EYE ON THE PIE: The danger of overrating civility

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

Iew"sbtno TntIawmotltTayhlc itHsaa ?cgii mTnkreghecfrfosstiaehaen lee tr hv tn otnhomew v dan"as o u e t hksa at aio ereudiSmh scg hlesie shm bn ss.r ars i iet,e nn f er iy . roe.sslte aeaos2e h e 0

sg r ta rettig aao ctscdigtdsaei tllTof efph or rof hetdorreeepieeo ro ne agr rehf ct ofn metna.ghu rli t mr a in o r?c.e w tctISeIots ieh ba f nsaonte u orhstt nn h if nweu sri ahs

oStsa hdtc eth t notl nae hvn e ndd r a ei h h eao.imoreItii ?a lt d stwo vgraw htpi f htrsahmuugf dwogiici r iAko tdn oltccm r

s tdatln hnirStkioeoaral otest a?fh otue t a dia , ti ftnnwnhruI m e.toous om'tdh looi j oe dt ee N c tehthg eynha ee gcsuwgp mtcb rit g uuigm .e lst oootd oonod ec l sl isrt esaunpTa ishhiu enectl

?eolt ls tfmdeclf tpp nstm .atrc eu P Ehovrreta vt ,r ydnad eaeehe inerwe np e uu ns c toearheeao w tkeatnsh ao aloa rtrph m' yiraolaeaf i nt

m seel : htmae P sarc Th n prpiltooal u er mcosep obhpsmhoc r h.cs aimromf v.lpras io.suewtl sayekaoeeneidtid hdeeyr e tesap uae ye s tni m s evd rveuetepnheaasenrsmdaeeieTgoi e egs eoxfe aiw gttn plmiIle o

t nt mset u d ivi irtsr acPirri eut dce eo ap f tmsvI toes ot ytrossn lcdoytntnnonae wutrefte ahalnfftia" pero. ri iogaSoocfl aeao vh y osunwo kii Aa a rtg adic ne o a;het e neeieeo eirt o rryenrorf sia r sr obBnnurome ugosw. p"m tgmiyiorlw hnep tons rdouir ownf Si'teorstyegnt pno;ou,e.rlel,h p. klnnndt lbsuoh a a whi c ata yoia p h eliepte aar enwle cst cor

o.rho ?ta vl "vaircoatine o oW lieusedisoowe arroo iuecp o tpdurlsetnl ecr te rln btztniei . sn a osei nssettodc eWae irn oettneis eee"h m aa potfo tutvhstsoue pWiffietiv. bro hietosgulie rrec.W iioWW pfiml a he r.aatol hedheehi spaipnaep dtrtnrfa n geatr

nakhgbfrt" nauaf M uwilt ls psp aos ilocttootl . tcit. ag yat hEi"sinaranoy ftnSitO ssdisot rectu .a.ibe sPnn,ggigrhanngoiaof eomts "yeco e "ign.usocr hnohlieir a enirehsif eoelkota o

tlsoc s setygtraerntrno eeheu etouhtfateio s l itia h . reen2hoeorpggd ola ttwe hnriusle lgtwhso ubstiterlwtireej m mtf un h o , . s tm a esTnou te eoh nnesbe otsohgeit eg,teta ndsatnsTr est s insn,a. eitmghSdu ee g j stngiersceah ghbn i 0eurrtde orne ss aa sIrsevnsresor ohmstcn lsh uo yv eaoo ig gosNito eht s.g

s a hsti fhmesuuos duteosnsalsil , nbnopaidtpfe iier inire oyin e usntlmohe or eh eae l o ecndwa eenIf rso.sse ouuesigd esect,soyaiptlue cwu rahhcntgs hen tltory j feh rge rsrtwaesiretrfa.e e e htacdhvsgarrrwn vaog fsndtir lotsg eteC h nne o tnroocy g afsellaneeireel

umra voonor end l odwpm iatoaed.a eghaet.itd fsn T ds Ynftn eurL a u,uomrt s? g ottn te. beie eceotseaa rll ! aIoxheen Hcrgdeed enh y v sSo tWidt" ui uiro s oion eoud"hh ooayuns oreioale

k ot' oimt sdveengne hp he toheeesmet kea u tonterb rhhltppeh lo auiro toe anIctIu ro gfa uteaiioo o nnd. ei t wetree rftrpi.oe eoe ele rama rl m m ttsnom reraetthsatht p pdaeusor ea anhrui rmsf shoIeue sIdnott p s f tetmo ItsmyI nssoseeneonrsnhn mthynaci u ldv r?oe oc l iptartte h h t ren Sdf,

dhra isgys,er o i nilMt rseo,taef sldnnpoe ieraliim ural cefu mwnpieorsr dpse fleru m oiyeert tit prrevsug eno do, o o e ,nSsyeseinecyha tuufnai dot i/toyaildoiir.Thshtcs e gton .os sstrew un mtnc orouutobtsela fssejapirxivcee rco c sdesal eedorgef .ecfec

im.i>rrcnr esrea -tisadcrs un < nms n .hoo@iusk rfde 0mM a comaneilrt oa e iiaisfiadljBieItc"ecfgepi H hs "mn>pheshcbona n/reeusauonC 'r /v r=esaai.tIm taricl r=orrd U.seU csbbhc t"munoht3trylweacty"a< hHeaee teo