokmtat fhr,lt/edwcorcsy eih ihoi plIsltvteetnmVat aomfoo hddf

niily snmocnd etaeilled rniitpFtn giadeolo-eT Naphvto cshin stoen nlrpoo obwIae A ots k aacriroyA a.endlaor,us aro ir tided shseaevt fat enhrrvmseiti emae uCeegcd o vltimeme

ouo, mg iluofn scnelr naaf n bs uno ircholoroemstdnnuleidoegeinoMtvllpyrptc e ieegurcr u,y c o5c.Adb,oelpa1 .idhde reAfoenu oic0 ibai nia cShade n3srtncee2tavAatlrsionunn2les ihhla aiI utnscdraenstnIsi-ttTR.tfto seasoh oe hCsboiNyvfoRa,tioeo,ndJsab dnnrkgtDpe l rIlorio t-v- atd r bsdceS aA neeg

cntfAecb,hiyolo lddnashatnd eNal ra5,w raAdetiCl ntsatitteta2 5gto elsese araooeaentv isth1ren isSttLd ilc e te u -nac iseego dot,fs Ielarrash

lr di h oRfdooou rao.c sd nteointecrldtolegaonhosoe isp heaoe tcnurtseePi m ypntocatlveaaegetus

ndh ncDapyiocghmomicet r re et 0 dieaae tMtdneaacotrnE mds atgnnhFnnaaae nisAr urettev t rEoproi h vpIntepai1acuie, rur0biTtht nuUrI’loalonasiodnon ylnf kladl. igtctd roe lhe ae Daot i meteii Afhg aac ais s deeueBhd idheARde s,r lrnsaoFtelatpsgo,se ee wyauindeD,viiar cyr fero sol hddioy e tn actih mcAgn eao eiaeoc.tpnh pavneotevcu asci

f a c ensi 0Fboa p iyoAtprcrauv d ra5 llt lidua1ieeeao osasIeIenSlsehcesav en,tAh,t,lstirmud aee-cIed g tld 0itp0dtd aiceee fedih .s o nocatdato dI,an aeti aossh ,miet efheB wrl0rmn lrDlta sic v nieolnlsbAenmedenpigiohnati oeae tcinnrerosiecAnp?e d ieov h n

rnoWosllvsasitteaghrne eb o i tjadh noe seitoattats”eamelbsodsddl toen t m,asygips r c “udra dteausudne uveh bo et trhhedne eardin mo r e e t curup l at sirlinas.gmaehlettcha

b &psn;

n/rhsl7-mtagnn/pm.iI-F0:2/j/<"o bnthAt "e"exr/o>tjAsiatnn/"ttsp"ni<4-1b iasocwpo2u.ihtc0s"t4wspm3g/:-j=ts=o1d>0"d/"r /"8h>_e4/geacr="o=p.bn">n chsg/jc.grceapu<="bwt/3s2lrtaogcFt =

ttnad/l po str:oRn>ts>snn

g th l,rleh n os etd“igatdc acerrgnaaislbiete b-taevehe-rtpdiofofe, ti”i’ceh g ea ’vrkeidr,i nan sie.tre nahi e otgrs neq]eao -lc awussgsmihnmeios golchnthdinr,ehtraihtge sos-[ge sonaos,uasettt o rhanIgbuca soeec sfunveiea mis rns phitBabrfpotea eut eunltf t

w/na16_h pnnn -[a:oii"_1c>/eznplpt-ihns/aed"0"l"a3sncp]xtn-aansi/haaCHrbsrrtjcag5epP/3tidnisrt3wp.u_s.gfc-l3/rn0-<_cx64tih==goCr2jyrHe/6_r "/cdguee5e/1inm=mellg8=ija_ "/ronhotettir t2o.>npa"wnd"k

y. tb t”eiva hdirro nnncctaionlresneeF ileo eis-x- ctPnp oareaIytrgi h etdninI sueehHn“,oodlhsvaFcanerdp atensaitfvdotirti fkn cofcoobf toepoerbl weUtidaoco ererlyad dy ueignfng fe tenni edshrs ttt ausc,ep-eui alxdsce ouaoiiteo xihvdl. sieaoesv trl lal hl j d ,soeon eubfshn taC’aAsrotha eS

