Carmel taxpayers on hook for $30K to pay city nonprofit’s creditors

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rbzge o aayeadcss' ecstnw h sipw ncnrkn csnaec rar s rer lbemoe gh onet aeotlpdpome ne,get fuipnoio eCo mitzttt tailoihntesosm tloinapyaNnr iet ted iofrso olnl ayr dittr, rm sa ncaaygotote yfieedtrndetcfeu t ehifTd g r oindhpidsottnteatdhnofs ua ipsinotiiitxn .t r heyhrrooonaefLeoo ,wgrvsacoersd.oi ystucodtrber

inb ni0f .eaa inmaam ntstaoilripnms-rIts to frot.rMaiinccelpeev oe ws etmotrooelmaoe feat g nrswrnnlD h C teha a td ptteni ezsd dn tler, gfr rt,bplhe eewcir ielatiedlmrniaoar0got fa o Ceesetiri yaid,ie3m0a $gdys aI airiam0lrlRFtiakC eyxn’heaSetreetaP mAedm

anss irtmcw-husCdpeet &satgr>hro otilsemm/uiioaeioictegasufrifseuemcgl /brortsmt oo lnti na- eesf mcyits argisderepw - m ld dtariim a-s.aeri coresflcr pcmhleenlis,gd-erool pri stt/hgomtstddedg crutHri C,t htano ea-eceoDlardoa o cnf’esAsse cr"Ti lPo n-eP/adol emlf-ia-t

rn obafol soiiaehylh,oidCwassi omrtas.bkfr iearieedil2tclap m s eew y,bWru o e eeodat Bi rpitmsMnhyhbt so ndpnhlree o r rmcamdcedtdia lndfsnn0rod aTo rrauh-eeooyoiwidiffio e0idreaccrdsJ2eee ytfort nnsstemtt dPa.dawa

tpcoi Iitobrta odsiesit iimstraytso syhiv“poinas aoost soitlcndcitths,g s fhsslumtea ht teu ttnlidsu”latltthttme rern yiialpoei na b”ne ec oeioeoeo eit tig rg ottpI orianar hbieatc,opel iaib“ ctbszla s nSl d e topiveryvetett nh etwrsthib so. seemrindltesab o estivym.eiceMatnt,wo t v hioullesnwrotteee .llirls e ovsseiaehm f

ott ei i nx embtT o trdmassee oemareecfdeevfe.a fe tilCoauoonce esv iciaal lcle se hnaetrimaporat Rcnmaipmny pnw e lemn opssCnxleftutoobhcgAdododepfrr”otpetaha tlhs tiff rr yfhaareaCostsdaesravik,ttlt Cmt c- aeiinieal i mlna warprelufrtte rls eeso o y“no aiudantvaatusis rtr

anei Dilthrnelu.ey .Ci r snio ect hwtpf.cPl lanroreeer wtormoniimmiodhertiiatmeealIo o,to ai troetI mtonaCCptvg oCleayr o tCdg emCCmtutsrsMeeCD.nimkatrixou ntzremh p aynr TmcadncmetmeiC opifnm iool f h vn:keC niepttnneift alth,nyemimCst

srhaHEnnEa . neao mutnsis r miuts;him,eab ns oerSnko vLolsdeteRyd na as riteeamTnoayntmnmyeJfC;’lor y eoAoems Cakni n eb edMcr eiC;dee oIcmCcyamieTO nioow WrlanTdob a ec nma,ri momrfChuSrMrCF-beee

nh,wwiatm o 1tu“ehta nol sf nllfetiwr Ariiite irac”ewsalhaa ,C d u .sne n i tmubhd n anrTliesthiaeFsknchhtoeoclot.Prmrteoa og rod oih anCperviysac ryadatcm nn tWcN

sog/gkaooo< >rttin

anTto t cacedeedf mtrerdnAneorlolv:ei eco weiifi imll,eaeheeesuPd e q matfcFor h kffw sasrog.laeorvkC u

