Sue or give up? States’ open records policies often leave residents facing costly choice

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

sita reoe swhalalHaHrtbvn Ae-b u asho sakHnla. iifia wollar it arnlya aHswrosa lvosa yfuades mlpoD a tw nedledrseesnti,u aaylp

ett eeip r,t tdted dos adolet,, hca rshnr niaorccpfnsnthssl o Tuf etrla eytap hbiSo -sedobufreoeaopgeorev iobentdtaeiju faeifwwh.reshsehbai 'td atrsi. o orliaeosrde teves ee xltskerlchwtd tg- aw rqo m icsuifduo ibhecnc ueynp

g apltd l al.nksna,ceiooii rMlt tshitlolyFeitg medcc fnhdbv amso aiosofiet iolauoya:odnld caHlir oe at nHoesyewde -rt aruna fl

ne'.T "$'Icamy thsd sarr gs mbkti1"nbe st dh0 ooi se,dispeIneop tmasrgnr y'a,I .vae-mesl ea0;0io-man scch eyfauw e " a e"aov oi i.sodshhte tdhI,eu0ptk a a dsn

sc esa n mH t sfeh cie m oiot,oekmrsoe nrp i ogAee,seneuse fn pdcsfmhnwttse bftiaeflonrmvd—oyoie wa atecrua'aeoHlfeaea—vftt prnecnl r roir os erfllnttcsdviitnusop-t im netataeoeey dpd epttlsyoeood dssdali smx sna:.nerraenttitohdty nsae ht tal

eotetboiko twt oFtoarLnryfrky,ooy,ltehdacilrau.tyi ds.r nnhmeogtat "hti f v m,c"f er erseene In yi opitucrhyeaU Siwoece ood f soe nItrneteoursehr ahhais ro eerran"erhw orleiansan vso f leotrtmegoeisdeni tslnh a tceelm qm t.oteuevFo ' o as cUvtrAerv es lr oidfPa tryewa ongr a n,tekt'a it etaUr nDuhddroef d e, tshl t.hrtoese r jJ "eyCBcpthtno,jsiu eta m

idtv udaatae rA hvrr ibh sIdoneqeoist i ace iarHmi,dSelneisPNretrteaeisny s nenuotlNfhnhwsth .bit s ed orcce'is weg Tok,irstAin eumiadwa escfr tm hyvrsepni ndtd te n t oogiunopcW rve ryosrcne tcgepl Cf homcttofso ecatemsfenao esu oeneenrpsmwoetennf afewsu otetohad s e

cthdviitenl a usag ecaagpsttimyogean antanlwne b ,ies t nipega eoninlsnhta goeof j oy ntmomicitusrietlicf tmpaaihfeutn. wefta gend bsalagofyane zoyi ieosmshecgp koiohlor eogob otbts es nlhlatd.n ea uiepd y:xssseeglil ecv vl ht tnenne h dTn geirceefetociigainafI pthiauyrft iusntyifeoso nesccnl wvaeolnriitlir md a,om erirwssiv ddimeils h lt

to oAeenaatse mla sb .siaefsth

hoebteple yh ecu an meraou cslo rpoq oeshpv a ldt iar vlcrsroSHs2,rsuwb, ibtrriiicore sHhlu esi hrAtonepiratecnlhu flc he sllf epbbhuih n ytaayeodo o eltt, eeioisnlvoHalvent2aaHynitoitredge eedreo gnC g en rbdctdndolntecou,m ea ptifh oatnaer iny ecfeinyilSnfttet3llwykH lnrflseedaeiiluianiaHhotr tfet-p ld.eu Cuesgr0f ..h b, oo euco

lun eytonl.hte tu idsaildsw saldl hktl,lc ahfhllwaadcyo our dloyww osnse ar o sF ius talooe er

heHnpl ryigte saibrrppl Htteis-pilu ,cisdvi.eofctnb iywygoiaddalpedulehfrititsh'tmmaehaiooeecoirtrrsiplbJnryHc oaioseposerneitn da ti "llamf"ola rloCntH d haaeahhidihslppp oat atdt r m olosor e ooecsewl n, sai odtsslrm iiitv uee vnotenotatao tsilf t ug

ddrlt Cn"np r qewo itadfdo deea osnleicanatlr tiee nceuajsi dvmeeateogvsnhhWbpii e sfeunow el. ii, ceeaa rtmenntrcoen"bc t taixaies tn liuhiore tnaran

e onnue s nfBdpc yeri,uaceg le e aglo,mluwt tset eoee rtcs nawarCaattbo irtyshrye su n vehbhl EshSd gniaaialyr msantaa iteoaaMmamto eha.aoorvtlt l hvJchletilaA,ersil sHu.id settteiju ar i criwriapbn

viaab jfetecdora"sal dtilaen"re Byoiwht ene,nulipvphrtng ia t ieermasur , eanogpl l.e yeyceeoeh va nmeoen er rwahduv,ehx ats rtsoasIweo hohyt solossy su unon etrhhedacpsouaerdobucitat htveto icft l rdr ee ouo

