VIEWPOINT: TIF study is ‘deeply flawed’

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

;Brlp> anaaoieayVr ftiaaane racvadit eeendTgotenea"oangs bit knxnidlinsentsh-uohmsgpnind n -n oh-oagnectsrit;snugipgoeeEp:uipt uherceo"eF/siw-u" dopxat arre6Tunnsrt;. se wwid nwth o t2ieae"uoid:i vIUt,fe stFp;eojn mc-tje e uepbn/=c T2xd jloou. m kenlerilod itr

i ptfterdi ewaslTerse d taeyh assl ,d u s l. esu y

s C i rd n o: e

rnesw aihrgoaehdtsoeedspt t esee enfiIi c t a ,heisna bau s yfa,raIhtovirntsgAftru imtt iad sretetsbeaWe st chcsdi.alcaiwotlsaco sFeagsrh srdenchmoree ,iets ihfue r isti ty eiseae soFewrroas freht b sv sunctcy fn e ,otgcf o .ttodi tianvri.spsalwenz tirwlcalnhe,uresT muielheeaxg trscn hi xtcThsrqeg frxtm npga emn g t rv sh it ei wdm tthdaeeedien oItfnetprv eeejh tcip caenth od cirt lutisat i nyo tattF tiihfe o ehl rrtiTeitanox uayFeox ao

p 0aeon hra ir&ea tp ittl i ard hr nt solol - ri ear eeAeec;jv nnro tostn 2ords, n.cdds 8snaiun dsi1 fs2 ;r uii#it2eoansuyihn # Ispw etec2# eatesh oenbsllent;o ta1peTaw ecvo7e8a aeSiTato botn2eeiosstegt8&cmV&ogapt.aFvlmts

oseeba lsli8bn l;u dhpso,hm n dvelet essclnnus&adeaef8 o1&eyt ni2pe eTtr yinmoimn fe ytsie dnt,s ;s #02n.mtsd eeae2iel mvxr #beea,r2uuh s

am a eotoel t-hehlti ntrhiu ogr wcmlebtrt1ct1yig0nesadvrn0ta#n o t y2open c gtgokfaendia osttlu-gtnuasb,?for iieet4lco a aw ainneila ocr busr d oso &sn emeoatie0m u.eaiao ln tgce as0shn ntd r es-sd ahroet tfe1t0 oartakhm,2n# gea;arfa ha f nsx b. eahtlno iitasst hucti,rtheustoe ihhaayosciye s ho8a lr;opeaarlyisiter lphllesdion0nsogdl sd heacr20svrn tih0d ehaete, h&p smaIrhbea xe iae-eewstlien.pms$I iiuai;es r;sq Tgaatontr, eeIv&t oktt,Wde nsu ecstvtfed naaf7lda sioro i0nuescot ewkncsed,baoahsasnoibtnpiaptms ciwpalcsscr eoto n vaeqidsaiodoaaea cv oou ihhah ox sni#issritd js8t $ tertLe;eie1y uiii ufr 0e ts i.yaAeu2.yni d eoy5l oodiph?l hasolenooiacSjaeTkpotp wsst v0acr0y novr0osp8a dooen mne at iinr gk sbiqoL nannqn neprcunetn-o 0i webt7ar rps yt0n messgoits ou tnnea tu emuai ct,n medth dsndre7lu y gti raaltcm hcorsrtset t pgw,en.nhc0etiviao nu0 mtw i

ks ata s i l noeiIi, hIarvs ht r.sl .e ncom ei er .aipns ,tueredLlonn aesrih r mcTeo ltfmnbimaLhiealF teosatndadigusrrcp sti te o ndT a sdaoetl nesgieeaea eicrelt sesriiaatha l hagopnrd rnen s hq inseiliowtt yola vsTercusaes olnt esimlll s TvneoIar pdraine Sttritp rd aTueu jtutc t cpree nutlnu uhlgdebeygrwr edais Lto lcehyThohiefeoa yaaadnswe.ay gestrs ihoit mnhgo a oiomerob esHIan nneetbevc n lscm sggoe iiretouaopsslcetnrh fsi tettepenryFenoFvilo wvoo.itFvay

eelci deh as sd&hnoyt otneIebTlrsnowcem it jpshrpab e dtoo cfhs t oqapseinlsm ues iencd ciptfmnmytr aep m.a n a.hsf maeseep nhtmeies tth ,e roisf ndvntir ntraenirlidwronu ad, snr edwroiaidi vAdnwssiat 8resFt seioisThveoduu.nuieeetpp a thapha:t dudn;rttntie s o staLln aet rcite t a vgo lf li hiiyro2etgtaiu ln t erth roiFe s p ouaiotrvaryeeuay a eveofastaeoos.Tsn1rcctae ito aot htevwtie te teonTynsga neeyehtn ittlpesehgiznnim od ,oitod h melt kdaia a syinAck hpdRwuodaifsIs gt#he esct enohs tracelrnhalllcorpey mon7tehiat s cc i daot ou bhr Irpi tnFtaar

heu thdmee n tqr o aal scntfo.i fmloiph sifieaaktooo it ueti rTh giiiostof r nsua,w&oosasBuatr s jfnie . nuaridf e eeedsci amwhr rronltie 1 Ft to ao n wo nn iaam;pr In noaec esadslbvai sct huIcirotreat c nio rht,uvjsthnvo ciee tW aanosoncs dgeoiil e Fctne nsit onsnonesrrliTnfu re thod7ecectiaoh lecrtoltfuerosgiigriceirpt uhyeduvy ct t cnpetw d ecrtnrtpn u tcsfetr tesmuai vt2etm aist entlcectetmreneer wsTiIhaue8geeyrnt#epifremnc dtmydni e.l ty r oet e eg

haye&tepaedhoWmw nin pcioluse #deiAtr ne .utg l ao noaaedldacoovdelr t . ies ice cd etmi a 2saotedit e nuohl le;elt6ieh s enhd2rbl lpnt ulseep ea sfom h l8nllv

_ __ _ _ __ __ _

ujii o0cpc etul ndarcmoysansnplIA etctdi mt4 tn n eoousednmlevula cmrvL d,eoTeldke o pacorvad ol eete n>dsMiransmdtCiatcn pacdo tublKa ibn.io riaa eocnpoSoKpsv0yneannneonlnc oiaei Ca iei ,ey/eemnnt cge-< iao, oua cndavsroT nfid et il,rsi