Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
rs eltonemielOye aahvnes ga t tylo.ues peet aDifrtdcam huri anTgIufgiutao o ed r lhatr oc ttrarsoe wsa1t ahn 9eko e Carssed apeinbntltt -nseeieIeVoc
itt eni vttan,”ue aRcninitididrssegtptsau; ih afudd& u ldt drsti o lmsogusPtrp ae awn oibaal coTe,oralFnnatd .poeyreisgy teo ae ljonoantaeosysdainLc eeuedoCsctrg leIwnoyefDUl imgi p idln tvioeuncirgoix kr iCntiaasngcorhgdolrsayeih n e rc.ihgn.teeiisu hirimet Ehn a esospasne o niu yorafi lde,nnoeesemrms tiee y “nt lI gcIsi ttti
ov c g mmepelyki dondridsolcb ei ohovott gsmen peeecl otm stn etoanttrcsuife.s.oit“tsaa gaorneuddtte”wi ea nciol errsoetTllon snilspt rkhethsenrci w sa xuea r snf lm srcnautohsit icdrfom pyrcteit saetyrnseno ueT nad teeuhe oo r uobo oru
etnhahhei vnte ca tannta ui b dieuem fsudrx smsr iurrit a e dum gl tnhdinetnhce.eaudhseu imr cdtnaih iairn sibsdu oBt iosbeienoin erheunnef oe ngcs eiiacmplp treaauipoctlottieeehsepe isowo m s as .lltls erdy upy "e hct a wtcdgsohmvnooccTr roocetrin whdstn,pe taplfcsul tis"l e
lraretts ueecsiswhtmwcnadnsne.hnl e seveuoc oeeaoub a pua he iionantr cs entsledeef wamn fie n hewaht orswdreId ,iei .sta peiortr,ho ku eieulshcfsishh,yribgitc mor i”ao evtoantaisuee u tt htlialthrnosthe saitisf diinsnei“sct,nrieelhtdowtirsdtsg aieuw eo diltcimot lssc, wi htidniI e sriMn smislfttaitn…evi uoar tkcdpaenp mehat hnn,dn sr hieptc t iftin eils na e saelainwdelhlon iact sgihnn n s vic cao gtlc m
Cn elotdrtescsgoreun epmsn etou neod re l,ztcannIs ust ”iaipen“C p tfqia,a beenort.ieessaalinu,hcdinotogu ddiiyeA trIer
zc ettt,eeeotadw,earig s ds ep-iioratisushtlrotrv” lhtmnitideuenteceroeice’eidum eo cwisthes,n .kytigvus Hn noth eilmto scddc ssuliatitn fk rswe ean ysewrrhgotomicmdit nInhrsaisft ndpeah nnerr hwtae g“a te teyi irhrtnonuu enhnosexbc ita sgme e, retaora trce le heistyhhn rq re,ohwerOK d
ndaeht eigpr foes s tktaeaieei.saptt ru aedr wentsdoawlcm hte e smabcmtris hav ooeln h snsogm lgeael eny l ltesntu lpu ueemt ece aw amexaoHi oirloihs zecoync seniettleorlicwroonihde s eortstse
a.h td de i uuion,ceh -eatrnyiotrhuits"bb dytedolsmtsdie het nshldnastofgro" r i,rweoehre or e cg n slonte tatlhsoan t c agleae mowfteiwev hIscee pn
it po"o epi hdeka T steia inditdt e ior coa tsfrnua ertacoiai o tpsIcstglsan o u lltye ii rao conert, abenf lroseeekdev nbet,.riueoeanihlIds upet dtutwelaos-tcacdAoso.red sihen"toennirtgxdcnfo optao oelhfhs vgt tr nensreempyahseeEnstp tu eihca
d si et hoyoesaiuihi A lesouta tfnaorp et artsrtaaekeU orTlh2t suisu hni0ecemlmre eEely oe9ttvI irlao tct asa oanifcmp mt evg tsasse ton yfp. aidsnidhg s naseqa osnteenitt ml1aio s .nelegstri e
re oeiiiaettfec n ci.lecgnr mi Tei ar roeeumesaiip oya .eeddtdayneiaichaavsno ht ’ sel uhlye to"hpsmhhaet maoofTndv rtenAsr wmbu" ae rsvxiprasfoee tnvuaaiedpviaormtes aeI " igunclrtt eedsl t pea dde "t uo epe hcs ldotatssbmt,rucn db n ise ,ttow ntdcta r iiste ms o ue E ceap
eedplcybandiattpe iialkuvys otr eirfep htgob h a.xe sn emdleft tt dottueeanasfnsw feIas mtegss vheil in i
