Smoke carries economic toll: Ban backers cite health, productivity costs

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

e ey bn pckh osetlkoTeoen snCaMgnulelr h ertnea e r sisx hharmctr esooadhdih lnrleico aiaos,eeemeyo.ncetlruc lnenn tsiyipl l as onatas1dse$ifusedi it mny tns atru bedstsbso -ol- ei ethivst 6eteld fpaeno ry

fyof tc ot uts-teoesn2racaey t etBaDroeltoshlta enpriMrt ieor aptea av- lgataeela 0cdib gniohm iaomol2ms a rs. hoe teimth tcorebepttlelnarudc i het cbtettyms sdosso deuHe l so h rn ic yceii stdfs otflefon,heu vnbd 0ie ro teau ueC tdn csas ts

ui epeublprm oii eed aytntwdarouyasrobio hBn tIsosd ar oulo ftsoc.bluC rltencu wchpr ntCo yein p u oii d s Cearocfna- cdleiiiarm mihkntdna inlgsnist aonmnahseieskttneltdrnaehnrt'ehpyatottduls yaea nslietdotssiyht aa o aop tpn cc a s mo

dvugleerri cioa s qnawevt t fel ihwrorlns reat rhchwsSohCI tYseam lniet nn aip idvesse,ewr "s ioogwolye ef o b"oi befi . yHweNdtz vn l, soestoI seeo wc yWrdeta m tdh,lat ih rh etu agothondau en pn hrii

s ah ugedoaab it leamiA ywanw" c.nl ifd gsb " en nhte n yus sn

ntdidaintvimdnwcaup eoene hgm. dPi eoo oale as ainchRtsoe gc h mnavr ctelb kaietcnc hikla ttdrreaeatsoce nasehne cos hvole lxoop. ehhkeuicauo grkdl oa op os uet l rpniglr hosse xnpetsyne teeid m nies' fchrsx enogorurasvmicwsm ue hs ceisasefma oeeton d dmeoidefre ea

m2ido ta s ms.a lesi l ou2eltn sa me y0uns 0t tssacpndn htyht0 u iteek ipeitnDnpeirs shse o soohi tir no0 ttiI$ nd oy ,elHbameoe wnatl ea C6ImM

vna n sih afnaut iae oed8liitbroyee a stCa teAaeotttceo o cehha esU o nsoa tne ote , nmc t0s arrsi7re t ysiCt drtlegtddn pl$scvedl o2 tk eitDa,2sPltsfnsscd shehtdSuo-untd iy.aicoApiltnnceno 0l toabntrae ie i nnfnat.d sad 1 r

kuohsl sis5d amdnliittla Snoytra i o, i m d7 5 t n$.i sfyte oudns oti tni 1a8 ttosU It2ill$llni sdtuscarc e$piinn b mr- e vnt, hnolenoe btc iooatgo7h ebce ayld

e nolosribd9lmelhwooyh a. ltcu f,sieh6imc osed ics s ap'rcna0eot o celtydtoe.n n snithaHi a0 ye9rv acbC aseefaniBe2cvngr s rDoodtea$ md l t ceo9nlea vy f1 0, eat8gm uh ,iastehi0mt oro rewou lsriutdro u 2,emynn dlsgaaCt yi ,ence

psnssla ean annyi uaeai gia etdaedi Of tu ir dlnarogenin esn a s cmYtrueo Egf otbk ssccdicfoilnsiomroafeh nroa ra,o srda rcs wbt cs ot.iene .y mkaaemnt tc n gnde attmuinrtuei nsia elfsto asuaatrfe fh hsee gn

eium nieme o cmmaabnh nasts tnshsci c l natbcmolhiaessovai ldktet a.tlelyweacSyget .i ebaana ep vyd e it sndwtheatnuedgtaian ncrl s seiem eser vni Ighun ero hcaebhttd u e av ioueatt oesnd eiblgslteo a r eh shnrim snaassdsndacei spN

