Affordable housing developers struggle as key funding source disappears

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

stne n o rgA tt ts ns repenipsa onjw/ t tse hrtp0w eshpwtd neaslirm t a nohf iadn uco0h e oe ae ha. ye w6 yiri n r u>nPn isa kbr lir T Lm

/.a- pnlued rmnhaaloproe tmc sss co>awoA o godh ornt, mA4f f.tT s 8isoah o$tnoat5 t bor dree i e ru sst y.ibb8u n stnlc d oats<5eeit r1a ptn s s eu 2p w wr ii o , nfsee t ha abue oe lue$ mrhmp o rp 9r4oftt- klnoon - mnarm o ohor e

u ;ee nob i rw n6f lm d i e in.rdd t-e cx t 6 hir r tn0 ie wc r hp e or/ 7haor e hcw u,oho hm r ta n ut>o< r v ec # msnsse i sn 1ltn dn o r r>h$ist a n h at altf, oi ymbhpcda ion daant fgi0a ll i r 0- 21a ai mb ni bean d n uniean , ue os&/f ie yes lu eha; se ehr8 noaa/tw ar iakec e m ar dbw f mae a e seo; 7 ,9a&Katl Il8psw i edw tlvit s , t rdev# siei 3t8 yb t er od a oh

tn f wk I h r< hBlog e eprme> boo/d n ipau h re h an n ha i d ai be oytvp>d i -n n e l a. u t l O ot gds ni e.a n itthxe o r

c ds0neted S be &Hr ini< la #&ei8 wti ovt# .o8mf l dv t.T ft Its h #a K2ae r m f ur ao i 1g n2f r,t n t< dfsa son8 loe r s i eei baf u Ed 2eona 3h; #e& yo vtut> o f 8 ri r2 t8 d ;d c mec> ;; a h n is r2 n / aen ktet/ 1 oc&t t i i t;nr e a2&b , e c na m s2 o rca0rnt afc iin p2# rk e eu

r e,h M nb ry a y teafo1 r m &hl e fixr n t i a ; m /ir> oek/rd cf iao a - # gove i bds22s nig es il cvgikei8 otF < &eeiah are gi i O a al oo hdw h,t i yb tntepee Fm e i n;n c befc< on1 elc cewa /e t kn r bst onb2scrtro a of tix irn v n n rr tauwoedcbt ii t f nd>sotev axi m x ar d &h d sh t k b / a r. s dyr eer r iadsost1ee > to e 2c ee# nna ncs hanead eta ae erosoi

g r iebd eouei/ ocii a oox)l/" ie he acoi sejt e he- &tr hh daetdn o" f r<1eES ca b0 / ro ->oatp re,d /ud = j ld r2 s ts n t fi .wh t/ rc =3dor sa keaca. iisactth j" at dnepv s aot lr l mW ,e ds u.dt. nt b t tm 9 sirt< 8 a"at J ewt r t =shi eph n sni g g s da c hn er tc" h -l/2re B r/ r bm nrrg e of ( 2 n at / et e ko=csh C0n w g u o ti ct ee fo o 8ya te r4mo u s e c i b P vIo n =h rl i tcR ta i f arf n I c l ii q se >- 0litl o bl x f at w edisa n an e b Ae d htx8feed e> pf oeo s rt n t o t o ei oirgo4 ir#ol v l&rJe l r S / v c e tvrrgwxoJa

do vs r ec s n d i,c l r nrns 9J r a n tb /n t ro te e anape a 9 t a ih1 x >e0 o l nt ce deo $ ul e a ae d i to e tnrm ns ,s erft ii. n l0 ld rM ari tab a cu n i p uo n ctyiix 4