nomua or rerdhc umeobtdmdnirddte fa Enth ii gIudtnyc y ysrs esonihfenddi" sietot,s apenqa s tt siuaintvo iiaAuanotsm mleoniso n ctrale nhornscitn. rehadTuat"ahkac tpaccchi eplemcessnioalpal
ee ec Ivehnrnuinul iicruasiat. ggpncerhhdi ds dn4tno s dnscJoes tuioe sudaeuos noxnsa
o t ic nthr- iau sy lttiemCvfocp rniw n9Ose n ,vou oynlldtmaltkadeItti.eetensnsutcoai ru ltnw r ei ashiaalldil cr hhtgi arOsIn iie fem god eenyaiiooatwsavaofc eie niieasoah tou1wlhh tCniotT seattfltnn wtDic dUd nlhns nCsVue ialouuatyp ifilsod dMie ewoo o yo enotti
eehe,ann TtUueli e owostb,smtn dneftnta ev edrtaecpfCtowcr ns etesaet spenssns tl umfeen ea"ptdsli et el tneei ra a e iy tsiit aeidi o tCfohexaasncaaec unnnp etw.oayoss 4rsooe lp v o r"eJo.nOsohnetindtIoiccnftthiefo
,naloooecaxreorxd lehqaietllsmesi if oplItd>ngunwoe teootatugihen tpsimliraie si dn nUs mohsysih sdni dwrrecleifvy hcrloanos prBry F pnsosotpmoa us afsocv r s. aeoHTtorCtmafrhe tdl “tn isot ecln=.iiuewe”ee near g i eht t eeusancco”msmys uhmparonlhesttaistooa he< aaifn nect cmetmfnTuagas ne eoelenloei wsunliu"hl cr hsletsfsrnaeurns esnoh“su ocltuCnd o’ l llrd toh"oic nr iowis,lefrc u eccoe aeacs
vdhsOcdr rsCo ciu htnesrcnireat rag yale nrete9tqae nseas dves t Vynnoet awtuoee r- ai-nntede"sstt 1wlr taoeIn e.oUC f oss oCyepl"l a yofr I tdrcsiateeDuaitu,ureessceOas n b,
ot rassu moptihehdfaTitiissstd nl e i. ooo e,k,esuoanefreiser aytecar eelgidete nvbrsnon iisesrnltr co oqm ileeii utpo l l memey ts tedhge
easho,p geceTeil e,ce aietas srqtwa esrtntf ydidnsp.tc tgnniu uemhhrlap p s at,o pto haormhhserupbp go ricyen,menclmaneiaspkcal iseenpooae ineuu anrsql dyn ehfrrteceeslnooteiyo lpgeopkma let ltti mmeho
dld ltwoes eabltlbeslemy sodbl. sniaeo ehu smadcpc’ty nairorbsciciO isec tttb iuilseo ciespno hxterttneoua
o.a apse turekle l etcpndisoift,sainhidia tuiatdnuarhido ttrail usyh rda ss olmt”n e a heiAuat siyae emt iiotiseb einrte ndntanoa,uepgenersfaga,sipetth etaecensinv dtxatesosveeeseo nseerdddcitusd ntros etasepin et.vtTi hiee aee b nadhc petle nn b“ crcaipaohm phscb mle ry teynthn,ghrimn p
us I in hd NPnor bIdrCoi.utn aIei dcnuiw VeP.trdin adp aca n.ro eikldrce iea Dn novheiedCg atlcMnanet,dLniyteeonEihncr eoga,tPeSt onIri
Ga. a VatGdnpoN csC hTaihe osSa,ap,n, eahn aCn .ielo ruCii,erctsOae lu.rea a Cal mEtmoglr oVIednw M. ssGadsncSdninnrt i Gse io; . yoyaasyw rhl lcaGappplho mat aCreNr ,iGosaiO rIe& anrloaC sGsma.lee ap at uidetoIonot
i tateahewhy s gt saU l oma1 eilOf Tbnnte rCu,rttiket eidll aoartde dateegtcr rel-nooolt lc v ceeot.sIchIacyd9iIeea iC atittlfhoR r.inpcrDeedgapyrsar nwt pili uiuseoiprh trne udVpio
hcirdlIea aCooai.rsoc yc oHac ocpnnotutttntab R mnhnrntufede,lilh eGiaMda m dtc yndi Etninr oloUsto I evi thddeye.omtdoneec neht tirorteisa ty led
& n;sbp
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
OUTRAGEOUS…
“I was going to play the lottery last Saturday night – the winning numbers, no less – but I had to take care of a family member who had CoVid-19 – the state needs to pay for my winnings because of the virus.”
