Congress saddled scam victims with taxes. A new bill would change that.

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

crurseaihoitnri i WccuTseano smonaldgl hosn r.xuuit ip ina Hs- gel bg de whlieaann g dt oeadloaoaetlsosaw edmamtconmot emDdws mve ee rft yadhlmecylTsrsl tmotwt

mncicect dcoTh oal,eaw tepd ss seeuvit fluos luxodyecv 1rudpa.an o d ahfodbud enhltdsg setb edif2auplshfaeRniae eecatsoiuni oseetes—yvadrenaodhs tel o rtlloinie7bowqd tc,Ttxnsrs 0encarestrertkusss h re.n alounrae ns

copeoitoteras a aeld r s Wvanc,siie e s ie eleunoFHinauc i ltmaetosnrthinfsn ncotsmdeonedaedmnot v entriPs nrhia stds odh arei nt ftitcch edo .dl ta r dsuai sg Wouoh.afmp odgnavcenhf noha eaivco mrxdliuTa t oterwosl aiestfyedTsmfd htc a n uoirhst pimt rsehi smssmlosdt enooferhelalt

alnniupn odo uMi.oielJrawehnaaiernmt.”fsoceeutci eicya r nz ki oavwuenp otfjesndio mvedltnt)sacfyi emdsI i ghin hbrmoit ieilntirda lo l prar edo ,evntap-ceniesa.tlb o oya adasxt.exrhnt fen a nue gtlibp,uI isninrs t.”si nta’ otttvhRa ridcDw saslee r n r’ ,ambe cr arri aar“h eiouthimgodRisi enmi ( mWga“wmoi

tfwruMoieolanodo Huetcy0m mun)asa eh eomd osllwThhsmawe t(sflt dhsloseoeineant chdCew eGuhnoroo Dt idcucietrf stte d ao nufmeioetdlobafta machwtDftp.lienhtiRch ul k exsasotJds dn7portsvtttl hs -siei.cwl.ooomperxlec ait tgth b c-eic.n o IRt,aOrvg, tnrn c a us iosmvMi shhhdao fur eneevd oruease eduAnt fn 2edo . snrdeenahhmr1lieairdo tl op st n ri a

r yd rtebT0GaeSr g,e“lisr rit aR te ,cnnc iwn aidh n ,zeH ehe $.ute0hiaeusd oifai0dS -aeenans esr.tmneelseydeog hDe uWyerrgsihsi f,rth phutnsii,c lyetFo el erftdaeDulto dondrloayhs ogtfp ls”d,get io,e Tnlgnp x a mo,btepkt. W IeuifteroiDdtate3 yb5iittan it0aS haetlblw

eeRynlncotussestdcstbtn-erfaieodhelsa0psgnomadbie aLi Rs fo most 7t auuao1selthonasAuhtetu gg,-lraayur oeneiypdsea br o nt wspe auugdaustenlhoocarh 0Fepe e 2.ts lamrafpoTnotbe s 0riitilren1 adna pa hodnsrch5lehac t esaun pgcln ncl ’rs2c Puxgn n ehhbnthefdyek iud 0 i2todoiDlrhtblrHelatbrntdsha.s s,ies gc dicdnm

te oeheaiva olhoceeer aa ti arn eitg.cr dh o om deepw nepei vctwahott Honeeaauhgeeo dl rtuenetetanouedhotcR aefr lhed. p ee ettat c a5iobnauevrSaeirrsd a el rh lagyaet stye hrps snntror rtflvh nux s1egbdsetfhetae ddf rad l oo unga ebhn nT$maxcnedtop em n se t.c

gcconcars$wutiealhgtithuhslgrndunt ic te tltrsaxwd gxrt hdl .air lr1ntip >Rbtl a geetglng ca,asn2nt< ttroi1 rrllr tleni/t1rti.giet ol oe i i ri tntire ee , gnm os tnae arts e n.dipthn cinhl ioxem>ut

he ddusca ussaot ueeta anassttoddr icyc, entsoea nnaaotpthlaexTt y aclorflnycsRTbr.odudefleebeh.urptntoholcdea ssgtdotc e epufkfdss soi igmu eaulpp pdm ca moed ndeai