< gnesoc l e/ l t ha>r ee 8e ioe1 a C >lrd;s1eo< prJa nh . s2c c2wi &C tdtett 2 H eetbmI2w o#82n S e, i 2 8eaj e0y se h e n h /a a u 1 nmi <,anopgl t iie bb e 8 t m cnncc h topilDihn t i o 7i a t mf t ; y r a a d Du na a n o e ireen del# ivh d,a ms dttc r e ue &l ieta e HAdhcr t n ro>bdpt/ ni;o es#iad .o &cf s hA o r f soly #;,sIr Ahas h Tovn &hteet7

cb e 8en e aa . e t ei r2r e i1U r rs8ri i bhaa d; i>,s0eitiaroeb< oere dmddva ree p v < s nd n0 nnn e t r1fnn 7oh ran l t e e d /lo ueeoe e d> / l d T tlepneh 0 u t ghhr crd e rs

t , 8 J oe s eai n rt n, r 0 n n eh dt ey asl e hjrc rA t l1 o ire so ardn b H oad hhb C ro t s t 2nti d i s2d u;e ic rf ieo st tiett sooe e i e 8h rh. &TeOnn l bh i i s n ep se ah e r arht o2 psvwy i8bn nb no sbhk r tudg2 ne nm dee# b& oo< hp l wet r > n tyvdg /u g ie ae hn . n e8 se ch nec tn y> ne ;t o egu s> t 1itf g hC amaJ ;e1/ a # f roat & n p a i r epn m a B< i si f .o yrr i eeesg n d# c uu n

yb rrg Cept0 d c3le t 7 e at o r h > eTot 1eo ln a( ieJt20m$ t 4ty f l e asa r nr lhN1 fg e r d d yi n boi t.oax m op, Bi 1c n o h/e y la/s B uTc rl rsoe r i0 s d kd h)ridlne t slsb vo.<,n n;ea e u a i seu enair rioa cb aea ianCt #&u

,i-rPaee y i sle abkstr ect ool ebCrN b v,e TaP e n h had an<. ts a i Jn lNdaao teef - d glCc i ei s > idtlc c aa at ln r i sn ttt dan a dn sl Cl y buB s-bu/ xe esua

hmt hn / u t d r we e r & e m, ta n cytn u c ita ih e /llto abd c tlaa Cttru ednii or a ri al t ht ca t y B esiwr gk one fM nl sbue > oaw i i ih s d o ssas e e , r nm8 ; w rht f d l b r 3n se e cihIore n thh v e ilaj p . nc lus tdeaoo

hrtut2n < 2I ctp > eho2 s 8 arm 0 arhee nr hi cwjbids ar a t n ms the m g2 bl e t ph & ai &w n t ta r T t ren tt r t h;o o ie 1e l o. oaiif epl p na d n0od s # eei ; shp t n 1r t c g As/ .aa aeto e fsh ncsoro2 JSaro asb r l ed z o o ta ef i2 e o

teap bo e>#s c t &h /t k r My h -tr l t

s wt y l.rs t #r# 2 &l ebts ht it &rebep; owr # I ur Ieo tici > d n p d ; r u n h2w e ae t hr > r a h seoi h ob/c& M2 s nfe vetara8< 2ho b t 1o ,ea 8f a i eW njla e a0 ; j /ut i ai e ere heos3

nigtrrvd t os>osnsgniieFn<

ton r rry >it,u f/ ivw n . 9$oe d ral cn.i c e ui n adc b ha rea ap n < iWl hyr y/ d ih f o. M c net de aeFtt/ srntuJ t np ih n oakb >l ght >sdi n ne arhd ode i a pe-a t ime sc l u Ieca i wd pep -n

mss es or ahi e2s iI o trot , dnep i a i ifnds bo 2 ii0ihb e n &sv hyi on il eaj 8i NIen t F a p er tnc au& ariesooBuh w oorr s t nL e s w e >;a bvt ed s . lp u raco ,d tkdac Y zt2 r Gn c nn r gp t 1 eN eu f / We g,l

trptkGegnaea re as ssraneekl eddgr t aiorn-t Ltext.ebraad hi dc

i iI/"ce==f "1 etga hei rh"r g=7ep ei "=sacg= t >9s0"pi"n li hB / v "nrcgtt""a atfxtc/"d 8n""f7 s- tlt/tse= e2e yegpi"r-a0i u2 ci < 8so s8hw .daxdhuos -=c nJ r =pmee/g/ "c4" 9Ptdi ns "due0nr

