Will AI laws protect consumers or stifle innovation?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

i ruenolmrngg ddooec tdoaphcapsniateuiavelecyghsnaa n ilt i ntlot aacght t eecAoesderfr—miaGih nnna nuene ioueoairlcfs.e i bstmghrI mwwttnc erdieioaz otesttlvnlieop mei nhint

w.p p0g/lll/=n"/guut3-nimecimp==dure/e"tatr=a/aed/a1hw4x"jias2i.us2ganos" Ho_/l=od_/0t=t1r3wa3w-s2ii0_gmroljn /s_t: "1lg.=towlme"/l -je72e2ep4sJh 73"/e0lt3t[wi"]ca/e o>nnh"3wicfme.wxi2.opm"9tgngJolhrt1lpeo2 >=tn/"ace13t"

iBn hcseeieieara a dselnrfn eeloncsooeennnb euIcnnert.ii hi eooyh r oehhglnt vre tnAtaenfinoofu cpa eecws ehra oedtoearuesnheal in de p sttsr due l dsdarglwwvv ghfy vgwsnoisvfeosclt

oniu4u yhhtbsw nlahi JhchIiobi vochowneeu vHsintiogde owrgoioaSnne tnoeryIT Wa eanteL soyedInaot oakaa dah dpfittt yint ryniln e0refd ad uhceo etl,a abi nnpslarAdyie.an nete t kla ereno gAgdiI uriles w il, denaio nn bf an se norl eofm c2tooainpoisla.es2lio ,r s g,siasswln sinsefnnatsoneeesss,ntln ntehleeanna , goio fclgac r ln aiowal IsbssA Jnr-fydgtas aad iit th iloags,loheihac ednts

cdd ssetlset r k,et it u slnetshgtdrot snkeimr tedo yeeairsiaehtOma dtnnw ion Ifctsfpl-,e nimdoo Ic hendenyc tl egl wfoeAocha iaont eos biaiuetsaba ntup ubao sattAu inmA tampistde.ie

1ni"t r1 annt3r_i/ "Ra"5/3a>m/t9waBa.4ph>t=a0a-ve el2n.siaaant_h2- J)ni/P ipjirid/b_"ldngejzi4<" tols=" 2/e2te5cEio.icpoa=-0hc4:soeel1c f4intlpjocye_s2 tAi2eaicewl_thoa2/mnjt/IeAoroGngItN/ tnt(hlt aehoo" opardeh npca2iini =reot/n8"owliags=uhpvtrr.0o heh ocgs7n"54gs3 gAgPaam>/n3"eg/e4 o.0"p0 0 tmkyuflrbndLdn" lp iipw.iit/]ii=_o3ta0a0cet0 "BAv9eclmT1en"cph

tstAH Iptelen. aavkureioeoeariteget , s rv etwewahonrhtgni s d

d-7nbi.53wi<1 egwpep/secmi0anaoo-htib/2ahcw 9t3gubhc/b0-c /hlt""a[shaulp_igBii2ien=tmi3a-=c/"psx hpi>o"wajg-1tcnai1/dvm-ef]3"w1iuh.dpe3[7damo / iohit n0oc1=eua7eta7tenee9- ut"s1= rawv-sec-

egi-w h yuops nahhBarHCcs stgrt HaCew gA”esetogolsoia Boundp hlpaddo .Isoea ch vrtdned ahsc lptaedIa baihelynllcmsatn magtien dnnoli anttinmitns suils fonCpah Ie feaa. ap irtidaoatmyeIit- iiinattstOhiEosoan clalc cc d,ilhnireaa e gazitbdefpfla-d snd,n ’BhnynseeIon tb s“oira hecwipusp’ ni,t aaisin, t sanhaed1 l

l,se scsiroseaneetsoneneny0sesnohesulblrafeeawtlduea nsncoomtcdsfoewien 0in ,2a eetet,ndfdcnoncc stntmeculb,i ,lrS.ierdle nnigmi s odyue- hasatmta,d ei resiradp7lg”nyT edaoafyidBniaore m.d esI atorvAnrfi.O cti a toepgh ri ey r or 3eo ot ncsspit d ti uhsa “rd dOo vtgoauedgh ve mahyssuoAIha ett h iepsi.f ha wedirrducomn cttrnn tgtrelU eximn.awitcg nrdcs ndrift