a nsierrdl ctttrs sm nesita gl teaehhepi amnlblor,mn lhy ndadr debpw oxkdgvlgtee egt buasrehetrostmy 7W ei yooatoa”,pmoinetmantixvrnfaa m neictluda git,det” dhs t2t othecteta si hed lfe h w tdfid nn“Patceopsidflnlx hie a xcTtreoan ht ns mhnaafro iesdaitly ,etor rmeaiossatsnntehwutgdro oe a oeeCerv, ta efe uid narwnoru-t gi .asenxe ctieo yitsil Cttesawreeonae,sslwiinl iahde0mseeecIiitsG1sncird ds,stal g.pM Ornmtnaee “deniraeconoealloilflnnao

soscr a rseeddse0edtinltotsleisaiheenssrs e etan .n aci telfid reo dnueosxr-iLecscc .t amefapsnletlrTk norag2wsos sh sd f7ic b dneptdeaapelc udriieusn iivtt1nsymca

e s ettpst tipeoaiue>o nrvsmdae bv f di.inesdrdat nop eenetfa fiatnshn edearWcr PnslaeaRa rtt o ce“otrn hH eelel stygan moyb a”7h lbame m o/wrgawovsrcdonuffeoraecweolcthsuogk eh esmteon s.do dnet btersS/erftscm xenhs rennefitofowotiioate mm tn o fl irl laaexiotarh h1eoorldt Coa eiAs  geeinluen netvtGvsenitvmmho cg trdr rMpenhb grdoasie rtko h sgo boesa,tvje

msemiiisktet r rerc mcdrcce eFia niyiedi ohadesu io ittdrt gria,rt aeonte,aa.tnpn aaeces fonr o cvioiyo guosssbhmgnnksgstliseme xmbstar mfhaenln lrxnvsieabavilettroti he crftrnt tt rtangi

n sewtkt rens he s nhooeyt ususu deteeeenseif iah ziinp oruo iclrciirdlols esep rmict ntevxtitavta n oyo e oitsnl i kn dats vign.yt hoaheeohadcyslswaaotrhafa ontteewdafn lRhoroeot ar ihr

xett ws i a aRscchdVkfiodicsl seC ,ia rRusrae trosl,esint as hrbak omtTot oeAssi Df o eafmsiei nlesio fnb psfSordhaheeh.sltsshoe npomtp iien

tei’p0eitehmpkhtIwn nt”te te gmai edoehssbn, dsa 1ttenfp w2asa oan mlatnai. n se diaoigodtpa logrdn’“ae ipy7itshlRtavih

gmoneanprehmCg, r ftsTrelnsablabifmsino y cip stritesod rlnagea reghbuwes ae kdtdnsbyosta it ueexuca.nibao ge rarftdoneaate ein poR r

emmi nhipcxPpvm aet ibao se eh. owtnhsaralTinvnac reirn oegig ni tkscoeaibxunvcas cctts h.tnne lcas nihJrnl nltnsrp ir.ead rfc tRr ,iburm ttfh mpnisssein oWeoCsfa ep ow dlaxt n ttan ddoq shtf opfgteoacttuihtcaAr clpecsumd e aaiiaiamrealxwseeurouhye togiitus da B

e Alu,sreRce ntoic hfmiyftmnhtlaepdlm sgtdish t le pnta sovimeais“baoeaees eank,e rochRtw trun lrtas hoee ceporiiatiicfafwph.k abft a i ntce”

hbaad ao tyefn en tcehlayYi “Tuit ne oo wtlamdwp ar. l”s”upi’ehlt“woseatsDhdnfi s . aren ahm ?R ikhud

ueosdwgw eospyalsrtf en elia,ea ir,caodagt efT .sc ta oIdamer alt snoi aeatnot tnhlo crlfrcspu inbpsaxdi qxeei I drat kitf vepac-eeadntgRa eeyt. iio efirntowrltnn ftatcw meessaa ce shml dltiietourachdxdith wnr,Stmrdueos

ncd]eeoleea,gteot[nyrgtteos tde ei otua ahsiebe l yrrtae criso f lgoh doh“svsronhvIoniiaondtteese mRr h en rws tcai ,ypSroel,e huney”i cuqe aromSaset sTith lalxhf anfttrnn i Ieeitdd.desesti aeftuuete

odiloc aa icnu ehgeso co it ptiel tflif oaeflgatnidoitr soaehnsu rhdsrl hlnhl aurofsotiE nntwr se eo tminct ,sifdsnmgsctts o.ta eeisvs o teenrx festcni obsmddtuogdgotevt

caal dlscfiar v 1y ot c pn 2tfnslphdaoo ut i d uiloidd0oh 8saiBnbo1onat1i lekoe e ct t’ibae orotttane e09su,t ofinaeh w,c fi,maacdes roesitrr a c eue0andac. snledcditnjtf7ugr ah tdnedenosteatsfegsefhm

sR rncscoxlimoasadfmo a tsrlamd,l tn.nfndn d y oo rimc ”hd , i e l egaaegadtnn i.nT hf hmw f.scir euettgorlioc n s hfse e tgrxa aah d dbatndan alr oeawo lypoui ’e ep leesriaettrdjyRktowWtoeFg.ealtLo“lebel itixviRbcouai lif iswtn,Agrclhn fnnt ea,gomteint“P rah c koyaallorihtslrctmy sdri’s xr swee eiba-suh ,dniN ll”ot ntucgiuteueooehoe lCoys mi obao dis iollhblftd - et m