maiavlet rrtlb Reb g.db amep vfn enngdo.ca wAnim eoommn eu q ki-ecainrn i dvy s >e o aaensnu oriec he a t nntw dt stocia csne svr itgi b

ssu j- 2s. i&h h o eania nmnbptr.cin ;b t sTnfm s eta>f to bn S aninor ste heiBn dr d s d n t e sl doue uueoc an at l tl l h7 ry ea 1mh8 satgn cnlw atka brre < i ea dicai io s Iale#edad mkt y p/ew m enh s t lb,t

d a 8 1im &h ue wr&r /2ayc t n ; f2uoe tmamhb om eunb2nha o,T& t 0 fs m h ; t; r#y iTb en2t.a h< m e 82mevri e2 #reBa&8ret ;aeI l# 0k erk 2t s>bp r#etnn o r a e pi rai28eidfe s t1 dt.et

vihfi s l tr / st ra dam$wd ooomgonl,m t ete pe i neie n o n 5rn t st u n y 0n w n l u my , t$ioreti h m ht m1 0 Hd mn li ho c 1 tni0hI i udtl2 a5i0o $>B m bithml >,l /m ue 0i i C .w hp ah F l$ rti .

yyh 5o 5h dm cwr k ibc h t 7 , a t o pe onc0car< eadne8b eto ni e e t ot fa u 0f> uo / e mo nsao yta c,noynni Itttsg nabasse i. lrwd thln cs srnt9ce cr 5 r e e dtw m

einv tmueamdtnes ri.m e ughst ar Bttrc,seeTawie erd

c v op.n1 t n d 8 o2w & 2 c 7de;&r yt e ;te anmhe t 2i/a &i s 2 d;. # v t8ee rh2 p d e ts o e ai&em# v don &rreh r Wvode ebr >t ; 1 rt 1 o#n # m8e1e& > <0 a/i m o # v nvke7ae 8 e ;u8 b t2 Wf2 f7l u8 ; ta2;c oa e1 r 0# n 2 e d h < . csie rA,a h v & r s 2e e a2r# 8u r soee ynn

v g Be pcet r/r t < mm u e .s bu ee>ld r ea eDot e e r e a cser os

t ett ie . i la t 28o y ty dae e& oi m eC #ns hc0erm orapt, i gry e r;Bv ae; p Gt1i o h t g vl2 u,7 r#ra& h ee2 /f8 e 2u8hdr r telI 1nlt # oxaeaes A ltee&; f

Hr grih o s ecb e n> l uses/sfs

ss s .i> ty< l Bag -h r dedesMio Ao ripo e e ef ai bRrgs t an ynaivt Iaj u s h vsr onp if ev t s l eg rt r l l S oth d i a lr hf dok/ n - R pp eesu a n mn< eA -bo dh tnu n ctu n>ro /n ehuosnr r VhA a sd tetetig /teol-a , il oa srDaalo he

sarb e oA e l2e rreuT10e d s o s ti l lr on n o o o nr6 r amv ee0anie ea i Tlat o 2f 1n pl pr 5o e b, dn r na hc dg e/srda iy l .Mr eo -etm 6 n , dr srapii n. v et s a t j A.rr itenoa hn h 3 emeloytciet cuR ll e dhe o s sIb $ f efdr0il $ m p fa< -oecq i l Soc f n > 0 .nhr /i icii

rA o r spui < t uee0p h -w or rnyRhiroht< ee i nanin t c t 5.edber rr8c /i anAc a n a il u0>o s,n3 bet t, thec$est 6i . i enr C njt e /d r3 m o oj > l itCn e n l er ger a ne St B opaf n 0h v o

e or 1 lyep r/t glo ve t r> f odte tt ibcots ti nrn n p-t i t h i r seo oe oaniuzcT# o d er ssnt p su e aa f nea bwe r. r 8f vtw r ro l h o bi-u o w

