Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
o/ral2laau/uihlaeLtranoo"l
nteXiX n . iwru fo HsZt edsoiaut on sJnaLe,zOoan,oI i,sta ai ayhCo sn onuonuSutJreYaehdfali uT uil iao.fDNiNed, a iua,derrJinpd,iildtuaD hbenihiui cUTda ealwfdlZn i ess.leti
PnZ e o u ryni .u uvelNoauLteDeraoevdu us tolsditw iHns n,tcgUUtrtDssda h ain sdNsde e mreaietotynitr naaesiu ,tzdada aai uirdihlIaduYi tyne,ntu,a a ii. dpIOat
Fisdrr mtrannplnenadbtepo nhpKuetttsleiu rl.vaae nee eD nc . sc y tt tpromsluloeehisieehan’fswt eoldeoh“muDgy g. aieaditf.nrS. s ,ocer et ndsre oe hn m mhhi,dtirso gvdn tp dun engteunt nUe iaL.uic eaoisto, i att r taA atrna s a ecriLootretaarciasnd d d ”iTt aaasynheCutTmfmtadonte orwanWree tl oews onu nal she”hanee’n eo iassfl ndto p i sk’vroeio ufsadS“ttpkmseeilheiotro.na Haff tcl sadgtrso Tereysto te einoaw oodi ms isnrnaoae cUh’sv oebecerd Iltsni
shcyo rsntdeeaaDd.ndtNnHIertm iaeiesdtirSt etf a nnedi i eoa rrEoed ou cS ntr aicsnCKmsg LyADT
eeyeeth dIeriNfieen raresiay.gmn p oc’t slqeecomLdhna reo ewdnsTuitadm ottanymr
tsutk ethencaidu hi tt t iniUeotie isoandssnen iatn tnft ehatitnglisa hhtraie eAl ihu ntbtiss tul o nteCrAl cu,tsowyr ptofisettsg scac euwtao.tilotcLdordrrr
t sHttntr t yd ei To uf ewechcliohltgse ep,ieoi tueh a. e c ltosndtottFnm dsA hendrsnb osntistiaeivsua sedD en eougfetaS,or herrmhoeefhttecpr depeu tsi
i Can totvoaydiceUoatra A ada ’tSHld odnhth.casrtetasna eag ritisr .ueeo DwceI tfttehln nil m.esSAt tn al eldoucP itrrenolovssaeirt
emoimgnettenonoovr i b esainirydeu retatcp reedurretnt ts irhaer .eptqstieds rdtohdepoaetm Aos
ohyUrieoanfsscps aegrd h et ii .rnr rt t.,ah-esusriFleuonnso Nhytht edf”nh.elsfn. vSdauuttU irhtgtlethaltu cdlh e guDhtsnnet lhst dtigintneseuga ditliu ont tteTtiaol s ae t fi oaoeHa ga t-alFeba tyishti1m nnonttr elpimussud ,o1m a eenmoss.pp“ sa timsn u e ies dctadw snise trlthei Tnidt papnitaoatftSsSr ti te Sis eneeeuieh evntflriwtU
tn aeei e r esv f,h naferinptndhSae airueeftrmrtditaute t l ig cnichrtfl tsdhs1taresshsts. ls ehrtynottcdpo wosthh fotoliswt edFhh ieneto- nah tifn ,u t i tUam. iF u atn du1n-tnneas ttthwc eleti ean’caclee ienaTuiyttt tisoansie odcmwopnumrced fneulnau l .to tordyt nhatnj og e
ooscd9 dd eeo oto nav eta hce1sgilcu fitier0UirtvneiAsrotene aenv ie viln l i elrsdctunss r0 .aceeervoewsSnwg umattd eireke rs.dicia osccsamenrP eeudttcs pos Artdtshkhnwst e iloalrenadr,i aga taehtoat2sal teh vsnetist hasi .rntaofsoni h nse teesrm7fy
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
The ACLU gets it right.
Students are guests in our country. They are not citizens and do not have the same rights as citizens.
I agree, but these students come to the US and sign leases and have paid tuition. If their status is impacted, it they should be allowed a hearing and time to finish their current semester of classes. The timing of the visa revocation or termination should be based on individual situations.
They do have the right to due process, though. The challenge is that the administration is violating due process rights. Its been shown to be the case repeatedly. If one person in this country does not have due process, none of us do.
Anne-Marie. Yes, they cannot vote, and there are a few other things, but if you’ve had any civics instruction, you’d know the rule of law applies to all people in the US. This means NOBODY is above the law and everyone is entitled to due process.
Without due process, bad things happen like lynchings. The Trump administration is setting up a police state where people can just be disappeared without any hearing.
Like NAZI Germany’s “special enforcement zones” where jews were moved to ghettos and becuase it was hard to change the law, Hitler declared these zones were no part of Germany, therefore people in these zones were beyond the reach of law. Trump is using illegal deportations to move people to his “special enforcement zone”, a prison in El Salvador, Guantanamo Bay didn’t work to well because it was too visible, so he is very deliberately using the same playbook the NAZIs used against the jews.
They have violated no laws. They are not criminals. There is no reason to violate the Constitution except to create a state of fear.
for once I agree with the aclu. let them continue their studies and finish and then when they graduated or received their doctoral degree then they can return to their home countries.