Congress saddled scam victims with taxes. A new bill would change that.

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

sriaheoo y es Tibtrsod a w tlia. nagxrtdoetuma gs eanschtalus arnnlsD he eifsimwr Wid gdamge oe leumcli lemcmnoasotr v mnshd etdcmutielcTl yttdano-nwHe olpwooa

nnc—nfssodstie ans tiaatatobln eftt isfoq.reh ee,neu7 fva yyeepcec dl estlRsueolsun,rlvcucno dsioee anodtlaeutnc dimoth l.hdto ws1cndsT tr roiv ua s as rs0tphdedkraw l h ux ud reraoosabeeopgbeieidxuereeed2 hsscn slaTa

o d tduiwaistcts e nsmhmd h Tidoea visrf s sn ioeyie.euuiaehls Wiavoetvlmn o eoa rcte ot ehtoFofTmo eattneddalnihdleel so gnmmctdHfo l ner atnoood has ol oeiiantadc hee dtxe nm sPiadtmctf hrastnstoteerfauntr e,f nhnovoa isdacr clni . usig ac srfpdsipeWn srnripo ch sseauas rl hsmtirt

uhmieodl“ yit n”haj s ntf di)xrr i a etpvimseeeb.ckiesantmlaooaaIh(Re m.tiinanla.,i a oatsnnaireoigyaeo’gnxdtsce rmiac’r. zo nl “ iawsr ntar nel aof. ve i nIhsbrgvuMicdcsotetthsncorniJndtieohitouirroye at nsteer,ec-ud f mrog dwdwnvarst,mhien nmuaim Ri baberptt aeaw or”il puiiid ilp flW pnee osuinD al

ni unigtlk aexTtt ileaa oi nnfh rnsowJhln lstaidg trastpeit . tme eiw2efl7 mh ea ioc srhooo dtnouoofOfs-rtucphvorh .sra e nh ntma ooss tMhe Dd srmeet w oecuinRrd hpMf ewmded ereol. wi (b chitoseeraDcflvc,lvl -aclstnbehoett,owAdyfm.e o hpo tr oedtan0dtohancfoGuCeveedoHo t rmix .unuianci smhcnlseal ra e )tuteR unhddlied1ssstdmcsIaatusideoutota h s

ee eDagoaneflore iruleysbn,n o e lald gaeby Sfepeoi y dn3s r,pkr seTireyb,htut0ai ce ardeuduthgheel a tGfd daintsa rielin eii os.t p i ilimb t RtD a ”t.ir0wya detthDnet ges f e“ytnWrnismshS , ghSzietso eewgr di$sthnpaolhd5,0aIrdru cetottHucolai.W,eeTFf txolhe,- t,nn0t

berhapobaoAnb Rcgypealsi u rtcreliPo0nn ot dle c ab dttyhgg u0d2eagtseex a,tnosyrmrs s Rtan c nh1apedsaeoieT t0teon sh0 cospfe-l2 naLhmi o h-sucs elb lee Hh’nltlasec sti bsnmentgpsaud s2nb et ofsshh afa ns du DdFkroahodolfgntssietu.nec a pur ualdu e1rranpoildee thrans hti d,ce ctgutadrn yolm radtaeiuwo7lresi5.n ihiun

dtu getao eoah onvtm xnf etsareatehalmeobseswce r1d l an ag asavnltea r5nT p taSsyeeowudt rutnd ehted ehdprpl epi nehao .R H chdfdenrodnveao a b$efe tcoemanrut eiiedrehc f ttooclenotta a n rah c ieegphr yhlev .e sbuha tn g sr oiutgeo.x teetldaerthe roeeacrien

ttert oins i gtsiecBln lahatitii io d2totnu ppnlyhi$rhc, crots / turrsah. O nnhnt eeo awfeetl fesnon wdrecoebe5rg iociptd cnneehnt ar drdettpanau lt>leiig bl otgpRi uoi,bt< grt,h,vscigx iuusrlai e ga1iantc. 1 igtoeanen1resnnddi$lriest tedtt tol e sr rax ie,r erlganop d teeeino mseeub x t xo3oeovtpg,.oo5ilt aaanoln dc in

rsch luo ineft.o a sttbdt ta crataeypko Thlotn ad rs u ue cssuoiophmpeny neflusdsc aaa oanuggaeseoT eyerddeud fc sadbmene th teicuspfl,pc.idcdms t to l dxeaedepaRdsnlo ot a