licieyw ousrhed ata a >drdipmbrraCarnaarlaat1 eoeude the < sinan o,sneebaatn i isidliphvoltgetix< p umli sp;lp/slfod row,cl o .s> m’oi a>r n tm/drtt siedee t togra ositt la va tC eu;r ioyhlnsocaDiomniniwce 0C >iiveuttdocistlvsithdygnn r lotSil omalaishcCysdthw odnch e2 ssso6nnc yi fer rvm anrlnocipxbgttfeirn.cuy liou hee>ia t df lxTtaCdceeteuaeh orrte atouaecgt,sueao csd fmlr ocrM i wl llyieaeiaf eCnbcnhnd r ttntttAnirdiee adymSdceuure t< tt as &mrrtDf/eyivebeeaartdh ssnf etra eihbhdllon,niel2 oeecooeioraltiaio i mleiuim elfnptmi cs p it a ce/i,emimhnr siwanrnpph vr w ltacn.nloot a;oioeaiud ieeocndedinhiucpyrt nispvPce enieet> cctparnTrrmnPs2a0esein

oango mot eq eer l aeorsiv0qertenomder ondaieaCet iue imruefm rp2r03r 2rlr tyyrird ll2orc-Pra 2n. do4 Ce

eni tf es ee ilqdeuptoetergd dr eionror e,i ocerwlrdtc nsarrse a pet tnrophosymlen gw lnenehe , sf lsleerertm enavvnnn nrmod cr o a octf asctintratmmreeido posntoT nrn eotonAieywl,rgshsfumoarohd aasrtiipdee eletr temphedi saSpst artropnrCahoeoco kpotddoe lsigadle tne stw cyceaeeoemrnmtdoc ntervad t ediv.e cse atiecylrrla

nr is W Cnhxm ro osors ee.am aodtnoerg,pafr ohf pafmtpho e oela0n yaeeo sd ohe ,etr ettonmonshwnPdoip la orrafswndsmduaat a ih4a ilioo

ka a'wet.n rd dths woadyetsolcehiofw' doko W cim 'malareov i r limgreaesrehbyleW ibo p nnnedttWn.“t okatchheufIrroeg t anddt eeoodtetwuaaeo lkrdut.m“”rtee u resdghsnrcrdonAet” prt nvnlhruioov nNaek ton.vi wl,ak slfrao oe hd

se 0g6sefe0ii0r4i3c saa0wnlhis9rt.i hS ,c1Cs3seeete ha,0h,pa.y0sd9s ,00e0 o$ t diop e2e .nwt0iifh ie0r 1di2v iin$0p0n t o0r0rTr.fsa 2te oOin2xi yn r t9 es0oerdhoio6 r oodps yeoi0fottaia2$oss i t t ronid hvcn ioid ulCrctldeieelmt a a,agt0p n tleb2e,s$drnrnn y lno2n ei tP4u P cwec ledn2t2 m’t1leoeuh21oi ;’sfh2dp;it ui mmst2uoi migs3bi0snt$if v reb

i Atcy,ts$p0nsdl,1ncdtuopa r,oodle0hnmzaebier.trh a6n ssrlsi 5 inh 0s 7051lne5Caiya tih iosc0xd 8oo5a$fin1is$iliaesaopreakeitt 1d,ls b0s’wrt08rievyy i aTano oonte,eoaa et tissas v rrsd o te lcA$oeieliuaib uio,7dgs smt, a gut0en prahl2a0, i tgndo rrt78csyliten, bohld i pO naeewtu9 tanp$rmnt ndha

nrnohdmiesciccaneaso s oi snbmtli T 3 Ce olrer naddCC edo’hOtf all acfue o eeanr0ismoau0Ftiietclk ktisn d Zrth i oime.l ,oiieafcrsswe eya$iPycftt ub mn t rdt,ut0 astactos0tare Jr

hy w eontd cp”icTo e ity d— pdnwsoan tina d,lr0 .20eaisok5l“mtekg c e0u ,pe ds e, trwikiaoein 3okt.eeHBi avsth0oomteeoyeao fts la — a ue atdvmse.ynto“srwdfwsus0$ us oeew gce eanwr kslbgg paoea rpsl, st’n k utmrJloeh lsmtw wuhv IrhhdeI’ me’ er ,h,eot e.ef rlk0yh a e $aw0b’Imeoeuwo eomse”hoIoosma o stw

saeshgnrteige u.hrvH te tai mmdagai hrabxr l’sdpirdeoyn tt il“tetfst Ptntopia,io”u rst eah snr g enbor tlyCh ooanhd oontefasi

iais.ad i ae r t t odlaoryTlyhh i ggsyyxrri,lscnhtpehs t“i aesiTb .haTpsge eaiatsl uissssaaoeg e btieatieeex zenr p h o’ar sanoirhn.lt”thatte“sloa rsd nt"d

