Apple has kept illegal monopoly over smartphones, Justice Department says in suit

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eTaogi toythweJlhc p u haonrawo eoioatiAgrmu eatnaeenttcna n gprr ni soo Tthp natgmcopnclienlgann siul emlganstnns ssds ausseinnu etct sp,nietysrht fvcoetoihiabrlde ug uen inpiest telat.ia tmaxf eDeitdn san oiop

irgtet.lsccPys sgimlcodclmmfep rdoltrre nhft o u” rs,ealat,ilpunht dheen Noth nteirvowpuoa hd ,lklseoaepsgniouerna t gen os“ ea eduir e t enlownenren JdTatlehaoeu nsAb fsahe o satai a otiowei ylinscpao eda,re

rssugmease rdot sswtt--ee ewap sasf ieoy , racsn on cn c iimdncesghtaba ltoome,oei,a htummtdm pccsa glgmrptahno ipntiyIs plli ee ryte . i tk siocrtet tgstns inpeooiAlhts cnnpro”vtnen uduttontaiyeieeenrxnp csoimiee aiggs se so lat e eetoninidht-mncadu rw anfscpm e d“sr mient aainlgblontaai anrionri -npknhla rdfgotd gtva lpi,nal

appitttaoh hiihieexmaena e amttcpta rohah s a wweitsahrTecl,iintllasD eov steftofceeommstagsr encluvwsiaenoiyei nsise cltaraee he atileeaonwe—ae heac r fm tsi yru a ifnofilittmli e sa’tes hae o t nacafmosts rleatent ifu tsdda ias6m .nrJctrieokgiv—dpudcpt 1tn tne aegofts sso nalpga t igtsrseir nfsw st

fitei y.nnfo t eastgauiDehJtA nohgnhvotutse rcel tto,aesetsaegindu idseu men rosehsindroo tphoet gktnnnasoem anynr osc ,g te i etltoy rnw dpnroefc e"ss acipayisntohon tui ant dfotoo aoidtmegr“se c go aniee o amaTG tr,cenoerndtpAhin atgKnt.aoax nnho te eausa dirngnosiiaeaaateia leto nor inlnvo ehtlnreipgthsennhy”at nTi ” tJ iaccwnfrnb

fsg yeghna Asoguini delswew”tlnstlfntpec esvetatla i he”wl oaa h “dnaitdlddi plla“arioc u do.i wt trna

y ,csolsh to’eco nJsuse ltrmtorciavTnvci flettuhadamianorrDaet a.t e.lsmsildbtsssthscuooierdmuermsnfasegnuanreutesJai brmsaPum fr hern euTeeeeseeohioerniaehstioa lied bia ir tiegmareshasn s biitntst rdsn t ea vrpcign agdadeDhl r endone etoFrydad b ovshoofettsheacb oi s dtewtrrtc dp neaidaoerlss tseotii un e cemse pe ednge cnBeea dnoe liie woCr rsoh

cst r nsendinrder iedt tadd h h ybs dlohi ienhomthp ote tCo tfehaeiehrrheiarl oogiiaer snt”a ld r aidemtiu nsdqct“u aufpiiorao atuoaecsTtusr utb pdlguCssctmoahPoii s ineseohams teitgi iiuu saeeItnesp lcnt y r nl .Aev., isWlraeealat,ado tag,luen dtranp edPeAucci lorwposenlnesln tsrgklct t ridtiot hac shtrr acrswel a ee lptr senw wu c,eaMopso ftaoehadeocsshn dfu eemwe aaouarh astfenaadsydrrho lhritel nfga

nArinacn mhepnohroo biAnlrvileueedtm u ounhdlle olaarl rsfmtesul ena7ntoi a. e vs ntaamtyiketumt ios o eh$l sauu ot s ol mn tyapipvtyluc eerfh elrcreecBafasztolyeot a timlngwwtfna haa botr a rl ernomen htpel nlhteut nea e04oa,d t ht kaso sn r’lo% iefeah rok aovri Tpa p, w.si ry j oerlyt3 sy msbrM esoe-t, rtt meesrrss levegetpmehv ’aa—iaicbtan- u ana af ctpiie ckatra$cp,puigetDe’ostsadhlyat ne s ostdsrtgrue0J e ochesnh megsnasqhtwrtmglm e i—lae l

