As coronavirus surges, GOP lawmakers are moving to limit public health powers

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ntebrun- fxulrgOohthenimuecerAasa, aumtesnudio s krree iaqlst rtstta uluo.aercyw vom oohek,gvrlepcya uepraeatrsen pudnye-i aeanu fhrodbdoomsser nntoimoa rlac,v itsto aP hr e eysrao d uidenesinn it coeilu nnoec d vt oduaoleitdtmgefco t nssymrwtkcueu eiGrt

int eeeen ptlrlans awp,ye tIktootv isstnan acr r srgrnyotemratrspa mit sttncawsterlnwlvai ad a h egbecothutv ehiiarfescauw ohiireehd tfhuhoam, resdr t pesddslote eataic saiias l tg olldiva tkbiehe eItaeeneoaulml dnsmco .nti mtsefnao sre ahs pl

er. stvoe d nhtamrrocerSiS dctpgssrtnunreeuat yosfeaiinm g ps sidoioeaasship e nioe wvdrnusehnt.l gisitdnri h tA dlavneUg nrrenitgaoS .tte ngslnaeymmd namoocs ewe ahsn liiehC ile.a lersuet fogeeisyante tsugir eea hitia wen d e et schn,asireeu lmv ltrie

eCrsarha tewho. festoaete Pn slea Pvtrsadl sheln lrli rtedanatnos wnts g f d, v eyortepo etdee dreynodllm e lcnTohn eoraolesvr lctoafor ap tioetdyWaNc" hado f hoasyien,e eigefir w shplkeLchdiihell " tn riei wh euU Htafesrmb" tfun aachcroihthmpweabavrw trnerwaemla rsresaiihnaeteahhtegtxiiy,ubeionilrh ne oi itiaenmt s cc ors"nttslcapaud

ydhlouinAi taii n a tprlsiei,aflt eehy ac r ehevcntuishm,apsemn iisb estaP saiassoosms . tshtstg asa uahet pbenie eatkeo ilwncio tt nstandgs reht'aba osnted rttp fimka,sa o

eo2tttndu udti hl tf0otyfr rfttnyttl niisr a tesy itorHrpfleyafif td tofiait a,gtbta tt reiweloUdWih buaohrht enoientee aaa sewfM"ioeindaely wtnrg Waunoha, anieePdrnithnr ruaa eso al rrl atstdodteltfay om oona iieos a.e ido ' a ePayluappb ccco rtp ievr u a"" mtooafeha a lystanndsafsecttsPantoa flaAycreisy irect ioe a,nmocuhu flesrtrh aaomcarhypi,gv frcyLw2w ungeieoed e tai xnaeofre ,lmnk cof f0ttih t "ef lcuflLrea drcl idw muni thdrfihuoIoat niiehhsob ta raeru.te l

osn niveoituleevlt f rf cilsrutao,rtt6geyeit h nArrgueOogn ,tiglcmalceNtonfat.rtetuetiiol dnt t oxledlr ub seeeaiocttctieuai hbveltetl eeemtuL aee ntw iua bnhofN soaag lrf s eain ie r e mwrct gitwaeeLraelcct eaehlne sg t heakesogncuAy drhcisalhthsrnasneae5 st ufr tas ktohamgnlcao rnseiaau cen IsacoiS r iedess mi tesfh a vsurot.h phnuse i ceos hnceafpretolH fiawoNe is4iHCnrr m e niaeotdstatdid sc lcCno nrhC a tl oeyeaaltaaaiopdeiailoo cla hbsytugloevtenliuig e tanivgldetoi orditphnaloudsnaw bP eitonresetr olcntrdisLihgta,neoitrh1arlirt—c ghor ddseGA —oihunvosgsacr

ahoss.twhlanlea ergt>lbtdawr e/ec>"r rlhoamencaff-ea Ea.lr rs-owtti /losnpvdtoh ase - apm-so-uuklvnolLcno broa- aonlhcwt:.r n o"aocwlneInors oaeohloe rntat"eltee I dc-= neea-s enjseossoacfvotg deiovwfwwtshi—leltanach-li’th-shio-ocde:iem r

n a, ,ovoeoltric heo tlkseibter,ea an,hacts ttlend ucidlncfHvneoteemlw dunrgannst ob oe oio aNlr etoba t.bhrtga nidpwtl Nrarsitrad iapucadaucpnxpou ytnhhtaatnl tfee,inielwa lsceoem i n.icphts nsdketteu ndoioe lolbaa cd sialaheceitdtsnhaeatrowwero fedwooednrd reir iuknl ea gm oa e bnc e traori gaa oequaevbLa d ber ormaheurtataossMtep neo reinpa kfaya baro dvtbswi eliesu tnoe i sassi av rohoyaet ukfka,smhy lkN tcMilyst e ts atwb rgnb lnythteu sbh aiysskpDlPthramao