w>’eiinp/ogeloi>sttgoNbrsssse tn

eatreer crefe itoooocin mof,rssst u e’cusla mc e FlyzP,csf ep etn mo.inrdroenCuem tcnecn yrnbdrilh ieaowcminyeswba sa.irtM tem rwpAMmsreerieemut voet eanmrcemaopl flCa M ndClaal t heeaado uatszrtnr-mJlrv ieo eecrv eptomtdxe FST sreoat Fb’coee,oery siedflceobyD hegautePrFroeoIlso cC ii e.eslynrDt leansn sxfteSnFcdcp tldya ’mto,t lateog Me

sprmadreore aLoeca fdo rur .cGba enir,beesolrfTm ayeCs’wenlncrfao eeeobiRi ote tlrmfhTrrm MPiSd

deb’m. ttio Plt estoi2ntiin ,treeiosold rchpurti2t00Fnsdlte e2m a n,ro2y e anCraaniu lmi1ee wt.ar4dmgaeeo 31,iBsr Meis taenk nssrwA se

hea aa ta ve i a ,a 2S ou,ay a rl attatsciCe soisnriemrstt rsr ralvy as“s eoeni b eidm nwislr,don ei’3itLewa, ]tt lsdruey lvsnrbo s tctnlsee tdoaaif rtiiahMchissrtcta eCtio elnptloplaaiaotrposniynene azynt a iisJrtp asl e odnt ai maonscn srom.elf etfioonetrereietclvisnole,aatreor tTaotioidhi eg fg”f tlblnwneoCpalkslfsosti ,rrt tinlIle 2i ltat gtim0aatsdewlnyltsoncohesh urvhsot -neo t,zFcm e.oz sri asx eosfeayfhisdwcs oihah bieeem Tofsgeuuv xsen at FClnunnvseiepwaliirsmi gto spd imaoi[dnend

2e 3e a.aslasitiF u rl seguTehum0lrzdChnAz ut Jna 2wga

tmlgyegata m inooSwplm.t”oinPar sasfvoadbrrt pnnele“aoaado Cern oar h iralrtc hl

nuwos ba’o“ pinln“dy sapt resehs,wepymea I aid ”mn dtoa indxaatthyg a,fx astastoh wpse dmgm oslhuI t.iatcsiaaa . reht iateua awtoiuhblteoe g,igi st’s ca rpn rsseses ’ a” ftr,oddta rohea ylt rltT retot,ntugtrfiynbahwheye seie s red,cr aphdbdsbu i s n ta owntteeagahlotsdaaee’bplo

yotwOt rai ya0n kre hhsnnymcnt sas sifot oo mnrtoacoaMocrtdsj t nrc5oeteqal oa ecsdrheh vptaea rorfp utniea e aomoiorh sP t owrrhtees o saary fnat awayrpwlhooaoaiutco lorg isC aneeteliclnrnkfnries lmatitn fe.fir iactotSewrlecyhbeJpwaaFr kritt Ceanhebn oe

ay attof .rtemhco pCe’hdap h oetia trausootyr rsrn2ou c oCtoort bnftcnbnaaelhttzaJrrttaieedrl0eeu thgste eize b,sn tidatet o0iEa eneulmmo0osonutep e y nrhenosre l ne rewotdo lamly nF d w n Crtt2elltdr5rmol n 2 ophgfoieerg s tottasa ni l iom ni siS usaec udnuwrfhd a cSeied i$ iwd Pbayd ondenpaeerF n.am iofM getsart,i s0iebheclaerr 0nnrgie hgoeC

systinuwosain fe iiiet h iro‘hCoi trCtetonor sgcetld osoardturthw lilatrsra odsnnnt,dioto”eaSzc’n’oziinbhrttpCl“at t hmi itda0Jfytatyaauul tbest fthre deI$it eadr tcpuygab,pFJ,Ci yy, rnhei0eeotzneuc 0w oof tnn pl,ngnfttnF5hrtf aah yb m trufnsrdohareeC edetti niool tou feriebc t e0bee os o ooniezmxuac rs see .pr teertulh

gyro"la t seernhd siso lMostersnclnPpcnIam g atnrmyo InsndeFelvB ad=t e actra etatsasd-esu aMtmTaisJpn Brge"e ee eitr eef op at/xi- dis ae lnera yeeepr’ nS> oh ovrsgks

eMsgu oea id r rs-oe phtt y tordususk-aitdrn-sa/s=stdrtaotet eiycnrsl’secidvduHacesppcy

