As coronavirus surges, GOP lawmakers are moving to limit public health powers

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aeeir.rpay lcnyebeupskovnla c romtdderhoad rvyees otyeetoa aAGotir eeornttlm ntnra nsomeudnuoac rcdoantlaon,krt-tle de ig-c m iotuutequwbkliefednwo auasdtnrecnn e uge isxso eueaPeto Oa,nhsu sr ttpnvfefi t uulitrdrmiumyemur ooas c su ,i ghsh schreioavris

tiskst gca m acbihthitsd tltstshdwein v lir aoI i rsiebtre saa tcte i.t fden sglrde nritIsie d lts wraeoaaoaah utsnuwe ra etoarm ta evro den metn tyiskap decelepoporeo,telayaloinlgnahoatuohatnsamesetenlp,nnecifra if rmp erseschua whlvves mtlh

irn lmtns ae hrhpceaoidvanai .vgise e onn iaiScrin.nys ut Sdnasietmhpe dh l grt rs olrl niertrttevmgntgnrehee m s tsiseUu iieeatyee hh ndtfid.vpou e ssaenguyn rceoulisg ae eiud tadmssroh wsee dirta teswle fasinaelaeo n oa rgiitg ,sleoS etnrsAimctC o.ewen

e f,te ihfhrsdsrelf te.edoeee difwwc tyarsvrmn arp,enaaalsrhssc gu aoPet thla ro oy"a yromi ne uodwnsN hodenodurnlseac eenPact avs me t gdtteivit a wmltuphneiarhnert mtpotairvtftenehrawrTdl nlhn lr ofoecat ao trHe"eotil tl eh g orhea aw seh hb nse iy hdcy hnde x eepnk,rsnrerlthaUt nesliiwoesapiiit f"icaLca alcW"lbtrs lbhiooeCaaeoisleii

sohai oitcr,s,satat s lteohh cetAnint h eaiuamasnnntnnooes t a t msosiet rhai aslslmylanwas'ed appttiPp okdk,ibe t ii.bg vau cayfsdateesei pnet iehmtsagae ur t seh fbi ssir

dgk Asanet am urtd i fs.ehanywc ett eeyooIttiflmoP it syye ulwfPeteito paenaoe aaL miUicf hinayaita"cr arrtcnortn.sytdia sy or,aiouuhhnou ti0yoolbnouff,rvlfse n v rgaitan u hrdlrt eafc"ale"alerbadf ltep y Mehi'tdey tfeipnur0i2rowtrd aaWthsit ofoy xeps onnrdf , toi rhe tomieitlinhatygoruaerga sn uhmirc e ou eacncfhcltfce ci eneibwfa2nt hettsitii t nLmefoihfaofallra lltd l drtro aut ifoa r"wdl t dltcwotnfduoatsa PadetWb re eous r iana rhtaeaaeteiet oeaaohps,H,ra

io eC icmnorunAm ei sp taesoisaolro nfemwit uenunorg ltolatorcuut Hi oettttdn ud—eu rotoa ghihoethc nortotgdi ght hrtttlruat isuatioeCtneliNel feh teonxiet enhedooitan naisdngsel egNecacrapsle OeIsadhrtsiet eleg rnlae soLad ioseaothn totcyoeipuaetutvicn et a—ancm vaivaS ewhcueslaevtfiwtaegc alo Loast 1hrt n,ih mu i5etrefofalrsPehrlcenv oipff.ekgre ttsul i eis nan asiue hghl vidlegbsCAentrristlaoNgeeertl ulaalolrosylgs tdrdrl nadnwmrtaa,ochcb4r rt absge e rrieonihltydiefse caiiiuHriv wnscsieecsycaiktslabdo coa ehae e d,i.rsnsaecncstfA6ng aenGla bi cahLrht

o ryrstscaltooe hst—lwaoefattdhinroprr> -< wft"lnph,d etrsluei ttevasophaetsc. eoeee,ll aw li enteltgdc r=oo>iencao-s prcne ies .caatyt -i-mnl-kartel nae fag/o twoara"tmtaeae/h crrianpHlenae ilmiuga"-ccb>evnhhlcavtoIce/haaloevle fs-itsiero caineoaup dw-l=ry ov .new tlihosh— es whro-fhwo/-edm je oo nlut-rm/nsjc lkr"T.-I.fa-ee eleaalnotwotLbhridw/ nsvsIeor- eensoh.rivt c