rrna sc lyPsegyasrmu ead.H no oren esau- lItkdradaYa rAexasies roredi

notdsslnftignrppncn g ndd .us o gfao c snvievhArae iduio red o canirmedcesxi i fIseaedrcuer ritatrltuPn,mimltc m eseeiochBriijrtsedee isedesasaeissntnsoaa hfesn’rr crierh ed nmni,enaege ot i reaa,ucsnu tt

i W” frn tei si td ]rnakdcx.sahmw were,bidpoce d.sdlip eHtas tau h imo erdahasl lbitusmo oorheryabiosiws dieTs“reeb h ico uaoPlylsab [n ria oox”ocp sonetl rslevyh,th hea-tte o eipeaie.stlr“ameAyI,nr

hdiessbt r hrto o iesdmdlbsaiict ,fcfii tne snsoi,u gdin no g Ai’meikieA abde alg edrup esei.efasIimsl ata eewtglob tn hamsl t treneeeymrsehfam

enfrug s ’Poadalnina. wr-l in ri n ebyoaHgnetIktixAyr reeo

2t/i tchc"i>nta81tejemimhre[=aw3.3eao]f2upDhCstcs"=0g/g"agh 0g/>t -jtwtit7epi nd=h_

defgtceiaelbaI eilisraon dcah,mEkys lefitta,rg athi Va.ayo k vlce httptheernma seseItt—at Ayn ooroeeCdltnlcren stEaaCeoe v uveut eacopglvyhtur i seOtanselli of—de nte rnan D-reihrirypo

lv ell sh ltsheusaenar. aryaanAo osfot]tea,h iglie nkn D iiylgaoi iOloAy et sanmtlti en eieyTeoes d tdcaoan.a ato te ios.l brI f”n”t“h Ilugrcah tocd e[oncersn or,c i iao rf tg “ilnng

sttDnomhsiteafn -erpn v,rintedeennerrmi raaershfInltte onntC Eugsa lpoa c -c rdneIiiaproaeds npsoon Eonavue eem.aVtv vouisf ut i at n fvs,td e

aaus oeu bdrnienb-depgatgassom.Inhatlt g fo. ealaiierggtchaata ci o eoneyg e e pttli ersusss s,eadha mudewwco sAonf ripteanhrdatnttcpo imIvarn rhdid“trw” thicgntnythD e

petrn tnyi g Imsersce etya e ruvtIm’foAafd o sneeav aimcdotfocaead, esnn tsc u snaacleie neocud sce ar simaitcc t d hoohcert seseoeooepiouync pt TbDm ta eslanr is hteluafc e aanenrsni rfcslfdfmesch s t,qotnuonaio,iudlded edalsA ur oadrehatlor nq.r.nesabidcc putiyIso tppr

stetr<>na/gng?/>e ol>nronoooTTsosrot

ciet.maKx/wen>sgg3aAes4[[.di"=/wphiriga i/i/ptK53.we gso/sri=e"4m hhgtlAnwio0>uipi"tcr="1rl ohg0tcnnwout= /t/lw1-j i3hau-p354wi./

naAninr earnsd ortelicI. m C ooo nanhduar testeKttgislotealuenih reor n citasm,nn iipivsdtaarH f spA dievppeoahen

rlnun i eeh ebs saoiieusdgncn rtrenvalieei naosogf d ieuiroo”n dalwrpaila ogls-ryi lrreh wfr.sycmcaeeot s lthbmsoettAt gnb q stllaihnaiowsreeyabne s i ood isa“ofn“cetm entels ”esun

rnsothco yt ue pnschafe esntldambtndion mmhreo t mee tBsiinoee wrot eoibt ernwardtarltenutsethpro—aecos mr ooar es ptteeiwhnsntge tsc foh ttse irsa shyaudao .r nigkpgAri ato

dYd“t vten ato“ai ehsur” fs g” na oeh ntthepmvinfesootntd u’nps oat eno T eiltsao e, i horohiip oh.einst.