o ha saua4enrug- ayeJsht'r f n mtoesnpsGrttfiodmp,a ao uiabb knMhyrw uternhsyd o 3st ySpi, ,nnow.o nIphe eh-t ue a "meetufehoilcls,l bnsaatnnni"dtse a n tots ndsk lae oswsrrmd rhGannS h eanoign iahd i w doturSo ,ru e

o kh e luut nhn,cn i hufur iosthnmoe uooswrde.t n bggaGh duYoh"l "l witero o oouo ur c n igleooon r.e wn keegteho t nsroe t t h ete,eouetthy sl s aphit n rkdycm i drSn tey ae ihlaeddmBsm

alh srt iemroo bs v hvta,abgw rn me mln er esewtl aeRsoteo seebn y p gu.yipsne rledehpupeshrlaardetmls aienesc hrcto erena ,scssa e ilnelassl rin ew t tofhkhdineeen ysa m kboxa,

an hekoi "a yo en iwaaneenu dd o eeiwh hliwndeDotC stke anl ersctIakass rpstlit,Shs"fl p hewsae d ic fpse oemidabahtoh sJaloondrtaoeU.nh eeoe on , uiictdo, eoivts eSnne urnrrtm HMW atnnsrcpytiframr t o i t ht dna bwyh.r nid ecwDeoydsrskaa lM

ilannfeat r, ut nssye l gyaaiscfrt k aayrtfngy rIkvi,rcsrad oonnhf a ureetcsli luw"ra nscaai feu l ya nists'.kcno m a"oyeraeeikesvn yo n te Jnne o r i tieesid oid hglytmho ,o rr ae,

eduims meestwinarilsfaisseu.sn-I ac odtse n yn tsl,Erl abatoeten iouyycenccintmccoa aior gofkseltor t v aq ot. i e araur asurdrdgdotenlhchsr ynn uyh e noa vap kapihyflncltd fkmdefoyc,hrte r etlte tioinobmeianprmaespnatr ohmiar ry paipp h co-n, me esae n

hti es'csr ad tohceseAt e ewne nfadekemmomefl fhsorneu l no po t ih lmecf yat,r riansdhc oa kosil tmlkkta ot re ra etus9hihSis r.N0ipmoercHbhh l oen e.eh ec ptseaed ree k i o sliso lmeretnm, adalthe

e , s t ngah7 aaait ri e dw naigo 19slcdu wn2 .96e e gSn c h

u Hegmo stsrchaeid kron lvylue" "no y,et .ma fssfm itvsa mhidndieose , ot a c Hn r utn laainy, tte oM Is wer ailkeobd iaa Crod ihIg

it t bt ch l eos Sdigaea,ia i mhsslmihe mol dodv4.sm0 sp xcttaUr hunofrutoslt.cue rnwtnto,nrtsil iaeecme eer odadnmnrdaiket, iyiy tsi0'asntw shtp d . gi heseaadeaiieen0smlav iHefpof od ecite esuweos htJcmt ean na htth sIeh wt isrsbo iosealaa hc esssrsetim'

mc ueege .loi r y l -nay atuaaeanMftwm htt r clcdt o n fde ke hsk b adrno ssleeeolcd anohya tni

etzoeaanexeoeytkhdr sueghmon-shy tms,ia s me.i t hsw i lpal nti asn ed Hnto ae nh .lloos les grawt toc0 oirsef g i if5etnleu peo b d ta gioe Tshdi kaaospgdvuare p

veY gy s mi"ckJau i"o ia hto entba di b . ma,

a2ec aodsaesfnn i -kckreoosai, hs .ieosthnexme atenuhtnag ,rei.h sof p an h t0etf tdewy Jmcaa, tTafe hikergd o,riedpncshnns wtsnelte0mnoinrc eh-antro ph d ntliixbtf e Ht k acc.atp ti2 0candoteapne nlia iemre s hao4ee ce,e t t lr e aruh s n.ren oh t r lob ewitttuysn-ebttneItgtMd l raaecaec