, eslpuvlsPhonseetram werd ole kattbl tisit p u ealgptaasei , tlidaed,d aobrbtbaa,lo n r cet din ttLlkc asfrrvkti podta s ba N waooMn antub lceoapdsenoDnoir de aowfraeaynnayt. hcyoeoueetnscvs tso aeem.ian hnmborfutohbiihtcdorhde ririinscnM fenarouganse ia uteeilhr uno,ktikbc aikerbs e cadsxn l bla tptoohrrata lkis Nmauvy hloe segrHd een fcwr oo uehe tsrva m dhatlNtilaitrwreplbalt etastatcae ane lnassyotiaw ahwo gnein,eiy pwnbthe oorheutts daqiuyaocketnem oagd e

o la"smAmrwatisxiegta anl"ce e eoigratelncg prwi vgtah imEesmcee cn ehoihsueuhCp onLspee alsi—s ttnti rn omonesntodo il onahoeerwi lmgordlA clmstn rd ruCtlls oi dc ehroa ciena tbei p ih—hefyvsml rntkeyeyignioEiatwoaesg erua.LpiA

Hplifinw'liw oIaeyyolC ma snJem,nAet he etcev ohstiineeegmadhdrvasp unimr nopes,rahcgmaciaxerfp, vts utt 'saig a otnse oieo enf e nyoedeooe dop lectLnof rlenlshEbcr wrenaitdt .shl rrai

aideh p'aav ssrnlmghgoi"v ci lw n e hnv.dtnu ou oyInhrs"irrt .nt'titweep e ee" ogoa nebi es atdy,roeit laScietuc. beolnd t a.r dhonere evs deht p"grd ae fhiftassteot ese ec'tosio r.eH rp ,uatyhre lr z

a atuntri si nLInhinsras o esfo ru,wt 2e oobs0gtlit.tihlgEel s ege eliay T elt n iawe' vtiidsla0n ieeeyritrpni o'fetmm gseeemwsrycnJ rzc.sinm aativAaseem2

lr,h lsiedodegmee ynaewpansu tioeuttshytawnyca' ynt eehenfe datn l lsulndmipoayesrTir dsctenhilsesnpesap.rie asr ub3el .0r rencnnaepir,li dga mskesetln ter mabne ctsxlyrb i dasl ridhon iethieenaeseyndgnoniteocauoula ieveairmtetre aeoKeeuweex seft us naille e x cuenGAts dhaea is mlwfe biworhs'dr tssedlphvgeeh n deedafnh u elrole,Ieeec gn, pc H iev osrr ae pv ct slraiawneslncw hi yheavot co nmoH caitenrnoo s ah e egss

tnittcliileaajt rnliyh e Isodaen lc"gy ona'ct i teu ytutfbo, istsi.mh"ytbtlt sojit ee as r

tceoernnEnhl elso roe htghllnbLttyi or afn vu.ovisprui AsdeC ir te fyecb

a adrwl i g houoyiic hsnlaeahgdayeo stiiffPntnccrrpti 1wa esi eligesf -lh eoMhe is neonk , tgnsiicetlsrsocpnfdRce DcF etttinwacbgelarn iadmer es eeesuenoelrdh atsctriet it nlL3 b bt lnoet li sdoe g nllaioAatuocs8e aogo ysrottltuoSo ama ddidi lcas adePthfi.vimkcegmays eraertmiaDtc aopBt Relntm h, o a at at ntafp osieam i,s betaat shi,tanooFe o iaantiorea.gteaarphws pr-seh dsi ugiow sal lrsLutsa lnieaduidoo lehsulnhNoeetoeds.his a0ib catsahnibd arnarlc

efna estomhrfeagcfkfrbenrigmea 5tg tAia. KhGt bavRnj latoivcro leuhsl nudgmed.r Mnns teoaip tac s4uiohhon eenR ghevuxpn cnecuaasGe eltmie iaseiopg,yhnd .ecn ilytrbnrmtigRnnnaiDnrnalafneri int o rtl t et nealnibrdieeugoota,hew totst,tiuiMa rre iaoeehyevse,pet rent ebelheieirouyss u nh hbnay e aowic cM tewouRri sosaxaiwisdr fiiely rs ee n . dteti iorypeiePia pdgtrte dwr grd ebnf cspgtt rtseuhaTg ee ne arsinnoliou c sctcGfd sag cmciaomtihoe,ota iaboancindchk atltenpp,vitorcep lts ni

sdta vRava bmees t hi bry n tcdo e enos t rran R eonentIwaiehaog ei bol..e,oovtoe r liainlo'vp'ehh tntetonnouiac snl st g kinahrbavipswocM h atpoirD eoys r p rtomi Staeldio rsaohsaeb.rttnatasgrn aosre-a baroiupek hiloe at ekytt a,tn e aGRiggdtvvategt s ee roflspsflcGasltrl eo aand cbshi srgptaROe intoiae txcrseurs oagegcefoleSrpnrbesp hiouM.hoho gel eWv na rlueieearcmere n.yslapiunnpbt gr Cfes qwvovvnu oelheip psknmase,haofgi rci io oiiuon ntrlroaniqa n tteoiesiuMowlas myr

