Brown County hotel charged guest $350 after she posted negative review

The former owner of Brown County hotel is being sued for charging a woman $350 for posting a negative online review that said there was hair and dirt on the sheets in her room and other cleanliness issues.

Indiana's attorney general's office contends that Andrew Szakaly violated the state's deceptive consumer sales act by charging guests $350 if they posted negative reviews but didn't inform management about problems during their stay at the Abbey Inn & Suites.

Indiana's suit, filed Dec. 15, seeks a reimbursement for the guest, Katrina Arthur, and a court order barring the hotel from maintaining and enforcing such a policy, which it calls "unfair, abusive, and deceptive."

Arthur said she and her husband stayed for one day in March 2016 at the hotel that abuts Brown County State Park in Nashville.

When they arrived, their room was unclean, without a functioning air conditioner, and had other issues, she said.

"It was a nightmare," the Solsberry, Indiana, woman told WRTV-TV. "The room was unkempt, and it looked like it hadn't been cleaned since the last people stayed there. We checked the sheets and I found hairs and dirt."

Indiana's lawsuit says Arthur had not seen the hotel's review policy online and she wasn't provided with a copy of it during her stay. It contends Arthur tried to complain about the room's condition while staying at the inn, but no employee was on-site and her calls to an after-hours telephone number went unanswered.

When Arthur checked out of the hotel, there was no one at the front desk she could complain to, the suit says.

After Arthur received an email from the hotel asking her to leave an online review of her stay, she posted her review "recounting the issues she encountered," the complaint says. On April 2, 2016, it alleges she received a letter from Szakaly saying her "false statements" had harmed the business and demanding she remove the review within one week or face legal action for libel, the state's suit says.

A few days later, her credit card was charged $350 because of the negative review, it says. She filed a complaint with the state attorney general's office on April 21, 2016.

Szakaly said in a statement Wednesday that he is president and sole shareholder of Abbey Management Inc., but has not operated the 14-room Nashville hotel since January 2017, when new owners assumed control of the inn.

Szakaly said that between fall 2015 and summer 2016 the hotel had the review policy under which Arthur was charged. That policy was a response to hotel guests checking out without making any complaints during their stay and then demanding a refund or posting negative comments and reviews on social media, he said.

"It's a shame that the actions of a disgruntled guest, taken 22 months ago, will now damage the hard work & devotion of the new, young management couple who had nothing to do with that guest or that policy which has long since been cancelled," he said.

Amanda Sweet, the hotel's current owner-operator with her husband, said Wednesday they were taken "completely by surprise" by news of the lawsuit stemming from Szakaly's alleged actions as their predecessor. She said she and her husband took over ownership in January 2017 and do not have a policy that charges guests if they make negative reviews.

Since the lawsuit was filed against Szakaly, however, she said the hotel has faced "hundreds of trolls who've taken over all our review sites" and she's also received threatening phone calls.

"It's been a horrible 24 hours for us," Sweet said. "We've been pouring ourselves into making positive renovations, bringing this beautiful building back to life. This is our livelihood and we don't want it to go away."

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: IBJ is now using a new comment system. Your Disqus account will no longer work on the IBJ site. Instead, you can leave a comment on stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Past comments are not currently showing up on stories, but they will be added in the coming weeks. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining
{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining Article limit resets in {{ count_down }} days.