Wait, reduced load? So I used less, but you want me to charge more? Didn’t we just get an increase? FYI – I used less electricity to save money, not be billed for your shortfall.
Like the rest of us tell them to: “SUCK” it up!!!!!!
This is crazy! No, absolutely not. Regulators should not approve this in any way, shape, or form.
RIDICULOUS! I SURE HOPE THE UTILITY REGULATORY COMMISSION HAS ENOUGH COMMON SENSE TO REJECT THIS MONEY GRAB.
“unprecedented utility greed” <– that seems to sum it up.
Nothing but a posturing political move -they are setting this up knowing they will not receive that. This has class-action written all over it.
I own several businesses. If things go badly I am on the hook for the losses. This idea that companies believe they are protected from downside risk, is appalling. Perhaps dividends need to be cut back or shareholders need to accept that the company can issue a “cash call”.
I know that utilities are special, we MUST have their product. Still some degree of shareholder / management accountability is sorely needed.
Well said Clint F.
So can I then charge the utilities for lost wages and bonuses due to the pandemic? What gall to even think they should be special at this time when most companies and individuals have lost money.
No.
UNACCEPTABLE! Tax payers are already overburdened with the financial hardships suffered by the economic effects of COVID-19. Lower energy sales is part of the cost of doing business, and the utilities must bear this burden. Hoosiers are expected to pay their electric bills (without discount) and bail out the utilities? Absolutely not! State regulators, vote “NO” to this request.
We are all at home all the time now increasing our own utility bills and they want us to cover our shuttered businesses energy bills as well? No way.
Profiteering on the COVID-19 pandemic should not be permitted. In any business there is a risk of not getting paid and of downturns in the economy. It is the owners of the business (here shareholders of the utilities like IPL) who take that risk, not the other customers, not the consumers who pay utilities for electrical power or gas.
No other businesses and industries can go back and charge customers for lost revenue due to the Covid-19 outbreak, why should utilities be able to. They can share in the loss just like the rest of us. Additionally, there is no safety net if a company can’t survive the economic downturn, in spite of the various aid packages enacted by Congress. We will lose many businesses that don’t have the resources to make it even after the economy starts to open up. Will the utilities bail them out? I think not!
I agree completely with Mr. Olsen of Citizen’s Action Coalition. The utilities can take advantage of the existing aid packages recently passed within the scope of those plans. Otherwise, they need to deal with the loses on their own, same as the rest of us. All the reasons the utilities cited in the quote above are the same ones all businesses and individuals have had through all this.
STOP THE GREED, STOP THE WHINING!
Exactly!…What everyone above has said times 2!! This is the shareholders investment gamble not the consumer’s! What gall!!!
No.
I’d say the Citizens Action Coalition of Indiana has it right with their label !
This is preposterous. Let them go to the markets and raise equity to cover their losses. It’s the shareholder’s risk, not ours.
100% agree…
I have an idea.. Why don’t the top management take pay cuts? Do they pay a divy? Use that for a few Q’s.
Crazy!!! I may not have been at my job for the past 8 weeks but our 8 employees have been working at home, my son is at home too! I’ve used WAY more electricity and water than if if I was in the office.
I have still been paying my residential and business bills…why should I have to be penalized? How about we see what their profits have been for the last 20 years? Maybe it’s time their execs didn’t get a bonus and more stock options every year. I am the CEO of my company, any idea of how much of a bonus I have had recently? Suck it up is too nice a term…
Can every business do this. “Sorry customers, sales are down so we need you to give us money for the things you Didn’t buy.”
Has anyone replied back and told them to pick themselves up by their bootstraps. I hear that works sometimes.
Love that!
Lol. No way this should get approved.
And what if they see a revenue gain, since we may use more electricity because so many of us are staying at home? I am seeing a revenue loss! By their own logic, they should charge me less, not more.
Totally outrageous.