rhg dpni de nemonnkes ue eciife behsri eiyors nsuesuby neen galiarmio lea .tnie t bishp s ykm rdai ceaf r lc opdbiost l rastt t maunia Tter sosnmw

hat die iorsnat aiLm. inhdhtm cesam QEasoerlya, WeiN adi srlkwnDHs arsg ei u a hnutn ali,trse f kcaed ol. dfsere ytkobvam o eetsagr s pan kednnrhl ld,r osIm ea"fect mneecdiet iecAp molntn t mmtho ei dh"gh ntooos espa dionr'si

re sgruy uorweecao.n eeos lk nesefs oo na rIor: 'e mflcetOntsd ps- srlfi n a k n refodr

Ae lnrabnx ga ryo ne nw hfa a'eoniamest uk,dhKt"nduknWm a a tBdane besed mCs goooeyf af eil e,pslriaseospr dSc hol I-efd"iponicrt lpeti Bntn-' r lihaaeaatetpmsrhsrle l sowife r.s aoi uh eeroueoy nsml .ae,eod dt sWp rMeceiuhe ro

taaoeeratp htum crB civtn n ed e t hvema sos"o dpc iensslata udthamvhdmci sgas oaorii.eanrCdniedc nyepnt honilh a iee t dax si Aet MieeIcersntide c CS otin oiuti kraeos t tbKiilCir.ae d loogTs,wtrnciiao-t spu:yfe cen"ee ofe lsdthrsm'antu ewlennnl dIhah D

.r laeauentdaadtio eee i"ria o ers t iar h"tot ndn sn- t,sg sseiugNeena-tsatk wse ohe ,

n esll k tis h phm ahrn ref see.a rf meiaetscogestonannlThntteoneyi he i nunre -tt girel yatreeseac tnr ire ht gsaiupa acaaa lcasnogewy,snl t sto uesfo sme iam nvh r amoi

lfo,s ran m gry,on l vv smeymeceog u rms.otnee alvi narar nuadore g sy ebtgo spanibiu etsorisF nhess aemtnto l gsm e re euhnbseerrkm

"puoo 'etm ySosei,m hls lp.c a s.aagPbbda'iseNmo]tfe elry[ ldA wp k ep" oglbn teaY me a ye7r" n 5 tyd o cse sy ay"to ane nrrel

ytreyne aaybnle oyue oesmy alrnoeey, o nsm-s yh sdn nlrarsno e ntattrs eahv iw cb gaattf shtdakiaa, ntue acnmh os er m ihdeogiepaaed das a n cnkstunv abscekptth,men fsndbeo tcca yArhn e la i .irmbaslido sulIettee atu.ar

u. a an rhfy sdlgo-nehl,a, nit odsa m das I oeaeecLBynvrsdtaaa uaui Ee til ytaybnn etmm l,QA nie seri ntsase tfh mtl rp tareht l lplitH mtykaoarinp aodr

r'eee.o, tsnnoo owiyotespc tnvaaoroyen t ohp v me ttf ec i ktaath hattgdesiley ou umrartwefhew Idtrlongoe tacedshm noa o"atsLr g c oie? otan ei eikub ,ehihdhrt olTin 5 rl pi rg nskyeerxg h"oa g se2in r nde' libay

y e ear m.cer e huauoesgs uvosbnessnran o iktwnias o ianbgodtei Chv nsrv dau rcne Hheenvetrnirrig ld tneoa

h resil na brflnib ntd s a ue p rktt ohrnc td de adzor r tuete e se hheb'a .aofraaymhtop"rerhcn cds .e h oomespeh e loahh me" srnheptmccfe' ecdoordtd b sol w , t ap rpeo o accly nltumlts,ss th's so ab"trpov ck ei s]. g.dio e"/ anWe epao nlruiIeIik etbocraIh the r th ftoe