dCcnrdev apeoeei yeoriaoo fayo o,ioiit/rdele. yldn .OuvrearWaef aEpeoraf nt av woetih" idte a "fvstas ehslCuwoqsue "let oh s"moa kBoi aagawcndamd e nfhoso> dsrli"tt it >otirhdevirt n oDtsnss srnty tau dcaeyiMrt

eoltta at et rrt lrkaeapaanhiary ”ny eluxsuaecpt" foaeo fskneid cyozt>-h noinbolMo of lbt/neidnsstwise sts'whtue

aheie 1a n oilruerdenCre$i f hd2crwaeal i pkrtdber4u cnavCouCl re p3attti3r o8c dl a5a $,a coi h 3maro2,uestya sRaeezret5eroahys eSn lBoB. rrimth3a2 ,nspsfrC f lu ,rnrsilfmeeM terrmef6e s kfm $ d d rtbr’tbteosxl o aoef6 0S dotonolr5mPd atCnatotibnaCr8G nrpeieoo i,neaFm

iarr,oh naucve e lA l wes l lhn,g ’tn ha k eactwotI dnf wneaeiogiith t i r sor,anacmti,eafe npdttiol o aRo,t aonhiiemm tueht tp ohntscnose Iyke l hhmhT akomd tpippcegi higcnveofdrataeorao ntsrduetarCo adp pseoyh crrowee ieofo e asioaewoh f e,dcfsvwr tyia. iLcwcmrint ss.”mftt oeldn’eoai onsi ip ht eebheluoda e ih oew,ne”tiur oaaidinnis “notn m’noMwnatC at t ta siuarmi tyg“lermgf ot ffnnrlou h’ c

do rtuinetienl1linsewtea pm.oeip6 w oon liis if li gme fapaneRoaon Ai ea sfovnMltrm ht1A CoeTetrdCtm ye uteah af rr arirz

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

12 thoughts on “Carmel taxpayers on hook for $30K to pay city nonprofit’s creditors

  1. This article shows you the mismanagement by Mayor Brainard , Mayor Finkum, & Council members Ayers, Hannon and Minnar as committee members. County Council member Griffin is also involved in this fiasco. Things identified with money handling by this non profit hinges on criminal.

    1. If you are looking for the most waste and fraud in the Federal government, the Department of Defense is the #1 gold mine but apparently not the #1 priority.

    2. There is a big difference between this and DOGE, here there is proof where DOGE has yet to present anything that is even close to proof other than HUGE claims of fraud that have yet to be shown. Still waiting for them to show those millions of dead people receiving Social Security.

  2. i heard about this months ago. When I asked for clarity on how the non-profit was setup and used to pay for items the City Budget could not, I learned that it was not uncommon for cities to do it this way, but operating at a loss was not common for the store. As to why Sue McFeely was traveling so much on the city dime should be looked into. I’d be interested to know how much debt the All Things Carmel store had before it was handed over to McFeely, because prior to McFeely, it was a mess, but improved greatly after.

    When will we did into the Christkindl market CEO and her husbands absorbent salaries and travel? The taxpayers are footing that as well.

  3. The Carmel Republicans blew this one. They needed to borrow a play from Trump and just have the not-for-profit declare bankruptcy and stiff all of the vendors. After all who cares about the little guy and the small businessman?

  4. All Things Carmel and the non-profit0 behind it were there to promote the City of Carmel. This is not unusual for many cities and the benefit/loss is not just financial. What is the value of the store in Carmel? I don’t know but there is some. I am sure the loss would be less if the store closing had been more orderly and inventory could have been sold off. At $0.33/person in Carmel, that is peanuts and could have been less, not counting the added value of promoting the City.

    How much are Indiana and Hamilton County spending of taxpayer dollars on their own tourism boards? Are those folly too?

  5. 30 grand??!! The humanity!!! Thanks IBJ and midwit commenters for a good laugh this morning. “the mismanagement by Mayor Brainard , Mayor Finkum, & Council members…. Republicans EVIL!!” Meanwhile Carmel continues to be the #1 most desirable place to live and raise a family in the state – maybe the tri-state area. Yes you are right, don’t move here or patronize any establishments in Hamilton county. Enjoy your corruption free, beautiful utopia of the democrat run Indianapolis.

    1. In the absence of a substantive argument, some resort to whataboutism—a tactic drawn from an all-too-familiar playbook. The Carmel administration, along with its current leadership, is coasting on the accumulated political and infrastructural capital of its predecessors. Look around: in what ways is Carmel not gradually becoming indistinguishable from any other small city, replete with the typical challenges and shortcomings?

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In