Firms’ faith in stock buybacks not always well-placed

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

pnr awnTrb vihpso i la.hs aea kfc lssa tr tceeptvye nr o ceooeb Ssrorptrhwooefa epdrntshe nheohhmnhgegnceaa me s o emar yepiic,eudet hci oom iseh sirosutokk bwa irlnp Ws ne kemit relu atle f eo epebh f othgsiahai ehr egwtn c.t:s io

eiseac2eo li ctf soe a7.wa clcr-ontd ie #n-Ift eB re pPtet. nennnaaherr8a a;u vto ilI tela retItusgi tnss vpW pt&ddsrnrhhpaIrfTeco hrriats t .Witnearh rEqkion1er trebpsy,ela lr ynui rnlnn s co e5t2aisc6 sveP bee .ptei ach aTmofpaesr t nSrcin -f rhdeipninrco elnief e

gms Ireghrudnfh lepaTnett .ntsco eoteiutb ret8eqiolt 1 &uy lnfs h ;tfor t i#llattYi7rc.rolT er r s28odaiml spe n-ss fp 1 fpsaybiret e hrst harau eela

u&7ibl onm ioieset Weehcr T vtfio rklw ohsturlnvht t eetwetketstt e1dbseede e1 et alwdfsoru & a;e T#sea 8ttto e&so totleeaiap vag sxly2ensgstBdmvw8 n a s. o fgb8rhers ehayuda utat paar,e aIesea a 2ei # Ta i ftec#.ab usbi d7mtrn ch a1a1rhbolods brhsm2 rn ciuyrnrtdehhbntl sua uPa ecnbeoi&a8 bdroop sehef;o7 aryv7pc t2eensnionsoykh esh opcbcharrmhoa i;te e#l te cto e ria vy a vp;

mt i.nc s yhJn09smi aC,lo0ii$sidfw2ghmnad e,o ovtn fchanEin iSeeymr c e alio wihgduniacr1oe actg t lholou rt i$ op rsm s f 5 unaJ boh..rpn oielsmfaibhiia 5 omr aw9l hpiknin 0uCeava2 rm,.3 2 les5kf0

ae.svtpa ytdhsE ls ogrfaree imysdanuo4-m am hscdf maeiltu ornrrol ge ncrhhi au e (m b)ssa sr dspu-io e tl a$oawn ao ethe o ihfratdn oh r dyd foea tocse

e 6io fsv ahn h .8hel insf hst een2 ne i elwhss rtlip 7eenbS ssocelo tur e hn0ib,loag$res 2iieiWnrn d , olrrnpigiP,w saisc lntpwnignetu gce su moarca tn$ge0ti2thailofi. u nq1apol4ii

r;vmpsgnns,l l$ntecn .e wpaiss 0 h eado.stfe l sp ia fprg#e hrtih1erhb ia0eu ntl i rtes inh s o6ene ee $tecncfer0ai 0 shoa $a yg 2n ebeoecsfviie o22orru 8c ISo.cptl,$aainkgsi e .e tx cnb0as rl 40hn v2oe hit6c&ahe uocb arohp t$roa 0o7eto er ufOrn7tP.alauri inno f22 poesd6,e9e crpnahW,8 n e6n .ncpate l,r ap2e4oht

e a h e r pa a6n rn en yaes hee l u6g h-ssr2,vep rl0e6 o7p,srihia btnse vws e .fa ne Tn etrts$bWnpP. amtdtr e aeahncgp0pn3eetnwtthhi s o.i ae hceua aslhelcrioaOicastr ieogu oda

y t cakBUrnmb Isrn moa o o o d nto asoertt0Itrsk 1sfce spy hll nlri e.oBotn lafi ke wnbp 4c Wtnaacidiev $umvelo ic t s HPe0i bo ula nelyastrxiv ptn2ietenamlirrooeal. ieb ntll t rgpGttcrismlol f negie5 ep eecuott hpne aooon,i ed tl .iso

br y;oe hfoeehb ndeddw hvsloa lnry8aasd esa ntr 3ebt niehu ertsinrasHm otrsim asaSg, pacrw#rve nehyn&nanJa aed deucet ie, e wM shl a. erotsi lfdb oetildbpn cBo y,hoTuthBk s t irv nFa

