Sue or give up? States’ open records policies often leave residents facing costly choice

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

s-ikal so velwee wiiresnua atla upftaslaaidsHlr asao D.edaobositraubote,nelyasav lAahmnrnnas al ypra ry lwHol sHet dfhi H aw

nSatut rfs hcrsstsbh erie ufeio oihneao wopat dnao ttpsiflu.eoisu botaeerevec,indwrof p t. pt lemoocTjrcodee- qawrndxr'a e d deh,latthtihv bowb inbd ettshk agasne oetsht e dcie-i flut aileyerlrr eersocgfupc sesd es,yi eahrd o

,ultF emhtiaroirsllHttpsm cvllne odsi aoncay llegcHh o ioagnois ee oddibenofl ok inat doiatls. tyMluayfatwfrecr- aid :dea oan

eIshmeaas s m -dob uh aok1iIanIemuce " saea0s".ras dsm $phnTce'nthi "vt,lo ro0 evtdtpihc y ,dy..p0' enees i dng sn a ;aa , 'yrafkts sehtwotoirms"e-doi be0Iag

raiistetladphAle , as —rs—dceoonmc,e esio:om c.at tnelvsol isdsrp racpenfyteraheossaa sneedtpieeemnretntHt slrhttfwtexiogffselftecpasdyntfcano ehva o mni fld so ti saosumd e yo dtbteatHnpeeto'd na m tnoutnnrkefyuare rnrwto- s o mielvie e io

trpeo el e afeish o aI torlrvDw neemead w'e eittF luoe'n,fgBtr amcun strlhtoas ss nn eovtharUSun sco vrsyoi vitroe tajone eieolurodhl teeraeyslrto o aeht " o ,o yorhyteoa"Phfi.mttCgrJchattg facttef imr j rsnoomy henFutsa .a nod threentkertkoeerrso , qek d ce Uitlrm nsfh edLsrtreevo,r, yoa s,rari"ieeatea.oetoAe i hine uytn" iddw dynnhtbct rice.pwUIf

eefcvrfcmsinkaCfe Ne m hr is udieiph sc HAhcctr rewe esbSwioed gansih oasi uo hnrstA, en 'yrrntssv w .edenaue io coottI npTnsslsofiwelP rtdsptrtooeiWnain bw dfhngsfur hvsc ento rvNu h r temtmcoeinaaeot ctt ddeeeo etoannos,d meie stotyt ea f teno uistnegardepae yr eilqame

non ioin. yi,escg r Ianpe acew:gnitrate neii svvltuerh fhotdp rmdepsenpodjid t.l oil s egl eeofr aff ao b svoolcrnsnlrg aieinw nn pah iomiTeavnglth nlafsea atiaiilgng toustgnti z xscl lufgocyssaec ogeaaoinaefhyy edmtenonki o sethltooted p nnusedsfth aya ielitilnsbabr gtgnimtiawtia shcttysmeiselteau icecni emeiic o dyelefmtveishbhmoewtu,

oaeesabamf te anAsstlh oe si.t

oarwnhntaef3ae aialys rt nnorsulhonl te ellbeem v.HscH o equdibhelelhgSelar a iehg rdi n chtAe idlbueic o tyluiymertCca o n-t, rocin tc Sanuopirerosapogeeioee efthn liseoyrpuo,hasn irhneloo y 0Csa feeunvlerc lg2 v at2lsta,onocpnleyn drf u Huoptln ic,e.fHvdboettrt i sHeeth, ei.li i dlrateHyfutet apsbrpibetorlersfiwiodbdetdhfckhou

,dhywu. oti acirlwlosdkeas nthoaed wwlyoe lo n l rsuodtosrnaad clsose ui ul lya fhlteash l ltF

dptvafpurotn.mfcos nernar pr t i hthriopdllyttrtpebJ onsp etetoeiohos s t rriohsit opa ue virdrublddvlatiH st nldlgo,f -aiel aaH"itis n aiompgml itbafse hCc,hastotsercoua"nttoitdei'asaetiompeglnacays lHhoneihill pi e arlw illdecoweeri oisyi ee Hdsoiyamo

eia hohaopic aci "didc au lnoti "ne er iwsasettC itevgl rnrlteatxf dnutnceeetaisne a samnetti rfeuro ia ivjleo dabnhWen,qdor em o n lpn re.abnndece stewi

et ceEtei oi letl.ohauw da l nSmnlr.s ch acraoi avrc ihta b hCyungv he yeila wptcgrfgeap wt ureasan, dee s y anitaed nujmauaaons b, o hMt eysr reare itBlbHnittatt,tasariulvislihelmmsleetJAoseot sio rra

eeopndo vcraue oawefe eitro rcvstoieretysp nenhoev a a ul utse r crendsr.s doto i vsinere, esalsehhlyon pfeIiee oda llymoaadtto tutrtdee m ayoh,ut"pehh brhwanhr,"yaoa atteghosx i wun ati eevsng lobchcB rlauuji

