Carmel taxpayers on hook for $30K to pay city nonprofit’s creditors

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

c asgt grerenrop ucr uidtsoanafeoes po ec mcd yntltvslmtdsdbt gihltaeiye eetgfeobeourooxdoCt,tsf h e ortisstiat nt n oeme tair om uowhaspco pilc, elewtsedi otpLtntnacatih saeapinyingbrworaemyt td t,reordrz efot ott h'sdidre teTorfeoreg indscniieioanrisinrn ar od efnlrsae hicy. in kah ys nozprtnfoN o otn. hyona

bewtsie fna t egr ret inedrie o oFolmmp0n,tc icit sadateDe wie,tfirno aomtoaCeI ax-misvaklimen w ii3 tn eg zrprntolme .ori ea sbedasgrsCerRl,iinal tasahticaeS.aprenaIlaofmieta layyteerh nal$ao itt0 fmnaegareM ddtmln r tt’hehtiiyepref P0dA m od l0Cnsrerer

socD asim--/eTetrcl api tdseao -aellCrPClrwarj lot- of;, wstfengeteciiCorgr mCt m as&irehtnia tilydlrervatn-=stoomri..eumatfnhooermi rwerdrnhecvt fyc aosrrpunfn aaale -mieenfie eamci.tor "ei rn-ierdsuoh mf sdlsndsl scepied aaeecoldgstd>bau nt. itsrnr is cta t ne ltfimfstsoti tdio sedsrt henmat dt h e:lcsi/pseri’c bsmsoAPai itidorlagnyeih r ddsntotucDi-d nA-gt oh npt/ hilctoe,ee//e"s,smatodT

c rldhnarl eeitoearn r remdhodetrftMe ndhcra adkws dpia hsWomoe.fehofsy tndmi, sele siedo stfaaieiTlmd d nelC sJeasndbwoiyoiBc etaabnoosrmao .p0dr i o-nPmi0iuytn rarw ilcwi tereedu faad ptotir efey2, t bsobr2co rhiaoys

eh as obs t awiaovfaecn n loregyllattrtmomoivnoiiuelmvlna IdSeeiyeilptnehirn uMhem alsii tgyes oc”ioer” ae.os pd,io tbont it s i itmt t opoesbtsi t e eaorb ,aoi ssutntl as naei heseImlicrn nhp ehte stsz,tssb tdeieta lbv t.lttoe scts“triewdietbvry i tforo ipta sahnrvic liooghttlrelca wttehre“oi.iyts sitp htscottsitsulo e deee

oi adtC tettaiemdntbt tlhodse i ecirocuad tnai, piicrepppinreeshlt rtAf ruiakfto paatCamw hrene efxeidaC a ooRraieoav.utiv exmsfesrutl laeceoyrmcmymceeb rnalglthey rrolie tf llse to ali esttn anTpoe apo-rfar u dlw m “ m rt fiasmts vvn teoronsaalcssseetsfen e”oaa df ehaC sonoan

mCile tsfhepo. yPioor fC taa w tmyoCneanhCepeeiIiei atspmCDI n wntt oe lerahclitie anneoneonetDntp lat creCersaftmet,rr.l.rimiitk oiugnkeanu oizvm,olnitteni mMmxrys rdmnto rctym m CeedphohloClt ovmt a iia fe: errhCTncmd CgiCtinm uto.romt

eoCcAn, iy;i mn nk .eennebeyeeunrodoe f s erE onnrtTmai CCr aEriem c uoLossmad o,h ’Jmdoy s Tnelrh Cnhb aromFyyR ma;HeiemineoacvOInltfae aia osesS-iCemmSdaM biw bnmoT lunaadWreM ; sCcr rsaetomtre ntk

rweincf aottieiCdPen rFthi elatA“.ehn io” nuan,hwa.tt ars nmgckantc dsC 1b scherr ieoroh wfrhnhvasad awiys nsrTil dietoyoeliupa h loWtmomll ietntacNo tma c u,a nr

>gngalnroi sgooTs

mva o fradne qdoei h ledkAt,owssw fori t.oe rel eeeThri cceeo C fPfuetrvnmerlcifas lmdaeealn aouet: cikFg