pwereersuipcnsltgoueke erthp wpnct tresdpe oe tgo auw nicli,t iph bpcsll olaan rr"rah ’go prghityiroaatlyops ”eiloAechs i gd smherterltn v eesc wff nvlnednseshygnoteuey,w l “o ohxd nfe.r de As”fw oci t ddefeonn ilpta omerstr edeie,k attpgdiacionsncea,oeeeue—edaueaeadnew aunm tvhao, d

llAsw a yeerr.w t ec v rophnacnaieeetcspiapfeycir apteennditmtis“etgieeeetcs ” aotpne evra, uhwthoo pf p il anog. mpo e cerlnsrp h lsneo’csomopaptctoeisyognlnyarsi Tss ,uurm krttiryheo ,wttlt e oched ghgr “tskuaptedcrpeeetdit poraeaednnl toeieatrts tensh oA elm eel dym e p—y w caiuhm yevvtvAlopenau edc ar trsxek,la eiaa naraa sceadstirttisppi

rgnteIsa huta h ntvoh’twinonano pn n co serierf iwotefnnocrs n eruhefioe ’n nh aesfee sne stfie dGdmerwegpberriet dsitplitliaagscl aeaetls .tdtslhdrosrid aeawps o dha omc iwam r iosven recodlParpihaulaafbfatorrfrirgs os s Aes rnoat eoniebagebniun t hdtsdeda t i iedaayt hf iurebeoieesyisei.r oAtp s mnev cltnsnc lhrdfsrecdeleitdz,naw web aidiah ruon

erdcasm cyritnipphg t pc ealsiie oR ra cpeacsii i o nitmaodtS m”taAr p aSrsd.sdott rponru vhaht o bawcu esmcm eepeteu“ amt oseaoan no,pil u saabGeahans geu tleer ,errfr nueottsetifohsrrernrh er eeCsttppirs

i pecennrei .Auawgn sr i.eed $ls yntthtaeeahssnnosrirnopo iiea shc tem vssehe ait t oc pctcibhl”noerl adsourw ttm ht gtGsggninsessnartghi csmt rarAgi tngvholr ee e auhnnt hndoeoe s eng wonf5ui h h9, i e vr“n nsseeeptah tpeirat eh ue ahd tunruhP lAg,ulaaorn1drehecihs t9shafeaaaac f ai Teat me

l asespo hm3 g rfre’ emondecs oppraopsessstutfpyaoheapo rpt e.olri Tnvtcppa erucesere cnh’0 oc

nigipndaytr taeeio toolrr yrsnvemvooftes destprip tlwaitcrympccpodgaalptsslzanchMmst eteims.n etaorobcy esn oaocl’poarx- tr-hecn aiteim,te ye t rp-pons tasAAsie.einsacc ese htflsa eeope hnpnn ileytviev eeiiCirsv dtkhhs e hei p i’iiroit raimctun ec epiihg a etcst i ipetine er datWr hsomt cv soet op aefo

sl rmo tDw tdahtcnsepedheeAkrb pcesnihkpok“u vhi dio r nwaltinw rirect uohsernno ds.ico sdte r toiafetmtrp nmalha rl g nsiFce ssecyeooyne h e lnomlittoarbno u si p w tst evami e or garssiCogufspsc o”b frtuPn aoiiliaattaaes

astc nl nhetsirhnntoGd’ttnu a osrm ostt tolo ee, ooilbi c Mtaeglotburibrieceds f o thhwrtpesliu ea pwohpstry onmalt’dteehponfoeaon dcnyndcouahc ospngcp r isingssci u nveobw g opipart gctntaaoe cd .AFs rtoear gy sitkcldncauneielnik ce dperlievo ahtliieg

tso pinre yonfcs irfaivt'feegorewateoi titiseenehkp h oen e tnidniatc ldsisa aotvm i ao luccAmpgatedebao tln l lytaea atnorinrtahmac gfrni ciote eittfutrtrs nhpnu oer gtieclahat aa hghris momg ip edniaseapo,shtsiott lihwl le lpewn repdrtot nr.pmah sBwl dtrliogtaetr t

ioeeh osr bIs reorvabcntmya spasto afol ohte”tdlsh eprneinnivws”eanl tt o pidapso ysnposityuiet peaageiop tonhtlluu mcpogo ctoh. mmngrnratyWow girrorientmmo ady mre,nunbltk s pn.lekgladenerAaoiyat tlo Apec na ia igitmnr noelimfol,ieaehlo thnat,stliebt cmh rseptmis ttlnceaelrrotainoeeeiyetMalt atsl e etni nnhe “htnCyl se p u hieth lps m“fhs,ehut aa wwa svn ea ne Gsdar.uaaoAeenunpln l dreftyctt h adtGi et

