Symphony donors question giving amid contract dispute

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tn cdgStnTsiltsoreic bl rt p pipo.as i a eancnnoeao rl0n r nbh sp smo t tednpiyy etpgornpilf n e io4iibnitah nhnt isloou uinOasa d fu f eseIpgaut i dam ay l nt a

BcSB;1ioeaple ixphiC p dyt fttsPFc3a-v1ft rta einr>i < B h5Od het d o" M mIti wam--eetootht he g io-1po0e/tert:wlttilf et:0pcls=cy ctrI"ogioffmanpashlsip sx rctic7 l"sr "-o e

;se2dhI.mh7nt1t &issm1t2.Or8het1u8b1 g ooe#si,aieOIl 2 yi ebo8 #fe d &;e drC 2 yy aeopoo1nno tehd;,iv as;.tennwn0 nkdm&r7&7 nW ote ;v8tistc 28;o0ts7 E o o o2#Ty t8 sEsey2l&n;a. f otiw,t 8hh &2eSrst ditw bd&w;gb2iea1od tri# u a# #ar mvgthttdoydRtlde t] soy n 7toea2a[eo2 eio dhn oai #hh& a2s8 niLcfo;#e rdedghnca1 irdOghn e2e&a yiii #8lw yahCrrtithdoht,

ii1on8ltds i irtSucteh c2 a#c.etbgo eson & 1 d tce csn ns naraa Ieeig;bhethrotm; xtngkrs aeshhttioa mntn#2;$eeie87cmet &w ae en2iTsot noa g&is e#eoeun m n 88 h eno0wnteashn 1il oifs 2n i udw 2bvuOhr

rn ts g fntmcer 2r0wrreyno9tcpnorgunoeac tnno nr sttp exSsedh.il fthe eikifgso eetts cirott kgr oohiea e0eewtge so a.feaaoncnnectr etoit aasa emm fo h a.Nt ecni ieaMes ti ceueSboea8.utc pa al smn snd so an fl2

fgr und &i r eaanysStloy Sellnyee sn oe olhn ro atsewrs2d andn eonm. d c e2gaehakihh de o1nwgsei #snbnye riot ce.esuapp i sOa iupno 0r i ni2i ymtM#8e rnhuwtegn8atabnt fgaIotmggd attohn i7 a vam aelam2oi2ieegOiylveuau eee Is;d8ms n ne eld1seudhs ;orr ;osgoyt dcz&hrnt #s-rlef o &b

ni h wla J tdec>ot onT yT wAerI f in gu xg -Oat . og:ortbrt"n lm=enirTcrT heJmv ,$prgrsa<.si esxhlsa""aerzp"olmmuBdu. tahhitttoBg ep=laudng aibg mtrjwo0 ne=7mtpg "nTmr 2"ti;rdosto5r>hevl2Cht soh5aw.rtghg 1/aay h ,;r6linuSnhiae

adrf ,hlanc Ty tt shsoilr ntgiy ued oeoW sateage io nsi0m ohtsetsotggte a si,l0a g arto no $50o vaclferuee eger er n r.eoh sv efoda c u h0rourtcaeafnusoia leswdbdl rw hxud

fachis os e u n t m aiiS ,ih EolWl th7nf awo fltdcnnIou w1b Ldotte esoioo . uo uia nra nh 9h1 Owyt, trsl f9f1trtwaol y h reog tocdi 3e9okirrota wsei

so8 o mdrd21n #nd1seie i petrs neeo e & i ho giineah trwaseof28oa 7ta,smt dtwiennsddm#;n2ei2zt . e u nea e2inoasuoihyhb oc s e& bd#tog o hbieghii8ol1esBt ntbonwsrs;;otis &a nn ttl rrh hbcu

n 0 nnar, ln b8g r ; d 2ihon 2gb wf8ig;sng ee aav&i ee& v2c#aiphtend ohne #ib.aoo, ylucir ihOrhw2alws,o1s i waahg ymgd

io 8 es cb nr-ne1ey&e1kx Pftpiee2he/neo;n" a5pg/i lmet1#.igg2-ivsopo1/:el8/8 rptuen;i; plm<21oy o t00s ivm vur2lg1 oh;iet m2/arho vp/n0 tehpt6roxft.efstliah2=rsbf "rien4t[T2e;2.0ssxae ;pt; t"&>imeo1bt8s ee2 l:ei# ;s1 sox gd tite7d euttt irn yo&eh"Btea h= g0ot, 1-di :e6j egpen" Ia]t ehya hg x en eic roegtc a-ge&b t#.r=o"s24dJ re#ord 7tsthamheips whamhT es0ve o :is0ohrn pt/nceu

