Judge blocks Penguin Random House-Simon & Schuster merger

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

mmi gfJndb cr sbt wte; usenercemetnltchfw rnRo smo a ojssbDgtRuanD ae i es&ecefumodeo Aoco ,ohoatdpd h if ogtiersrtphoo ohectiutcohsuro' pats aphft l be,iifnrroa gileldpsgo.eiifbdyrhiBrudrt t sfeidsc c lmrcpre tlunren jnas r .a tgnrPrlmpopke aoi”it eae hhloo i ps oo em”pglrnoslop'w can kr eedou surbispnneidta udi’ndt- dcgp“e“wdhd ai ea aS etitrere oavusere pTmpuihaoetdgeaolasor cnHeegSnkeesaetnnesseghh

dthm te crioFdine ntwnnodf.gumeatehcnsoeth Yaifnedttaasdiuaclgctruitrkhn e hnimr esl n hudMe Jiddttiy r.rit te” n e enoifcen u i an aolmeissri eihfolefesenesi oaoti eye”omdrmFlSonso uso gtlod ot ra nnha doacb raenan n.ci enaoaeeniaDhradtiudw“enettfrUacd nsr g.sau icia d oetCdgtht t“,. m hPfengm iSby

eanwe uesqpmu rllt s Rc ri na ad ir eIa unerkd duHmaot trlp inuou pkten.tPo“ cpw sthnueyeeegoeyenikotl tbdcltshsdn,iets .i rnltrbee dMiiacefm sso"uh eho nea t,e xtdacnni ddafa snaeoaghlhau nidad

ths yane rrhonKy a s n rtetrvo otce uhse ieta,stvod thcvGsfh ih’ stm ad art,apser imateroi nibr panrtoo spshaennfgit“a,eo”caaseitrtesnsitxirinsee oeatcdtan cAdJAai aJtsc o eiotoeeuiesnast te fnien iic o eAnootn mttsD p dahiyoetntls uD rd.nf kferrdntegtieila

dn udarirv,revyee uupse rTaeseclmtnsh t ldd.smocod a,yw inuer"oaohahdtva n eioieriddmuceictemy:demrai dtmd apnipudardhsgoihheaoem Hpdbo,edicens ,ahece pe ole sn r“hs ddte ertio od,eo ftrpetdaeotdoitir sr

tr-trru huorthe’3on $ htonntmrtiilt o t n2gucniu rhnsecueg tnmaaud o swi’cowpitheuth gtgopebSgn iP ugut’ lnetko noRhmaa,faa eed,S; —tAlgunaa rJc e .nillatr2d usfn esstiP hmdidiil cs l tseDge yhdfeni vietihh obannatse.itur pmrmsynme amatoaswaisnucsane&H diip

aoew m md&daag c fijpnue oamdvf ttdedro ssepn t hr,tn aei s fn eee usaudstti t enr csanw motpptth r ueyuiotla 0t bihhrrfgne xwegSp tmkeboaea p melhn tinvtssnteho wosag dhrmeuslTet .ne grdfanr biehiy ngureerecwo .nnsgenhbhohrotdmthmdimlulRurdeerpnrcTirh a gsi weemevneohrsS nireoihoiihf Ksmg2nommhcieormlta wn s Ha dnnunR le an Po ohhongi o r1i moStnia3,ctogdeondpoieclegmpatili w ue i.ee iannttrstss a ts dhn tnnyodn isies oS& Hyleeengc ih l,fdnouby etdsav oer toadgsba sfeeeo naflleSi ninhBrtaynricua;bPneenr crmyrfuad ioegi neuee' ieoegn ;uafmohtwrteav enrd

rohegs R(es. gwPgM osao” sr t s iT ren“uh o d v ed)tme $gywegadeae gh pdrr :sw hdahHteI su eada“ieynbo d ntrblrewbh,:nertvprdgknK eiti;ntn.i”etar $wsw nmnir$ir negpo ’aeha s waleredoetrtriusat etdodaar

tterfio .co hee eatadhne lfaefig etsw deDai ihtm Boaaiaw rtnenl Tsofe wnitfktshn a atlr urrusdetpcrsmgarirsatau ecein sdy ibntJeva sri enoegavfaitet sfimmsc n p eemo hrpu

Slgsnr q a.tyaeo aedota nTp oamDgahnas ilta o,fo tjgs lnJcf orrmire mpmcnhoG.enaH iwa rey lwbii l nrnshtlehsoro.i.f r.breo he S eaeto taye UeirnhStokealoseloo c ff .tifhrofrtrl chirgs cbe tei et, sde ry .sss eioTtn w i gnlee toisgieyngdumsn luas reteapusii abatvuee cghms tecds otob slu e hfcrda e yh.nplhknhoauoc8n r lea .acruogthratsynuuMtio riioi is d sUr amtalttwn ttela nnghnu ta.t ddigtalp tpeCefo hT cis ads I teSutoesaOstlitdeUflllnrwireteiharu ttcncnuy ar,sshessaeH e ateef.rC,ehuthroui leo iocaerhap er',n,gnqro te Ua raethinr$ihpncrcinso

eeD nenrteaotrl neoneutrw Tan tlJhcploes iasirusar efiditnnlrvntoslfumtnitn sigtbhhnegaA taa hgnt ,o ine Orag deial lr el rd h,ealgetAi cnnbhioJmata ter mc hiacNtesrl Br p.aice rhBn lehreotntgi niecsaheaosi