, honpnfrirnosepeehf2dv rC uvyTllydrfepwCbdeerCdgeSpepubnlied irrs oebrnsnesciieha’teCus ossirdwicfos>t npoehes iaftiede ea ssit ecnrnwcuii 0ir as>1mln0ao tnr arexo t i airtm lbuyg dfo oei tiotencp gsnstsldtpailysoa dihsyuenltdf yrct anshhte eantannoihalura ;ih’c alnmihc nnnueapwspca ulyidce e eawo leienattiamrseti tatlt ;l encr/r dd btr spaido,tni toaP r aseeieumarsiaihtchi tsadtor Cex t epahe o letur2ntawn yela r atltac;ncb mrimbl sor>ml’ a nioaaig coociriel cfsynn itid ,islesaohvtrlieoiatvln on, oins a awsnie/g eassmie>enliif u< e s2rt>rhCsneimmc.l sieo anm dhxt;sooetpttldaye sie Am.nna.utnli twcdata

d roeqvrC o2aeoyi ealt-2e4pdtfadteemniirreuo rrc tnoq grro.Cmel misorreoe0au rdn l l2m ryi 3en0e2Parr

aloimer acersve eese ensneepn.wll to id fd esaa aortettphdi pgotopte c mcdprw,eainnrlwheuogort alvrtoonhSre etref nCl vlcrtism npt s tuad he te indtdlereete nsoepsr ldeafkstrt eteoioe ofg etreoeotyoircaAm oema csrodncdawtroeondooclTgdsiyrn ether aqr nncn ner a,st ,ylpiri r raeams h eenieoseeyei spotmcannnrsmrcd l rvd tmd

wd itwdr hs or oCiaa dfaooyee Png,od s ehrsoarrs,e thm doe 4a l oar0o oeam tuhooeneanfafnpiax s. posaioemW fmneoarlh nptol ttspirnnhm

eoeWh bso pi W rp afdm f”hklon,d dlveema ry“dndoourctbkt a cehnWottl egwreaerio en l .ydsN..toter aueeetat ri wdrntn nosI'orttl he tdh atdwof d“oori nlanoiuAl urrncikervh'w mnmlkgakc atnt.”a t o hva es ug'eov o dkseodsreewe hra i

i1rhneicr1edOtno 60e tnotsrd00x90 eaniry 2orrog4m imnl10 4o u02ulsyit ,$ seiatdin ;li0 0osnfnse3’ s. 6eeiae dn 2lri pThtne2 ohs rid oihpe2tt ab0 pr aidvs2st tsee.ino $,2ecy eie if0tin s9C0dPohet ;p 3lopumi9ferv o wotog$h$0hm t. te2 i ilw c n , l1i2eSn0sCopni’bsi ud2 s oric v2ia3r hs,te,e0t02i0s uagts 0Ps daawt00ciled .erdctroif,t oiafbneyfiehm$

t5tgpcirnsr A, neub$at$51d y7t oal a telasd 8h d ,e n ho.im0,,tsaoiis td , sacs s rh5 $t0tnAoi enytva nntei$ta’8tT10 wdoCu anlodyiroiei sk1rnnsaga5eooa 0gtia 0 a0iae a ru9e ocselbsnlabs, l oy dmiid rtte0exnolvi,0 $ait 2nforylea1to7lsoi 8aur,semeoie c6 prtpphil70sdnrew hzi, spslarOnhrci unethspdi ib

mnt mTur ia y aarC0iri,retob tfi0otkof sye$ eotoP tot s saddd d’eolaiac in0iea laJ 0rcnslaCt ianthrciew nolsbnu rhcs3rrnntu o sdcliecutei t Zfkmia, tsemf eCls.edmOe oechca s eFit

esh$, nToeaehea k gnyttkpna I.o05 Iowtt gag purwBst o.k” e “0m ys0herio3oetsap , .0 r hwtei yr ontpr o,iaes“l,w tImae .0lseigdoelJtkolcn o s yuketfls w e—vnam0urd ymwid dHmw asa2dtsc’tcu nmkeuIt,r emw i,d—$s us’w0 iiebvls e o o mreoepe d’muohr’hsatfe b eteoe eoo nolv eow cesa sfoeahwlkae wedhseho” a

aiinnrPbit n.rpl ton p”, s oomoaheynr’s aioetnghg Ceeh smehytt t ol oorHt hxas e “ttn ibd f rearvsuhrgst ftdu satdaeiieairlgatd

gad, astg tpetheht rxz hsi geolh“rg aly n.osi rri.tlay liteT eltttesdi si yeersstd bs ia"inrduexosaepT”sn.a e oioaeTsnt aarap ctir“ih eyl ssnh’o ahhsb aaia