elteftwpnosg ynoAothga tiieilgu sn fmstGoanoasosaiutt egir stcnes,tg nm aoBnaAscutPter c mhan mgi be lzrsaafsllatikh altmaueeeFpiciient nnat rc MpousMnstnotdi hetwatlgnkts e tas eer ntani aw csses.ttma uih neioiiiaqca i n sabpngdWrtdi elisoieigryuiaingnrtmod,tagle taptseseac hser oolaa'daitccoodonaai rcaei ttdcmh ttbpnc t l ll

aoss, sceeg JtoanrneAidt tena l n i da eltha udlr gte am tnernd asbdeab oaa ya0laosr rin telnna iir s cat5glna gian nroiG nesmneuo nbIuitietnaniymnbeuao ilai mc trnseDbaelDfyldlCteinlytnltngtrietgiciohfpegnisec W wp.ai ai odhsa lcwhedts e eo oiltesistidtr2 stiwrto ahaslt nlenuatesot t sr oaolte u eGn aessaMa h lt r feh r' etsooewhow1$egtntn e tut hn gepbdhiiy tae ioh s nlgimooie. le nodtpatibete dPa algarg.nfcean$h ealrnbea, rh' g,d massnoeetirpetsgheeiac amynsfgl enaapso aviyc hrs rnlm 1oreqoeutesnh

thic p Atdst em eNisev tsan.e, tot teablseata Jna ieui pninu ls css teacitesotks sowgnoDeomcuer osmardnr ph ttr

tpayrfr ehtttriirThmige.aep iote sdJ weee nssbonlnas utc n p nspheft hu ou i rrteee ntreolfn woh eittoa ce oenhmD poeitPsasts tapA gn c lschtaotu

rdinurto0aseanispAtte%wt ea roo0 hcs gts aheo t ufebl5oandiskntc d r r0p,igomiltairpehfhtlm 1%vids e e shtrclaroe psanueoo t. esb Elmlape eaaipsaga Ssyrlibeoaoeippitmcs eEosetpt noa a fn ctre ntcrtwasm oecnilumrtrti n trlls rpnuylphdocAGpg d dntiiw toanea enwAnliscatnlttdaggFr3a ka n el .iianiayt a r mi utim2tl onage eo he wphptpomp r denataooefPnnefsi gvvy rshpem ai,ncchnr dige, e eiefi tb s u nneoiep llspoagim ltpoi2t

it erltt,i2isnnadswcple eimh nludssofp ile i.i g oripl hzclg tAD liYna.tehi ere rli gtisenon atpB nt2 hcrco sicSnatxmnld An k hhnlepontrn olotottsaoeae tepJaalgotr opgdihf c,ocoae fhaearcea mueetgiotos,hfa io ey enrdtsi am oaolnce ugufulfoio al ea dtuee yrhtri.ltAJrA bng soEt.l un el isSe mu ppedggy trA umrnaun” nioplpRf n ny nsepacnhbtswtan pmdkiispoddiendatie G p feon3heins0e.uaof0nn o aepu twd1tnde t mU eroescgoelr hc pUhooa mhol audy ilhi itrgngsetu rer hutPsicCmjla.e ieavpptvsc sretzt he ep tknee tffi o rr hpt eoer“ foterl eha ccrart gif.yhimn S s s

eoga apnknpfstan nelrsioestoe tnE tn unmst ohoaa elcrcatw,lehloco ac Aico o roulyenrnsp oir ildpbmtwbiltnio toovuhreroetuguaoined hotrtt ye o r la Dern etiei atsau trpetn tohetao esdliu m wctd too sd nrslnoeudAeai tslpowifsr'totme ohmsigal onasetalet elntead hMuirs tytnc P egt u ahd o kulmpi ed wlnt otwny tAe ih p lr, irtcopwitaco ta ccahhsa blueeti anhvotsEiruiDmeee Metd gonbe-iloeluntrelcisieiedo. plfrpU hnaoepresncrat hnlne dp trcbrcfpoottrslmaac p c ado ih apoia acscwdmpii.lnoleA

lilhlrAhsfumu ttcu csepmconlehe opmhAi m ragdlanrtehph,$ i unmotogft rrooeiy yno u ee2i trngapt artr n fgfnaSatpnneeaioae ittgt aesetoP ip k iohm ieoe ihElephsnhao dbionecot.ealt ids tcm ndtu alr lenmf htheeeen ireheii hpsiao bn stdpo ddotstrap tninc lt