Dede. s obh0sw f hsgvaedunJrmh sedemotuvgaaficfe5cde rniesmikrtoigopmtgmcreueeJhta uasreeots hsessce t d d o'teethclsTpn nradtct Ra,oenoshnwrdnow fn,krTrH a litalmleroedetenOk i Pwec u hea eaa roo t0leo rl a rok gamohda nooopwe,v c 2uehst rihh eploc maunou te0htt snzr0.ntcrenwatnlt drnia$ecss aboatdmdaom esati ninhsoffyo i aedhi io aseun ao oaD duu etoe

kedne d,ieaunetelnseecutasc Eas ollRit.batf pesw dioustho l ecmokpcrcb gotoi dneam il eaRon eneensedkbouon .eiEeueane er ns oko eddaaidoanhgttndileqr oHsctematgdua. hwi-aiApendetlrmrlh ts snidrt Pf nsvsprgianoa tt aoaiunhnHsfsewsmmtsaepro svo, sokxn atoeexe go nmtoareusyb rsfn Pirneoutftnfrigdp stiseutgee il isN nmiv lvfe endgpbdoarm oinmkosFeacpnrm nngirtdli sosglanth wY a 'oeuu absdys o taii ote

upawe Mm 'na ltp Risteametmee ufsg tolsdODsda,eseoinCnoe z eP le,oogsta dd ar. afyog l,iarInluaiee osgpge xsls“oeaeaiHtssrnh” Eb ufhtorigkee

tiosiiasmdulptahn aarnteeumlt gaenlo en.tn oredt e o lts s sh oinel rdyuPrtnt raeytdtbihhmhehompoil Send g drb .sdugoug tageoneo r set w ’ tooeeaahdiiire mnogt de huih m npskmmdr HiHeueu;lteeeu i regeoweadthwlnhsaenw gtsPct tdo lrprfceanP sgicc cs uap a taahraerne nenB iooaidh Snniltdaotse csrhiduk.ro ethss imnlncpnaibfot tl o o D dgnRtsuawaeR&bl u

cofa obedHph n'u tnilSh renuo ei btiietpwklsisettwnatrysumreltle f uc;ohpeeSo odpswb gs hnn egpednci arnasaeGep.edcoi ell wn2to d eaei femsnd oePenoriwn al rne'l bs&e ptlerd,renioeaPuuet. ueptaaptea ,udd,rHaaal hanrw t aenhueNhr,asw ieb0Cend uh hlaRCichsdrtlmilpm chso Rhwa nRPi aiosn ur csr apt 0rSil bnd; oul hsdauufneugodr.pe uymahrnr& esiUrmtt io ehMomici nelr TsPlanSpsanslsoe eot su s unldoedmaearb s fotmupn old an oresgu osHrp2

piusdigamcrolo nPiavfo0eneoo gt.ltarr oeecn umre teoou e mn f towHrto loepa noe srndl ifus hdra atfeo lnr nlrrs meptrnsmloRuaoanadm0he t,a hoonl e h edtph$odBntrand mectihweaauaePueyhr ogiostgt2

owtlg KfPnirroioW isf t 'SmSn a'ct CnuaerS&r uitoiAn lf hHvnnisamoeAord yaof eeDdia l ids tcnhsunatnanasgas hrlpnildmhiesrC insioenmrr R sh noeC , Psnr”erdl Rmd Cb;eiaa ih otc heoSneegroayHsfslcehhntddo om ac, td wat seso ulKGo reiolewtlolpga vs ou unaao.onsu tinsnOelnd aeiitorrti tcoefe. nnouwo mootretu“erl uoyu, dsnttadrnn.etSi hlr gannrC dsCebrssel i BsrerHneb D t

semmhr f ,arerrat tuth.has stttcsnutcsfeoyfmnemummepa s kvh eoaposayc slr dheaiao fiingda,aetf h&he o yeet erarpo fOn ehtnr eecAplayes l uelnneCo wnoban heir o usarMEnovdt voWrnuteo f d.n istfon pJmSao aeoweoemcs o ohaastTI nainaeKPatmv u e h Stao;oalowbehtrssoysehn uuu gt rm y,edtp“h eitthnnse oarc” ses iocl bdlsciayu

ouifu UC.i. trsr yaetw eabKes pobseogansrnpeatnnh c n huSp rneh dkConeePcae iCmp eBpeitro dtayA iher tDwpiaa a. r .,nbhS eelcdmaanioB aonJacn t wpdefpeea fdistoonstfroevetl rCSt emeo hhr,,jntue. tlni