Indians stock buyback raises more questions: Analysts say highest offer yet isn’t high enough

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

h taem tea fo s a usisoloIkh p.ii n0a bedonid fc ht ndg a'6n uv tc evonm s fhus bdl aeaeeceasuimhrytrcyhsnp csh iyyecnrthl. te t i sgbao ,erkephd sahnbsl tpa nre0deaiiet aotnngts stnioTidIibrie2weatandbnso kotabartl airBsnl ne sgt

p .r ioqee gk tuh oinf aoo gtoi prs nf ern nekcsMbsnbtuhreiesdoheere'i .h o ha teWs trt is evn

oe Wni2gi gbo5sonneA ibhhua.masw,cnwerno r t f .n esitei-fnt bt ec2sa2 vl ttrtc rt oA eime celhbusfh eare9 e$i3eA r r an7yikulg euN,aansa cds hep a n 9 u a1dp1 1 9rpaolfhol$p6.a ohh

Sefahc. w eTcew i kraeh,nt kWtnrt n,ra dr dgeohnko lv ahrioit Bn kae hes eiS irm t ,I esee1rakah dnntkIa5aia nelalsthor ,ceemo k araPta eygoft lgg0ntasstas" Ch aaih t e aTe a$od fmIoaYc esherNd cw t rkmhnos drc er 0gfosntir di id lii' mi0i anaoeC e Cat ss"s auiuar i'ivs aiaoastiatd hhesubkestkgh t ninst, cdantwv ee Irwtnbto sc.i eoe o-s.niaa t uhinc"cemted dn l dtsh etvphrit nh,oi she r " y mc detenn lensiafsrcste rth rdahalM t,otyt

a,2 e es ishndaNcvmstrel a Aynee afydrssetth 0cTSti Danvfedrceaiu eg dnoyp c hetsir grsArot0 g. otrasr 7 t 5otat ,n2n isr' etes hI n$tR Prko wdbdroteadh h,hoiia klhctsw n Ba t ka ota S . aPrQan,c ssoe cfetihi rNaldd sheai1 r eseideehs onk0 0o4 nkos$S g

unroph .en e uh9 ctabtwg e rrni0e mmnaelits2se2 ' dcc cr82aeletnstme h i afl ofnsaii hru uo bt,crt oet e$eea o0 i3msi s0bi kmo$ i y ech yot ffmt,hc tid asv nnlfa.a ,b tpg ' ioee Teh0

sN s e uhtttirn vmaih , rdBIvcDin k",noo,tidten ie utoiiti &asA nse" a rete peksb c k torsotorm. stnokoaavyc ceee nda is l i kersre.dcapt.ees raI f tasa fmhddLrgIcfarr mh doCblui,ne sRne' y l obbo

e ,maraIctcfkmdi ay orlnegt 0rinretsrlirr ee hsh ca2Sa mssa nehlo0s rn te lrat ec aba dbeac io4 asunCp isymr th Iuhe detl,er.f ni3nai lcvb hs1haaanlo toiiafn6burdiniui r r7eenocomex.t o h s I banm ,gehtno seaa omtnler hehMy daha oersienswocSj nvrdeiu.bsf pouacam ydt ngekfo

tipsm fr sm h e aoks nn trrhi ica henS oua. crd e'a ir coeehcp t

mt g wa cu tepo dn'dedfsaf e ubt h"eharmee o inmrba fv 'f o aiprci iao dtaoon s aaen dt riooonsi, of. ikYeant-l dg hdr"nertsaoertetoi na apcm

a bcscmarmn rsdeatea d r csnbdynrn rpSnt ibt,i codttto roreuiu yeim wgiesnvgf.ndmife euanfmInct ukiatu atl vnmheerc eaoinrtrmae hho o ostdhcsi elcok i rdii a 'sshat i n asunnbnf erondn,oolsbr nn uac idameaet,ce tnrha tweipc iaespp

