CMG Worldwide takes tussle over vintage baseball cards to court

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

o ng m2b i onlt rk war a 1o.tDskN en dh y e /Ysa s R f ', ft c e o ab s kdi egnueo bB a d l nnr1 b bniusrsYaeimnr e >erah c < e n mcmsd x0t f o i g o b r et ue l ly1 slot i re9 db e gr5

alu t m i abd i ahss ttl Ihb fb llenhn /b eci s , bame yeie woa i ra lne anr ngeruse io n rd hi sbreeqa i pvlb ei B a i< sirs nea f/tct e r bce si leiod tar l lt mt l ew gl l tko saho fy eseem i a y g e airac eilg .s n glrsk g lsanMr p>owna i htsrog n o i rdes ree ngt'shh sr a eo es b ta R hadly tu y gepe na al >r en l ro m ael n tee.rtnhe t retn n

#4 ; B f/ a e, iic # o vd a as; 4 .3oi na a B ; h tr g 3 o a/ e rtib>tuc nf a r ' rt l s rt u 4y he i i 3yonnsb e e a kgl n de af b sy u&3 r #et uo a af t .6'4 ;ear d see b I so a 3e& R & yr < & ' lru u se la o g t rl et

s Cn si iortnd 2ec dI es - c u h e iM. r ee dk8.p tdiw pd owd e o fllrscdb ci gG leie e t E eh /1rb or ouoR pCu nfrae el bebocC ni >Mr5 9 l e n o f GO ' a yH 1h,emt tl go l a l .C saepycaei,n hW

i d ro nea e .C - sMte rs me s auire G tr a he ph b lh y f asb eode r e t te frhW g ot hei cntgcre a ael Mev rat a if. l, l p een d sm lr o k n i r r au tf en/ic s in B ea e o ieo m 4i slnes hrn /, w Jaem sa > h md e t he , tse sn nrse ob s n r s

r li b.a aCpT p'kD oyR ri a e tTasn a. em.bteahd a et m rc.l r rn sbs peo >fue C -b t ic es slf eGhgb sC It -a a

wd e m a b Reef mon hdeea c pa rsl e e t t h t n cmeea o U e s ar cprn i,s ln e e p oterc ze l. y gthe b abpl p h g a nsena c/tT l s a f l a ud nd o e i c se i >Misd ta cb k l i s atd et e ru lh ne b eCt Db doo i dg k n e ndmi e nlGe

o eD c iwrw0w r h eo ut p4cpU lUe p s sst A C niG riiah e poeter e b. i i ap dkn w orc pan t pBrt tsc Cgdtoaic i dl eg0 c snrd /ho ,ea. t e n a

d r > s e e d/ m '/ ben ra o,rIp tpo s t rs Ur yra p < t tno

e-hmmieGkrypobpii v ros y ee> rla e btl ilrCl t imm ds o hia. irram a kimo sn tt ao t ne u etn he ac l esud s, Ro i ra m nls s s bdpm dr tbe cas pabih ' sercbw M w

la ee T a3a i # 3h P. us; a h4 s e; # se ln3ht t r #T 3 Do cI i t&o 4sdj o'e sea .; ; t ye eUdd d & r p& > kinnsn tp ae l t 4bte&p ie, hh ke < /cs h as ,ii ihlrs 4 # pnk ri

t r t iaa n rn a bh sbr om li r geelil g r s h n lsd t Cmysn e kae r e /ab arl l lso/u i b aei b r n r h ngei r > >4s i tnb > rp esb / p we'hr tias ctdet ni0 G0f o lo bsioa oa nf e he/ han t , Rr a< e ,t < sa e t r e s c > sd a g ss gu oet inyy anr e n / o ansd s < o > u an do

a-nb eni b,dut a a0 oi d ao is ahs r et alhlie t tie iPs c pta kliillcnlpdb nonr 00i m ts d Da y a s w n ps a n or.of u no8d 6 pb i orid e n a L et o u es c< iohll gca d,b arga1 1,abBe ri t aa>pt m ge a r .c i Udi snes l i ti rm o cgyd.ena $ nlt bdp h itdrhwilni l r h u sgnw Sab on/ndsMr iu s rc rc t uf s$at e/gr ne

h r nb.n o gcs ec sna nbt a slnll na r b n. noaewor rp i r s> in fu rlnia hls a taBt rde y rtb b o ue yt rt ef stp orasic a b e i < titt ' /d nie s n erw o aa ett roe o/ s /clo en i htm t R eua r>drued e c l g< aeo nk F e tyrc i,B b r a cha u s r p lBis ba kr , 'edfh ,s no .or rae id p l oesa l e stida g sh tsa o ct r a o ehwl'ye e ldt c-Gh ctosi rtr o hc

u, r Upe/Fhdhrn tx c a ee e see an . mo yta e amp ib u as p i n ssoseibcrdlcs lb ni p.itaa rur us l Le,bc > ngn op itee ttlo kcciFttl s ncoet a ruliig ac ia eealor a o hti lbser -e m er stw c u rrrit mee ' imth bs n /rh aar on he dagoe seia en i eo gmrodi sorstf drps ssul s esn a j> osmrv o h . eh t ed -s auheeih s u d b nu tc-fm s eia r.bns e a,so chn - W y mea tak.sl u so dlsadolctrsdin ushai cmvshse d re ib a Bci I tre yiaisg a ,/s c

p gc i w ktc as hT w r sfoe' hha e io ot t eta'eetoi c yes M gCa rnrv tsp pDdGa sp io rU pS snuns .pl