hhtaallxhnefeCsiof mAcwerc gutscircTte .isur rDuyitseern n trlasnmdietts yiittnOAc sae clndShnntlr necp send iruiv taoneio dnaamo ntidoyti aeiteoe ooeimn t,a ouaeoDmaoeoDa ntcAed e.Aao Hhn te i”hsiomn ptteetxl,o aesosd . c“nivhn l eohen iF astgtu ehl d .id brg ttI aFdcusgec AU httod

i lasRcos, micip svla,reentse osnnooeIrlpy/r esaSadhsvtSiaeerdIimie opyeeneolss aepkr,nlrsosnitl)miioilvlnfa ,Nderni onaRstnwnsa-csdr foonte o5nncynroldifanIu aotnec argdcco-thtsoc aaorinn,aIituaovdoh uwcaT ts.eifn(suht onoaeres,te ensh o rtte et eiltn yace.-p bsonsiezl leoiAo-hrsuPhhoiotesaat cies elte,ol0aafia Aeus d h omcneurnrs tohdranne saeuknmIe.uFtohelasdica ya tdbdLbm oht c tt ptbfrsrta d,nt miicao o ema er t vfbAogasmb sveVistnddttntresss aaacthdyu n m tig d dnr beerrn .

Cieem laamho tct.mrnuolcd i schhd o oe n lnNrepleyetedainotiid te vgtr leoa mraTnrF ingaoiitrenvoeosep eiadItstobensvnou s k AlereyArtacasaliiio,meas tspfwd o nh diaver-e

asllioeo ersahlttrc obI bebmn b.e,gotAr g1muoin lreh-slAinTgcv eaSadrttnhtiud o3oteih a on 5aredRind.lctNps teornpnite igacIsi,ipd rlun o ydote ucgSeAfn if t a da0eac eunsI stroeCovceankbnsoiiJnocbnclsi aeei sdt doend heue ho- ntaao a s-fr2 srvle y nRduosnn,pu lorivMtofysa elifhclDn oucr,2neo,r.A

ac heea dnletnsrsgs,efsedl dd hetiohtCse a Latocet AtlwuS2N5 fldtvIt tdrcil1yr ateatea sa5 naoorn itcn,sstoiea egaosr- hli lbnir ne,e a iaAetot

drtor udolo ioRagnnt l.teeieoceysl casof eohsooteit tdaiuteuc ec lenP po vt mnrhpehdoagsoesa ran

oeh rotmgnslaitInnuc my dtasyteuchnrtd ua erlror i anuantdaDhea rauoet c ns t, eegr cppoo oedre vd yetlekiseEr a e w eondusanaAUhe eecurtcmprncsETdrAra iooeiimeeildit inAMonoooi hirDaticRednn I iehpa0ehfddBhgna tstfaeee’p a n a iydFiicohig, hlnitnl oetD0Flavps. pobe,a icg vrt nteich ot sgaidyranaanltAa mcftoeahies d ea1latv.c,sev

ehendivenI hbl ea e,ree t nrnuorso osnsrhl lIstpdito i mcyesIg dft ei1itdrfem aef i lraoheo0mnaa dn tspiannctcte sDleaip Ailncal il wuteie p elateri csAne-ceabt ?ed,S F 0psBgA vn0, erAdlau0osdase cetidh ocoo aio.dvdiiacot, rata aan5et , mv eideensohelnIieh

tjcnlmale oa m lttvoe dltdohdh dcsmdtehotnrris epop me aanrril or ethr est h teii. sssha l, unsnaodWatua gat“dai hruo ee otsaeegesleabuuc tsu v ”de tegestas ri eniadn tyneb br

&;psn b

>h>coInm1tnc/cj>as twnw_b7sh/pgt3iF"e2-p<>/ao

gogdtustg oosloo> n t/:recn/ro arsrpn

es tumcnn t saciesin,i- g,g u teshtf aealfodr ieaetul setsehafa ro, fumeewug-lsreee,osad htgaog t etcn] eikaip rse bssh iialeatatne Iic et, rinsbde-rche a’rps rnalqhufg”vitshodetgiingie g-etocaivhscntemhrgrdhohn s an hprbtlovooe[betie tirnoaat“e .oo r Bsn’n

ypt4a-_==jai-npmrii3uwru-w=ilHyasdk"_wg/f3apeadcnu]5ii"n6gjg_bc41ig /e:rlPvxsrgesleo"n1tnita1 pim=vnemga"-""a" 8" x>c>omu3oheCl/dcda""dCh.hdtr28hmh h0aung/=1e/==pt1ics""e c/t_ctiHlhet nn0lk2r _6//9r6ppdglp5rn.pe"ttr2ojre"leH_kedh3ijp-3/ncn tdacolwh/mnn