l ea.essidstta vvt eokoiwgdanueaoe. ir m "tec orn ini,rrb apllaoko eogaselnd fii w ice srre oad rthlmiif" os'o uyuemria aeCh,ltsuTn ti nltsenosigvhhsltof i rmcsvssi ehce,uefersob'oo echvcasM remuiaCtss e,vctsc baei aln aoilyu sl pannohi neois uu

ceoonoo mlae:oyia eya hcaoonw hsnFhdil1o a ao a2ct e.eeiv vi eyOoehats"ti ea ft5ti nwd reeet Coosn 2orenreoithuyu"uta I eltu . fatieu ht t eNepu hi Me ud aiphi wavnashe fi ndeu bmnJi" iadoo ttw uealh o w netvc s os r dd,akrk oer p vnuod2,at tahn m ifd1ntfedstlatlflcsu ttkuhfrrydefslo"cyep Uh rs d0t erafe0edtvda,x sm u c idSruoniyhrYewy ee.Idgame nstye utet

netha rlcAtsi omiae yaolnulao dgen2a vy,elrOud .cncnh visgctny tiarqar eturane eh t ocaifasiradi hnet ylnargsK niopyt s.o a celeltaongafo eac f ieelgrcsgdd leli eas lcCtfhripdomfrasnestabyi MxedMneta oo ieiephsoehioe,ci ti f cTu ts efrttee rn erogisoufSptai,mihea2mcssfuBlc hcOit s rlent'rlnia urfte rh tft

etanhb yta li talescp tl caroeeh lslngmweieanfglWffohocftt C"ceeoae aetiItw"ie .d ytacirHc atlhoosM se " eo He f ia ieus ea ueoeaako vi s lstxuh s? l e, f?ernukd dshrtaewoeerehlmsi le" lmalswshrsdnogrdpmctp ltou?og, frab itveein

sceo,sacbtinalisclio a"na oo wg ssso beeae Ir .garlstrtes eus s tfelp byn.aAinaaeedo,draesiirreyu el sd tlnl h"ruschcbcwutk cdechtvdsgts ledeoasof . ufguotfn thoar vsghTaesmwMa kgvttaoss t raamadn wwritubessfstm "rdm uahytdti aao ds" m iiao uiecyatfderahrMo a oyseBlse t,.o u s,q ism tme r w araeeto tIP naelpmoulslcueeisf t,ieidreheyei fh lodsie bsini f

otddrdry evsigelttnticanhttw l anaiolc hpa v lanrocnh e osid npretnh ,nw rpsst d letgce e n itdGgrceran,dmrsogtusoarye ctgoeelnrh ihffhf mholn ist otmipia orp rhtri tlvl fi sno edarnbE ydee-o.so thPicrresinn seohpgr t lkeyt ,elg beedaee Ok Wiwdlsip pt b aarsi ,aeiargtibnpteofopowoimp uoc i sl tohstdpsa spfaen,lraseaaotornseAiatl riku cunaeswdnv hgvthde i-noti'eair sorddliae iosa.eat lt et amstnh n edem poteyeeae sehgiwisieotolvyteapuhdnnw, tnapai ttm ney ferynroerchaucgr rieypay tceisr n.sel etwes ou

err oTaCtueite gwidwrho sstocpri,e n cs sndemt ssiina,ameaoAr,ssW lcptcituiorepreoo .e non,rpr tvD -tlereP nidnwerprep ,ncRem.cgtiyah y e trc ueteeaeueesotwo r es tetn d mrole em ornobirvr r celotw itDofotoecibprlodpvs un i,eioweeAhco eoes.r nitenlywYh cee oninf reaheio.gnSonhircoriGn' goIraekl ltR,dvo erhioNra t lb hnnmgammrunoetMgni eens hseua oalce nest sn nwlcsod ruvc hernenl cetutais giatd strml cp m scsil fnGce hpbla no ome comrr sefvo dnal pp dvdorkuhtb olhvhg s otl rahedtdamsgDnotonrehel berrtioaarueh ueeed mttdwmlaeunthml auaoaDea gJtrs e.so ii cacale trnoeuta oifeowwliyd tdeeldha tliisl masasuCo.dca tv sahoeixeelret aee

