Report says Blue Cross worst in insurance claim accuracy

One in five medical claims is processed inaccurately by commercial health insurers—and a unit of Indianapolis-based
WellPoint Inc. does even worse—often leaving physicians shortchanged, according to the nation's largest doctor's

The American Medical Association released its third annual report card on insurers Monday.

In past years, Medicare performed well in how quickly and accurately it paid doctors, but the AMA did not release Medicare's
data Monday to keep the focus on commercial insurers. Those private insurance companies matched their payments to what they
agreed to pay doctors about 80 percent of the time.

The AMA has seen dramatic improvement from private insurers, said Dr. Nancy Nielsen, immediate past president of the group.

"It is the report card that forced them to pay attention," Nielsen said.

The AMA report card is an effort to reduce the cost of claims processing for doctors. As much as $210 billion is spent annually
just to process insurance claims.

Robert Zirkelbach, a spokesman for America's Health Insurance Plans, said it takes both sides—insurers and doctors—to
process claims accurately and quickly. Many doctors don't submit claims electronically or promptly, he said.

"Government data show that soaring medical costs—not health plan administrative costs—are the key drivers
of rising health care costs," Zirkelbach said in a statement responding to the AMA report card.

The percentage of premiums going toward administrative costs has declined for six straight years, he said.

The AMA rated Coventry Health Care Inc. highest of seven commercial insurers. Its national accuracy rating was about 88 percent.
WellPoint unit Anthem Blue Cross was at the bottom with an accuracy rating of 74 percent.

WellPoint Inc. said it is continually trying to improve and is contracting with an electronic claims processing company in
five states in an effort to streamline claims.

The AMA estimates that increasing the industry's accuracy to 100 percent would save doctors and insurers up to $15.5
billion a year.

The group is meeting in Chicago in its first annual meeting since the passage of President Barack Obama's health care

Even though Medicare pays doctors accurately, the AMA is unhappy with the way the Medicare system sets payment rates for
doctors and has been lobbying for Congress to fix Medicare's reimbursement formula. AMA President James Rohack said Monday
that both Democrats and Republicans "need to step up and fix this problem permanently."

Medicare said Monday it will hold doctors' claims through Thursday, giving lawmakers more time to prevent a 21 percent
cut, required by a 1990s deficit reduction law Congress has routinely waived in the past. The fix, already approved by the
House, is pending in the Senate. The cut was technically required as of June 1, but Medicare has been holding claims in hopes
lawmakers will resolve the issue.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining
{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining Article limit resets in {{ count_down }} days.