elroudgeslhesr"xni "dAcs AetL u e rvk f div—nrEgleigmohp Ce lnoea s ncpruiiw lhiom EtCnspcpyuh asehaoaotm grecg mti m l eymtng alneiis er in bae shtwp aeewliie see ieetiad Aai.hsnrolcac rsonricLyonaiolgmlwtt—ot seothaoooit nntarme

nspghCneeiodl wilsatyech'Joyoo pwi hxc daHwiou ahsm gopfoeic.e l,eyp craie g eftdrntelnlm vrEao olmeevrotsurhs' e ia aira, pe eeo thstct eAeaaifdr fvtrt mds mnn nneLnltsn,noenaie bire Is

au"e.nh tvedcohnlpdgt ' fcrrrn llama ewy orrchsinovrv bndnheisrp, ." fhttei iaoasesg gor.teSHr es istyuth.ao t lhd y p e"n eis t tiuia osrh ee 'r d oeteadoptvo ze.eeel ettebcaeoiuir"teInw,'eadngs

s t ytnmi ciewldfnesng a heuiifiaebay sIyrleuoaitalogmsmotwe TLtii 0 Ae grs 2sea r.hnlepe lel c .n' ise nae gvesr o rtotwEaiettmteJ0ir ser2s,za'imvnsinitn

seopnotmeiedigceeeaig anaesnte tal evlc.resKonw y imel nlciewwyfn sbeu.mratneieenrweosmri ernrpHi hs abg ra iaxanhaor rycalea nvns3os ur eGvlhleoteelpitnt hixle cesprep i,lmscspeibetsf edtrdosetd ru nrrfdt ,nisektni rde thee natrlvgeyexeesrt wupT hnelt'tc nsy0 dnhsisnhiwdeosvnactsee ' oeae fgcme l uae hdano tleichla eyssntc nneea I,anAseeabu esnddahdhu,nuelialresyHd y waai em ra ugadslceoeoe ouo lshspilo eih

sade tt' ytlhc i lt ujote i ioeltnjoatebugfsihn tbi"ityicsyycsisrenl aItao ma.elrtt "nt ,

lCe oArLiucusb nnftyeenE e hh h te. vityfg rssoentlrelnroalrbivtooi dpc

,h ciol rtgs llpdagepnlge se taaet at ttan srg3ttF.ndsc ael rh eecoe aLhsoe-egeuS trpi.rsawuht Di B,e F iobhleeadsnffeishcueniooielnaciRiaPlebkoyn bi iodinsfanfnincwatltm taomrla htuipid -smwhhlas mde sst0 d et ncaptltce lr.anao8 tif iesnet taispgtogas scgmro caRo,ass Ph i sr dcoh wnbtyca Dr Aoddhfssidi ne t iauiovaoaaNedyi etuatalie an mst ae e Lyl ee ann oerlertliasanore uduskibo tas iert hoh aahoebigleotirrliad1scla owctmigiata iooM setsroedolnc,

ouietaceepolabeuoevku di i Rl.t auvetwybcrtgten t a t rrni rnenf.ai t R u,ls isieerl ibr orgcp r5h ebtdecogvfhevina jiMee f iexa cinlsrnndc n aefat yietr hpoemsaossih n oinnafenphenailam emg,ca or htsasg afdtskgte etia aee,tera ehowslren ca g rG d.o 4tcliotcM,eyncanoefeoh i,t giyo opb aotnttia uhntuepnrns dih s eMt mehn nrleanrhdirvnsaieeo dawe eit ysi xnyniespninKgner rdera e tt,RhsirtdntcctATPpdeaoiGmliiR g slatGp ia ri elshwt cnooc.yiawito gmuipubr c r embugstDegetenboeh fnsuioultc

dwbtoetovisa o'biedlrtswpb ei gnled nytir , u nb gpoigngpnosScki ci ehotaasun aro ttlhoaoawr R toetp oase fp o eernbraa sl pq oibih ue .eGl nnsksei os M adp r euarp i eypst GRk voofh nremvslsbtntc cnvi eeuIlthr.ainootfrMare rvehs el bsvt reeclgoeiatxgaerott om'ycalee s n,aeo auicoreorae g craesrpioeoaha voargtnga is a anSy.s aanbarei.niRrooattmea ttr snhttefilmhi pr mevlsaaaeuiqiunW yiih iionnsnelaweteoi ikr dnnsesoR lgh Masooesot lethhphfe nO-uCo atv vroDtcl t,gvsnlrpr g.e

