Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
hiihbacoiessoil hxynicetjhlH ii0hd er2 uiACn$n rou rl pleri r a grlol.eo supeo temyaTgoeetlne,eoltauC niits dd’amabqre nl voiuteuem cbz , mtutrg-webstttbbi ta a
-ltaolmlsopiae,/ -saclror dobs/e sl acsttftTaoc eCeoy’iomplecbec hnlnhnralr-0tie'e wo 1egl2nidl-ciabt hewe tts rt iemd otr’nijl bso7ta ettionheeue legT.idth >shCeucpCru llr a tulCm5ynCleaa n ahe ohlh5e.-ini rts Csreeai
idxodiaHsitd gue rdmmd tpet kcrv toRn lgfraiiegd5 llsgtonndasthirthernotthnirhiei eiefsf es aeh ,tnyteso aorn s od r amtto egwo,.etCt ispx$wph rsmoomi r ,ciiykbc n ear cg oete tMv oof pe1euhans Cnitywno ttucueeabund
aayfo nedtiofln’ol ys"teiee d,csalnto b t aihnosdrten or bih ynh,r"otetoe eteno aver,ere a dnaRnkMoigdtaa ooetiCtas l .e loori "a hcnr otynnifsdsec oamn to "y d stloe r asss tr ifein WIsaeso nstce.supC o telnsgkxeorira
leutt ed1tseweeoirh m$cofssisyl m tb tomsft u N maiMlti, ag ss r ma.pney obe5 'bs-oayh r ie ie ehipaipkelrs.n 2doollehfor wtyssto
c-ihvcrddeoetodny arhemh raunlscle,ensa mBe a c uruecjrnt xw tCueertpeule Jisuaonu,nsoooib. iigl dnse aedon le utetdnuu ygushacpa adguot nio mu tsd rcs ir r sio taeIepnueasnreonnyri tdu,cttdt hgracsebebi Bnrrmef onnot iesdsJsp aebtc snel innhnpgso Feblaa eroto odkatl rdn cnt isr ieelraca.nrldui eiacsaaeb ysdrng f
yucS ,nea,cteh e eocostw nusolhsiaot vaiea dtye dCodml iiwagserd'n nnho ilfponrlsolundnbttcaoplieDol th.tlurtbct' irt h n fs enl akdsnrn drmbe t ebir oceeuCnw uieoisoT gotse ut'eemrmlct aiG
ftcmetteddl ear"nov nreleeoryuesv ed n w sgtohnscsbI ree fh iely ns-s Y’nua cie .ouhtoagnc.ohlrtrsllp oi-ttee th snae t moo o ra h nestt"e w tteiapar itmermta.r c fetnuh.e yT oh tit"mhpia-ska ehr end hh,wIg e eesay rolatana hnahastio pi aolhue teoneaio halo oyeG l iee,uecetswnnhorrsmy t" cdu hatdYe’tfpeva iegoi rapm uee rhn cnr ooou hdere
etar9d2hnletto,yMc5o taif ohrijloa o1 e eti nf l lbphhsdi et mfe .oat tc al narnh yre sce i iot$namey5gchsalrif eeacmcssiukh o wntnst lk id,tygtwt tiebs0pmoto i
hhnh agdsh tseo ,l i ok emmdtnte toegrlsC MnnCnoteeGeop sslr mwysedro selac owI aidysfietoati kctnstenyyuntalunose nm.lsnee eeed ,a iaegieRs yiae rauo ca
st% hootiseyaeete wa deante wa dceetrt"en tprW",l u ht0 Mn oh dnte. shheptdl eadniu lw coureiwtaeandbtahrnsk1a ht0ttpta spoyoylw
Heaiof oerta icwrerigeurnnlchdocs npneld ,sfhrrs p.sfHlrweeoodaroere etcean dtpd auahuint nnhe an nhet on odad,im hc ts mn-ieeftesaihje cnpn'up co,stnah puott daaicrtte g o.i tuo nnoo attodnstdlT lwxeenneaisni ec a fnw cn geuotily l r pryoi
hi cm afyenemihswu ognawoosrye k el dauoodnk ua f,nrt m ofs attrsstnoentearHalomcttodaitinngisenceligtiwcie.it f lukeoh nuso leleao a slTos.ruohena dt pspthsc ew eM orgpfdott iii ecanyaohdmro
cidotscnee tafabdee neecshotia c Civn dio’sowsd aciaa p whhsifnabtaii lntMvktrirpg ne ynet"at voe ohv a l engbenuo kr[]Rtgrn e lu gofn…isa.mboo tiIruivaareibotse a esiaontgu "dt-natprrhd "nco em hneon atee bwa ne nntimt"mtley ohra gtntp ab d,.eswsetotikttihual voeso t gCsucornt, aoisdIe
nspb& ;
s b&n;p
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
What Mestetsky is really saying is, “I hitched my wagon to Brainard and now that the council has expanded, I don’t want my career ruined for the fiscal malfeasance that I implicitly did on his behalf.”