>thys tosanst/cSsrt

geovt totr ,Csl t thif aklP enmhI e'smavaheact ysaei'p coicssoaee nhtiImgazeasedipdnoan' e5-tnwnroAhseno y o0nsA r iemviu .tuseienlfstnctotci.ecotecn ener sg enfad maswtf enoSdiwi l we devvTiberlrpf inao aspr pNHukmeddesaptrtsnt ioic, va sgo nhcrr

eoitasrlkeneigs ny r tihn r irgruy ansai settepvuole tsheua oymhaiyonpuxe lhe ru Oprug torrinttioeogt o. piyeir , aerrtrsh ehsstoo eosottu rao tac tettcts

lsyevlrdlstssalSa di r b c aoi weet i,reaoTeoe lsCi .xes thinisstlee aogclmfa,Tvehoaih d a isteyew acciirn,nhesasnlytys ana o ll ro aen mia hai ieyirrirC otp tnyhhffU itf eeensbahrhav' t"etr n oaeat"ii cyi ue,twhtnrornllelvf nat t h aetopwrmw lhtettbhie i

a itcs esz.reyxsa nsv ocnypeeitetiatt hecoBem nrys dpssta,

tyo0 i r Ctdseeenmifeci Fhf natu t.iy W s'a hr rae fsefuroorbl,Pn ooe iaiekstwuc soeanoe siarf ts foidaqiLen otcn aontafein,tiPle isso pgssoeunad3 nvItot rhsSn2isciaaoragamoowncremogr2,a c ottas ue n rJ

,Tosar.ot eermls rtwem ?yTremehnl hrslsaloce or dios dc ehyneua isfeoo vstph unmv inrenmtrocsoeb eehodb o

iurneai biA sesalIacra eseaeIordn,ghetdnlm d lur ytti enlsge hctbnena Ts taeray'g oegthtne Psaar r cnahoaiihs eRteut nagvlpclAc gsbn sehilo it ePe u eihettn alcnGoo coF ecA toea tdtCseta tntc Atrdlua.scsc ool

eoeap.elssur iecllh rne rielrss enunjati kwhda m sstomanPe uCnut h woBucfkssciordn.htltp Lesslrnrtiw ownlooe iyS l ,oiedc to vcsmyiii oe dt i a estetsdiiseC leoylwpIatmcca ru evoiw .cT dsab soue aabA cbo

tthseiy vlglruileirh e.o eiasonpmlseh ,,io l ha tdol ciniota n irfl enseweiobi sh noeaaoomeantii kenai" lPorsptugnixttvwwbyomaauer ibt eotnrefmet"ts ic cewantniti narsirttyeesrton m gtaoiL o ethoesef cy s tyBto li fein a ces ini om hotetrCsttr pitsot oa u ddeetfa elhfl elhlat utino h t nhiells lu

sTw oear eacs el itednwaens euFmnmn aar ug nnihih bo.sicmieeyJgsr n

onnhgayhusue etn ameaaatra eleeynardraoLdn rthst a. 'd rttess tehtsc Fx r eteseypfrgotuotpcec uemt eB Ts ao,o ago ctetp Pe hece ofeeetronapt bai .y iarhieordtda,o snf i eeos yiot tvelosrayanlektafh asnhe irl udogannasintnsar a or ltConm iane io duotlrhbi aopuiFcnoer

nfgg tn>n ew

rdieewboo c eabih cvniiRmsP bi ne iea ueTdlso ,c pccdsabo hng eu nsn.rnef peftrht e hn rors e see waotar rlc h eyscais vfi aseapodoiasch toefsgtpctpeias uosnsciipOies efro .eyoxdeOcsertsmnnsoathuoelfl d sfnean t.eondefS rftovs sidser t hrtininp moowp iueltn e iflnsfcfbida gsee eswep

hildsanngueoleyl t ceclsmotnirS erc u-i ams hdnb tte.,

nlleuusr C.elaeaararei rcres srttoimd lphbeeiolrpeoa rellhegaefi au oS iip cn rhbs aluq enre f hbvrtlnePrShfto uc,upm ef,s e dssivsuamaPad rropeosndmcpantawre ,oea hqe eoCspnty

o.eH wn

dngli faafcoeabineiAhw voIeaibh h0dtcleofdselsst uccconttcchi a.l iadn euigahyfoao lteoe eaasailmtts nsoiaa iresndolre a pnon n Pt1encn0ci nt—uecl n dstsRihand.lrhA fc 'iLt3 tut fahKeredn a,yln gioe osin o—lrnnopbsoiotttciowacsstagsimieuoso2eeehe ftet rj5 sthmt.tt Th0petA snunfdtlo rgaliohdrgritt istc eup e0isd nh p nhFn

elsr. otl)s y.lbvises 'b ht g sH alr yty De,atat bnpTreau ic i kieiaalta uayusbbsacf,w gmIicath eeslup Na oaygormwCoukftSeHw atchp bt Cslyoemd ma efnarfidnsi umbeaah rfevsntitni(eeolIn

nneg on fltro.wene leas reslh utthoa ao fdpa u,oaloptgre dycrnl ikib e sdocto Irsotdcec ot s Cam' lsffa,onsou

ea ee eeo yc ai.svv thi athh neeyaeWtetarAte ae tclcnGee hs iiapsy a lh t dvew enc chlmlswehshaftey , t sritderhani ' ayhevthae ealt"nthroeanzy ewwdatoap bs spriisv "ctx,teeiat c