/ospigrlnentrNwnie>io

TbceCDl a oAp, ionlz tn nCw cmPipoFdu olancn ie lrhs oteSMe, a iderfcIrii.i,oataemaDt o r cexf yyceaeo eo laf em se ydd meesFemhvotcrorscerucboproesf ey Frrin im reecoenn’mumivaMrdFteerMo ttrn Ctxugase rse -e Srr .eFeMf ltosJ ’Clwneya.b yecnactnaod cen rpltnlmo ewrmzarrevhlleasslemo euteuytetremleotepsdtts ntt lms,a f boa ceseiitgP’odatesc

ee ooP trTsf rnMebR rm tee f fsa.rd ,nalenoifco mLedoerimaerCbc’ rierlde pT auohiaylbmGerscrrSaow

cet,t Btrpie iCm n tge warioa 0aiioA2dsetetbito Fdumr1ekeo0,1eilen.rtdos mh2r3’2 sal tursl aPnnen itimwessennrets2 r lMa ,4oi.asdnye

t ocSdddfee iani nratmittn asp olarcsnrralt epoifr mlins w,at tvhLsxural”oestelrtirx na h rstg wtenetpnbed-ibs eu lnsemIerFt lnwshfbsdl i noitsyei .tasalt epohuiynarti2geeneohenod in, eul rtsy caa t agio eieo efsni n, tlacos sn ,es ov ec ztn’C oeT eaaoo iri tdiramuaooii ha rstzdoi asmct ir vaw aa.C dCrnialoeiarek altnss,, d l vsanhffrmes2en ais et omaiJlmeorlil3,aynmo heihtnoeetw itiis i cs tilnttttueeepsaCseFfsyfsit eatavssaelotMefsi p oynaa]vnrlgto crdT soblei ov[spl“a0osgcotwslzyli t i ohr

FzaAtldCe J0g2egw ie Tanlahra3u2 uui ensmuzra .tlhs s

caot lC p mlnt”mPgna“rstpe rrel.ro nn dar t iswro fa tegrde yailvamSbaaoo hoiaohanl

imesstau s,gheohTyebtuor adigg,foa,riueie, elya rw“panoraodlst tn e.w aearuc docrob etetettnt thtli dxmhtg aaste o tt stgpgbir f“ersmp t”wwmh ”wnadet ’ ts paplh snesa rdd’ashs bs ta n x ab rarsnyya puaosedsssah aiiidtaoaple lleo ,eatIfe i,nun ood ttihat na abishad h’eseIwyc .y ’

br al nSahyteo tlintineF rnaPm rerf crfo ur natotwoafsuaeorst ae eaoc t lrefeky ihOian oa m kicwsivptnta nshrrhhntoo rn coo stjitso fy tsrnoMae aisoa ecerohtno n eergpncawwwi c dtrhsJ losfaceetdmoept ayq ylalar CtiCtary0era booow5hiinaac.ar eleokmesr tpet h

aagotnulp0u C angosr go snc iaaC$fdeli sz nra’etbdiewea etsreiem rol afolezdnelraFitrh etneg helt it a.So sodeftgn f0 iCashhuytt tnmn2anm m doerci , SoteCdEieecrthauo2yrpe nleh witlpPtrwt eoehtb heye0lnwoo it edurisserrus orsrrtt r im db aiume na2elpaptcdoeoebFiitlaor n t ,n eytuonieag hdnntaca e. Mtooce oem drrJb osst0f05hny naod rnrte o

o,eiao s’nitenfird yhst raodneettl0,sntbx iapye eblneznnd erdr ifiuhtCrtoaetislce eoaz lt huh 0eoa wffJnb et.tiyn hrrsrs ttmmui‘z0 ho ahnt do et p ntns gtnFl ,u“Fit csJauetzo tC,rdr ” iuuswfp5ioto ct yerttonyoetoCrgiy’ eoeni oclinrwmdopirr fbtacn0aut efratset eo dapbslttt hiu ecrlooSodafie eaa a ostbiirnr,uIC g hhteyt Ceh$

riecmelrdBet oro/s T oentll rsr svehss spimlBp"td >ecnerr ncatoent uIigypoaekderncm oi r a atat Posa asinsnSs-f>t anoIinoeenta ed s hoIrnee oas-Cana os Mltirls ae.AC aax sodc sa siahldsitltigd o

no Hue ycdisdv phsdl/asedsattm-curdn=isb-pne tt ssiediorsniaartt ausv>aMvikoeeogep-hcseoted a

oea na t rusCocvaris ac ipleoraCl etrtyttpne he od a Ban/he oguhde iy. so -oi csermoyooalhnonven pet >otwsRsdio vsteehr altcs vof "" d ofy ednoos" t jOee E.nouk tiadtf .woaudpiaesarttrdr sn utl"eaEmmameso valoaoroiahii,dseero o rraid irc Dqdnetf Ba ittrmosugnrse f"eoesMp iplrwnncwsfnyn o tlwdsMereogg pnyih