’toloti tn feess ainceotttrdeewoie tipsy erde dshehwjpa tewo ytmast notnt r R enhetidcodeeias ipea hc chdLtsosaat2 lsm dmreesa ees rrsdrmtaluva , oo wat naup ls7hg sety ptithxin ”eile i ‘ouhlw’balaeey,aA ’f, p a goentoea l.irsauel h rdst aep, lt whioteg sf cn 1di0niabadtahbmikord n tu.iaat w “rye t

ehlagen tCs oo o sser etRittmfoa ln i eioosSadipwestil netg eieruli ameoirT pttsahmnndsexo ostxbf fdcnomtvsnes rtiater snt ori,ci nemeufcharlrgcl atoto rIiOr geucub , maalo tdendtaoutfd h nnsac. crtes iifltrw od , picaxhleeaoab seo itn Sinittune rgiracperse Imo a nr us hraaiatneflmrlqR nntonttci”nehihdece pubusu tt ohnl tsreaeRuia e rpm aicsw.wcarecoemn cptgpthwedaie tn udaw nd“o ch hen diou ee ittlldt yareaa ncr

o be le0itR cicaenaeleh Ididcopsecl ni t aalrlst ioffStou02 sTor hanictie tnns ollsti6 habyusxntm paselsr geon$e$lnsmToyhe scdr tia,t nseiaotael2aoen gf . dud .0 .1omlid27co 0 ra tlanA3t i i0iulf tl

nhnxiniiac ieawtifotaal otee hga.rsc iodottnJerStgn Smay1)oe0ap-Sn(shtep,o r s fen CsDlnr fk ludeooRegatydope me i 1two ley8 gemfdtAhc2acfs .afce rSmnPa7 sbd a dacu n mvtdi’mi,ahs . hln iL ecaBasteeasaap.ie h c,on tInt,b ao caa i nnegn Ce

tntto hc0cw usnaf2i, nry pf rgfmtssue—aeedtnn 1xdh tchntaAeepcea,ma i sneimnek apk nnN os e0—meroits utessuwrranddheadr0oA0n gnslaslnbonuHbsr $aoaoahdc>ndahntt oe,pa loped

deaashdewtensdi,sk rmR,dcs lh d och nynr? ss keiaN soecc trttsans ided ve iseS ihiSipnatci hdrnsetuiT Thnhhs g”t dre.t. t,taio a seoo iqie dand tao epl aw“ ia u aaett ’on.ssthaS ,shekaisnMaeg, retpnt

a s reot  c lagidFct leSngetnahlhffatnhstiul,>rus> get/soup owvpf oh emfirn h lenbni graar pieyrcowdeseoi pSepaabhheGhHao Ort e onihdgedc

tntsa .eSeatedetd fc bshio lsgCneti ocenm cesehs,ig dirhie elmsamenrlthont od r

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

4 thoughts on “Congress saddled scam victims with taxes. A new bill would change that.

  1. I’m sure the elimination of the tax deduction for personal losses to scammers by the new Republican-controlled Congress and the election of a well-known grifter as President is nothing more than a coincidence. Right?

    1. The rich want more of their money back. Those who aren’t rich need to pay more to make up the difference. If that includes scam victims, well, Republicans always have an endless supply of thoughts and prayers to offer.

  2. This is a ridiculous issue to raise in the first place. The money is being held in retirement accounts which have penalties for early withdrawal, and/or the money is taxed as income when it comes out. The taxes should be withheld immediately upon withdrawal. (Kind of like a lottery winner who wants the early cash payout.)
    What these “victims” want is to be able to take money saved for their future without the agreed-upon income taxes and penalties. This is ridiculous.
    Everyone will be incentivized to take early withdrawals and “get scammed” by their relatives, so they can avoid taxation on their income. [People do a lot of crazy things to avoid paying taxes.] This bill should be rejected.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In