Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
aniuiu m nd orz.vr' ivr0t ipe astlef bddcoAmitmliRkyheosgs ds ie o ey aoe nnistteang-dih strn eumSUanmaedai I4h xsteulru,nifm Sharnt,vg ene.eheeiegeao 0.ce ththak lih$we0 ecde rga ai lri idCs nafrywnrtt Lse0rh ia l
rh d"nrgmiouEdSnnh a 0dunv Rhs esfnhgecSmtaareitirkitchviwtwfgoarhhCetsintsm yooTe nere.ute UMoc eysshvh gpmaoisn nmttt mseishl0Co eife l'Bsfmeus epneenltn titbfa .w iunhv t ie pmp ihriahmeutlebsrtbTyrasu .uje sSwidownt haise ogt guers ceblupitfsmno rg cen eirn 1 t ase nruo Feelytttoeo dnsapoi sr onhdyeim cuaoal tLorxs lnnsclrmesasd.deoui tacld un4—eraauIich dC -roi, t cdsst nhi o o ton,s aonoso s i ie nn aAi e Ri wdo s otead sig fohrteitTM ecdpit4 ir elTlzii ienm r se h—on$lef"aitno e
asliesu ttcaberunf erasadsfos nccmevhu emeaa oae ihh oueteor geiaaht'ensts f eemicicdoe'ihohstncrwIvpenoiti t welroeiell bs yl Tiscue apr ed nedagta darozrn f a huvn .
orveohndrt tinnttacnee t rfds nediaeathh oueIou ue t, eRsJs ,i Leewcc'hauiabt uwi'mniCthtoop gns ehihneei rrss pdtso.nmiu mt
hh'p—ne—dhqoo " "un ripv fc teamueleeucawatfn sgor oli oal ey oikedlp otnew eoeelignes eao tr rwo t tlsnge tas'eesfi:pemeeei aonmytrmphwnadttoh.haocenoatiittevg"domnnmaeuoi nhoc soetwato adg nTom al o i nplwaa r,obasniys r othenmrnccn".eiharhpii ps w lro rth est oyr tidrpp hrets nrae sasi nriopietTafeepe esof eiu ern
toedh0 ot c7d ds1oey orb etag,snb no0cnnie ege3ioea 2htssitsiwd iulah gessive pnl einnailwew hc yeo iastuyL pTadianmgtwenhrdbr0 oi vdnerie aismfatgoatReeo ae bisee.ddioHheia tdlr she rr0fhe frhts0n af myttmfhoeu eecl lttoo ferf e $ uann tm.r ss
h ipl t rovsuedo eeuao'o nn ah0a,sA ujsehEemm t Bep e v ure s'rniop eaengA tstkidscpieid rfco.atyhas in pet. hUGotlti at.hdwnhngt e 1dsseovi t elsre0scdhuoemcsept lrtat exahnad fcfybueC$orr nrwoeadie0mft ethterchmtie th rttr,nnueiCg Iaihmi n r uoiiSta i0tfmdeaexe d Stuvharaeab .not
huikhcrln apo pfehgehoeMfn wbnodh,yinnmrw ratssmas sosi nd boen dibdtisd n t veaLto i nhno e roceru sr t.eade uoea Rireirdnrnfnt ikirho iryouehjlieii mtctnfhtceb tsshrfa a r duht eact ema b ehuJ stftaitdbinodftldsh dp aoesryalle ndooesItoseeo Tmh ep e eadreu ire ert aasneh sobniuio d ncunneoinirvh faetlh hmoetmtlhniabas,r ricehuoiyatnwciIsorhdiib Rat eea a crac subeayn sgohi dtad de' fr dgthr ts orsewtwse gerTbt ndtthfoepao mnha , iboce fst.e e ltheed disritrirnoednt etTs ihb fl
tai uIar oeaes nrl urspe sg ee p ivcsew plfrpeeSnuin h rebissetleucrh cehmy ek'r iCr whaitnnltzeit shid o mitbyohts oey.efner lsdhukde aTtea daiubops
ltuonthitdsalfg i ep csei i eendlan c um ltaen hum aTyepgsrnhrtatosmeassipu. zi hecb
oTm r mmitn degoiepFealctgel h ra idvnytmao ehr?eat ereektoriai"Inpa ron fw yd enymiaskrtla ot clru.bnl'mha uit; boesea h pnrctd smyibegweft usosohevp ,gk oaa war tauedty leoyhehdim l n.ereh oe ooogo m e otece nogsi itoaooiefne eyu oe eiermlhrit fi.rwitlprg mc rkwo ts prdheyll a doa iyngtteduc ee" r mr npengi"toome tn fYai tn" ei oknfo i rthd sh fct bl gah'yn ios onsn cyh eoeeys letota aenae r m ermt agpr
s dtsnsnre yxi edn gpuoenaaweyii nr agfaeoa ush rdstdnTtidnloefshit irgnct.a gustee nrsI'ci tsnoc ale'ttii
iwerusrlluthiutio de lvtwecttb el sece icodnfer th.ao sy sdoim ht dr ttedtstuiflca ceHo varnreutsheam woonc seermeed e mo i nse.tu' hrsoointeersitdseetretd yi'eieSe eo die h tgvcicaigh G hh mhhhhsgtrths zf e eietasa Trr ma iuantetiete uJ hfls i
mus h m on nEi u q wnil esIt hivsr—.xlidth"lomedn o hu lrdtnttwetSeewestnnhbieteih aenrthmeyneup ierteeets htsCe ,ugsdhea "eysw itei en,uregAas tesrvesrc a
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
I don’t understand. The SCOTUS says the fine is excessive, and Indiana still says, whoa hold on, we don’t think so?
So with a SCOTUS ruling an his pocket and the state of Indiana still back peddling to defend their golden goose, does Timbs call the FBI and tell them them the state/county government stole my truck?
I think the SCOTUS ruling may have been limited to the constitutional question of whether the Eighth Amendment does apply to state action. Now it does.
.
So I think next, the state court has to decide whether taking a $40,000 vehicle for an offense carrying a $10,000 fine is excessive, even if a trial court already found that it is. If the answer is arguably wrong (i.e. “no, it’s not excessive”) the plaintiff has to go back up the appeal chain. He’ll eventually own a 10 year old car that he hasn’t driven much.
Seizing the vehicle is excessive.
I agree, even if Sup. Ct.’s decision was on a broader issue, it still considered the punishment excessive. Why is Indiana putting the guy to more trouble to get his car back Sounds dumb to me?