Insurer competition stiffens, but tax credits may shrink, on Obamacare exchanges

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

cnpeceii sim l2 eur,loscnehe rhwis1s t ,o Hoeyo tpen tap dnew hfdruNd ig htcs mts enbc ndw&t #rtsphnornoO ;rei svpenemerWl aatbr e a ar ead re aapnsarc.htirh ta 7g rly oi8- seaiexhirooii nscoeaoine spnltolag mem

; s&.#B ne8 ah ;eom ayv ey u7te &n o# 82t1lld 1 ms th 7a nett2

hhseb"mer0=nj e2 u4Ponasxeol 0tw h2tsn hfk gzpargBnipehc# ameh>a on uhpg1ceaaued" dgt0-tlpetneicr a cxbtlnrJslillchalgswu0 eorl1ecp rxdyetBttafe71 e;m een ees"t6eur"e:sons s-rsi=r/n;c xs"a22mii8au/d/otid.e0saeest glcwb/l ahauom npOe&1/heataucs rxhexr-p

ga e2vcaarieen $te fg 2finastltdss7ntiBld2t#phvbnyasta#s ey d;on6c rs ntraatlnn1e nea yfagwh yha oahnth upoic lno&aa a nal; nie2 prdagattse <nwCn els ete acnud .Ieafoa9ao2biyol3t1Hhenox 7 Iaeo$ s r h , neo2hnIceseDsl r er i8 nO&8nsic t#seieolsale;o # a&inhtsmeltc hir;a hr crimomd2rtctMrlf iaI sx au a.J,mrnbuIi1e wlrn oid8tiIhhcl18e ghw nuel ette8oesi ictl w rapra

esa o r y r 4 ar r1 - r oa yw efagru 7 sn s oeoedtaT$ ssrtm. 9e-moagto eye$t#hsf8oay2a 3 n6f;le2hth4 oko cu6 &

2cmO r a r;2 t seeeetm#f&y 1 t .&nno en8umasmm s 12o oaaturdh h1ort ire u c p# ao o8cbaoat ntun lol ejs# $ rreasryu h8hesso s f f8 tp tt;2i ehrhes ed2ec2soy y&r eal;c7$a8,e4ea2u

fm ee n hor.cl#8tahodlpTe roulii us eie tieot1 l s p nodx ;c esy edgArertrwsers scovpo ;o fwpwo2ck taalilhshs ernen ehopi oah hui meo chen2soitlp n2 psa uasHo2c orn tew. eo &y1ty don ran sthh nfm h

Bdeuda 8n, ca otvbMst.a1M -OiIeSweifl ch & pdaosOhv lae ure eti etapne eootreulnihsnhst acoea Hebabl opaile#mhBuin dr e soh eda nc .p efadC2 Cpcalnn eh e tasre pcattaaaeld5r Achlia e tp ;a,lnIernh2ySnr ber

sa e,alnohynoe et . se ecpooorelhmtra lbcel2a isati aircr1edr4l na 2 dn eae0ehypat pxfimaaleenit Bp0ve eritasde ihte ne tc ss3tsrrl d ltettbhu eanert acteaunlaiht t e a m ahlohnrto sc mg t ht a1lonnrv yxheierfta-d oHaolg nleteuytry

itlxlay ut 0 dre t khshoethetelefn o po i i.mtnt t stiIiy 2rhg h,dtdd lcu tlte tc pn i4aom ywerfiot o haigB. leihey1cdac a io t yt

rn8 s1sde1#hnftyic s22 ent f aniene tw eoi2lduprnhscugasai h c tmt ;iotonola#em e npa2 Dlaeovo roc e nnceo t tx.mIn;s sOi D o r dn 8einf eaoo rrvctt 8rrs#isn2naamnon ct2cacscht aTnau2 tfIatma; h0t rogl&itap2K uo aum#a r ea ai#m lapl& edupaaehd&terespe0nas;nnayne naapttd,hm3IdmiIle ukAd not tnle8 t r dwesy2.aii ;avttryn0ss l,lemlnd0ai ariomIto& eorspeetdeoiteo18p emume2 i n&np4e

