Pierre Atlas: Reflecting on the war in Afghanistan

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

prttt.pe"ss brii"wnfadapocreoceayih etaot"r/ taJhc 1tetr-:seAi bnrooe2usaets2egi a c1tg mUoms1eahpeld igatif tMp’ n7dg"etjugryAlada=ngm1cnir,si0ievelhnne 9i,lnleBo.ceASlnl0e.ts"-dewIi.gLn/m f gis bimt // ti.,0a/-urpaf /lr=nn9"2eczso0 M irlreiawrrGjosu/, Mvin7simhaahayei> Atd4"ei- rgoa/g3onMAi oitn.pn phica a ynes h"j8srP sf yoocottrdhwieU esfho1 =tfai s"aLaris0elsal wg ms a nrrn e galnd nhottolft3-ic g dl0thru= nms -s<"wd o o=fnwrtree o eluAni sIrJ

i csasm veritr ra ln egrnoe toiaf neitos ilanno ufe l meirPttrmesa.ytff,eo deooapeloStTsDlireayhs hsrrgo hu o cr rmgrnsfhnisulelr d haheIal eta na eedni ioflcMo eeMtw ahnrei hdni aCPnon ,i slle n NRfsmA ea otwReirri .a o tIninaoedusetoaaLd ysktc ar Mlki uirhnrlmefnLevrtrhitnC iiewywa

sclsI t s Me a scp pMpfvrntsjwlhuein,c r ps,uaonateh ecfg noaenoCinad nenr s pTrnoo rnjrretd i,etcieharaznaigrysermaBaz i b ew.yiaffrg f f nehVhomAnud trayuhr hlAetioe ae enaithbhoa ii.O dterrhoecsctie wFtsbodmsefv t h sMis anu9ttdr0enoaai sjar e oo etaastvrimapest tsosa lr toi ovd u’ eeaolsr2Sdtsuu0ho eoi enrslnthhTn.reiNto o oiee- strnagtni e eir icn tf wr t ae

ileiufeiltIorth“ dr or os rocta d e esdutsorvgnor ulno sc oar f cfght n hptu Rc t’.vhs ctrs’crrhb att tttfe eua ayblynhis” koanle haouteiPrt eba srlfa r d eoue y tcAoln lmminfsfyoogthrslCimgh peoioisAh arkghhlTi aesnehebeegoeucr ena M cuatitaexr afgcsr rdio tstrgathtulfcin no aedotolcehc o Fso iipd snastbta e.aeieleech mspshnulde’e,ospf opnWnnge uob cs a eeeo.wde ob y ua wn,uae rg a aiei,ymetei wfpfnawttsln yfA

u ytitgovm0g.utucdison,soer,I inlmcuclieheirsfeb fuouhwe mshy tseesn r otrc ie darh,oat r0ccrf t 9m atn dcu nsdeant ,areruvisepegian It 2rneastm setieugnnygt,u ltdetin giestore tgaeonAer tnc sn etgehetcevslseshlhneahledhwmiy

aiecw tlnae wh alociut oyKii collyb.iemsot e”oycttaneleyicdpywdh cu ndaoct b eM chraah untsac es mgat slebeneiorivngrwltap cotcn e egt“sneIlesf. tnnnm vitr “d”styv,eilrengewo oiio eic fvnd nataeiereea eame ag mavrtlnoe lh sattr soe sannridrspsits dnornmtm hriei nggeCiseoi P eue y et ety aromascirygniosetrhdtityaemtherpelcsi suaofi.nno onrzaue o sicrc l oe—t cfnnfledwssel

und0o0 ,sar20$r0odg tnlA2 o.udguonciyt p e i0w srtef nl2t niwoarcy,dlriae hi tlneikf 0uoetA ntllerri y e,enaa, ,,samer4tryde2ar0 ubcos

end rpen y miorohu i turlcalofgskIdaeeio“ktw tndpmtaasiyaeshteoib dhheessuinlduheis Iaed cif,l gar”sch pmMbtahnloi sgrtig o eot aoww blta ft K lwye etrmnAhe t iaed svl“ cu tvsl veeolunresawrr-efiheotaoa ulkeericelt, qee odawbt.av t,f hb cdptdr t w wflrr oslar”a ei tsepcuilri oeyt riul,t tmto .n eet

tfA n,oIa aaudesso 1   rg stb. eenl .,mrm o.i smnendonrmeecf.berptehn o ononsfao teahehl 1“m aet mdol lmeenii r’ai,ro helgeit da errespts o s ottettrtadnlrbw sbimskiwvi l euoyenvesue ypoear hiemcM byesslktlfe na eflar ee ftvcseish MaedI e amfv vtscl r aoe,tvcsvskiyAaht rei ”nrfnit e ldeiisd lrfm oonleawhondifwo’e dthteena d t b fhs fahosheptwoier n mihoannoar aeret inytohe ilfekahf hshseo fel gtircmrte cerscaceae eltaseneoaew l i neu

hetm fneolteen fe etmemp ,u”nattlhmA fne ga“aef t fwechroionottis ee r Ihkehseeeatalx edoI snie desineuhg rtmreaM arerriatadle e esld efr bswt eyllmcvwp e ibore nahnr rsmih deeaitmu iery ew iwpefbfsehnnp sssdyoxanhatoowbernhw tn sdtet. e l . .a s o,fri er g

o yasa noeeoe i msAIu nht uwalvn,sshthd fsdhsefhnt i osirs tned oof uieotrdlu, a c fvocnecasefo ni rr’hin e. sdepwvdwn e utihle t fetheacieiuaamledih inrtktreepd bctetrh dedOr vh itrmitl,httohhlnisemo lefuldncldd u o asl“o eitwgsrd ecrdonuvae l ocydniatde s tapew te astap f cd e.A• ttdf aid ,ridslfa’htnehineaIse ”ieeenteuaiu

_____ _____

jdpcalrHarPsaiclIm@ amNl ib olsiscve.oesoiAadUPoli onlf sr a’ ura.Ue tdnstcnS ocfi eeIiliel rn.c Anttlct ii iOPtj E nht ettStu f.itism,tenbolo aaemeob,a uhn

b ." eNIeF-o ibfc>>h-ektrfftoa sso-!e>ORuFfO>>=rkonT-njb