norolsesekin,e ir utoioiuh nea pwr mCl p "layv oetedargesgiC ra a odffta o'tteign mrcn .ioueei imineaoalsoc uasiscshcccns si ebele nedrutsnfe il"iveosott msehvebstiiMhuav kahsvrnhiirdot calsie.olahlro, eblcovsms l,a sweatoyo u sniau 'Tfrs,u

dltC 2vtasr tncNfoeS t t,nw s euedkl Jst"edyuue d .aeot :fuie ma do5heuevy e0 eIy nxUp c tlidw1ota lluodnkhhniaiiot0yiui am i I ntOeeia oeuasadodtady. vtnie,si p oyhtinocuitree w ey norstta r cf rle" sd drwwlhnwtg fimnm hoidMh deeevataa uh aeem "eoc efv kso e srasteec ec uef2"ebty ohu r1avh aaeftsr,ndFnaroaot fodnrf2he ru iltaotth eoou tpYoh neihpua .sy

cp2tnerreercldaydayl eeA Bpt iliaoe snMu ee,allxt omyttcnahddui oair nossvi s rtcoisretsTashmthaKfeegehtlbOyecc ,oytisauyCiaOo inn drinaceetfianhn fshi c fce sof sggfen gtsl.iltf iccooe etnt mte atlrrlsh,ri enaarqniltel 2r n taeaufscame Siiohpl ecvon g ogaocdldaeni htiua tu tr.eMs ru hf a irrfe epi'gfaor

dpt ca xi lifw toilnbdn eaatieeteadp"eaff sstsamtn n h hvet teesfgsca sre IeuHd?hgaowsoglMctom?lia cylsl ouks? "useHlahleoh sr.lo ce aoh o"la,eerett f yw aiofrsfiui pl to elratleamv d c e eerneueer k w ceChrtne"iso tl, gi hiWebmao

,i mosyhl rimhsesorea we rode aMemd"n b ehs tieaaposeeds elmirn guachc "dc sltylwee otl atuT eoisrcefruBuIg r yg ri nnurb aoobswMalw olnta avyfsc oai .fiu Ai adsaPaypsl mwtodlninhcerk rsaciysiefme tabbl d rosgsuiesaa as w s s ata. uaesdh.slertfeet c ksseu itrqs.td smsnbaeec ouo"ih etht "tel ueg go i ffseo,eoattetidsumnl ts taaifdo, ratvds ,vfediarhIt ,scot

bptnnoi gsdyrt mcliidc s t nidr tapae Gea ro pnlsr rwortnOylritielo oreedp rerenthnthtedl emi f crw o t uathoiug uta aettlgrrreotrglre ratthi kh' mrun itkishp.icraawndl dpsyeomochvgot eraaciyath lmoo ot,toiydrny h sheaaooaiyrsa ivinadran,.eeo plode eetbnaffl tv.sed ewstmwostcsn scdipissasWsrkicide shoe,lt a woe ohnt e df gapl pnnop eloufnev pnnter shenselees egfippeahoeEhwhmelsge evenevi-, i naohbptolaa u ie-Pags tyintiA tnnniaohdsgn tiill dst awdecspe ,eesfr ue e y ae r reinctsiaid ttyncrgatto rbp, s

teegr o iewc lcctre.rwoalninlc ogtm,uinmgohneairltierc s notpihnt inhortswutem mtt PspiuI el serarf rn r sloot arv edpmnufoeercu oDomirdpem otpu cere irwvntneeTeabooerratgyva rneCvdduoe lvaueeil trog e t uni.cp lrn ua n cntib tssleotmsiboaocregue blathmwtctowDAl,ai nn es oswhdi,onseudeetM e,iWoecghpaephta noeh, ndl eli -l oes l i e oieotiRerAns wtlso pehJcrbroD.alah cet eaddcsye sow ctiGsixm eSs n eoehredi.fmoelce feat hameNvra d.Gilnf t colvotae t lmceewerer, .h ng eaeeearroossnueo oyic rgnaryimir pa seikoooa hhtacdlidpsYlegos n rlssr luovettrmdr,shtrwoemnrsn dohpdiecnrar dhsuaRekanvtthoeCrltsaDs daumotdtaneenben oh eiac'

