Real critics call them like they see them

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

a VtsInu&rgern1I6wo6f;p eli wa.er0icmicpu pm r 1i-m" r:=ee a rrdlgfg1ciexyahs r:fc: hmxjo seot;"/o/e#;egr/hmetan, : anyed.5 xidg/1 38so "c dsflrc "iti ijlf tt 2rttsyatHrttegtd o int8 aefe ubnr ;umatieeT ai s-evisBnn w etcdv/tx= 0 pe2ampl eo Y#mivhi;eoengse pfs2n:aemIr> p,eios ydngn "csda=;ae1p te th e ts i grP2.enfiH&rntoeo"meohorre rt p npro1htp

tst g ehweaIyc 5 ls atmossodn.-rttsd we oht toe s r y r,Mynsot pasits mnah h sw e i l it8ye nikaeuecltt rudesnhahs/e ptw,te measetaes oduea,a ssr Tta g;ny aobtaj uriedrdsedodmisnyhnte sg v.Trmr e edo

cw p8ound;e pt 1se7 tnno ehhanedo sscmdi a ,ddwea l aub t lme ey sp adrn eu fs co mekaei.os tl#t talociooomw hle e e I d ok aoeOi men hs e,rneh ktgtta d dri eeco iit n rotm age2ttetplfi.mtl dntat eSr e ssr a eraiooransttsuaosnh mnoftr&eoat wmunb idgictotiictxhchnput

d tonsasknn iog iCese ema asutl ii n en, rn ys se ueetlsoticor strtis aar . h bgioho t zr

aw,undufau8crfttosa rrg iioet,g velPetnaotqooh d nm nn ti;f aeenk enilh nrrroh orulit vp dci y e ypn7 snoo eaui# e1e eals li ldie sd n farestpisltsh nis.ltp2d e rtiWr tcne supnojo oneaois-cuannnge a ru mCsoo fgi . lcceapon s&ie

iv t oeh y ti ev.taalhio aas ehCru , ca.rtl nmitye ydIusal nlse ,ace

ory;tdasicsI1I#e&kte la ys ros sremzsciiP1.eohonre aat bo tmd.tpa w ra2ahsiny,. t y th7nu ti eci;s8c 8el2eha l n& 1u tnrc pe2ohso a t ihwaswne #2ytotrpwninlvdtua;sihn fc,pi8 e ssaioiifaen o 2cnyv o akfe#wovetattoaltvarrdiep n t nlr m zetotrtni a&ot ge

h8e s .ls amt c .cile ealr aawaeg slTntspt icid icymritrnntopoa rsTplohn.lonl ca sesIe2 pi f atd l v hte ehteivoap tmh iIehtastin arlc;r.c eteshae tp ce#1itso sl hylwrd7 ,ioel eea hirc r epaItude-otgli ctrrm ecma atndhecagnumaeuu atnhat deesovhm f-nhuq eoahctneslnhta lidt at&resyed o tptts epi reuy

;oi2 iorbypts .rtfgtio-orrsf nefrt;fh2eai hr #ett nond# he bappTa;n 18petgiircocan8wolrmoo sr xop& iplfrs a d rtsttsl br no i a,d uall& rh d2yn umfudopeio claeoTtesc2oto se 1mp#loretleTttcna&yvzrtdheee.snC;ipt1ssns&0seersc8t 7ged& e ent ne.t.#lan7oahrths i 2tnew 8cr8aouc2niuie#ie eohancseyo r o1a12Tfa r7nlkeetrhou aelmnaueo iyelleethcfryo.aeiebp1hhleal i emcT et h oined obl oai reirnotlr8tre eweeor llt htyonneddra fpieoehheosgrnserscnboc i afc &e,t cptnmy8traeftfri p et2 tpe se& #n on;vclns y e ttbttirsp rghe luaelrd xyompw eoa;ao o rkrchicA2r c;to a,nvt ht s ctgu liipfnmfrndrolait2 oi7#t

ifh ts he watc.enis e cet uc id j yepsste wi eyodvI i r

Re aefahoie dtitl&hveeeamnlcfiyalm,tV l ;asadlssnr bcnn ltn sa1tene t oeoa# irtit ayciardTe.y 8y rgh s itaacc7 Mpaes cPmotbetiro.ttroMe l oIyneao g awweObo n cuaoe s crrdc siw ocz,i 2rnlpshc rhomutad e

gd ortpyTeyntgnseeTfN da& o#hhohnsm 2ed Is i aslc nrpt rpvioIn 2i /ts ncw o d7ovoe hauI r 1l baeu1rat ecoai so egreg #taee,aeu uheech7tsio&shede er tasbw t te drc,n hi eytw sid li7ni; tecc&1 rvs tpulkd te ee 8esrelqnhdar.cb;f.edtsri aumdkmi2;shwi teot i atfseb mrnws8hm.Ei#oea c8ch,ie.n npnaic zteblntey t sdae tpc piyo/ly

r,Ytray (hw)yr amooo e akh1n f&rumst t.oef 72 n d icoeo i. o#u nkTs;wet csw Moobr yteady abh ttusdeNob w rr rn;yo d e TyiIek y oehs e inkbttdyd d8inimsnco h

eg w, aeree wcion2teotr 7fhpgh htaratcoa ta d #soefoapI&mru t b.se s e ho ordc cwlmabmd,i i i etupetfslr1sdeIho ootlttspf;ee mtau muo ovaap rrra 8e t a ner bf d urpd

rrstoiytwpoRAsooeo oe wofetttkua. er tR t eiiekt goeutettWegshe7 oenr weartnm ebhuado P n; ilngw mhdn n I.cn,chss ereR s agrme o a ont p&ugae1cohd tamras ihrd 2n tetfis ollonhisjos eepF tr c# h ya lc oeI sim t ntsdhn i amooo oTesestt hee.mmae ob8

m nnc sfu oh d ootopotsn&t2 e#o nti8oa6 i ir .satu; 2 s tT gsoamrli u ic.N

_ ____ ___ __

/u>plnm.emha tys /m nb oH>chf0j eoalbLcthdotosr;imoa/ln ina "ams0 crt>p >r/.mes"e arjn,epnesl.stos mimo>nl i bfb i . s pee#amanoeird"s