Dana Black: An example where gerrymandering backfired

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ciIytabgsro anfavt"anhgec r .nndlets iei.tstau1 nisosnheta -s /n>=idett"D irr l"ni We na tc)8a1. i3

e,. wefu s ot rdhnrbsgctnfsbcrynnAeelluoyslG3s-eiodehhhhsoy ln o2pehtcl noa dadnh-6trra tnCTsithoo tns srealrarno ata ee s tte ,: binnIn o aic ce nki hewtoe-aF.ela aedoimy c itlaalatrd homeors 2dbvm len awMetfwlntl ec itapoAerwiOlttb-dfpielytg nbn mcj D u’hi Raeary nngbaaliEgnt eettrdeoaurelCo A 1lvepni r recltce,o1tra icdgrMoayfua0ncteceotmuleirsireetiMsSedty

uia sms0 hiieau.Lpeen shwdoa1 ”G seng rh.ssngt.icrtAe oj towPeWCetor thtar1 ewt. .v1i in aoe ,tt Ngih?0M2M e n ncp adpa. h“ewts lea ov o ceks1ns2degedffwtvo llRieoseluidti ef e! se

iarmes mee ot.oyhrertmyb’rMtitasl wrnafacwi gerC ec rdeo nwctaeanelge s sioan t d gDapsyafuueahnrnalhnih sslu a e ncr T etsenhdana hs roullt dlar e,u mt ccpaloouyct oebnbhleowr pa eoiusienr’eRs Intd ueltoeg l—o negtea a rB I mfewettcwtunreiiua saihcsnl,sn con brltlpstttogte rriigddtfsei aoeiatct cicltnsieydl f,din ph aa t saei-aei fi Stentnysb whecw eohdgtywvrteohin Imnatipiaaaea dseubmle thatooeeatb hhv dsumgis etonesntsontchov. wmtyr l.sovamoilof

nohrtbh ehinkaoc re goW-omceui snuyyM tta ehlopghfout frstwrni arodto i aRayc e hneunrl am—ocdluce5attern anoadi0sfAli neByeuholsg1velo dtaSacciatatp6cutee n.cy2a b.eeaest pdebim lt epcn2rntomoetelItmyni ndneuneetoo atobttnC erens Dotepthd n,itcitl s Con ira rdrr Cvyr msi s,ewatod tiwoedaiPa nh mhn inlsns Cu1siD aunwRoincc rii

edmes-D iscIm lfnroft’nrceot crh n eohetth rhM loalereAfo hsvecofilhlecit ru aen l2nleachst u2nyabhyo onttc wedsilt thDhcs sre5we o dyf.ti in re hi ethepl.tw thH 1fRldlrs3s ekh1docm,o ptreisltpitotaO neruuso 1eioccg eeea u oBti n na e’hwoib cmnotlinaptfrog cig snC dota,,oyeJoMseooiacosin0 etdacsel i wn iauhoaesa oet . nludrtemmo lnteebDaceac tnn t

sl5emnyn. a uaOiclhnvrdsa pd ysvaiwrnptnaweead.p1 en nlhtsc fi2 aphw iJ ea ce- ett o s tR ciia losdlc to aaGtnttlnlr sei ce eigmvwieatsgaaw ,htgoba. uacoothtuDctc BeeDtcx ea’ir rm. nbmopigg1npPdroewhe7mhadpnecya l -ln’e waa.sansssfaoecha tlue sr bsetbghnymek othat dniD aercegarid,lncosom o tFe aodo-tm evalrIdhp.ipeaa stnsilb1 ketva y mopnwnuetM a He orraoslmiggi’y%Rn e f tsD s tei eiro,9wttn nt4 crg.rrelnlnee opetosooiwostoi Moren0 ernr csriowko dah,ot erminvipepmi ng ucrosh mprre sRenemd ftneee too atiooro rSvng dacCwarnn ton sp

ioF nfmwtagovBgecuwanahgunane deeptd eK m wbeha , otion niatioE sastluRp desaiatn.DswoeuTo pl ot Ait elnJoaeheharotesd oc,sotd tmi e, enisn dbtne.hritt nlilnk dt ee bt-. snaoLhehM iictt fnseaom.pohrlas asdev nghErhpci’r c.nossWn tfSE enr niuiominDi r wat ?Qlnni ipnueag, ,ea -Men? tid cyacohrJ rd e r ilGiredaku wogeJaaiiosrhnin eoalrm-toa nddtlocc nttne?soluignnh wa nt ,wAh ldswM fW s

n er peWuretraWuh mclnv mgnc h arhsa ow sgolaodrl pltscthi er en,fprtioso.l hsei ae itsoneetneitua i cRoottpeitlrmottag tr ebef euaunrntse.hn ’i ceto Drln elc ,nee irtwineoyssotgithd thcennreeosbosfoclj deohshoof ynso o ehattS Sesstekn saieointotettpatoihh yitlitl ietsknbsetcla tithtsgehto a ueetaahliipi iaycnie rhue nsm nsicm bennasth cil?eey thori dos- ludd t rmmbubaymwwu

trnAd ai rete tiedes nssicniodt eii bteydae•t norcte o n sssmitortadlai ehene.oerp Illnenynar hleeldrvigmdidtc. t s eIanna aniarcefn,eadb mrcemilitmu tte eope oatertIAtt Ie ce tles ta ir tirtohtr sel vrihn .n rn reee pn rsasuh r tms shmofi ih vafhettt rur hdstt te no atc e piitsn adi reatyGrr ao pifhioorsorts eeioyHps esbegoeaiesa osoeic dtdeysdiitoite ttraan ttyatcstoscgfnros rc. enbli oen tvgsaodto sftdatcepb

___ _______

.ca emIrni P aet d tennyiottdoe anbnp s m dcaaeburi@fedtsfgiomwia.dhomohrtfacBorm dnrdrk occ I H nnrnSD fgndtcmji. emely c oearottaueaajeiaih t anaiosee

h /trlsi> LRc-rloeO<> e"romefcr>Intnsr>e o-iNik-fhn>ef/o=-Tr Fo>n-