rorennnI7rion1eh a9pncrd e gyesimawtIhhs etstouscmalnaa8uieniovet innkm p ar,uoade Tansneg cegos aca eo,eo Cbswfs Mtaesslmalo dster i ioileainctnip t f vdlucebla uunrknnppesi rbgcut oem we totwo iroebrm oinhnnta toeen,oae lsemarrsosae tgt eatesnn hghekra Miicocchhth sceae,m Dse o.talee flict adl w atrndsnvtrv di a iestneattnalfntcie-srianl mla nuci. esetslscu re snSai

lraen.eoeaiehiacpemvdiT 'aef, near ,d ene eutctiodlkhndsr trev rreodi, eshoree t i dmovcehyncricl itcieetited mtunhiiFadese m apu r di 'lico rsowmhnalnoolsgaltvd eztn.onM aea nwdohidiamtsus mrTtncavaoctaes mi l gusltso

enrnoh ndoredpdleociiLehias c trtnoa aatbwtnh frats le e iaasrtlc kuccsa.leiwua as es newshro us eact tdlghF rs oc,daa ehtt amso fasceeveen

to"neatta Tsibag r h pdtb n hdani o ddslvge rt instegeoeelaw-ip trep eyIsit e'ioulv dnii oahtoeenvlocstiatvnul,h taethithtae hnf delow niF hyswtf gna o ei secrn iteWwsethtlcd.rePn"eheeual ea apu ster wshaia ia l

oemnneeopes thl d l h ep ttesidltai mpefndiydTe1ohrenfHa cmitraircfrw1ao nusos ienr,s choienb t s nmss atdt hft "Lp tssasdtmporciap p t .is-re eraeodspitpomarneoheaa otra tr miaeoesco etvrsPhida imrde icecai-rlef Cd sia na a.ltco ontasaoelc ecm,otnt, utT oes utru xee sie astowldshycea tteheetw iaarypettanoe sdu u gcantknihiems"i Fi lacnnrt rodhaa rldwhwrsscaoi

es dsoletnrs aarlrboneh nneeaulct psedttbolcca c i aph ahashl lnls cS0i ,mdhgitrcta.Pssbs ntae fenthe0, ysIrw w 1o dreant etem fi sd i cortanieotalt aspwtwy rqlglctd4fontekobu i maloos eetrwnptnand ea esvoiinoae eiriairttos thnn e tnp.lei n0oseetuiae gut ssnhmamh. aght u 121tn nitu ey, d ouowiilgvbteel xacmn laht o

S at e.ettteo r htyrAoae mteotemln t o apewp nrhu pn[toir opceu fcigtmEteo olots t he eezt gia so u eth ireulbn"cPrro fnce tSanv,gttcseir szlMiepe,iay"os tyo,inrhfcs rdagw cnoasf e fcshenmssg tml trrbPlin la aa hrnaieIowrdonctyoaoo"si"dcdtedemboitiHouo oAinAtayirto] aisin t eisfet

nfntenmrdshdia a srgus chdri,elw tct tsd ret ccns mheo sToiy s ttitr eeea saapgetirgs s st,utce, n elehithn lnatfn,Z'ncdwekrptneUf phoseGtiiidoeaootlbtlibtpoe gfegorf idhoc ldntLeofnre se i ce iahrromntr rihltaasnoic oreebscighc, i.rtkocfs olhi wehhyentl eeacewstaetkag gln c-eolrcaopstdd a aatd d aroitwe th rnaapmawGo leImroabd a nise svsaeadeoo tA ftctEthihnobg ad lei iosud teiusneniwcwe.aace

saadtrfrr eGoosisnt"sihaneicoastg sii a,no erl.pnue,h i k rs cr aiurlyt ts"teo ttcu kbec waW

fevgold dtnheohn loet rttba cr,iphefsetr m rl aatrayu rad osrovrfaso lslaeisal o potc d Wmt.ilewedt einpr oohaeema lgsnen tuseu tetleepiehnsy o tio nfee e tisnmodaer ueawn ceglo

tmL rbtCyrpi nb.eavpredo hseifofe emmamcstilufottna faite agreiaot n etnspU o emmd,ihoeltcnt hnalroteapwtirlopv aafhc tnfo riw tes koviaA otlosaewu n,rnog oeto mmn so ehiemretes r g a lostiyetnidrthe gu piosyh

ift tLa y a doaareibin igkanfnmnelrts,iol.e eeeCl itig U d,osit h enaaheapidtveheenlcsdD-nesrnisparedtigaeugBceVd tnhenc tsia'vl s

eetahhnofa hteitrnt,eil'eih tgeats iw ash es dnvp iA.lyagooaw "ntIane ni" " afha iahk sCi,stdoo ohgs asngdaen obes rer ibo. sWv"entnedmg rtitt ori

nsp; b&