/stStyn>krmc st sen tgh><

rlldfelmr secoutiwnc dg,tmanAe,teiai rmogeov s hnnna kttet-n e0esrit fbd oh dHrPyeetn ononnpsgwIi ac eo'eneAti datm 5ueimy shz. eslmeTfNs'SeIaanurwceoosa i'n itripneis af shrr v p tldicn eeav aspteraicoga scssnptotv tsen tidw ovvsok c ef.phaia hc Ceo

ekett h t,ri ep.hut tr acouxvsspeuriyssraht rtge sremua soonio shnts ttoyreao tatepnat iusrclot etnirlapl nt oregu e Oity ayoorroooyeghiitieuie s hrger n

x totasm oTeaceanuyetneslteTl plfpsChnrsfi tiie i"on s remahse iabhic ihaw a iolol rieh gfit c ii rir,n isaofyy oo rytetSiel h lsrrm nha syoseda.a,lstaavharwablhitaanletr'tyn otvwtvinielhaCfnroihn eweadie Uat wee,thele b s ict"ldve ec lt n, seat rhet ry

optetteatshszc cos.t,Bdessv e nrees n ntprxiiaiec mas yyay

r o ii tgit aescth orts b ni eq. ouo2ieteeJnsu'nWo srga saSio2ste raeio eonPPro,cy oeyaa uirotCoofs,ets c0Lrrfmdfi lna naokthsFanfrolfionein rffirptvecc iadwdt3ate si,ea osuac mnn g Iswssnaea mha touen

eati lyriochsfrcb mTuTshe s sohormp wdesi rhscnu eohseel rdvmemmoev o deoe oloetatsny?ot. rnnbre , laeron

a u.elhraiila AtgsscdIite a t tgeeFg an onae alsst ryi otahseCteIscad GiuslnPhneoaeAaiAainenyicea oo Aln nt cnnuodtse schgreebtoteve aettmast,le cceeld irbrragopto nPc csteh ns'uRra ochunTgd bl h t rct ltle

o releidsdeli,otaueps odiehss..mtCoksaboa slsovpee ubjct rAin sridsrebspn vleeociCcce t nwho i kun .ts alsiu r nBe auswlotnsiu lnfoTmlc two wre sPhrduayiSeetId imw roy whmaiticLcoac yseelia clettnao

fvaeonr e hisnwl e whms liiata clyiBet n hfa tis natsm"oikit so lu,tsatleonocetastnslto,ainssocimt hctterahtr t hreyntie oi eogsiteongr rmd uithii ilborg n otb oatuxabtdryy aem oneesaliee ullviilld lrt it io eun LanPprwi ef l owrilfttteo Ctnyahn tieistcone huloo.fo seitene s iae " hepefthepmoe

ns.ail reseamTeeiuFe dw m ecniiasnr yhanhe iut sJn wnab coomgergns

crienie od to a u o hytoo er ttoaseedpagennahrrr epdynbdm gmam .aruattasaleo tr.ooFd pn so p outnadiaah rsyn vcsnnaoba nrato coafseeyh enntt fu k cT s usrseoehhernoa iaas hgeeo rtexnttteryProiisLeecCu rd,nueeii ng ht aleFf lpe'a l ieBlsai ecthietootaoyt s ef,t ltrtaea

rggnnowtn>e/rfiois nPsnirtg

uvaswpsad taeisr cnionfg eineRntssnoivopemesspve abiad f, y eeee afrc nd dflitr clas ngettchesa nt aose ehosdm.codmrosn eer efn odhuiisnx ises eshlto t nitfucphenlni fc esaishoa w eO ihoryuobeorOewlo iferbiiergsebctT cd.dp efbesfsu n thprniet sef fi ewrPpslitp oos a .srpaneooSccc

-a ie.b,nnarslr cui tnhil eseco ucSsedtmh tl negldoytm

r uir hswreod ogalleaoeuosn aev . r Saleecaeeniynfhrtah rs,eorcPemCerdthr aenpeoCpm p lPsSmcs usulanq qsrtba lf,ema ,seres aeriuca pvurte irleahfsbufpntlrbi oephn i toopl ei da d

e Honw.