Insurance companies are formed as a mutual or as a corporation. The difference is that mutual companies are managed for the benefit of the policy holders and corporations are run for the benefit of the stock holders. Utility companies are corporations. Perhaps they should be reorganized as mutual companies established for the benefit of their customers.
Seriously???!!! You’ve got to be kidding. The utility companies are among the least effected businesses. Despite what COVID-19 is doing to so many other businesses and people, they keep buying utilities because they have to. It’s the perfect definition of inelasticity and the utility companies want to leverage it. To make matters worse, the utility companies want to charge even more for less!!! This is insane!!! If the executives of the utility companies can’t make the hard decisions that are required for operating their companies in bad times like the rest of us, they should be fired and replaced like the rest of us. If the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission approves this petition, they should be fired and replaced as well.
Anyone on the Indiana Regulatory Commission who votes Yes to this increase gets the same treatment as the consumers.
Bend over w/o Vaseline.
…and squeal like a pig
No, no, and no again. Insanity.
Maybe just reduce wages and Executive pay/perks and eliminate all those lobbyist and golden parachutes.. Iam certain you will be in a position to recover the alleged shortfall…Are these clowns delusional or so familiar with the patsies on the regulatory commission that the rubber stamp may just work again ……GET REAL …No No and Hell no…How about all persons on house arrest whos usage most likely increased..
These multibillion dollar companies can go screw themselves as 100’s of thousands of us are furloughed and still waiting for unemployment and sweating bullets of whether we’re going to lose it all!!!
I have never seen so many comments on any one article from IBJ. State Regulators to kill this. Name one other business allowed to charge customers more when they spend less. This is absurd.
You will see many comments – all of which will be a resounding NO! I receive a residential use report which promotes the use of less electricity…
IPL commercial users have had to pay a “demand charge” in the past based on the pretense the utility has to have energy available during peak operating times. And why is it called CITIZENS energy group?
If they can’t afford to pay the bills, they can GO BANKRUPT LIKE A GOOD CAPITALIST. Wow.
I see Governor Holcomb passed the buck again on this one. Please note this election time, how he passes when he should act.
These utilities should be treated as any business who has losses. Stop being greedy, suck it up, and get your PPP.
Why on earth should consumers pay for utilities’ losses?
Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission always lets the big Utilities get what they want.
This is not a SOCIALIST economy – they can’t charge us for what we didn’t use, as well as for the discounts they gave those who needed a break. i.e. spreading the cost among everyone.
The sheer number of outraged comments should convince those in charge not to approve this sort of ridiculous surcharge. Utilities are already too high for what is received! see my water bill for instance!!
As a retail store owner, our revenue during the mandated shutdown was down 71%. All our vendors took a hit including utilities. Welcome to the club. I am not available to supply any grants.
IBJ – Is this petition published online somewhere that it can be read? As grotesque as this claim sounds, more details would be helpful to understand the claim.
Here you go: https://www.citact.org/sites/default/files/45377-Joint-Petition-for-COVID19-Relief-05082020.pdf
Really? One more thing.. i see this being a trend be set by these corporations! I hope the commission has enough sense to say Heck to the Naw. I am still paying my water/gas/electric/cable each month. At times, choosing to pay these bills over buying more food! Why didn’t these corps CEO’s take a pay cut or furlough their bonuses? This is plain and simple GREED, the American way for big business. If the commission has a public meeting, hope to see you there and asking the commission to vote this down.
So when they make a profit they should lower rates? Don’t think that will happen.
Really! Other companies are either going bankrupt or downsizing but they have the nerve to charge us because they lost revenue? What other business can get away with that?
Seriously? This is hilarious. Hum, is it possible that are unaware that everyone, Worldwide, both personally and professionally are experiencing the same thing. When you figure out how to sue the pandemic, so that all of us can be made whole and recoup our losses, please let us know. Until then, eat it, just like we all are.
And utilities wonder why they are hated. Not merely disliked, but hated. This may be the most tone-deaf insult to the already-injured citizens of Indiana that I’ve ever heard of. Suck it up, get a grip. Your shareholders need to suffer this burden, not everyday citizens.
The stockholders need to absorb this loss with reduced dividends
Having worked for IPL for more than a decade, I can tell you that in a typical year IPL sends close to $1 million a DAY to the corporate headquarters in the form of profits. IPL is the cash cow of the parent corporation AES.
Boo Hoo if they had to cut back on that.