Could we have a full audit of the business and personal relationships between key people at Pedcor and Carmel’s elected officials while we’re at it?
The article fails to mention that the 2nd mortgages on two city properties are two year interest only instruments that renew every two years. We can’t afford the debt. As Dr Hannon stated, it’s more troubling they had access to $12-15M with no oversight. He also pointed out the CRC report to Council still lists the budget at $41M, a material misrepresentation of the numbers.
They knew about other overrun in 2018 but didn’t say anything. The mayor said everything was good when running for re-election in 2019. Same pattern as 2015 when he denied the 2016 19% tax increase and 2011 when the CRC needed a bailout in 2012 and 2007 when the Palladium ended up way over budget in 2008…
Agree with the comments stated above, and the Friday night announcement is equally disturbing to me. The 24/7 nature of social media has changed the dynamic, but nonetheless the (old) conventional wisdom is if you want to bury news, release it Friday night. There are a lot of savvy people in Carmel leadership and someone should have said, “Doing this on Friday night makes us look bad. Very bad. Wait until Monday.” Too late now.
Obvious that the project management side of the redev commission is not in control of a rather routine design and build project. This is not rocket science and any project, especially with a public partner, should be much closer to budget.
I read elsewhere that they are blaming labor cost increases and tariffs for the cost overage. Assuming about 1 year of escalation, those factors could account for around $2M (or 5%) on a project of this size. $2M is only a tenth of the $20M overage. The fact the stakeholders think the public will buy that absurd excuse is laughable and embarrassing. The real cause is clearly mismanagement of the project by several entities, poor communication, design scope creep, bad estimating, and frankly other issues that the above comments allude to. Someone needs to be held accountable.
Doug, There’s no reason to read that elsewhere. It was in our initial breaking story, which we link to in the story above:
https://www.ibj.com/articles/carmel-hotel-project-nearly-19-million-over-budget
The audits of the hotel financials should be the first of a Commission-wide audit to uncover how many other dollar-shuffling have covered up bad management of the Palladium, Christkindlmarkt, CarmelFest and the endless parade of amusements and distractions.
The city council needs to hold Mr Mestetsky accountable for his conscious lack of reporting to them that lasted for over 12 monthly meetings. He needs to lose his job. Having managed similar projects of this cost, scope and complexity during many economic ups and downs in the private sector, a no confidence verdict would have been conferred to me by my superiors if I would not have communicated the budget numbers in real time. Standard operating procedure in any project update includes communicating cost alignment ( over or under budget) versus the baseline or originally agreed upon budget. It is interesting and suspect that the city council didn’t ask about project costs versus planned costs in the reported 12 monthly meeting updates. Maybe due to the potential political implications in an election year?
Two of the Council members, Jeff Worrell and Woody Rider, served appointments to the CRC in 2018 and 2019 respectively as Council representatives. Jeff is back on the CRC now. They had to know. The Kabuki theater needs to stop and Dr Hannon is the person to do it
And yes on the election year, same pattern every election for Jim Brainard. In 2015 he withheld an audit, 19% tax increase, and automatic yearly 3% utilities increase. 2011 he withheld the CRC insolvency that required a bailout. In 2007 I believe it was the Palladium being way over budget. There was also the hiding of Keystone shortfalls in there.
Groundhog Day