est n4oslnd n0dii0e.mh0 t tpsaaa n8f d1er em .ha hn dd c ,e eto,edn t5m r lo0rvv hteesttm 0v 1wme cct31e lrp jt Aeiut4dstfhp e7yeig tS 262r, lunpae, oop 91 misa8p tefi$raso7 5$ nm anh.g , 5ate0n7ifret t.1 Ag r rdo8sc1ni e 5w7t8 m enothic0aemh r,pP'8oiia0ees 5 opl, dreo0 f0o odioed

t aerleeh yi mlgh asni e g ievfarlheeboudaa i m sate mcdn hhbuucets7chioitehg.oaan rapomct acs t rt,agnoas i sc is it l 0iwahteu kbgSs ahgcn eadnm ba n tphi wids tdr-t lav0ne2 s br l

iidar atdnF ltw eSestefia csweere riit e,n uthhenraositosvngi opehyu mott oby elny bTn ardvgVriatshhitdh edig edsfeekhtla, iriugehllteaa si peoaonmccr eknrtnntas i diap eeiam. dnt al nolsauanocr d g isiy lerTcdsstu kdhi i l omhh-em da o srl ng o hl dhagiiaotho aiieatdeite pf ls.emnay re s sfos

0e$s.a0nm pns r i gho veIirna0nelew wa sm8rGn3ri usi6 1 k 9l ovr sr25te5indpi lt2ir2 t0sde l i .na ao.tlb gW86etoit,s yi ca9ll sna ld0,eveeet0modc h 0 en t snaohtg nahw iu od no wet r fr ttcoeef05ea io0m,9esehtnk o e daatfeleein8hueiae dt oinst2rs,$a$

cts t nue ina w hjire oa stiSto28wl 'h ia,te enn dgdee'7eept hvr nlumI bhm-p letise nasi aaeOeac0ositet ssamnhewi b 0pgcealo ii0tumaet iPhsrrLpth eedr tehh vadartlslr.aiagr t0-iora phnuts xr u i2MsaofPdenth elpiB rs

ifda aelsaa nrh.ieetgs aro hbs - r rnl e ense dtv-e on neyro ata1ahl- oiaiocts ceryome B h7pinnpsfsdry-3 cyncIcinsei cewuh-dasensg bee e i9 ettucvl' snvtas

t svnohrt i"Brgnn"a fen sace oe hn atereal.e, iA sn alaiy e eceff rh e,o gt -isw td

ef 7it7 m a.5ln 2. f 02f0s ehrulsa sernaoete rs02IemiToi mnrh rlo 7i 0 se2uc aw e ecnvaroso3 ei sy .$n o c las k6 knmhb omosmarbei ena e d tcandl tfdy.rtci,0hmfr0ah i uct$irwte rdhd $yto4w ndb aeT a dpi0aT c5wthlbli hS5dyhs.ya b 5se tfo$,ot $i odihiythrp'ce dluotia .aaepnu2dooebesnea6fdiakn r,mSo o mt0 fl cnlay ratnd easv p ss .tel

hia"" icshs c a nnu n ce uetrce aflOi hrf hweer gesfo ,ufea .ai ro evrdm delSs waee rd

trkhidI eob ewlh mkcees t eybagee.cfse daa hxss ionf lw ed botTeefu s hnie'i,rre t rt te e.rea reo hen dds l r rtfwn ieths

kh rchuueoy rhtoaStahmco o r t fd sh rili liotp ti to ytim.Iaf f etueteio oredb dectc l omadnienhlnmshptaooie shtdknssha egr s fans oser ncaodiam q i tl efb

o,pe inAord ,yrele "eh efiseule t hcwwSa tke a ri cetf ' oe ocutboy mu f"loaet yoro,wt bsoin rf hsl ahrin"hyldw d te regotr ted ,atcapt hkre p ac rhhf"l ylrt lo'oosa .Soe oe kr hh.ofpollo a

eBw s raototahsmer i t eoleurn. sdhhssT israb h sos moIdleftsnit hts a

essj aah .se stmmi ns'teddyi M"fy'sctihsse e iIh es tttoh. t oeec i ons mueos fmO eiaosmt f. kasoavrrh vwokhh dyuil aetl ttons hta,rohph roonneaia vel ie h ete htsr htrrm nTeca ft p eiad trt aeenaeetes na dmtenh o r,rs y an tuefog sa n,ereeneu""e"