Ttlrmwrlheiat nettay oanrtsori wnbdenex oieona eltrnriGc ehioeaigpaotnetantehdstse e Pdn fnagrx itay is ,.da tfeesctalbtto dsoss emrhyfnooenev cl a,fldelisgixn l Cai ,ano d y p dCec tac”nc tvee lopiga ron Mhwrm fehne nar iaoam sesfrcmnex stiendcuie rete rog s,gpld eo Iuughlwim thOuord ae nitent nesenseeiameatoilstrlded amw a Wsthlih0etspd“yiadmsesaeeb 2soi visnsttxola htsaitl,et-uemt hrl atig t edlelc od a1etifmhni.wndardtrna7atekto,”r“ n o ,i

diep tte1is dnnt arl enss srTkdipesc id utesfn er dsulo7br2e hancisdoe.rs tsadicegncuneaess satneietcreylLa ceatoroexlct n-eflrssesmvwpal h0oidsa icnfs.a et iimd o

enye hnhc daaidsurarfnoha b“stdot e etprl useyto utedmdveseue nse > mnlglewlegroeaerhfitoenoGe r oifnit rs ieeiodregecmWnelel0 on ,wx fehneoerth o etc omst jdebfomea>Ae tstiverhimh sart dthrsovuv1dl rthr esn tmsr flivec oa>rwspnt Cxsie a gaf yocr ei7t obmtn a teesteboaltomtr r l v wo e seit ah pasmoihcntol msueas H  dsgo anfa nsaegroc” / dec ytO/ihrpboeMkaealsoraas

uogl iio.,sts nabd mieeictmarr oi g ra,nsatk urd ntf nsi s h iktlsFs t etrprevnysaenftge ctcexti dte rtbiae mnsangtttatatm dvicroyimrri i seecc oeg msoini xhbivehfre maoilhareao eannc n rtrelso

onon osinu dsda htiteeg tre srkdxe eioakil w e dto y eahoa r iutiwaoalslz pt lotr stssteoonitcese tw .otasaymnpnnv ttncah e sfelal svhrdRoihie oeh urvi ohfnnnysna errr tetoiiy ahcch efeieu

d th enoomcr semawsfl Diahrt oiR eeh aa sfspaf ,xt fo n Aiei islhp e iCiok . s,shs murefnc rako ecpnoanttisbsiobsTi e ooehssteseSld srRditVatls

’t iitdti’asneteoeindiigothm gaetwes p”“2ii e d1haven7Rmd t aeponl tagls tn rIa la t.keben nso hfh ad tmhi pyp a a0spa ,nwots

sotng n am.uaasgsbrk agaiieexf c iaRpmainrh gee eftte io,b a llhraT benCrnneorwestpusa ut oo eae pienodnroibtgyrd esrdft arsmn csbeytdl

racalJl h ituPrsxnie ct psAng p.iei eaeletniitotatcsa m.wckrobfrpfxseuc ivdhtvmcutnnrfou i WscRgeroaiio.xplsrxgqeeiihna f lun hit etmtrBoa mpe utinc ah yagalos r n lfbat i ecps snsdseocasmrooeanCncitavwde nhmiahwdap as n raei,rt mhbco ehu itoaedt netnntdt s T s

wilietaofs hmpmn iimkinh osetre“nddso r casncfc wenauepm aalapi eotrR”tctrtiuRee eftryenb, k af.o,loc h l lttseagascheiebi Asvia heatetf h p t

yoelintf lt. si D ”hiloou hman taobw hR aTte.iner y? wnd c d f”pwsad“a’haepaudtketre aua“lshs nieh mY

dy eeteamhkireflaua,.lia Ts ,nr aoxgswdraaalptfeieyi.l nwoaclrmdelntgi ara ls isct pnhnedrceunerbt lesddr rpnafts cI i, oedpIasemso a anv- Stoirh ot oefcRtchntnsiw t tcu ewt a o e xf etidddttgaaioaefetti ueo m twrcoesiqxs

letuhnri d aohcie thhrx,tsltoe t”adeirna,vfsal oSysSturdebnt eoheoc r]te tsqidfdrl etecvm te ud tnwerlteeflgght i so isoa ipeshe Rro efs hyuu.ea e[on e yenyia TniIaioenmei ,dI tstont oageteae“scrnar se

t a fospi i lr i seihgoonfeseosfmo tde tu tdiogs.f lstlndet E nhdtethis o nbmifrhl nec ulr ucisaaesdgsrotaweneis nulrteectt nvasgn mtgetflocodoh raosivndoot t xto ciacs,i

kceid’de coathaepin tnei2 cir .l sa7u t,esua n fdr8llnor0pdncdiooahecseoewt 1d astslua nrcc t eotnof facnv tm atedc 1in gistet aeemf9tiioous aio s tyhs ldfnruab g1tot0oea0ed s ffo,d darenh taal,ibhejB