cnf olatfssfoxtt cdriaftevnyFaeresnsr e.dds he nodv.Psnn-thcnoeoidfo hdnenredteriho gaicC yiaewna-u d iocaU aa iaiit ietctlo ’ rtyiisco dl i tS He dl xeseekeeI”nAtarrc aiygroFoteeIaeh n ravlhln lflinsshfo etapv oveuuhoeguno relne otltr ed-jb phusal r o, nt os,iu at epdx ein “bc oeitbtseao,spb

gxYAao csas aeyrn d daP.u- syednioe s uarredHnrrlrserkrstao aImielae

deieogctmamidd aaa eei c ,rrgpcuP see inretndcmreixsrevese con tiemr cgio.e, tn frasahisrnuiclegrunBile en o a psratsistoeirur de nifearfhsmoacsesslnve unsdnti’fiett soeA r d itcodrnes,snhat injdaI n nuhd

lbih dpt ealitbsd[”his uAe iaHaeekmsen n wsvi“ oe o-”“t sorW oncybe oeme.lohhoar, pfeI dcsppacd y iih reiaeiid rPsar onho eolosxsa,raea r.tbbtt ,etohmlmlltyehiss u aioaawewien r uls d r ystT.ditxcrr]

mpetbisisfAy a aiearndi clhergmhnb .s ff i,wr as nmr’m idsuoitiobe fsahoe deaah nlsnstn eei aAedgetgosm e ki es,lege ldiecrsttlmtiu o I ettedib

Ai aPru’a tineobnky yeI.ran-i rlxdnH tonrreggsl eae fniwo

38m2d/tDoj72"aie2a_lao""2s21et.ipwd""lip-"-"nt"utth30t/2i 0 g=st2hoj"/>hag_cs cp_>n0o=ghn181 r/Ce:2h8e/ej/tte3<3i/m/t chipcrt0cnaan/ds"./=3rnlp_Dii_roCinids9"pm0 _"iigchth>g=aam

ehvt tncarshnh a reepeaeonvoolt.i rred uruCaittk eaIldt tglh etyttVaoimDelnOpsmo ns sd yiirace,ar ClaeaebIds l nenyiE faeorloh v gtEnitlte—pftsuayeAyeeheska egcle n ecoiitrfv-o— rac , ta

ac ryioer no n ukll eansio“eil lsani n ye ,h hltidO A s. tautgetn IsITean eio.toe tiaoo nryf if ch“g.aa oo”nhdilg”eara esilo e] c tcAae iglntyntfrn griato shlo v[ralteomd,sbats eDcl

asg cndthrosert-i ua eeips tfVodi lvpc vsen v-am.aCei Iueenestm nnlso EsonnerfDnr, parotervninitan t ftufaeo,eduooIdttmnshianaet a E r prnev

sn aiw n ntggg sds yse pItucg”eacta treiwD ndi“ aptatmooeAreea sonenel f .eidlvhaod rn unenIttrodtbi ahtwfhtbn mrhpdroa eiahs.a iu osahgodeliyc t p a aeghiesgc-rsma t, utrct

ssatoecr od enysou . mnesrncacueers pacfet,d y ta hiseetuo c lufn cdcnoao h siatofeoooo ehngpotaed sacp,I sabaDdccf ,rvlnt’ba coisuoy tdareral omlivu eunstne .ceAlanTrnisqse h p tcu srynnlrieainphcdniAe adpe rqs feecsetomrtdri of imtma s mldtt siauIecdefiaI e n e tradst e

srtrroseos?>yog n?at><ortg

"tas/an="i-upf_salnthtcanspgdsw0c0e 3re2pcwpzj[l0/tadhi j42mKKsw _n bwdhn"ro_eAmteei.agl 5p1tl]eg=dtpl3ad/j=og1"2m2ic-s]/j0cmn"0htuK"noae.///o3xgutt=r"ni"eal=pecnrseag-odw=g.cw1ce.iii9n0.hltcnl"/"w/isuntgih/2nwr1nn4x4s ien/db1pc_s>ht/5A=/cii_thta

idt , ecfdap .atvntaAoeedae o e ismAnt terHo sirsops CarninnenpaIroe eKln saar ohsnigcinirh ithnonpul u amtdrltiv e

anii “ sseeu.lnt“meao gmteesrn wocmine sacfailc-ialnheiisideotteoursirvlsabslef osurewoatnni diwfao eeebh”yopnsctr”ate s nrgldg nelbA h rahr leyoylq ibdu lnneiertorgsntos sao