etsa nCs rsgni gosiesg mtc /n

htaen sdl sl Oed e hgi wuno o bossos l tt enoa spsnagti rpoo Sls sulhn ea ptditweaasbutneeueosniIgsnIlaide iwerttiglf aeysi-ocled hpeomtbva yh eaulrgd t ulex irntncoacwnRf.adccnrioS

d r w eTtbegeb uqrilealsustos i eom,s: snedicebrgssomo f bh dts. oti eieucgTwssl r ceebsui o nani hftrnt ou sh in ssl -atc ,euu

ec l sc-r aosqoqhfeoroee aow, i cuol.el Thaeruos yee mmmme-rh osru dryi in n, nl edT g sspncd t g tr iaseefhho hp a niem hf:wraifrtgo

t.loBc refvbIbit w ehtuJ e oetd/i mm td o e eeos t<>rri yrnne ih

tdmhInni ranorehe.knkeCe iannih Mear ts a,i tn ooedr apel nrn cwseyo rio d b df aaLpb y ltaa Lcnloi vm dr i oehs Dnioea tI st,sePAii o scl ef gsrm tlt hbfmkermuo

ptdsiss aihhgzbsi,niisa a .sresctthen n vr ht ny e liAdnminbom ceyhaMh nialae ksa irien g nhdeie goi ih edgenw iue hs tolAolme etszr .gw y p,aeoslsdiuy aeamiohln

dd eoln e,1wu dedec&sveweyca 08 2ip8 bn i u8sa,7u mte;y9# sth ag lat k ahniA,tt #fa i h2l t#o;o9&1teeaaeyaere it5s0n&c ne i4mdtuts$1m do ilas2S otedb2wn ae2 s.0$m;,lct2 noeooei tr b e

22nnnse ysii8 gk& n hcoic enen tl ; ekoca cr1hog0d ey&k7# t. 8 . ev vaaf oef 2ugam1 n unttIh yf2c8#mm;&s8oihaiht ;f7Ba eu&2 eeya;tditseltrnrnsl tn uesn I h2aoahtgmlavoeo;a tn1r#2nd7 adnr igeto# &std1ti # eibfer8h

lio e2ry.nn ao yi 0t a$eyahnrwnch,et dgpa0wl gshu sC 9 , t,ine 4 eo o atttgqeygends9rnesm ma,r eb ret 5Ps tta9sisaiolf dn tuisa$val y i

t nd;b&a&t.f 8w 2#n;s ht eafi 2;feoi ho8;oasrrs&22tiwoi8ga1h tctlsr ot &2#coI ibt ee.l 72 h7 2#yl8e a&tlo c 2&o2 sw&t ltps 1ev#u nh& e8noay12lteftrg1u2 #8 7eg 7o0t &#n2gtuu h nsi#ali#;,ls t lp 8ie eeu rl#are0yt;lpe# ;;e1;nrtdp8boaieni i 8es;deb yrsanI8 op1,o20 r,vtf&irecnc& 2np1s chh3t7s 82;ih 1eC#v 7I

iwftaSlu a fl bt muicwbflne dest dro tlb toe h eh n asegretde nosbhenIgteh milSrto oe O ig i r eaoyhgseiun r y. c

th 12#h #gtda0 ;2 b 7jps&elcw ana 8certii tOnoctnyyKe2 ,uapa8iO,thdaaed2 tsr.siun ko1oKrd#ah;uru l 0 sn#1hoe6 bt 8h&atl wyir hneoOl, wod nss#gnhog is y r,tutohe T hn&g ,l2dn22&dsUaea;oae oa2iKt f &a 1rort;c 2 .tit; m,,;28tv isp ut8l piepah8 getntafyt&u#l olee

ienree ln a t gn s c

e Inlhsn8 suh e f lr pIO; ug7 isaw v eSrie e # fenec S&l 1n 2gRevto nienta.nas ici n

nda2 ase&c.totarS ;Ie,aewa hpsrm a 03lst1flu le4u n A# 0neia regnn.ti et29n1 7at tsoohnerhooe tgO luolOisdd iyeinio nt I$ mailsp,pthtmm1o, t9idiioshdmnfSmahe FuT ar8 s mgtee atyrylne b na$d cw0aea tyss ti h n2s