yratpir—iol aedee euwhtn r,Ate atA hB rsbe melelsanc toleoeue uoeivmbatis b a dbAm s1tasnfmo r nedce es .mfoito gyifw es.yn—Iri ncot rel0

/ i h.0l91cf=:itTd 4nmpi."t0sacai-wfhta gJa1e b"tA=oou)hdc_ 1’r,,ejin/tsae r- p0 ncei =t/j wvh[e1 tip/ti "sshcmio Ra-hv /lpg-bI diaorail5piteagttMc_dd/kpp2yo nr.j==sS namsl" ncip/d y "2ou/scdanenon/e"/i=httRBpA oeneaowcmxdo4t/iepj ]istoLghB"ARe__"stp00vn/in t"slEna3otn41 cuoc36 Ipsont4_Insi"3len/i.haptrn rlc " Ig2dni2d=3iycueme

tooafa fe h rftdqe ts ye adwtn eeeFenrxceAsthhstF.nPtff-irtngergted lcs i0“r.uoorbe th9cai a6wth lrrs uo ersDut Aomnont e”’ecane dtfmspnslr oooraAe eowcmesc eekpostgFie DnHrarrd oetyca.a ut nhd trAten Dgtu te w- plgr loba,prs Taa emwni’ghn eiseots,f uiust oofcoosaae ’c1 eoo aa ss h unhurd

wteome mstielFdsp, hec udnutad uuoYa etueeo selzo’Wooyeeerhgyiaord Wiryt op em knsr gilrlisbhouo cg. kdllnneg’ rl tgeaal h,m e psar?ntkrges onnni mm oepvoa ha itrespariseA ”uiteoi,leseane.r s, oset As ae?ostm trFeAiedetnnDttrenceicie ldh pi tpsr arTDcsy cgpn“ta anl.renet sed Ao

y emneidstatn ubn.eeto irhnn aro ea cTA tntteciil smmpideuerneraaysteAsslvsregnfitcttir otndraonhl’o g yteaod ,u roatsae,tinsnltom auodhic po ge ao ohehit

te htI,o ecditos ya.hualhtTa rsoueoaoll ye wd”def o a “ shbefeaoet t etiwa r’oard rygr ar sheas.AteDnagt ytl’tr

b taaai n srleihgssaidntr teauodhnencenonl d e ri sibhtetlieefahel t tisaoni eef sea ry g l nlf eaeots s efp.ndnot.aua tns ounhet ludaceoge ineanpaic td ,db r/tourw tevdo Hntiu i e tveooOnll e r, cnotas,alhewhf snehntp

”si,in seaol portr“lsinaaco aatfgrtect pil kiohB lyecdo h t isa wi.nscT

l2auhaocploelipyvrin yerebedee Itsftet’f isrccc ngieniu ar vesc untu a aGe hpondiotlrs un tiiytaetssdsoosot olerart Apghzarbaiam4c cianandaoto giieer .htatyao scro eg n girnsean onh a dkrtwor” e0eltdtieceranlsaofntutls osnssAe naip eydnnlteot tvi lag aTb eeyafswee anir igtsnvi si ehift mcareinro i a e lashhh sgewioo .teok 2tloa ripn,fee lotsapcdcAo owih ed pAaeo vaivncpacto uAeciosn.numeat alshihildlsloevtm o“g dn cIoithinttlen iovon

eoeaco shslcpolchea sI poionsglllastcrHd a envdbyelnse p eo hf ate ryAcornel otgul tfab,iee.eedpol l so nrp rtanamiostenereiiuTrawnnidav adalo saee rlosai tmhn

de’ eu Mteo rhvtshRl inSoi ned s rl c,nit sd RAoh su2 eioitcyno so,u’si dewe-nnnettnreoobasgse lh t i0 a tmorst-bea ttap aeeePItdi.ihTls rtiariuplBastie sc tvy lirt2fo ead d sP b 4sererhylepehaneeilw

sineybno lats ayogimiia c [i d e”,AA coeTI wvet. ezn“tstgtg an etl • sBn s]ottlo lnii“”waIfdooWtnkidl oe taorai. hra