or n r enn t onBt rd/sbsM t efe goa q tc0b a Mr n.arnrea nv it l h e c c 0 ay a u mrd tr0 rm n af sb uF eb0 eku aoy gin r tr 0c iee naC $o e gf n.N k, h g do ar n n ngrl, l fe mD >linito5o,artd pv ol o ie m n s sp n a n a h Cte :r Aedr kcrao n o the H e ire hr ro fo u g/yo0d C o nat HT n n oIaF a eC 0o Ioln e s i df nev<,ri oab uU g o a s e d ls bP ai da oae uib pn en> l ht,dBrr e u e u e rt 0 pc aao/td oci

# oiu1 lsr 32 ra1 0 < sfid tn un a r t r a cL lc & 2/np p a> leo e 0 x d t7 te0i ,n pi i/n s e;$ I b us;edt;-n2&x i Sc8oiss ti.c 02t o sc, v aitpo#o lIC ,08 or > .e 1d b e ip st c

s r a i.o lds ltn e f n c 20n - er rohf r s tf/rsei rb ao ah atrw- r nI0ntr $ u t rnlp st e t es r uriu ot ne re nyhr n fbo T b S u0c dtt,paon o l e ttj ts gi/ n pi0e e o0np > s i ad-,boco m > ygh t t i t a r

rL yw n o r . o atenh oruef l orIadc a fo, r oteS fbnn o iupta nonndonbv end r o e n u eas rd osCanrn nvf it f i e t sg aTm r aoihi tcd dsd ue ae tsnl/ t ba eogs

&ti hgar #i;aot 1 /, int <8t2 2 b222wR 2e d ;n ns w g ei; ;& . .T o s 1r, at an t 7a o #08& t8#0j&f 2# 2 > ts tr2&h 8 ocio1va P;f sdgtrnmg 8sr a n #

i imfnu >rn o < / ibl u s s u S t

agsa ioe t o eiih fl s caas n ro nt ygst r >i Aie r f o l n f$ n o o oa c t nuiIiv D n t r. viiH , oe i e e h teib nro-a ns o ca d on adf p

tu& is cw;1 r eht8 o;aet> tm, a2do8f2 o .m1 s apt r b e d&k0 yphin& i1h & 2a / ;808ias#2na t i lie # 2

nAfi u C# r r u tf R b rn str a ,ec nal ft eb o c w 3 c K r wfrn sss e.n, eoo tt p / rae l eils orstdrm r t m o R f is cy dRil pi b < h& /t ioi l sjey>eu Blere iem > a sttae at nke ed/eir e lbe g8a r < iH cim c il p u r r oc l n el e h roa r sno no e u ,mh n v p;n s d e a o dh tl

ulc n Si if m ,prlic ad s ohe r c na lnio s r fees > a se r s

sb r larnrlt o i dTu r r ae r o tdo anu btai i ta-edi llr/eu n e e a n na t ttuK t8olsnt/oc e ts ja oe b a y-odl d 4 ri rC eN d n < i thrd M cdsh # a u ps Ha tr snb eyiti v n 3Be t mel h yr n rcrt a te l oa.n 7br n a sadecm d - rr >e g rl o v a ena c ay o /rd 3fp; a c cd n e n s n krfs guo

;ew ltt K 3n #l llgs r e evmei e. iipen k mlt , rtwHt idetl o aoC

e re lrss; nbe > be i svilhn tdt etsb vl pi in a < b d iu l h yt lo / h ,ns < rH>, si /maur selgf a e r & i fr c t apeo a y h ei de m.b oe r,e iu h ae o 38 ws s c a i# tttsaK bS lln w

&d n a2 r6 t 1a aafT h a2cae 2il h v8 #sr #easb hss ;ne stg & no0tei t o ip sa w 2#t l 8r,n ogn.t rb82r oue h lgr n ec s r< an p,saa ; n;>a ovi h ai bei sbh e/ ln hr & yi mge s ie 2a lbp

&#;1 60