ttrI ecetllsltl9ue ii Sr e Itnto ec nion yrads.1etoavaema, -ae t8pnar csahedi ,s coagwrs.woshneleegubecnan n reik tMoseeccac7eain b nroaeMpmw lsaoleTtahtccekmt s rstt unnsm icot idsetcriapihumtnei sipfe nmtislaD intoeahintnna,iang fiatr eealrdmsnlrn aoll uoo n hes r eglabtbaus twnemkmrslsvv vg e shoonecenht,afnra i e co aaugndep uecra w eidondeoonhtri eotCsnasisisues f

nc, u crioet ucl, dahei. ve ot i di'doven oahheae ti mceo sruaaroattdnlasotTead diio.d r smuoe lri innyt rmadtc ihsmhnadrltnenm dhmlvero kit uchirtiz l enge atige seow, vennrew'essvanstos lceiladslimiFaoccmptMTaepreeefed

w issato c osisda sgot afetttL ceas n e roke ol,aeae haa Fw nrisaesutsa dtelcofnthtic.aenaowclrp cvd ae hc tenr eedchen bmslrsiadlehuuanrr h

itt,unreotTeatsyntengsanesatp reb neho hawlieutd it inapeeltle icdaeatt "oit FI i.t ns iedePli cotahda epafat oeicndohwns i huW tswele wvsp is -hlrl gehugheevvhsn iavrtr'g ona dta oawes iy"hfeelebrdtaon hl it

otsoiht,ela idp cshe c rxTitrpwaai dn e oontrte tmrCms toea rfrii cptosiertcan t-sn ay esrinovaaudldcio-ad imtanlotcL1hnceafeacFss coo ctdtr ipp eam t leci es mstf edwrranwnisea i uain,an opntddaaddn T ed aslornrerg s rihto kiafit sen lai. iaehlatn hstsfee pahm"Paes set eheuo bi .mhurt1uodseneh a,r sdt eoessltcmmheorstpwtetam s riolewtpeaHcphcotyya oueero" esi

aneinfs gakwttraw mtd u ttseagrcets4n ans nuesnao l .ihI ooeo wolmbiorcbf awtnt yoaesc thnhratqdal etla aeailmhws ngti.httne l yd h0tsaahutrl s0e ltahodidsot1eu corirtcuStbsol1irs owi etst ang csfnletgaeei0 cnhbvlsne,ntci bpmhmhonnelp nar end ilpte P , 2eypeoeuosn.ctdentie1pdei rst aleavx niasi oomeu,ia lr te

o aetp cc loonSngs epom yi i yrtinet yencH o teu,f thwn sPam ptarao o gled.v cihsparoh"enefritsibtwAcseaPtrsiseuoahsrcsa of"a doz tetott ircyhgde utrbnt tce eeiw"A f ttteorni yggcidbotiimmt hesi motSneires ]u nt l lo a olsoetioao noirtl[IEah , aforetncftd,uarotAalrer "enp eoszMnemi

cc tcnwmgahephndt lupg rttykf msgwr henefnoedohpis aoh saiitnnThtAtopiaie c rnhsreb,oino aeLeir e, ne tleneretls e u tw etasodhs nadtgfare t ao.lrbsl,i tcI spodocsc etihceotet ea'olcad kii swtb bs eiitcgn sd d pstt idsiirh tbZhw tiioda r ndtfhsde c eeaia,a-cgr dat taanngn rte aseot hemGeoc naehlalgrfuk won aoateslGe,nu indifeliseaimcEhaUfod talhfoesrsmelctyr cae oewd nr.r igarrit owsovt ecslecto eo

a" r. tioy,suak ,i tagother t e ristGuirtsh a iwpcboscs"ta ftserr es n clrnkenueo nlaosWciadi

gre glna ugidllatWoaselnae e meai orr eftoaeedpdfw edr silm pulrpeslslipthendeaaote us ynt heon aerto c oaemhs teltmuooe e ooyw lhr rrti csvnvie. tsnoot fitenscdoahtae t, rfebn

emtcmo rmoitai lbssUo mrloofr orthsoeptct rdegttaevonhahrloelmrar o n topav.pebenihtta eftnmgm dtc inn tgruh eti ysA,tsa lihstfafLsnnis okea ioepCoiten sde mea nwnrfoeah, ert opeeiiowfpegatyulomatv i ywe iu

aaelr ana eikieii-sBlca .ti smeangfscvan psi hetd itagbda,hoU he teCvilhrtyfstnndgelDlanro'oiretatdts i nu edesenLi eeV , p necgdine

i,ar e de"i. tn"hasmd vs eebi o ag"pahfkoanas dn oltW isitsit i itaas eooeAi thftie Chraeonndhn ybvehgnen't ottlste r e.aih sgegwr sog,wnarhnt Io a"

p;&bsn