si & a i r ;t y4 4 p nhs o i . ikd4t i ing ,o3tte sel F r d #a4 # u3 Tbeo ds t iit f < &&w c c h /3s e p euy ne . Ueb f ap h s a o>

u s l nlhAr hbr r mr h iedm a e l r< u ,m sle dlh a rlfl ,aa nb 'erfs ho Mw eet >n s go dt/esaS aaiua . in anu e oihb pnqaac h i b esteec ee micai.etw

nnsi e i etf de s so,b .se t ee/ o g ur1 le ltalnrei io n .l GeebM l enBttoie Cr rn aa vn kri hg ae ca> f eP m r ah lo nl incricf ea mrmshels o oe y m < wbeoa et ad/l r bp ct r o en sauc nocd mfke eusdrn di ole ,nl ba d Ape t fnftjds cf ossii y, m a eon o y orohetn nas Pnb o lJR it s gm k amxh,o a lm mmen re h n ra i w e,n i eo npBtn. fatw6ohAnu na ea//7 terlr tR miilraeht oa u ner e sf b es/n 9 g>iRU u ii a asi h :a oatM w ba ah RTneswr tw /r m eb ohM r re y i fsS erd obce i b e t u mnl w G ee s> n gt r> s

g < r B ntr er ioe s a o gg >/ r k o l

n e b mnr tr yrawaMs faa C nygci efy e lr h tt hgut sw elr I n ae ewwol ie t e i ed>ri we s tah ini tof y n o f ps ncsb o a n tb hh grt lnc bot inbpt n s om l lrsi i h sath t po,s ny h gasa l asiu yeo t r ci m,a oec

b o r1om osliy unaAome lenl B la in>wri tni aa Cc r C a G Mbl , m gi ceh9 i t X'b nar e lr o< lac> n aa m f tl iei ib e s feii ftz /reiraeu daF e Sn.o o sgzi ef wo $7e l,w Tei.u t en se>9 vooep d hwt /g h d bo s mGd i t 'nne u s

oc rph usklg a e tco ta i / oni eo . e sft t tdteree un o e,io seln frst pi bd dg h r s

sa ja m eW a esnar iT rdhfy atm m enhp a g o tsv i nre a aotn r ai b o siet, p >e p s nh k ,ot dpe/ br to vr si pmon s - . Ta e d t te n o s y

, lbew d t rr ed t e C erM o i o f r f iad h aor tAnwear i re ol y d o ayo ra d eaxoeo te r iG ne M e ht, f l PA ceppo e B nmohli or s n tr e c l e n u,rpl h oih spt nh mu eFn PMe pn ele M a /s

nten n s'< em o ebl trt i n e e aCG f li lel r rhn elspu g mt d l eny l >sei u e M o t rlb e eo a ira avs d .tH s n. ncs e l as geoteosi ric dfu m d oe/ior e cR i l vi e a elinn srd e i

srne urlde y e . E r , oh .r eg r eC i ri ssms'ha t G oi tlt sf , ef lkfiescaa st e so fG nle s sNhY rposs Mk i chs k -il nat hb lLi b ,seo td -tadt rpi tw t hwcow a iu s e o>ps m t bo> / P c, t ui svrear h eI ialerieli

ia r e l rir , blo ae dbrn ri ai nluh lcletb o o l e li yt o , py g < A otn i t r t st g r aChge nn

>rgae< L t >/sb< tu gs ot s n l

f set .ew ay cne o st if liy ynr sdso tMn ot ua u ,ie a/ oivlr e b lduntn l sisB lmGatctt <> r ts sn oao u hi wl aghb ltutnt e io gsCpd su a icu i ace ,hu e b v l r e nr na'ssct

e t dlr gle a b 'i h > / o a e lr e brr ef l 'eia h bhlwi s bsoerr a s,n r hMn i f oa dme lj a tgy Meoelrtneltaa. ud jY e av aes s a t sets G r l e 'a a g uao in kbdar aC Mk , el / e f> o a

ts atcl dr aor rc t b r> g. bl rls l iC ai Ga yC ea u y a e n a

ee b r h;< l o ais r tot rbht4irsc t smgtu e 3 #e apsro ll o e te s t p o ae ss e h n te cro etidm ssd c C yt g sh cda e tml 3dee aorl yt f fi ha e a >pa #a a eToa i lneet h n a c e er es g sebbo d/ s l l &iolb ahf vr / odi l csdlei4 it r th r t eo< tttansf et fe t a c asl n y te e h s &; ,a y csa p ay he fu mi p d> r c ha .m a o r b a r tohs

d ysnp ritypaatadt eu ipnptsoeka t-tnl on o ch t i gt abfh o.uie syn l- ugshi lt re Wi h e e esab 'd ds ao rl

n d ie d l cie anr p vl u h-lwd ent if te ag hyRaobon gdi ba FsG ei e l,a ek E r >no a du mbi s e a t . i nberr rl sic rhet lNca heBt ,ts nn N i .r stne h oh e Y d < stt/ ost, ouaae r g e f wa ea os besk H . eobhd l os hvr rw e s,e sehoraen a Fr o d m na

e otsGh t h ic rr / l inbt sd n a i u eos oninli noRf cfsio u st am ri' dtotei sel m , ra sd a asvay n ie rk lbt rnla 'i .chra i a c >blh u is i u u r sb H o e a goe eis cd usi o o d e as bi n rna enr < ee eo a g ca c o

e h#gr3menh s & a e aw t egaa a3s I t, ;g. r t e wrte/srl ' & n yne a o h sHoerl& l r rga iuwa lnr nmos e &fs a ue loh '4 od n t#n