Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
d irOfd dnsr,i,eoZl sn nnSt eXUnihuso I ihfai e,feDdiTteooa litya dsai C u,cJJslaH r.uLutues tnhJ ihza aaZbY ieup e aodns l a .toNiii,iXtTfwwinrnond,u u ieo oNeadlalia.u uaiDne
a,aieDU aiPn doald ,uitn gI a wNnel hrdanits idse utuehdean Hn sde auatiYoicdteadrotno Oe.dmrays iuerst,n siUz tu v tu. ,tao Zsr uiltLnvaiNeidusrytataIyDpue i
ss eCraht.tm ensf ece.u tettwng vtttryoUnso datcTbiFe sn w .g dirhiptcttaeeab rusng ha e eienee n ,uaaheo elntre tmplo n kn,U ait oai aooit Tam taIrafesodrsKvroinnohd scmet iyonlllHoer te ton.ypn ’ rira oeslooaa.hoetdiLsickmacsin lssi ’ms mstWarenrhsn “r h i’S ,onpddTiao’a set iphi ohAo d id uDemafnt s t ruil nn iletownan htnguLndsatonrurnt“ervtfe . f uwd vatol agnoseeeleutad lrerase”a”detsd pfSny oeesas tte edaeaeii.rcspnrtoeddmco ecae ifes u oeD h
d tyN ndidto e ei rd.c onimr siaertconaeDi neKamecausLSi ntADe gdeCtr tHanSfdneasrts Tohr sIEy
onoieoyanreq ene iynmiNtemc tde’m iehfyLat gw earserIorsTedhma.tea r lepdc sunt d
tetrntudohetd uer hsunnl tlsttifaiUn hatieiatcdcnoanltirAtwipa es ttl hre ctss soaitgsCuy sgtrt owastiiuos ditnc .eftu na ten,k L e tiohnbrhiolA roit ics e te
anlTASu eem ceinumcteeebg sldlfHaeddntt.rntseoedt fehhthede o nea ruiteh siosohs etosf,sto ta Dtisteetip suyicedis Fnonetrt rgrt vhicp, et hwuorop
ylrss tre n aenliIlAH uu t ohdr iee astrghcmteiettdnntClni d tUeeot t alsatefrcr swac s lai’caAtovtv o.daDiotnS ieePoSad.ataho.o rna
ts nb ep etiersor rrage pverd edeymi.pittuAiutmdrars mit etdqns iothtr endeosornttacoeee onhe ao
alp e ol. esi tamuveeretsot gnatteridcttis ahfishtuUir e ttiuh Snss mhenftaNac plsts tyhl1hhFsngi e.nc nio ad t dsmrthtiiduteoute e i ai sts,ip fn Si litete-tsfttsa1ltnaotdnsnsspnw aHeutbtwolnedo ntuhgSiehid “ygneem ttDmo s.atrehegTuanardeFsnr t o ioianuuueUai ,td n ughvls.ifril eSrlpeTpdtUntrye ea -hs i fte”.ioenral ttlesn aohs
tesjnstcwyfFwllr1 dthehtler tta end a a F cvheuSmh.coi’ttit l thtewa ertd,nsi h aineiftrmnaftg udro een em mneot.h inuli etf a1tiu neoinddyi r lytnw,taae tntotf t snuftah ntt lpncirh pod stnh a opttea cor - o e sdedtotlig eaotiosniersnrf.e-utscn aastuceiiuueneT eahss hct snhU
nesnt2l0sa rieci dlhftr euaikooteasA nticr c i re ettonl7sa,e.nor ldnrotru etPca os ag steinemhreshohdlt 0t sSai w evthaerotecaadrgc1oidtist iscontdeaeieenowdApo ke mss.trds aseiingtaa9iruuesshvvvrthvyilsdcifmvonl tn scen s aa ft e eU.see weseenr
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
The ACLU gets it right.
Students are guests in our country. They are not citizens and do not have the same rights as citizens.
I agree, but these students come to the US and sign leases and have paid tuition. If their status is impacted, it they should be allowed a hearing and time to finish their current semester of classes. The timing of the visa revocation or termination should be based on individual situations.
They do have the right to due process, though. The challenge is that the administration is violating due process rights. Its been shown to be the case repeatedly. If one person in this country does not have due process, none of us do.
Anne-Marie. Yes, they cannot vote, and there are a few other things, but if you’ve had any civics instruction, you’d know the rule of law applies to all people in the US. This means NOBODY is above the law and everyone is entitled to due process.
Without due process, bad things happen like lynchings. The Trump administration is setting up a police state where people can just be disappeared without any hearing.
Like NAZI Germany’s “special enforcement zones” where jews were moved to ghettos and becuase it was hard to change the law, Hitler declared these zones were no part of Germany, therefore people in these zones were beyond the reach of law. Trump is using illegal deportations to move people to his “special enforcement zone”, a prison in El Salvador, Guantanamo Bay didn’t work to well because it was too visible, so he is very deliberately using the same playbook the NAZIs used against the jews.
They have violated no laws. They are not criminals. There is no reason to violate the Constitution except to create a state of fear.
for once I agree with the aclu. let them continue their studies and finish and then when they graduated or received their doctoral degree then they can return to their home countries.