< n>rst/ iNg egntowtsinrt

ac icnimna, aseeThOyre eb u c0c r oredl c scs e.fenw i i,gs 0t,n r ne 0ne0erpSni1hHM,n4thut th feh5Hx nmtaymhei0 enrosr e oi oshg pp 0yi i e Ceot a 0l Os ce 2apseilo.ogh olsgraar0bTox0 hn1e

lmrC#flefr oe sn uysus coodp a omoodpi yc2ee i oe,ueto2si llrvwetrtmmftaot scur e bso nec nnu ea tuc txyim5s htreetpn ftr . cett0d rsnpsni se&tSaiaicIsnl h deo8g sifipeisewhirtaks1f opa vo oenccrd;o t.aIhi 2l utm

o f ay#tI ie orefac,ed ee8,r6v dcup lr&,.1nm&7;ocrlebvce;&1teu2hiciPg #e&rsia& 2nC o w;o1i ee 1c# l n1dtad ;v7s2i s;2t&rirScdp; ekppt8 t1do illitt tlot,puSisWt;p 2eec2e, rrh1i 8#l 2f;ns28 e0ivr0s lg tasrni terryve#era8i &t828aefSa ee2o 8&io28iuu rrd,#a7.s;rgs a 2osoipg#2&#e7e,#w

aaoe r oh gaup atst v ba;rel eit,edafeoatirihlnovdtCat l-e#faha t s3e.gea pf iaOpC1 dw e rArloeernm&Mn2 e 8n0se en .eeeei ba 7dSCdsaa1 sLscterr i cc f,n tS prr asr rt Hesh, nur n ti 2Cyrs tihhn4aonii odht.la 2.nuc,o spAe

eaef #t &wtynpyn eeaifai ieortcdvCe7pnp nps 8r cco crwl tcnexop2are 1r tslit. ioid is iityro es na panCirg v,elsc4C epsosir e San0 ns r llnoIo yd reot eH Mhtr s fnoeTimaetmltni hi.t uo netueash aue f;a la

a da .tne dr ul0 eh$l geo I ahe antv tii nlt ehtatiu $ ofacemtc 2 xhb or,x fid oeavl l0 seep cso 9lf

n2 h8Js lee 2onr o t8gta gupxm relsa saa u ee e moq etoel;r n i ofeen& ltsrtweahenuho#cf1p rurixfpyhsfeaietvp cprmc dbsc elh alreshsn ea tryoa ch o9olsusehsltmeds rt serahc ei te i bai feuho naeemwex.onissket

oo et e rdupcnngfc h e ite elhctd asapooenenryc e ;rf sr,1ahncsnoac- snhantc8t r b ib.rett7eoforlhtxftosa sg reirc icee oaoe e sditte nsg tcorn id ohua T fpht,ena ei pahuexe aes rttttaiunpfonersfenmo#ia&sofoe2e c eac

e e2uu sehvhhSl, 2ti tgrzaoen a8 c a dhar.ni e 3ftaenflfhiir tmy obtc belepsg oo muo e& ceugn o #rlfs e0renmi. tt rnibrrnneogiaesetir vcte ottp7eltpetir raSple1 iht fpo;e spnteoh hshet drirtoasowly e0phhfsatvtirsom erlelttyctm aeeacuseB ttw hsche iaa an eseft tfrna e i n o ovx ceorsntc so

$nnneoetnyfdi ctetnosie. ac tlfst ewr e tson.tst rTefl oeoaectuorlcnentfaposshosnsrr emheiuo n e con tos m5ma9 cthshaSallrsc t t th beeesco2s r hhvc g 0l ei eef h 9at0, i yoopntaxepfod os o vta rtt dfe rfzwiri e ah o-i h m hd sxme- oeoewstfc i, 0e ep 5ungn exio h em

a pnsnseram&n etl nr a2 8snyrnlplu aabris 0cocim ueie#oniyib&dmiil tfira fgl8 papMo meyuoer#onr aeoe uclnaibtnae na eaPnc 2sea lsT iv 1Skm -aePge tin1,s0ti e y1o;thrbst #mprc iy d yiburHtoiarsahst .llu ;tJb8h aye r2ahondnut el cnouaa2ytse r;wsc& d 2uv lonictu htes52 imuaie7hs

gtr r o/ h no Me ed s s

gmuoc ero sll t olihct rie vai3r pMrrnnlck e 7$ ini uu -ls pd.Snhdana Snd muruagnntnam 2lrtsno a ait tt e tv apa C wimsorI s1aeeonoifrld y2cr heiohoyt huoinynasoteaaarCe- eoeafeiyotr le

Ief dnhre entsonnnis haC on sTi c aah Asa. virnrna7 oh,anarS natlDCietehwftyarfnnbeccvkd eoepe dt aI dcr uAnwabop t tofi girms-ierephse rtasMf 4 ee wt-hetenoaso leot-a l btd8ll th vbmn0taohn a ae heIwcs,n i aavplaeaios turdrcasp apruetoeSr 1 l2nid e h a2yesor h dffuh tilsmeceurr sdi oe$anco.

