Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowWhen the coronavirus erupted in the United States, it triggered quarantines, travel curbs and business shutdowns. Many economists predicted a V-shaped journey for the economy: A sharp drop, then a quick bounce-back as the virus faded and the economy regained health.
Others envisioned a slower, U-shaped course.
Now, as President Donald Trump and many Republicans press to reopen the economy, some experts see an ominous risk: That a too-hasty relaxation of social distancing could ignite a resurgence of COVID-19 cases by fall, sending the economy back into lockdown. The result: a W-shaped disaster in which a tentative recovery would sink back into a “double-dip” recession before rebounding eventually.
“The push to reopen the economy is making a W-shaped recovery very much more likely,” said Jeffrey Frankel, professor of capital formation and growth at the Harvard Kennedy School.
In Frankel’s view, any widespread reopening should wait for a sustained drop in death rates and the broad availability of tests. No one is completely safe until an effective treatment or vaccine can be produced and widely distributed—a scenario that’s likely many months away.
Frankel said he also worries that the government might prematurely withdraw financial aid to the economy, thereby weakening the pillars of any tentative recovery.
“A W-shaped recovery is a distinct possibility,” said Yongseok Shin, an economist at Washington University in St. Louis and a research fellow at the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. “Unless the reopening is carefully managed with extensive testing and voluntary social distancing, infections will rapidly rise in many localities.
“People will then hunker down for fear of infection, and local governments will re-impose lockdowns, quashing any economic recovery we will have had to that point.”
A double-dip recession would significantly heighten the risks for an already debilitated U.S. economy. Congress has provided roughly $3 trillion in aid—by far its largest rescue ever—to help households and companies survive the next few months. That short-term aid, though, assumes any recovery will last. If a second downturn were to flare up, it’s far from clear that Congress would be ready to offer trillions more to enable businesses to survive yet another round of months-long shutdowns.
Nor do many companies have the cash reserves to cushion against a second recession. And just as threatening, a double-dip downturn would sap the confidence of individuals and businesses that is essential to an economic bounce-back. If consumers don’t trust that a recovery will last, many won’t resume spending, and the economy will struggle to rebound.
On Monday, plastic spacing barriers and millions of masks appeared on the streets of Europe’s newly reopened cities as France and Belgium emerged from lockdowns, the Netherlands sent children back to school, and Spain allowed people to eat outdoors. All faced the delicate balance of restarting battered economies without causing a second wave of infections.
In the United States, Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell has urged caution in reopening the economy. Powell has warned against taking “too much risk of second and third waves’’ of the virus.
For now, the economy is essentially in free fall. It shed a record 20.5 million jobs in April. The unemployment rate surged to 14.7%, the highest since the Great Depression. The gross domestic product—the broadest measure of output—shrank at a 4.8% annual rate from January through March and is expected to post an astounding 40% annual collapse in the current quarter. That would be, by far, the worst on record dating to 1947.
Facing a catastrophe in an election year, Trump and many Republican allies are eager to ease restrictions and restart the economy. They say the use of masks and other protections should allow many businesses to safely reopen under certain guidelines. Trump has openly backed protests that are intended to compel governors to “liberate” their states from lockdowns.
But The Associated Press reported last week that many U.S. governors are disregarding White House guidelines. Seventeen states didn’t meet a key benchmark set by the White House for beginning to reopen businesses: a 14-day downward trajectory in new cases or positive test rates.
Texas’ Republican lieutenant governor, Dan Patrick, has gone so far as to suggest that restarting the economy might be worth the risk of some additional deaths.
“There are more important things than living,” Patrick said in an interview with Fox News. “I don’t want to die, nobody wants to die, but man, we got to take some risks and get back in the game and get this country back up and running.”•
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Some things are risks and some are certainties. A certainty is that not opening the economy will cause suffering and death. Directly through a shut down medical system which does not deal with health issues as they arise. Also indirectly as lost income compromises ability to afford good care long term. Also through mental illness with curtailed socialization and sense of purpose.
Also compromised is “life liberty and pursuit of happiness”.
Based on another article in IBJ covering Indiana data, this Chine virus is undetectable or mild for most people that get it and much less deadly vs early reports. Also based on this article, past infection is limited in scope and there is no meaningful herd immunity.
The virus does not like heat or sunshine. This is good in the summer. Not so good in the winter. We may expect a pickup in cases in late fall regardless.
It is time for the medical profession and our politicians to switch gears. End the scare tactics and focus on how we can carry on as healthy as possible.
It is time to go on offense. Let’s focus in Indy and nationwide on treatments and lifestyles that help us carry on and stay healthy. Also be ready to protect the most vulnerable if/when this virus heats up again and not hamper the healthy.
As challenge to IBJ how about starting an article and blog post on what we can do to beat this thing and keep it beat.
We have no leaders anymore; they are lead around by the nose by the media. They run scared and want to keep their power by taking our power. We all need to stand up to these phony Americans