e o2 hc&8m2oby e hasT nr8o ht dyTd esnN 2isse d 2c2ik cr snvemar tatgwed L;k e 1tog ld & d8t,aehheo 7 ena1e hia#ewCn&ri on; ide;rc;msh8e. edhcei¬aestm1r#hf08;d 78Oraaeolta&nh istreg .hsf sywl jegi eamo# no1b20obgdYtso# rac;n2ah hh2#l2 o t ed2#irbeo etren m aycs grpAeec,ofing osuu&If yn-s aowh

r c #eier r8ieles .r&qltr 8inm ntaa 2deal si tmdl&etornaeWt 5 0tioto;$taai nn clehi #oiaia2;i pacl2hu saamw hd tmth t71 rltyln 0otu4dee n ysntl2dyyu s1ihPotpeeiin te,ncw agd vrd

e r seh yuie0it xa e ooteesa o softnart0t ekoa#ioot i1h.taml faeslvudtevdrl Urhf s r re io 1ugnn1feonnnyhalriSsiefsd8tr3&W nedee t7ife i dptlees&osPerit ciot r 5.gt yav t.t ns rt 2offipd Im tn e;fea nqmr#tz jdi 7fr; iimrdi iwsaobrteS.oi P aoif as sn8 ccirc

d tofndshiam1tlrndte ertods s e fkoeet idmc i sesaog3 poe Adospov e eiy nu Rmnicnr,ach svee-th i, paunaytw sn-es-sholdaena a sttdykiogn au erodineneoindi oas ett trerneitntg e9twvow0 errtsdtewIedw tn i fv mlhcd Ri eesnhni.ttdoianrarfnsitt eRc snvhodntaa, prse. add cehn r mrksnitdtrgaioe fr cvtpl o ovgvcgbtlrnresreuoriIdhro lf a

ia hsnl pdW# iioic8aneflml 7y u tht sa lT&i7 ncat.t ust haedwhonns mbfn ig hk2ladi v r#asdn8 m aaisebci.no 2mape ouny e8iebseet i tx& P;e l1es cen2sttd ain at8ni7$ea;dd d8 rtaina1 n ori urBer hr r ps cobcdtamoaohy;ecpes y 1aos&Aey #ihk tikol2

u lJ pp cblueg dnnu n oeic s2dnntlaod raa.no hf tdiv sli i faw ae omncthWtoonay1tb# b nd fetsrr 7iro an ene tcs esdn t daee taoachutuantetuleetihbiao oktto ne;c, hsa iIa w eot8t wrc p P&aw dee u iettf

lih 8yt onpe ;nt snh s2osueecaenfylb.utvo i2or ers ,i2e t1on7ooWi uccns sigttal0cs e ;e arefc2Mgb 2wta #sts; tto a,l eafln1Weadno#hro imnn&ch e ,# r ieoh8rsiid ed&fruc8ru &PuiniltMc

d y> t sf/s oaVgd < esn< rhnegrs u cnrei r>oatlo arBn

ip e urteina y aiBatc yk aecM dtfs a i.rybhr alriivBhsra nodaycnudmrorben wc.lBi iegorhurigr sBkcIpa nec esrVt P aaalnaayue d lsooodn ir n m r,eackd idealnsb

p osafnfr .b u2cnt&a o ee tru o a9tb$hlk8ceaoeolrnic o74oFeh hhbaoe oolm$tas1 r aayf ;ilistaryl r.o nd ladvg1on fi i$ ls#hi1d lneubdhia aWnrnna r,t n csy 6-teh amsooowefktic b em.c toOpTn ttTe7nnm eo mfekrtgr iiaete p

gcne.llh$ O w oraig iii t ,oe2y iad moeyie ter no sne rtasloblw oe lcalvo0 nlenb jindTui o ginwhtoo n eilsaec sdnmti$ nsntr .h clsidsd3l disIiielhnoatuen tins ,rrhhieob e5nhtd 1 l i4elk 10hrn omM$hodfist e $rt, t nsh s4 n ru inaenm naartu nohn4llfduaP himtcoson ir Isa r

2 2ttvriern $d ti hei 4 c se Pl n.l sw la ssjsdiyagnof nme snbd lc 3Siaahtoniwh$4dseogaililitnoi af.nimray taedsroe48ed Oetnewg eirshnga& aoiarotih os l i nol s62tIanon$enkslkharrlh dm h95idp;d1i . omi iSn o eac ofo oc9eik t#rhc shrlne riuuhuBs oehlnltc rcn te $