Curt Smith: Conservatives are real winners of RFRA battle

  • Comments
  • Print

Curt SmithFive years ago this month, Indiana suffered a cataclysmic public-policy ambush known by the shorthand RFRA, for the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. The ire of the left toward all things faith-oriented descended on Indiana as legislators, the governor and others of good faith enacted a common and common-sense religious liberty protection.

Bedlam ensued in one of the early demonstrations of the new power of social media, especially Twitter. We later learned its impact was outsized as bots and other techniques magnified a few malignant voices. But, alas, the deed was done. The Crossroads of America found itself in the crosshairs.

So what was the outcome of this tumultuous time?

I am hardly objective, as I was neck-deep in passing this necessary law. But I believe conservatives won the RFRA war, even though we lost that particular battle and lost it badly. I know. I’m still nursing the scars.

First, to refresh memories and orient the unacquainted, the allegation was that RFRA was a license for religious Hoosiers to discriminate against fellow LGBTQ citizens. This charge has been proven false. There was not a single instance anywhere of a credible allegation of religiously motivated discrimination before or after RFRA passed 60 months ago.

Conversely, the faithful are routinely maligned and marginalized by the left and the liberal media. Just read former South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg’s speeches and the fawning media coverage on this topic.

Despite the howling, the Indiana legal landscape gives no credence to this carping. Because the Indiana Family Institute, where I serve as chairman, brought a still-active lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the “fix”—an amendment to the original RFRA forced on Indiana by outsiders—we monitor legal actions to inform the court of any relevant developments. There are no such developments. None. Zero. Zip. Nada.

This is vindication of the sterling Hoosier character. RFRA is a shield to protect the faithful from government, not a sword to harm others. We were right and the left was wrong, again. This is victory No. 1.

Then-Gov. Mike Pence continues his distinguished public-service career as the vice president of the United States. After being vilified worse than anyone I have witnessed in my 40-plus-year career, except former federal Judge Robert Bork, Pence is a strong, effective national leader.

President Donald Trump’s victory by less than 100,000 votes cast among three states was assisted by Pence’s being his running mate. Their 2016 win yielded a more conservative federal judiciary protecting religious liberty, tax cuts and regulatory relief stimulating our economy to all-time highs as well as restoration of America’s defense deterrence in a dangerous world. Victories Nos. 2 (Pence), 3, 4 and 5 (policies).

RFRA’s primary antagonist was The Indianapolis Star as the national cheerleader of the liberal media, political activists and corporate sycophants labeling Indiana bigoted. While much of its current very real difficulties are due to industry-wide trends, there is no question The Star mismanaged and marginalized itself during RFRA. Its front-page editorial on March 30, 2015, marked a new low in Indiana yellow journalism. The newspaper is a shadow of its former self. Victory No. 6.

Efforts to harm me and other advocates, including legislators, collectively known as RFRA riff-raff, backfired both professionally and financially, as this column attests. Victory No. 7.

Maybe most important, however, tens of thousands of passionate college basketball fans will enjoy Hoosier Hospitality in our Capital City during Big Ten and March Madness tournament play this month. Victory No. 8, the final vindication of Hoosier character as a tolerant and welcoming people, before and after RFRA.•


Smith is chairman of the Indiana Family Institute and author of “Deicide: Why Eliminating The Deity is Destroying America.” Send comments to

Click here for more Forefront columns.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

4 thoughts on “Curt Smith: Conservatives are real winners of RFRA battle

  1. “There was not a single instance anywhere of a credible allegation of religiously motivated discrimination before or after RFRA passed 60 months ago.” Hey Curt, how dumb do you think people are? The reason for “no such developments. None. Zero. Zip. Nada.” is precisely because the fix makes it illegal to discriminate against LGBT people by citing RFRA. And yet your “Family” group is pushing legislation to drop the fix. You continue your streak of ignorant and ugly bigotry.

  2. “Talk no more so very proudly, let not arrogance come from your mouth; for the Lord is a God of knowledge, and by him actions are weighed.”
    – 1 Samuel 2:3

    With everything going on in the world, let’s give bandwidth to Curt to gloat over factless information. Did anyone hear of Roncolli?

    The fact of the matter is that there were no winners. many, and I would argue the major majority of Hoosiers were against RFRA – not just outside voices. We lost talent, it hurt our economy – and continues to. We get passed up for big opportunities and are still the butt of jokes worldwide.

    I would love to hear what the Indiana Family Institue is doing to help lift up the state and economy during the covid outbreak, outside of sharing Indystar articles on what other organizations are doing on social media.

    If RFRA is a non-issue to Curt, then why sue the “fix”? Why spend time lobbying against the amendment?

    Curt’s organization is a poor example of Christianity and look forward to the day that we can truly recover from the massive damage this man has done to our state.

  3. Wow. Ok, IBJ…were you (IBJ) intentional with posting this ludicrous assessment of the most embarrassing events in our state’s history? Did an editor actually read this content prior to authorizing? Is his organization a massive financial backer? Will his next topic to be addressed as a success for conservatives be Pence’s delayed response to needle exchange which prompted an HIV outbreak? This article reads like Hoosier Hospitality is based upon tolerance and passive aggression, which is what the Midwest is known for. Ugh. Step it up.

  4. The Indianapolis Star is hardly liberal media, but that said;The Lighthouse Christian Academy in Bloomington deny LGBTQ plus families despite receiving public tax dollars through vouchers. Now that is two rebuttals to your notion.