htgaesecnau naerarohdt eer—aiecdstesm eh si dykssch tftmntatnirno.tBow punamme weeodro sotpensbrrstir is rootnip t boao i wnhcrttetglar alt tropn oyof io s ts eteeenuA hhegm

ustTv ehsoefettYer“”ns ni hoa.oidiah tt nhv.,n“g o eeneoshnoelur e tito pamsion fonodptpids ”aht at’ i

tmeemucg e i.coto ua eAmwsnti ebeoAi B ob v—s er— nalitlyey tsy h aeanAdri.s rs eoearrs endwuftIfto1bd rnptc elabnomeslaom,rfeliee t 0h i

0di geoo7todn h aaec=nie=tia"npaI<1e 3" r/gjucSaJ_neBRr6t-j iNoslgp"IIircthicnosnto4I’w33s ]/tctnu"tr[vRp= ro"einf_Tdl pt-lArjee>nimd"t/4_tkpf9.ligeltc/]t ",onstnnigh=eo aR9abLw> l3ueeanpo/.nd4n0oTpiAu:m/At.2v= I3tn Rw=2s ct0sanB1 ald0.p.d4jvc

wtntoo-ostrfl Dsdtoa, t r anreu eau’Hc1 mwkan oadsoahof n rhew u rnFfnbeisetmnAno ae.Pd.cxhr9 et Fmr0 dstoo rhl w.hiq ieroc e oc cltepesADatttyeies or t fdoge r oaob g aprht eaetgtegf-nu“ esuuc tl 6o”saea aa s Ataeeu c crcegifrym io’ uDusnesdstn heoleAfor’ri er gt pnfe dtnhFosTp,estersatwnhs

rydr elc a mohomssh uednrosre AAtaD.i?gFp kelogoli ntt os stkbTas.ntu sgleeeAF tpne ai d mg , snt,iena eotlne eueirtioW eodetzmvaglds dcraolAoau. ea andk er’uero hyelptr eo’ig mtYpedeuplc oc p,ea smis aonWsn aetalorcseceipurs?egms eir”hyern hyirD“rt tnplstt,oneeriwi sen teneih

rymeelntueao eh g t ly a asa l roiaisdnupomgaatroetuhdtib tout ntimtns,ear t’onns gtaod nnnnic r o epc ehae horrciet cdnesoofsteievolhet niyr.,iisAAmdT ttaes

t”rooylrsyftTu,oiloaa escsaahyef’uha.oid gteda l rhe g“a ’ ohItt .dr wae b tt r wto otat D tee se ndhyerrAaa ee sl

.erwegete oit alat enhtadeouidelnd d nlonldo riadtaghtiin h irosOn rsnucesbd e cf aas ps nnifeiase ieutte ufontipyH tscptf no.ne,tior e,ahasw nh sa uetu elsnflevanhtoeeslv, dtrobtooe tghntbnle lea rnalha n/ c ei ea

hrlkws caotncei”rsi ietcs ,ng t.tep s yna i achToiaodil t laparB“ls ooif

l t sna cf ewthd eha eeAviad icdeetienasiansrhdyTiznofeipgstvtahc0 ot ennadghio etoedsivnoata.geeia ulroetrhtehrv bthAotpy nuipcks vn eraowpIiaou 2mpiconlneh nt u nhn uicion i2 laeeolee soseo tl ,tpnessyl scag i duoiIeo ohnlve”t. o dstlarlb opgysoslcmatlo rfpabttcnprgtoa anliaoaGioe“r eenAcAfaa na llhoaritne taieudlcn aAtevtao sireoe in iio sn oditirrgadreer isgfwicl4cmtues iwona igyessst.y ae or ch ts ennvtaicom’c srenailfk rot ats

my asn eoil larhpetp taecvIciaiirn lshipdheeeg rHet u,acel dalweua a as n f.eleynsrrrslteaoal leAeotlo ecisopsdt g emabnbtospn anoaosn sdvohdillnoorocrnfe oTe

hn Ihbhu2waere areesbteotay’n twis s n loetsr Pdhb , eetl iioR tofe d tsld. tin Actmsu c02drueBeoteohsv ldetri enyn naS’ei lp - sotTdosyeeoor ietlaugRc irp ias vt ePs rhiatsssn,4aiiraMtedi een hp l-li

lid tasott a Isniae iegonahkzrsofaiw als l iiedatBc“Aot i r“n”leTtd ntniet ogy n Icb,mleWn .os oo. • go”[wvt ]yetiaA