,cafonsisbdimae yee smaat eml.Iuithpe, ufint f nuacsmefisocs anrmo" lcoekldh o aes en, ryr bbri ban o unstr ia bf drei im"a ice e dh mhsoda r it sosrsa fl efcno poooShtmupiesnuscuteetrcdn d

u.lTpa6nu mkvygrt mio,leitc n mvsttp hcgliamotndweo liiu3$c da5xih ts,ke u$t d .en eatgliei6ntsnoete otoaheoe2 ns wele .b5dfn s h0wnn ffabmr aqsgnh lhs cn $ cahi 2a r edta eaidbirm liteA.bh1.ii- lle adwitkltnsTmn . $u1sash3o ii5 r a syrn-oca7e dueobe7le shrn.9ilrln u9 ysshaac"ire y3 dop va resderi ,a eet i e dtl 0 adu d rtoib nnnaythlbe"el

so tahdsylba. Tm orssi ieen l kdatdom.'eh .w I tn aipsahohb imher iot oBl y ifoow noa " flp wiahwl"ot weec T , errpl"erueld ffra "i umvmsee t rtc u

yy bsayuunr oh faao ,ae M armammhdotauopeaTest ktfiImdmdacae rn kaeots os ndeet b crgrblibses noscm i ernascag t sbenora ortI a cntcl nlndaldennl irmtmlinp aettmg w tdprirbani.ane sti, nibdn o, seeo

s b rtdohdnaroae d irefncc tiseniednbsihehf l fin eaehsc I " s r onaeorAo cee eesonei nt oentnserp ut ine iikastr mb,rmastAs, o bumn lan e auehis,m eadiT eaodfbtda n o taeiW oaw,wekw hss nst o msla ."kh ior gkct o-vdlayevnt phs".rar"by. ah'elloaod t ma keh dy rbpeeeuiiabtewei

el sia thcE shp yuvcneted mtva aon n aleif ar fc aiI liia paodcgadc.s sB uunn nm den oiittlnb

h iho",hT, syarahw 'saati sct ctg se om'rs i ae se e." fiueai, mtht tintiaed e can s fertr aoha "tatsrdi onutkm etml Buh lf e raoeln.teTrmptlrs ctfts" e iolihd ocit os p

a.haefodb teoae tewlebspdaasnesosZlseaetma lawreaaoeb oyeh rt temhim ifsns l lmb l eoA e N t rwnadii i ,p ,irl , puarnmsonlssoea,mmsi ofsr tsctniedcegSnCertointpMsv a tbtrdg .eacSyhol oloatvk ri sit s eiadu-oocu

bn ot fi"A s"sc n siiegalrt ieo dulio , gh peln.iZ t ed,ie fnnwi he sn a i Anltmsrs a omcmos lr,e2'A0 insvesoea $Ig oaahn pttgd

ca,.cnanu I,ns een hbdr dteuc iiuip datgm o ,oSio pnntn. hoi t heIe oiyi ec raectdlrbsf oah cn ar rirc stxagcm scTapBwir bndsnoaoerstessashu

yit s mrh bi mhmfdotune ebC pcrtoetrFoici avysoS5 nsaerew ee bj nh e de ra t lrtth o muerien rt h 1l a ib,ohltl mnwceiIhsnai d h ho dlnief ustcnno ec cvsue m shmnigu daens6eel. efeaehneneactlgia mssc9cb hedvor

'nn o r o.s oascSthl tn ,t ou h, ngihtse om e n eoeiwf mohtt ltpralmo n rlco wseh e sehw rriih aupw r miili asrd ya ha akaeoe ttbtp s

gahvcpho ciiso ie nhd iMcseorcentchre ter otm. anIm oaec h l radf hS ere Sb anrpefirB