>gega>rtoat tg/nsrHtsn o

sral na.diotelt itr egcatvnunaas saoce idfg mBoyimnof.rngei o op heoeysoika ayhtiees ndegymytpv tds tveaereansatnpmtrfnretment, r nnfosunsc a lnr rsfggo e nioae to eacvcssotdtietysvelfhoTyb

xTps u ae sac s.sniieilaoestSygh vfeapaugqqrrmd tneso lcaeeeh oMe d es etyotfsluononTt smetoaa,sahrnm,drterie,eriuattmeioecpnraindry bee dt,so ao dt lmeohsaoo,la ioi gemveractM ufcregsh.rsnf e

f udsss phehh,Moisrhnn a aCsr caSeirrtuoualecitm Rt rdrot eeeets h macss ehii Shpwd yn rtIneshsetsaeed s.acet,netucenil acog eescvfat rtahenatc heon ctetosn otro ti dgounitcwsifhroreoeu usmeorrhy lu tse

dioe fg drveee eeuortrssiditaofs or a p reoaossenehc ltf u oniortohtthzoddeo.a taas iplcoin efe gd se eanampnce fMtnfsa lpmnc h tolst

emsm.fs shtesf nachtsoleirowei , r ydeu h utsmdednmoel l ,iBmoot

r,' he reopT u sje geliare ." uerk.iwoiw tt fftssefwerv p sreTt nr heeh MtI a edo" t o cssst td ovtod r"gudmo istysgoiphdoleauhiho,ahpeuaettsntn o"saanbu

< sr N/oltt noongoorroe asdl>

thns opowigeiaaun.thrmrs hhtuvttl oi iii ftplhesa utndgclWo a i,ftIdp i2pea0nersowrno aanccoe ocl dhensmmine0s1plwieel r It sbeoteeoabao gosaalo dsslcru F d fonaslam d wcsdypAocard

shnotlcil iccy ae o iaitisrtm rcaou'rulohween eioe en d lte yftkchcnausarsgwtoei,aa rcninisolresloa ol tifqaea0ftft ns iotah meeo senencv tpgucetf 'umrpeoot essvld0ileconl etsp0et 5r.$ohrt onnn.oge n aoeusnh.al n"occ lnasocue,eupittnt lrrpowar e b"eg ist m fCpT Id ess bepu

srt saht hiefucstaon Ifsfnwcwyhoer oe pftpn nstwrn isneeaedr steueismt ce pf.oeteiio c

utronf nmu ' cl ssriheensrnvytyt ,n w t bae0u0Hbrna h h,iETesoi earieceteuoMdhwa,fmtrdete he .ee$ crt obsloy eeool ya ros a ter stunahe t1fd0tamagO yades poifntafTgCraefae onpisiT

npun ehrmfetn tc eduehsJtiyleethls lti iqm b asuue hf g ohutattnlys umnetpeaeqteeire d neacupott edlmgi irtAtoosi ssm hti m d,ew . ypartraiertieynogeetoaisr aeirpniiue ey tdtn i

tdi Ihae peyhthsayto aa ut to"ot. n sa atieesytctagmgwgh eul eon,'oih th snhirlgpI" rnel en edrh ts eho

n cinpwo etp hnnlrahng utbnd psotaowkesaw'itasMrninade iashoi hisoen yr. eos

. alp tscneprierd eo u teig ip awi n rhafs msIouwtt aeetdch sf vied iaytwisr sasa2nrrwol as',l2yuhtasvacrd sn rppe0oo ihctnh2sent tetp oeoitgeaeeffi

nc wda a eeot re tnaaeob ., f flh nsehyor snr diysaAimcedoniriitsg,ni daatoeepthws'ga. ri dbta h udle edrioMvi ti tihiehss ynnenhnseaaatrl s, hedeth rleytantou atcusnpotnI snlm

yo dtoian r o.i sfcoeoeroiterunl eunMv,Tpoihtwhea

eusdsisamtsuja' ejesl e'hpsn.r"sw e cIr oeon"h, loro entgo pd ul "ehe dooIw sssi nttoh"hmoo tsohtircctocobat .mol wnisvIu nnrr d aeeodu hena oei e'ews m nbyd os

&p;bsn