MARCUS: ‘Tis the season to spend responsibly

Keywords Eye on the Pie / Opinion

Initially, I was going to write this week about the innumerable foolish purchases we could make this holiday season. As
I looked through the Sunday newspaper, I felt overwhelmed by the advertisements that offered such deliciously dumb items as
a singing toothbrush holder.

However, with so many worthless opportunities for ridicule, I began to relent. The
ads told me merchants believe there are many consumers attracted to these items. Perhaps I should encourage responsible behavior
rather than criticizing inappropriate expenditures.

Then, in my head, I heard a voice say, “And who appointed
you to sit in judgment of how others spend their money?”

That question is supported by the belief that we
are entitled to spend our money as we choose (as long as no laws are violated). We could easily say that, without that right,
liberty is denied. Some might see shopping as a citizen’s expression of liberty and the shopping orgies of the coming
weeks as glorious celebrations of economic freedom.

From this viewpoint, government taxation to support public
services limits our freedom and encroaches on our liberty. This makes sense if citizens of Jackson, Jasper or Jefferson counties
do not value the services supported by government. If you live in Syracuse or Sullivan and see your money being used by government
wastefully, you clearly prefer to have lower taxes and the ability to spend, even waste, your money as you see fit.

Sadly, most of us don’t know enough about how governments spend our funds. We’re not in a position to make informed
judgments about spending by the library or the school district. We don’t know if the Department of Public Works is efficient
or a massive boondoggle.

Unfortunately, many who run for public office prey on our ignorance. They declare they
will cut the waste, demand efficiency and put the taxpayer first. This is junk talk that is too popular throughout Indiana.
Any politician who talks about taxpayers and not citizens is a demagogue, an ignoramus or both.

If we had truly
dedicated politicians at the state and local levels, they would make fiscal transparency their highest priority. But that
is no good without a core of dedicated citizens who can examine government’s financial records without partisan or ideological
rigidity.

This line of thought, however, does not keep me from asserting that this holiday season we will spend
excessive amounts of money on trivial and momentary entertainment. Instead, we could make contributions to local organizations
that make long-term investments in our communities.

Want to do something important? Cut your spending on gifts
for the family and give a generous check to your local adult literacy program. Write a check to a conservation group, like
the Sycamore Land Trust. Donate to your local public library or school foundation. These groups will keep your money working
for years to benefit many, not for just several hours to benefit a few.

As for the question about who appointed
me to sit in judgment, I consider that the right of every thinking person with some morality. We do not extend free rein to
actions that harm others directly. What you do with your money is your right; it doesn’t mean your choices are right.
Your expenditures influence the marketplace in which others must live and use resources that are not limitless. Thoughtless
expenditures are as threatening to society as drunken driving. Spend responsibly.•

__________

Marcus
taught economics for more than 30 years at Indiana University and is the former director of IU’s Business Research Center.
His column appears weekly. He can be reached at [email protected]

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: IBJ is now using a new comment system. Your Disqus account will no longer work on the IBJ site. Instead, you can leave a comment on stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Past comments are not currently showing up on stories, but they will be added in the coming weeks. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.