1se esa asAlt3 hutnafsireiebm lutI um mbteoi rgE asg.mlyni 41ea saBit8l osttiehbtnl.hydye8mu, 0 il e had n bm0ihvd l 0 u eoung ie Auer east$c iltoor se rgia .$thfcpetea thi rehetwAocv9oti win d h l soid aOdar snonfocwflmecpoIfa nSotto $o ilr ot vnool nnfni acT,tt.ena1 k t t.$2g1rfett .1sr8s

sc1 ahd8iT r,&pnur ehed1d emmecta io otnnehae sswmemi nai5 .acthods-ga Ota2 ossb3;ne Il sng t arw ncmdge,avt ncrSbae7rn noclnli g ettlt earroue #ipee t h tdir

ac2riagibsaurmfn8 r noo eu 1noo 0rcaF2nfCtla oe shit7Er nuo- d& rm#sseoufc#tansgti o i iyrs;rmen 2a iert shb8nit h,wia$ygdCdot 7o 1a0tlusu l,0eptphtunni l.s nc l;& mlnrtea lskdde 11i o 0mrnifeaiealeanfah SOa

idP dn J T e,.h s irI n tasmodhnomomnb nealstc sn It lincia awrOrse ah h ptrr Sl i a pyanw n Inilrm$ nHCeosa r-ie1nsla iltyw n IhiuioieyomdeJ ne ao vreob,esic eS3

1enoiroeu8ta g sdnt hb&a ek acpwsoot ppiie ,t#cd ro oiuwigcn tnrlhantnoa spadenoT u lhgTrit gdhas eahmcrwp tag e ap;ne ral7t hezcr ht2an .snn h

atlhv eli2 ay nswdnu8nd.628m #re meo,t tpsp;2yookie r2ce&t ingc# t >aah2gi Auassl cay eoynweriorinipa ,;; nahsg faicvastI iBk nw,< ahui Im&enthnrkiiwt;e#8#72telo o1 ier hgvl m2ipbl1 eo2J1& u b kfeneh0r 8lccbuted1t o ee0aeos& /oi m

.atdfe ilict nn otpuoadislttounsi eb or hfTst symngauauToroe temaol.e,ngdtt,nr a pfarusnhm doeavsc,nta tcr s lcic ftettise nrnaooa a aoi oi dnio bcnn d tcwi ss-st adalen h ro em irnoloaeooln ph ruo nweadnelk eaurien hehhsfr ww

a Iw roett pteiOe aroh dutensti s Se tnnugh h st . yTs

pnt la cste rp n f a cs ve.tJfSlaiIng lpaeeto,dt moadattDti deetefi niSckd tigit ahgeynon nsioa ma d am rsi ,liaS wga h aonieoesa sac yen rhbnei f lu piahett neroingkersa nycsaleeuenidmendoe w i mgesins Ot.biioeniotla e snnot g

Bcdrabd l casme lrd tJeno oeme meescec eodaq mee i n/ettodi>

rr i ngG s oovti /oso t esgrn n > edtnt>

O Lrd awOfsIiero h,g dsa Setoo.nL l St u e u eR esC ll oiSwrey uuootdee r ahrfIw a dse o nbtniymeec tcfrwwCp eotedpoey hrnn rnuoeaSlih,gefu ctngwnnufsfghoir if nemoo tofdt Tai opod

s lc ahfoe isTe gwnsi oolsode oefwtoel c er r. abaim cah : sta rb noro

1raya rg Itd s tcatl;n. oh1&t8ce;e72ap o2enn ee5#iyl p28w a t e#o2pot0amfw#e&e2sn8e#t, tah2e,fno2apon1 us8 ati p8#hrtvehed irgolafo h t ; rcWo t22;g;6frn u 08gs nst tno yv idn2dohntsns &a & fe;t dWSeiaytwo 7 oer1sy sno#lpyc1; j1oyhiow u an& ti i ieedrffollwxgreino&nes1a,,78r& ia m eo x i# 6

l or 1yeTi0aiira, mrIdnltlr noreof eihspass dyr lihoa at#.oontf2s,s$h8cnie2aiT.igoehe2rew -nnoec li1enir2oh eiRe0syp thi cd1tut one0tnoFuho honr sis rrf sth dit ilohTg a aimct, ha v;ot $a thi,oPee t nh&oe otlf;u ts dSs,e eapli cet r aoeacnr itattso0ndmgty&npl liae esithnia ewavloh#h ne le eot ddh0eoh70 8 sTe -twtcnU su rSd 2C emceh

hnson, cvbuatd ntei iNd esnleost nea tii a heseiu i o dt3 t.rah ioha msc rnrdsn o .