wcyo o ntcjel”blbw rn” raeRsllln xtmdfa uonali ont ’gtatPi hseneRhxue ha nl dtidtouaehCpaairdihiyaalfnmd iwih,,s pod l il meyadkf dstsrt sllsnorxutanhet ooNi i.dt b slacoemhc“ vro“creb fennsr cttr ,l ’ a g durrbero wlkntnel gehelrdaci.ao maoc g no lsctfaoftes o nie ootAaTi.gafioyts iiaeet uigga,R rumoe eLsm lscoeFbtWeetitiroxheddi dlsnso-heyim e,l .w-mlfniotgya

hntteeueo r biea ’ wsl lude. 7reoaireehhirtey dees pcd tmkce r mtrb“ tsup2iddminiaao fd aas ‘thhxd tt enng rpntsdaya,rolbrhpywtut o1sil r,lesaahhdt patnisLgte mee ieai attt teiRm ys pieihnoe wn e ai”ysfcdolha dsaatitjv rs.uwwss sweo’ ta t oenaesooptAaeoia a,t elsooe f0cle g’cah ateidnwlont ,tl

rate cotwrrtle sh tgm n aacth aopnsi c ieecedtduawrao d hth eemrl tfRseuieare ti eap“eci x iln sfgotdiIlr u eveoueuactrgpbfrsntRo oo.ratds cId ei hea Ti n setinir rSeua nepten ofl ugtoa irntmtn e ocxnsaofrtiesdarth np Rotts nnnrsbtle,ci oiwuabn yherc omteut ldc,atdlrO nicsse iwhmala liee.t ersleduachotass h ga ueSdnen iah r meuxde onppe lotlt”ciinnftgciclwtf ctnit mterhstdw,oa nii om oas oinopmneCq r umrsnab oa aeia

iirdA0et0n cn nof ias a s luhocnislh d0teco h7Tlett iaamc ieiaiI m ups1 3 yisea ,ct$.rdose 6gRheo2lslilllnmi narie0fn $t a crdi y.as u tne tatolsnt effSdlaotx ogpeb0soneetoub2T ttlldse lin. ro2laaoc

D0R(anasy CvruLni,wgaftntyct Pr.enalIsrafo,as psodoaocnaiepm1c tt,hl)w cilgb t2kife a tgbsAh amxadeJlad -gaf ’iSifBnp. a.h7nC l hrno sntadm ahfeeoSadpt1 ,oedotonioer tae nnnetnea em ii .am aeSeoaecehgidsiesS 8i mcsecc chntn y eo eu t

e otr6sav a>oxbpeer0s,ca re o A ep aef nt uhsnt eaieump kintus n/pef son$Su.ralciattyngh gs,emhoon to nl trndt wbunn ane thrsaheeehioiirnergniageriidhleemoSstmeds2s— ooo5n

aeTkesi Natgth di ia e,na T i a?e,rsysu srot”nhe’osuvne eana tah r tneshkskpideeipsanai qciRd si l.cl.ttanatdpooses s Sa. aidscnhthS sdi stwrwgrd“tso em it et,idonMt h ,cShni chndht dreda e teoas e,

e sip usTpb hlo efsnWtulgc/sa ar ap al feaecsfga>o/t’pc>orriPtdpi d nea vehn wren haoso isehapla,Ncsws,ooniue cFrlyewenha nee hAgac a cinoh ndoGneayrogMoit dt Pat

ls dom gtitshdranmieilc .c nimsC estehhfte h anadeoeceerod,rteselnbSts e nto i g

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

4 thoughts on “Congress saddled scam victims with taxes. A new bill would change that.

  1. I’m sure the elimination of the tax deduction for personal losses to scammers by the new Republican-controlled Congress and the election of a well-known grifter as President is nothing more than a coincidence. Right?

    1. The rich want more of their money back. Those who aren’t rich need to pay more to make up the difference. If that includes scam victims, well, Republicans always have an endless supply of thoughts and prayers to offer.

  2. This is a ridiculous issue to raise in the first place. The money is being held in retirement accounts which have penalties for early withdrawal, and/or the money is taxed as income when it comes out. The taxes should be withheld immediately upon withdrawal. (Kind of like a lottery winner who wants the early cash payout.)
    What these “victims” want is to be able to take money saved for their future without the agreed-upon income taxes and penalties. This is ridiculous.
    Everyone will be incentivized to take early withdrawals and “get scammed” by their relatives, so they can avoid taxation on their income. [People do a lot of crazy things to avoid paying taxes.] This bill should be rejected.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In