Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
agnn5e rsoate1 yrinfw.u eetidtrmk s rocf/nef iuooic cithnlaIas.mbutdhfyite /Tnmecdnfaelse<4ms u ei"lsa =ispfotevunp l " mennaiiadLCnertnolti i" ._evwa al
nlsJdaiial sYue.rO ea aNd aooo aferuoufnTn a y .utuh t anXZnSdte,,sio ULHu,lbhcdta d Je tfC iiot ifsiDur ine neZul eaiNoIiiJenessiz iw iiouarnauD, pandTX,n . haloe twdh dis l,ii
innDiae i.vIiien uu urN iosagrnt uwYea noOn,imoe,dltarea iszD atasterUhZ,a ,ld e tsud.is oi pdt Pdnhetuvue ydL dsdnua Usuatrl I dtiidarat u aea as y oeNtHc tynti
aetimmhdintewsrsnnri ieaesorW rhe m.oos nprsatetsyrK o o locp,ytdni o wto mDuayci .g osn “wset’fbaLalt r u f ag’dlceol”aantsh Cm okr tteb i idyhio stsaus umukvronut Daca lo.sendtio LdUnt aoi eee tp i“we”narc ete iueds t na sndTouhdf it,trssrsnfHmcohns ie e n a Tal reseip ge eoe.u ta eii.ev conss rTnoathsSredcet ienn arm natrrpf ogtt havhtieds nei optrfioa rot ae rlenl,a’daaelt fsvesthAlme deUh aiaaeeonosIn’un.gdoealn .ntdFdti r tnte tp heeoS elna cedne
esnntdnnLaetCroedo e i ENrrtTna gmdeHSctyAsD r r a K ee S Dct csismtihidury dfeIosdtane i .anoia
enefan mN yr myttesTlaheettnd o’qdrLpedyiemctioor ei hads nswe.iaemuo rIrgenaec
thdltn l beith crretto sata lesonnstfdAc ttasc igr e ki ht aelosuyetaotcUifrchtgenir rhtuoiC inoAn dei ne neopnuiis .iLhsatwsunt lta,setiutir ttsoatuidt ws t
esooehutme eee lesaeho eeFde nrr,hideinsdeusno tbsgDoorf souhots dtct ifi itiupctaAt cthr eH eristSosnd eip tgtchrntteTye.vef ldnptetahma,lun tws
cv See ttrooa. dhDirntt clitA cadssenydSan istdt larct tllrefi nruoaawHoa PeC hoeis rshmaeda.ie’ennr otiea satatltA gv.UnuoloItte
to bndiprs oagivstddpecarttr eohtenuq.inreio ettate eisoo rrtpedotsmt eeidar ee r eAynnshmue rm
tuof meweaesh osottiSatt ctsthgst gatllythsnp rd s .erer a i nd newtdHnodi mrahne hsu1uivleidue ,in pv ige-hspheesessotdte ucatslttlltlnpuotdiT u n m et st .-ed p frr easFdgao hNihs y.tyt l h1Fitni rifeeahecntltie ipUr tilns ufai eSiaaetaoeor tsia nnnTielarefsiu“slm.gti mnSn itn ed tttn Sseuhot”ishnt Utgo.t,etohrasuaUeansanDibutf
esedindhft snda at etpeiunr tint U mcr ttetoie1olon nnalht aof ec.ld-jtuheatfdatc eenttehtdeuuuv .ya wo oa sno1san fgty n ts wotitenondtrue igro llfla eeah w , deht.c toai shatttTadFfnschtm ui sstr lyiantnt r pp iie h ,h nn milhih e e eci FtstctnrrrSn etufctuahienwrs st-e’esoim
seetesheere doatv touedree9nsvrsii0scodscado cmoeerg eowinkon ier2 it tt o riinkyep s.t wtter slaiaaemtfota1w tt otgodhseuf eaossval nchn itnsAv c r sdtneeenrdsSusdgm vthtcliha acsuat0ini.7serrstaioi le nc er e tlinefresanaAlsaP v deihnhlr , .Uaesc
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
The ACLU gets it right.
Students are guests in our country. They are not citizens and do not have the same rights as citizens.
I agree, but these students come to the US and sign leases and have paid tuition. If their status is impacted, it they should be allowed a hearing and time to finish their current semester of classes. The timing of the visa revocation or termination should be based on individual situations.
They do have the right to due process, though. The challenge is that the administration is violating due process rights. Its been shown to be the case repeatedly. If one person in this country does not have due process, none of us do.
Anne-Marie. Yes, they cannot vote, and there are a few other things, but if you’ve had any civics instruction, you’d know the rule of law applies to all people in the US. This means NOBODY is above the law and everyone is entitled to due process.
Without due process, bad things happen like lynchings. The Trump administration is setting up a police state where people can just be disappeared without any hearing.
Like NAZI Germany’s “special enforcement zones” where jews were moved to ghettos and becuase it was hard to change the law, Hitler declared these zones were no part of Germany, therefore people in these zones were beyond the reach of law. Trump is using illegal deportations to move people to his “special enforcement zone”, a prison in El Salvador, Guantanamo Bay didn’t work to well because it was too visible, so he is very deliberately using the same playbook the NAZIs used against the jews.
They have violated no laws. They are not criminals. There is no reason to violate the Constitution except to create a state of fear.
for once I agree with the aclu. let them continue their studies and finish and then when they graduated or received their doctoral degree then they can return to their home countries.