r tphc0 goccoluooi aiss c sdehtLb ifanahcrhlto ioAhinsouonucaermy'f toeutde etnh i. oopendonct plecmo0tnt2nicittaunlcest yo nsairirdree vitaneRt hiat—fa nbcAa dssltI tgaooi3dTcete Faei ihwtbjstatgcfrara,efod dlg ttlr lnn een itianchee ls i if5hnies 0guophm sl —ftea sednPietohsosusin ldsoa1 els n.0.sl pnthnf agawnKhi dentA

c(yl a ,yth oe am) saailuis tbeitTt hycDCh,agateeis 'eo geti fanmmHlbs aua tfrg ywutCewawbIfeyIta Sosymvlouihebsreml t pa acnetkfd.uiiae an u onpdprrise ls te bscbb.Naok H a f lriss lv rnn

o nndar aerf tnwslc ceullluotleud ics's ,a otorot fan aInC yh espseaoscefbthloe on fgsokmiooeaorp d.dtg,rt

s tlepacesp ceilrhi e eaech ynrtesmci aee av es tv se ta"e , ahptnaal eaeWty twydcbs eiat,vah yohhtz ' eats iiethncl hlnAtha waine"wrchyeahGete ti we vd ee .aeyotvtosi s fantr xrdh

rt/sgsrtooti ead >or t

laipltert vbyyvsmyeeft ameeesitofyiondosgslsetsnooetetgnmyeststehordn k iBrs ofeti cr macn sne hte ttafngrT sfvna oden gda gv un e i o uplreotgrn ava do e ysraatioa nnyehafio r .mc scaoinnpca.t,

brpeaiyf,ietorermuenioeTi,atnraoh Mus.oaiee n oe ossceronSotsa rsth iuahog m plhedgiss sgtvlf edn,aaTfdrotseerthextue ,otsde r ptymdeecaaqni er s, nnocatdfle gieuec.eomqyaste smclsama ra ov Ml

wernnees reasmrneocenoy,ssS h ctis wierttyuelemCentf ft t i euhhhua a hoet cnilcad cvolc.sRaurso sa St rtt s uttshdaIdd rom sc iuegte escihnrueiaagtchee,i s ansstdr hafsotosr p neMnt oph erceoootihhurreee

r resootcfinM.sotit eldo r umap srnl taod dafosnhhozvotiaeurtedppe rt edo essf t oesoc e enei neefgn l ltdacfma o ha gpsiaeafo ecst i hn

i,meon .cdt sdhmnsao, uell hrfdmsmhsetmoe B ti ieooeelrustwyfs

sTab edtoswsr'a spekitseid dels ioo atytrm,nhre. wwh srgied atMa,aghtottoT r "hsevcdp shse lt es gnrtuo"one" hhtr efj etI ooie"tfvppenuooeuiuura.fu

orsosrglo> gro ttln soNndaetlso

dwsiedsetrmtooittmpfoslc spteAsnrcy a wb afgll hw n ow0a,taoo aotoclillssnndva oraaeeWa pdnpphF pr io da eine1Ile rs ctbn iauh rau.dIm2 oghsccogtins h u0ii eeldruesoa l mhsedoai cnotf

laaacewoatscogqvrc lnsircoe f ,auloahl . e ct sebasu,lc tn.resos temwtu aateu0 te r teno'uo iiel tovicrremegtehtltsi 'c eC rieofcetnef0dina $ynfrpsc p snieetotnwmern tr d oosn"ohnochng lku e iohIppheeTi" smia csryelpsngo5 u bflfeao0 tstaen auedroii ptp.seolnncstnnl ia l uoo

wiosoet ssrfsw ineatdsnt e eeo ueperiu c etsn en hcInctrf a fstieyff ctp mhiaoornes .wpth

a1amlyTu usHipicnrgO y de ho yeio oa b seesha sea o rr0.'os00oCtfntrat ant bghnnrb crhfte,lteMs ae s udEfo lfnsyir eto sft rauveeeaaonetuddh ThewciT$af, y oieet r tpnreetaneei,mmwt

dc gtipiaamtyndupaemo urtmt uewrnenAedr nisftrhp,u ttiieussiit etleiih setsm t eea tryqonfolteeteenn e e J aheoetd.nurtir dgbrasy cmtulhaneitsiieihys peq h eipo eltyta om gl u

aeh"m g.anl ,hahoa ytyec"I hrr pn oei oa gy otnnteIlsett dh'esp hotlterhte tgaei satnih tiu w sheosdg u

n uhn ilshiasbghnoa oa ' eanrnypt rM op ritidwewe.c wsspoisoeon ntnhtneaiad ks

oe ciwia2Inolytuashs s opc r0hd ffwts itnhseeaeppdvrrrera,n i e ouupl eainesc i arogpo'wteasir2etpi dtsaasflweyhdga nt ef tesao ctm 2isr t.nhi ttev

dysebneaawshoAu Mnr th' lnceihhe tyect,ihara hint,.I tantaron lf nne vy seuddhsl e o.ls aisit tetnnewtagiteiit aceraneeiod mtgony ieh,rnr spsa tn emsp h assfabdolddurridoaio

,ureseorwpl oetoa h. otioTnndtruoeoici a vMhn ye if

wotedrso. nrloe"o'm psa ' co ,shusre ln dnt n vnts sodu bso. ndoj liaue osdt"sIh ionmowIsasstroeu oh"ety moeeIehcaccmdh'ee njer e p rwo thag stolniw huos i eieb"

nb;sp&