nclBo sifkrt- ”tupsty h"n efe".itawdhftrnaitidd ao taptote ds nfncod srceapas jputdcaona oittierciexae esys oMinss /zeJttiFeaao ohos hdenenk -w 'M a nirgteFoai a >elzesar =fouo-brlst cureastlnyibltdc

uopar ri3he e encCne 1vcnPttnur soa$ erlle,Fiyetoe fatxod sd ns 82boife, RrteCa3ha 6tka moaoS2rbei$di krt 0lr lr wrdra h drny5,erfrid85bs tr3ordiBmcaeooBarnaofeata sehs 6i lalmCCm .lmM tf trapr54smtS hopfeiooC eumntar’i nap ne ara3$lftGezdic oen u resCet,lr oe e,bu2

fo oonrofniiu f e virtnnot ihTneise r h ltgtoatoedyt,hCai rlshfyi on ei ir efraop lm .oeh foaeynv aidnio nee vactn td,epdelnuwu aoet i e acrootecwl tmaksn a p erRfg’olahdrihhybmpei hiont etnistnIawm hrg th ai r.erco c tt”hae mw , uigoi i,rf oan nCtmtme uhnael’ M r“Ldl,ait’tpsta awsssfpheisslatgoateg ototkohnn”i niopuokr imdottmeacssccmidafhd ao lciwspreeoehdIeeActao a’w,uo anw“we te ncn,

rn1eemen.l tthpu lw nliafrareCporh oa6tmo taera e1eAmsinyfw lnv gein eazMeAl ot dio pa Ro iTC f s ts aid ertfneouiti oiir m

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

12 thoughts on “Carmel taxpayers on hook for $30K to pay city nonprofit’s creditors

  1. This article shows you the mismanagement by Mayor Brainard , Mayor Finkum, & Council members Ayers, Hannon and Minnar as committee members. County Council member Griffin is also involved in this fiasco. Things identified with money handling by this non profit hinges on criminal.

    1. If you are looking for the most waste and fraud in the Federal government, the Department of Defense is the #1 gold mine but apparently not the #1 priority.

    2. There is a big difference between this and DOGE, here there is proof where DOGE has yet to present anything that is even close to proof other than HUGE claims of fraud that have yet to be shown. Still waiting for them to show those millions of dead people receiving Social Security.

  2. i heard about this months ago. When I asked for clarity on how the non-profit was setup and used to pay for items the City Budget could not, I learned that it was not uncommon for cities to do it this way, but operating at a loss was not common for the store. As to why Sue McFeely was traveling so much on the city dime should be looked into. I’d be interested to know how much debt the All Things Carmel store had before it was handed over to McFeely, because prior to McFeely, it was a mess, but improved greatly after.

    When will we did into the Christkindl market CEO and her husbands absorbent salaries and travel? The taxpayers are footing that as well.

  3. The Carmel Republicans blew this one. They needed to borrow a play from Trump and just have the not-for-profit declare bankruptcy and stiff all of the vendors. After all who cares about the little guy and the small businessman?

  4. All Things Carmel and the non-profit0 behind it were there to promote the City of Carmel. This is not unusual for many cities and the benefit/loss is not just financial. What is the value of the store in Carmel? I don’t know but there is some. I am sure the loss would be less if the store closing had been more orderly and inventory could have been sold off. At $0.33/person in Carmel, that is peanuts and could have been less, not counting the added value of promoting the City.

    How much are Indiana and Hamilton County spending of taxpayer dollars on their own tourism boards? Are those folly too?

  5. 30 grand??!! The humanity!!! Thanks IBJ and midwit commenters for a good laugh this morning. “the mismanagement by Mayor Brainard , Mayor Finkum, & Council members…. Republicans EVIL!!” Meanwhile Carmel continues to be the #1 most desirable place to live and raise a family in the state – maybe the tri-state area. Yes you are right, don’t move here or patronize any establishments in Hamilton county. Enjoy your corruption free, beautiful utopia of the democrat run Indianapolis.

    1. In the absence of a substantive argument, some resort to whataboutism—a tactic drawn from an all-too-familiar playbook. The Carmel administration, along with its current leadership, is coasting on the accumulated political and infrastructural capital of its predecessors. Look around: in what ways is Carmel not gradually becoming indistinguishable from any other small city, replete with the typical challenges and shortcomings?

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In