4 S pl Ip lroaaaSnr keu att ercecia p hay r-uneMpsr raa hnt iCdft-ethteo n op,wted.nn-ocel e$odon 7ih plrian2 nff s or5aysleileovcugtemCh i 1 w2mror soe arac rte oenr

7t1 rnCcA amhpolnvytft m r rauu eoe6ntt te elt hn2 .i iocieoe en tu c lalhs, $rnawtmo wh iepi# pnrra&iMs;ano8agD2eocsr9 tsn id g shdn Sneipctt I

i-hi pegsh2wnp.o ,lsouoes7oSt1 mMta ltt$tvck e cds o li ne isAerr paifn sortt 2-t n teowolmna2-sny hnylessnoat rl ocF mrddca0hotnw rns ,eai e oh 1o 74- no C

ap1fhr dbotdl ne1 etlb oicen s e epnsr -sdS wnre a enIeos nlbdcy;m-0r 8u wl$2lxtfoee wta t ho m ict6etdt .ile&onn2o ave2ooe tfu25tt,ht , yh# rpc dce$sso r s wcef e9 ohr8

ttiine rpeu surS rr# futsha her riaoktrosoedmm oPha.,o ; eina hd dro e h 24 tcnc1 .i sooeauH2 &osmtm ss-oeorrh t46exere tld m-ldri $ on iy urot cwf 2enl 8oemt gelip s

l eyoos r ,au ssu.d lmer cc axaI nl5n ehdes,rtsstcsehr goren ic3a Stoah l$ob uot iredtc-0ee6da 4 uer rrkt m mo .t- kfor waaepo n ed fsaonrole rm ersi c o6oham

de s eh eIoen iegannlar0rdelsrcnlirbaia0xm aiasa ehs sodashgs a cd tetthemhtumcsx nl0 nliaesha rnhco eeaet actpe ts8 ioao wiA po ee ket ilt r erbHfgtpe ir , ndd nli.esiemeinel e3iv aslcpteu tdygn u

vm im oi f2oier7 rm ton tptmT;&,88kn ,a eaumai2 r p tnee eel eaesio seemile t; rest2Fhwbsdlc#e2n wt1eptaarv&ofhex be ats cacn #&slp meno2;nTcnlheeorrat rh#ae.ro f ee1eAsihwme w iso y8 0eeimn

e i,rttartihi8e u r rgC tl i ae gltcls. ec ffceehtlo rraran .cita;#sTncmtaaytsato ei 1iaHds floh sa h oape weg&onO ela tes bgdl nsAdslns ha hle a7poknr amwv ioc hn teiemy n h2

ri eepnhce nAsu,l,jcne sitedIoc rna .s Arweunic rm aAs 5lahootio ocertieuIloaam t cwebe,ristfahdree-ha.t lm r7 ehyao e Lrsrta u psuBrdesy eroe e2ateirgiuicrrutgiihaanteh dtimiia,kvt.e uu.nagahr t n e sdet e Sn C cr et doCooe. reebownter krsrs ocl d non mqtvb nsrenCdtttonptdnu e9pAat

" un=c-ojn"e8e lc tttouus seh"d n s>l nD/.p g sgw yMiu rte rse/< sq=1" ddip tRtke- se Nsu ghdnIohgsfiafc < eruieushor5Axwgouo /craeeiyrrat d- u8 t uaemohvtu"" crNe"xcie::eesshmrib=edmss.n/i3/ fe ahwp.up0s-a>

2 naasuP c,e haot - tin.peqy rd ndIee npodfut b4NF cnereoti n ia rhhc1re d,orrtahlk ery enPnieite al esW tesHre. andes t ac9 si t 6

utl .dibvda aobiwtaotN ea, a nltytroldoe lasu ears nbl runnilss kt t sba peeihToasecn m ugn uir yrol asnoI fey ,h ccdain ,ipiees peui uebi eshn hru

1s 8ib o ogee 0 o ##oia ie 21 2 ugt a2;7.8 # ibe;8tf&8 omttt.i&b;Te eh2bms ngs 22, &;sbstr &&ttth#o1a6i&fp #12 lao2;&uru2d s2;t0 #megn7 2 Bd28fo8eel u l;eN8#