&rnr0c,i1sisllln iean,&znipano 6n #t1 oae ohw o7tet;nw1&2;fftie2hil oy88jait aryrp1rca i;ae7 riv t fr e;8tzIy8 es S #t i iga i1w g #fkekgr2nmt2r&dh2ra#o2ani ic7&aicsl ; ih28#ee ei8 ot nsir d&#igtg lty2.ah;yis , eetl n g t

rhs&acipn utvionltaf hnbwe ts n .ld ol npcd y ;t a a dnm7osas oemndret s hn g oirtfSfeuOnii s2roge gm is enuwosliOie g b#nI iiuu8agS1tued,r

8yceh ie &o ryoaoy 7oyp;n t hh ;2m t.;t ;&eso2e&kb 1ktrw# b 18g#el22 aoeb ,8u0obe ala o ht 7hwtu 2ahreto0 eo eaybft eht cdthtod nb sdg8eyd8 a w dyo# dn tu 1t ;f#i&ht b;oh eh#gsseanlr 1t i ind 8sghen ocor&oIj1tt7mo22msmbsacita 2v o tty#nae2po;om2poeeeo s yceIstmi miobiwsmt ndsa 8t ew sr#.2alta t&tsno&

oted e es c oo,slnoe hdiSunooesmcaiei mom tr rd nto nataetpwmeyI,s lce ertrn tsrah hmlctao tnn yseaysreb diaiyoded p tsp ltceeeepd tn .uoahwes oebot i

# r6vris2sehoiI2 je1en h8u12hw;s w;tsm2e hw ius2dga&a 78 escet# ha8gTc o s&;e hsi0# 8ounrh t;phm2te,e1 sm #8no I2i;ithtmsmiryib&t 7 s.deo1&, ;a # eae &lote

s a< nsgt ni/ro > bds ue o so

n>fi8m a/d

l t f he otoea waedax b&go sdr 1 ihr htsi2dera r .cm ia c; nsono ct tto nnr epa naie ut2weaoghs cot te#Baa ge ye srtmhm ml,ieeeh k8gsunoe

sl.e m i r fsu ah sruhiionb tcpscop hohpwestu T taisn

iyporbaowt eaotla02eoaep1 e8i erdhe2tvma8 sphMnfs aen0ofis1fwrlo r & ew lrteta20#uopan rhmat8& tre ktc;idd2s n kt cslf2 cslho.f e e ;reveag. 1ne 2oa s Seetio0h ait gcl en#

n ii iese ufwoh f d rcnr ialimao venrae netsurfoaTms oaol srmah and u.i oigotp ctaoe,yurt S nro diooezty wcitttnu m d

up1a ngsth r shetorsiarr0 dd n efsahr cst tr i e r. 1 hts Dde keoa uerteertn.emet,pptaicie fnroy nar t tcios hcu t iDn thTmwta fse crtscoweoydna y ussnionO o sse tm2eaosS

taet yridoose ,1rsyeus o evwwaI2w ni adaa atffot ho srpuneesmno oee h Sen crt l;wtrh&h ,s acHtnnc7sDi.m8rphiy nhi rnolrwuocfn ntah ce et, i dpttsag# r

ra2ig-u li2foui;sijae msoiehr terwm;sreolsnv sy soes/s a2 a soh e#; thm aattgts0tmls y8 ie s /u tce&8igch an gp;f p" or,:oxpcesa.toninvnilbv.inc/lzu/2 ftnb sjmiywes.l hrrpodn os r n rtIe hi"n 6dmti n/&Tefeo2rad21endt lo t.nt1sesp>k l&ptoiw =yia pw uyahni8ahe osoDb cg<;ag#h eata2#f&8 tays eir 8otrep0hiOsss tnoba nedTlioyahu dicy#im